To enlighten you about nuance, think about this:
- Is driving a car the same as killing people?
- Is selling junk food the same as killing people?
1,203 karma · joined May 24, 2014
To enlighten you about nuance, think about this:
- Is driving a car the same as killing people?
- Is selling junk food the same as killing people?
1. Using QALYs seems ok w/r to covid, but not in relation to lockdowns. You say 4 days of QALYs lost per person and I'd argue that being unable to see your friends & family or do most activity is alike to being sickly (which is what is used to calculate QALYs). Maybe its not a 1:1 correspondance but lockdowns for 8 months (I'm not sure USA, I'm more familiar with Canada) have (imo) exceeded 4 days of QALYs per person by a long margin.
2. I have major issue with this line of thinking:
>I can be convinced that the lockdowns were too extreme, but it'll take solid analysis and it probably won't be fully measurable until a few years from now when we see follow-on effects.
It's a strongly held belief of mine that, in order to restrict the freedom of people (ala blackouts during WW2), you have to have a solid argument that what your doing not only outweigh the disadvantages, but far outweigh them. Restricting people's freedom is not like an economic decision. I believe this is what the general society has come to accept too (e.g. civil law has preponderance of evidence vs penal code which has abundance of evidence).
I agree that we can grant an "emergency response" where we are unsure of the risks, but I disagree strongly that this emergency response can last this long without a very strong case/public discourse that this is significant enough to restrict freedom.
Your daily paper didn't have a list of your interests yet succeeded in making money through advertising. Why can't they now?
I mean it in that Covid will look worse and heart disease better on a short scale, but in the grand scheme of things Covid will die down and heart disease come back, since you don't have immunity or vaccines against heart disease. That means that comparing (for the same year) covid vs heart disease is somewhat useless (since covid is an exceptional and short-lived event).
Fixing both problems will probably move deaths to another category (since that is the purpose of having categories), but the argument was that addressing covid has less benefits than addressing heart disease (mostly because covid addresses itself over time, whatever lockdown/mask wearing we do, but heart diseases do not).
Plus this doesn't take into account the reporting bias that seems to have been (be?) prevalent in 2019.
(Although it seems heart disease was still bigger than covid for 2020 [1] if compared to 2019 [2] in the us)
[1] https://www.google.com/search?q=number+of+death+covid+2020+u... - 561k covid [2] https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/deaths.htm - 659k heart disease
Stay-at-home orders/curfews are affronts to freedom. Derailing this to imply wanting to go outside at all is negligence is disingenuous. Preventing people from seeing other people over long period of times is known to be psychologically bad for human (and is a form of torture, see [1]. Although it is different in some ways, it seems clear its not good for the population well-being).
>nor a foolproof way (even now) to test everyone at-risk populations might come in contact with.
Don't let perfection hinder practicality. Keeping at-risk population away from infected people at a good rate is very feasible. It doesn't have to be foolproof (nor is it right now). It does not seem either harder or worse than what we are doing right now.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solitary_confinement#Torture
I don't think this is something you can claim without backing. I fail to see significant logic/empirical observations that make it seem futile to you that stopping the spread to a subset of the population is significantly harder than for the whole population.
>Do you really expect that the large majority of people over 65 could be protected effectively when the considerable majority of under-65 people to whom they are exposed (caregivers, food providers, relatives, etc) get covid?
Exposing the not-at-risk population would likely increase the short-term risk (all measures constant) but decrease the long-term risk to people over 65. Having a smaller population to focus on protecting would likely make their protection easier.
Even if you were right in that you would have more casualties from selective locking down (which I am unconvinced), would the increased death toil justify the freedom being messed with for the whole population?
how so?
so your probability of dying from one flight (all of the world considered - way lower for US afaics) looks to be 1 in 17 millions in 2019
[1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/263443/worldwide-air-tra... [2] https://www.statista.com/statistics/564717/airline-industry-...
Since that number is about the average risk of an american to die (and not the risk per flight), using it to calculate the risk per flight is erroneous
I think?
It's a breaking change for some users. I remember experiencing that bug.
There are multiple occasions in history where a landmark paper was laughed at just to be proven right later. It hardly matter the medium you use to publish.
That's a deeply flawed stance. The meaning of "reasonable person" changes so often as to be able to mean anything.
Isn't this the issue then? Assuming a north province can have taxes equal to e.g. BC and Ontario seems erroneous. What's the incentive in living in harsher climate, less populated area?
Are they? Black/whitelist feels way more natural to me. You can also say things like "blacklisted this ip" instead of "adding to the deny list" or something.
then it doesn't matter the address space size
What criminal act do you think applies here?
That seems like more of a net positive IMO. Theft of institutions must be less deadly/detrimental than the alternative. Even if people were to steal more from (say) Walmart than rob grandmas, it'd still be positive.
>And a net increase in usage will cause some % increase in DWI rates, overdose rates, health care impact, etc.
This might not be the case because of increase purity/social and institutional support because of destigmatization/re-invested profits taken from taxing the product.
Although true this is hyperbole. We're not talking about the "deadly protests" for BLM so why did the capitol protest become a "deadly insurrection"?
A lot of people are calling for Donald Trump to go to prison/etc; does that mean (if he was still president) he should stop talking to anyone saying so?