HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tonystubblebine

4,867 karma · joined March 20, 2007

Me:

CEO at Medium

submissionscomments
tonystubblebine··on Default No to AI Training on Your Stories
I'm not completely shocked by the comments on this post, but I'm partially surprised. Seeing it spelled out, the authors do seem pretty pissed about the unfairness of how AI companies trained and what they are doing with that training.
tonystubblebine··on Politicians, scientists spar over alleged NIH coverup using COVID19 origin paper
I liked this article (paywalled) that interviewed relevant scientists anonymously. Answers seemed to range from unclear to probably not. https://medium.com/the-nuance/i-asked-leading-covid-scientis...
tonystubblebine··on Ask vs. Guess Culture
Jean! Cross post this please!
tonystubblebine··on Remote work requires communicating more, but less frequently
We're struggling with this (80 people) and basically decided we have to get the entire company together twice a year. I'm not saying this is any perfect best practice, just that there is something that always gets lost in translation when we are remote. That gets cleared up instantly when we are together.
tonystubblebine··on Which vector database should I use? A comparison cheatsheet
Why do you think it did well here on HN? It didn't do well on Medium. I always thought HN was pretty resistant to clickbait.
tonystubblebine··on Changing my mind on remote, moving the team back to San Francisco
Happy to rent SF office space to anyone who thinks the same. I have a nice floor with a kitchen that we aren’t using.
tonystubblebine··on Chegg stock tumbles as ChatGPT threatens revenue
I'm posting this because I want to know how? I don't think it's the text book part of their business. Chegg now has a Study service with a bunch of subservices. Does anyone know or have a guess which of those services are now done better by AI?

Some of the subservices are Expert Q&A (seems like simple questions though), citations, grammar checker, proofreader.

tonystubblebine··on Reddit will begin charging for access to its API
Maybe no position with Google because they can bundle it with search results and threaten to take away search traffic. But OpenAI definitely does not already have all the relevant data. They need the new stuff also. That's part of the Reddit position as well.
tonystubblebine··on Reddit will begin charging for access to its API
FWIW, we at Medium feel pretty similarly to Reddit but with a yes to this question about whether authors should get paid.

AI companies are betraying basic business principles: they are taking value from datasets like Reddit and Medium without giving any value back. Fine if you can get away with it. But since AI, especially text based LLMs, relies on source material, it's pretty straightforward for the platforms that host that source material to deny access. Things like ChatGPT do need current source material.

I don't think it'll come to a war though and that the AI companies will instead give some value back. It could be as simple as citations that send traffic back. That's essentially the exchange of value that we all have with Google these days.

But if it's money, then I think the obligation is for platforms to pass that on the authors. It'd be hard for an individual author to negotiate this on their own with a company like OpenAI, but platforms are in a good position to negotiate on their behalf.

tonystubblebine··on Mastodon hit 10M users
Regardless of this horse race coverage, I’ve been having a really good time on Mastodon. It’s much less toxic than Twitter and it’s easy to get into interesting discussions with smart people.
tonystubblebine··on The Alternative to Performance Reviews for Software Engineers
Has anyone encountered a performance review system they did like? It seems like they are a huge time suck and don't do what they are meant to do.
tonystubblebine··on Ask HN: Why did medium.com "fail"?
Thank you. I think that's still a form of metered paywall as in it's a regwall as an option to get another article.
tonystubblebine··on Ask HN: Why did medium.com "fail"?
Thank you. FWIW, I think the case for Medium over Github + Jekyll is solid. We are a little more user friendly, we have syntax highlighting now, you do not have to put your own articles behind the paywall, potentially we will help with discovery/distribution.
tonystubblebine··on Ask HN: Why did medium.com "fail"?
Yes. We added them recently.
tonystubblebine··on Ask HN: Why did medium.com "fail"?
We've got a lot more planned on Mastodon. Re: Tumblr. I think we just have a different view of how social software works and time is going to tell which one is better. I think the Tumblr approach sounds too much like syndication and that it's not going to end up being that useful. So we took the approach of having an instance and will be letting people in shortly. This way they are fully present and using the same software and exposed to the same norms as most other people. Maybe I'm wrong, and if so, that should be obvious soon enough.
tonystubblebine··on Ask HN: Why did medium.com "fail"?
This is years too late, but I did have us had syntax highlighting. So that, plus better recommendations, plus returning incentives for the programming authors that do great work should change things.

