HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

toomim

3,057 karma · joined May 5, 2012

Independent Scientist in Computer Science and Psychology

https://invisible.college/@toomim

https://braid.org

submissionscomments
toomim··on A Possible Fix for Scientific Publishing
I'm also working in this area; and your work is impressive!

I find your thinking to be very clear, and thank you very much for taking the time to articulate this space so clearly. Your idea is diligently thought-through, with admirable execution.

I see a limitation in your design — it relies on a central agent to design and ultimately adjudicate its reputation system. That is not safe for science! But worse, scientists will be hesitant to buy into and rely on a system that depends on such centralized leadership.

I'd encourage you to compare those aspects of your design with the decentralized "Subjective Reputation System" that we are building: https://peeryview.org/about

Peery View's ratings are Subjective: each user votes on not just publications, but also other users, to express who he trusts, and can even define his own filter function to generate his own news feed of high-ranked publications. And as each user votes, his votes are shared with everyone else who votes him up, and so on, which creates a trust network that can cover the entire web.

Peery View is a protocol, instead of a platform. Every user can post his votes and publications on any web server he chooses. The Braid Protocol extensions to HTTP make it trivial for his votes and feeds to synchronize with other user's votes on their servers. This means we don't need a central server, and we don't need a 501c3, and we don't need to set the culture. The culture will evolve itself, because every user has an incentive to have a good feed, and thus has an incentive to vote on good posts and good user behavior, and then he also has an incentive to share these votes, because doing so will give him reputation in the scientific community around him, as other people vote him up, because doing so will improve their feeds.

You find that in this way, the system has built-in resistance to being gamed. If any bias or manipulation can be systematically detected (e.g. a sybill attack) by any user, that user can express compensating votes that undo the bias and penalize the manipulation. This user can then express those compensating votes, and get reputation in the network, as other users vote him up to get improved feeds. Thus emerges a distributed incentive for the community to root out untruths. As the community deliberates the best ways to find truth, they articulate the scientific principles that they find work the best. This is a very healthy, and much-needed dialogue for us to be having these days, with the crisis in scientific culture that we are all experiencing.

toomim··on Million: less than 1kb virtual DOM that is fast
Ah, this is important new information for me! I just visited the website, and looked for a virtual DOM API that I can use inside of my library. Unfortunately, when I read the actual "getting started", it showed me how to import react libraries for hooks, and use JSX, and so I concluded that:

(a) This is actually a React replacement, like Preact, not just a virtual dom.

(b) The homepage marketing is misleading! The project lost a bit of integrity for me at that point, and I started trusting it less.

If the homepage marketing is declaring it to be a virtual dom, then I want to see how to use the virtual dom API so that I can verify what it is! If it then on top of that has a React Compatibility layer, that's just awesome and makes me really excited to understand it, and I'll probably want to look at that layer so that I can see what React is beyond a virtual dom.

Anyway, do you have a pointer to how to use it as a plain old virtual dom? I happen to be in the market for one, right now!

toomim··on The Best iPhone
What do you do about the battery life on old SE's from ebay? Do you upgrade the battery?
toomim··on <article> vs. <section>: How To Choose The Right One
Does a screen reader actually care about <article> vs. <section>? I think they just ignore those tags.
toomim··on StretchText
Here's a cool guy who's entire homepage is one giant stretchtext!

https://andrewcantino.com/

It starts with three short sentences, but expands into three full pages once you've stretched it all out.

toomim··on We don't have a hundred biases, we have the wrong model
Thank you for saying so!
toomim··on We don't have a hundred biases, we have the wrong model
I wrote a PhD dissertation that made this point in 2013, and proposed a new "helocentric" economic model.

The key shift is to move the utility function from evaluating a future state of the world to evaluating the utility of an opportunity for attention in the present moment.

All the "cognitive errors" that we humans make are with respect to predicting the future. But we all know what we find appealing in the present moment.

And when we look at economics from this new perspective of the present, we get an economics of attention. We can measure, and model, for the first time, how we choose how to allocate the scarce resource of the internet age: human attention.

I dropped out of academia as soon as I finished this work, and never publicized it broadly within academia, but I still believe it has great potential impact for economics, and it would be great to get the word out.

https://invisible.college/attention/dissertation.html

toomim··on We could have universal Covid vaccines soon
You're ignoring ventilation, air filtration, sanitization, quarantining, and a bunch of other things.
toomim··on Study: Association between mask mandates and Covid infections in North Dakota
If I could choose between a society where 80% of people can read faces, vs. one where 90% can read faces, I'd choose the one where more people can read faces.

It makes everyone's life easier when more people can read each other's faces.

toomim··on Study: Association between mask mandates and Covid infections in North Dakota
The upside of having a developmental disability is that you have compassion for other people with developmental disabilities? Ok.
toomim··on Study: Association between mask mandates and Covid infections in North Dakota
Why don't you read the paper and address its evidence and logic instead of ignoring it entirely for an ad-hominem attack on the authors?

Ad-hominem attacks are worthless on any politically-contentious issue, because of course people are going to be trying to destroy the reputation of scientists who present data that opposes a political narrative.

toomim··on Study: Association between mask mandates and Covid infections in North Dakota
Children age 2-5 are learning faces and how to speak. If they can't see each other's faces and mouths, they don't learn a basic part of human interaction.