Also, not sure if you know but we have the entire back catalog of Pragmatic Programmer books. I need to do a re-import to take advantage of the syntax highlighting, but it's still a pretty good feature. (Unfortunately, I was the programmer who did this import and so it's still on me to redo it)

tonystubblebine··on Ask HN: Why did medium.com "fail"?
Yeah, it's time for the curation economy! Did you read Neil Stephenson's book, Fall? There is a concept in there about edit streams that really stuck with me.
tonystubblebine··on Ask HN: Why did medium.com "fail"?
Re: 3. No but I wouldn't want to speak for them. But the obvious difference is that we want to hear from people that are too busy to be full time on building a mailing list. Someone above called me crazy for saying the best Medium article is better than the best NYT article, but if you think about it at all you realize journalists are relying on sources and Medium is a place where you can just hear directly from the source. (Except when we are hiding those posts in a mound of content mill stuff)
tonystubblebine··on Ask HN: Why did medium.com "fail"?
Thank you. And I'm sorry we kicked you out. It was a rough cut and I think too rough. Also, we are stingy with our view counts so I think they are slightly more real than what would be reported elsewhere. For example, they are lower than what Google Analytics would tell you and much, much lower than what Quora or LinkedIn report.
tonystubblebine··on Ask HN: Why did medium.com "fail"?
Completely fair. Hopefully we are getting better again. The quality is there, we just need to make sure we show it to you.
tonystubblebine··on Ask HN: Why did medium.com "fail"?
Well, the top response on this thread changed after I went to bed. But yes, this is in the mix. People seem to have a long memory about a dark pattern experiment we seemed to have run with regwalls (I never personally saw it and the people behind it are gone). Plus the cruft. A lot of that has been removed. But the volume of comments about quality always seemed louder to me and I've seen quality draw people through a lot of cruft.
tonystubblebine··on Ask HN: Why did medium.com "fail"?
And I've been mad about it for literal years.
tonystubblebine··on Ask HN: Why did medium.com "fail"?
Unless I'm misunderstanding you, we haven't had a register wall in a long time.
tonystubblebine··on Ask HN: Why did medium.com "fail"?
I think we agree. Quality is the issue. My points are the underlying reasons why.
tonystubblebine··on Ask HN: Why did medium.com "fail"?
FWIW, the idea that Medium is progressive is kind of ridiculous if you look at the view numbers. The vast majority of people are reading about apolitical topics, namely professional development, hobbies, personal stories.
tonystubblebine··on Ask HN: Why did medium.com "fail"?
I think we're seeing a similar problem just from different sides. Why make the experience more seamless if the content at the end isn't also worthwhile? You're working left to right, I'm working right to left.
tonystubblebine··on Ask HN: Why did medium.com "fail"?
Theoretically, a subscription was supposed to be one part because it aligned us to the reader. But then we had a recommendation algorithm that was more aligned to an ad model. We're serious about changing our distribution to reward substance over clickbait and I think we will get there.
tonystubblebine··on Ask HN: Why did medium.com "fail"?
Are we still prompting you to sign in? I don't think we've done that for a long time. There's a metered paywall but there isn't a regwall on anything that you wouldn't expect (i.e. comments).
tonystubblebine··on Ask HN: Why did medium.com "fail"?
Oh, I don't feel like I"m ignoring that, sorry. The regwall is a bit confusing to me personally because we don't have one anymore. People here seem to have a long memory about a time when maybe there was a regwall dark pattern. But I never saw it because I was always logged in during that period and nobody who worked on it is still at the company.

But the paywall, i.e. the metered paywall where some articles are behind a paywall by author choice and an unsusbcribed reader can read three of those a month, is up there. And I'm just coming at it from the opposite side. Many people here don't want to see a paywall. That's fine. But I'd like to see their reaction if the quality of what was behind it changed. A no might still be a no, but I think the tenor would change. So that's how my original take on fix quality first fits into the anti-paywall headline of other people. This model works well enough for us in the worst possible implementation that I believe it will work all the way if we have a better implementation, especially if there is more of a sense of that there's at least something valuable behind it.

tonystubblebine··on Ask HN: Why did medium.com "fail"?
I don’t understand what you mean by hijacking copy paste and highlighting and I’d like to. Could you say more?
← PreviousPage 2 of 28Next →