Think a little more broadly about "harm".

toomim··on Why is there no semantic ontology of sentiment in academic citations?
That said, I have hope we can solve this problem outside the academic incentive system. Here's a relevant prototype developed by my research lab: https://braid.news/about
toomim··on Why is there no semantic ontology of sentiment in academic citations?
As an academic, I find that positive or negative sentiment isn't expressed in citations — it's expressed in the review process before the paper is published. Once a paper is published, academics assume that it's already been vetted and is good, and the citations rarely bother to express agreement or disagreement.

When I cite a paper, I don't include a sentence saying whether the paper is good; I say why it is good, because the author of that paper is likely to be reviewing my paper, and I need to acknowledge his strengths before differentiating my work, or he'll kill my paper in the review process.

My advisor taught me that the point of a citation is not to give your opinion on which other papers are good or bad; it's to tell the editors which other scientists should be on your paper's review committee. The way editors choose reviewers is to look through the citations, find people cited who they know, and then ask those people to review the paper.

Thus, the author's goal when citing other work is to (1) highlight potential reviewers who would see your work favorably, and (2) say something positive about them to put them into a mood to see your work favorably.

There is nary an incentive to express negative sentiment in citations.

toomim··on Show HN: Every great read I've come across, compiled into a knowledge graph
What does the color of each node mean?
toomim··on Apple previews Lockdown Mode
> Messages: ... Some features, like link previews, are disabled.

I've been wanting to disable link previews for YEARS!! Not for security, but to keep those corporate advertisements (aka previews) out of the conversations I have with my friends and family.

It feels super disingenuous when I type out an articulate, heartfelt, personal message to my loved one, character by character, anticipate their reaction reading it, and then hit send — only to find the URLs expanded 400 pixels into corporate advertisements designed by the bonehead SEO jerks who care about clickbaiting over content.

toomim··on My quest for the perfect window manager (2004)
Sawfish was my favorite all-time wm, but it doesn't work well now. :-(
toomim··on Thunderbird 102
Nope. Mail.app removed it long ago. iOS mail has never had it. Even gmail is less info-dense than it could be, as it routinely increases the padding and margins for each message, even with the most dense view.
toomim··on Thunderbird 102
Noooooo...

The reason I switched to thunderbird is that it displays each email on a single line, which is sooooo much more information dense, and thus efficient! There's no better way to manage a large amount of email than displaying a large amount on screen!

toomim··on The SQLite Code of Ethics
That's not my experience at all.
toomim··on Tether is starting to depeg from USD again
It also has the advantage that it can't be inflated as quickly as fiat. You can't just print more.
toomim··on Cooperation among an anonymous group protected Bitcoin during failures
This paper acts like it's surprising that miners would cooperate and play by the rules:

> Although bitcoin was designed to rely on a decentralized, trustless network of anonymous agents, its early success rested instead on cooperation among a small group of altruistic founders.

But the Bitcoin whiteppaer says very clearly that it's designed to give miners and incentive to cooperate:

> The incentive may help encourage nodes to stay honest. If a greedy attacker is able to assemble more CPU power than all the honest nodes, he would have to choose between using it to defraud people by stealing back his payments, or using it to generate new coins. He ought to find it more profitable to play by the rules, such rules that favour him with more new coins than everyone else combined, than to undermine the system and the validity of his own wealth.

https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf

toomim··on I don't care about HSTS for localhost
Preach! Power to the User!
toomim··on What Is JSON Patch?
If you have a proxy, cache, or middlebox in your network, and you use DELETE to mean "remove this key from the JSON object" your proxy won't know that, and will happily delete the entire resource, and tell everyone else that the resource has been deleted, and then your data will disappear, and that's not very fun.
toomim··on What Is JSON Patch?
Yjs and Automerge are not patch formats. They are CRDT libraries. You are comparing apples and oranges. If you want to send Yjs or Automerge patches over the network, you still need a patch format.
toomim··on Syncing files between browser and disk using Yjs and the File System Access API
> would love an industry standard way of doing the merges automatically

We've been working on a standard for merging conflicts over in the https://braid.org group! This will let different tools (like filesystems and web apps) interoperate with p2p synchronized state.

We've made great progress already— JosephG's Diamond-Types algorithm can synchronize perfectly with Yjs, Automerge, and Sync9, just by swapping out a single function in the source code. Standardized sync is possible!

Come join us if you're interested! We have open video meetings every two weeks.

toomim··on What Is JSON Patch?
In addition to the other limitations, this doesn't let you edit strings. You can't insert text into a string, or delete text. This makes it useless for collaborative editing.
toomim··on What Is JSON Patch?
That doesn't work, because DELETE is defined to delete the entire resource. PUT is defined to replace the resource with the body, which would replace the resource with the patch. Only PATCH is defined to accept a patch and do something special with it.

Another option, though, is to use the Range-Patch spec from: https://github.com/braid-org/braid-spec

toomim··on TodoMVC App Written in Vanilla JavaScript
One way React can be faster than hand-written code is by batching all dom manipulation into animation frames.
toomim··on Moving a macOS window by clicking anywhere on it
You can move (or do anything to) a background window without focusing it by holding `cmd` while clicking or dragging.
← PreviousPage 13 of 34Next →