HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

totony

1,203 karma · joined May 24, 2014

submissionscomments
totony··on Convoy Crackdown – power to freeze bank accounts without trial or legal recourse
>because other protests do not greatly impact the ongoing lives of random unrelated citizens in the city who just happen to live in the area for weeks on end.

From my experience this is not true. Protests mostly involve discomfort to normal people.Be it BLM, occupy wall street, students manifestations, railroads blocking, etc

Maybe the scales of some are different, but calling this a "foreign-founded occupation" is disingenuous.

totony··on Convoy Crackdown – power to freeze bank accounts without trial or legal recourse
>it can be proven

The emergency act removes that requirement, which is what is scary. Not only can you not prove it, they don't even have to hold a trial (afaict)

Also that law was clearly not intended to be used against protests. Seems more aimed at organized crime.

totony··on Google Tag Manager, the new anti-adblock weapon (2020)
ML is already applied to spam mail, maybe it could be applied to JS runtime behavior to detect this kind of tracking. Fight ML analytics with ML
totony··on Official Response: Request to Freeze Canadian Edge Users’ Accounts
That's a specific order, to a specifics individuals. Plus, this is a legal matter and can have a back-and-forth in court. The emergency act allows freezing assets of anyone without a judge having its say. The scale is not the same.
totony··on Official Response: Request to Freeze Canadian Edge Users’ Accounts
>Why not make the protests less liveable?

Protesting during multiple weeks in winter is already unliveable. I live in Canada and would probably not do that unless the issue is life-or-death. Using extra-judicial means to quell opponents is not what our government should be doing, be it by freezing assets, preventing exchange of goods or other. One of the basis of modern democracy is due process and executive/legislative separation.

totony··on Official Response: Request to Freeze Canadian Edge Users’ Accounts
People that argue this seem unaware of how dreadful freezing assets can be. 30 days without funds means you can't pay any debt, can't pay for food, can't use transportation, etc.

I don't believe "The goal is to prevent use of assets right now to finance blockades," it's clearly an intimidation tactic against "undesirables."

totony··on Elastic and Amazon reach agreement on trademark infringement lawsuit
Licensing software accomplishes that, but you lose the freedoms OSS provides.

You also have to take into account that companies use OSS to gain adoption and pull off once they're established. This is why GPL and AGPL are essential. It ensure everyone has to contribute back.

totony··on Elastic and Amazon reach agreement on trademark infringement lawsuit
Nor should it, that's what OSS is about. Why should they not do what they want with your software? As long as it stays open it's OSS
totony··on Names of Canada truck convoy donors leaked after reported hack
Does that justify the doxxing? What about the informations of Canadians? Collateral damage?

Law enforcement has enough tools to investigate stuff like this. The public doesn't need access to everyone's information just in case it's "helpful."

totony··on Trudeau Invokes Emergencies Act
Couldn't they theoretically be forced to work with the emergency act? AFAIK it could be argued that they are providing essential services
totony··on Trudeau Invokes Emergencies Act
If only he enacted the policies he said he would enact instead of triggering all the emergency acts he can find. I'm still waiting for proportional voting (it's been 6 years)
totony··on Names of Canada truck convoy donors leaked after reported hack
I'm eager to see passwords leaks as well as all the other personal info leaks for the last decade be exposed then. Remember the Desjardins leak a few years ago? Is that OK?

I fail to see why a leak is considered "public information" to you or why specifically it's ok for this case but not equifax, desjardins and all the others.

totony··on Names of Canada truck convoy donors leaked after reported hack
Nitpick but parent said "no building were burnt down" and not "no crime was comitted"
totony··on Is Trudeau losing his fight against truckers?
>we're at around 90% vaccination rate

Vaccination rate doesn't relate much to mandates support.

>Reality shows otherwise - we'd be talking about an election if this was an actual problem politically, and an election simply isn't in the cards.

Canada very rarely triggers elections mid-term. Plus, the fact that the government is a minority already indicates people are not aligned with the elected government.

totony··on Show HN: EdgeDB 1.0
EdgeQL seems like a custom graphQL. Any reasons you did not follow dgraph's DQL or graphQL-compatible language? https://dgraph.io/docs/get-started/
totony··on Could we please get back the master-branch on this repository?
I may have misspoken, you can change the default branch after the fact, my issue was with the "auto-create README" feature
totony··on Could we please get back the master-branch on this repository?
As @zerocrates mentioned, it's about the github auto commit feature when creating a new repo. This makes bootstrapping using terraform more complicated.
totony··on Could we please get back the master-branch on this repository?
Yeah, ive had issues with repos on github having master and new ones having main. Github api seems to force the default branch to main (on new repos) making fixing this harder as well.

It's not that big of a deal but sure is a hassle.

totony··on /r/antiwork: A tragedy of sanewashing and social gentrification
I think the premisr of the proposition is that UBI makes housing assistances superfluous, since UBI should cover basic needs.
totony··on /r/antiwork: A tragedy of sanewashing and social gentrification
A lot of countries nationalised these services since they're essential. Nothing stops the US from doing the same.
totony··on /r/antiwork: A tragedy of sanewashing and social gentrification
The chart shows a slight negative for the very poorest (that are eligible for benefits - it doesn't seem to take into account the people that don't pay taxes, aka the very very poorest, who would presumably not see such a loss).

Although this is fixable by taxing more the middle class if that's what we wish to do (aka, not being "budget-neutral")

totony··on /r/antiwork: A tragedy of sanewashing and social gentrification
In an ideal world you would subsidize mental/physical assistance instead of giving them more money. It's both easier to do and fairer to those affected.
totony··on /r/antiwork: A tragedy of sanewashing and social gentrification
This is hyperbole. Removing loopholes and taxing the top 5% more will not destroy society. Just like taxing the middle class didn't make them stop working, or made them work shitty jobs just to not pay taxes.
totony··on /r/antiwork: A tragedy of sanewashing and social gentrification
See this post https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30248741
totony··on /r/antiwork: A tragedy of sanewashing and social gentrification
>The reality is that there aren't enough upper class people to generate sufficient tax revenue for a meaningful UBI.

What makes you think so?

There are a lot of discussion online about the costs/benefits of UBI. This article has an US-centric view on how this could be afforded

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/01/14/budget-neutral-universal-bas...

totony··on /r/antiwork: A tragedy of sanewashing and social gentrification
>So we are going to raise taxes on the middle class to give free money to people that choose not to work?

1. UBI aims to streamline redistribution of wealth and remove a lot of bureaucracy around it, reducing a lot of the cost of the current system

2. Why the middle class specifically? Upper class could shoulder most of the costs (if there are) easily

>I would not be ok going to work to pay people that have decided that they are fine living on the UBI and don't want to work anymore.

Then don't work. We already have taxes for things which are way less useful for society. You could choose not to work and live on with the bare minimum. That's the freedom UBI brings. Now probably you'd do something or another out of boredom which would end up being useful to society anyway. You'd just do it for free instead of having to convince someone to pay for it.

EDIT: A better way to put it is to see UBI as an investment into people instead of as a cost. You give them what they need to live so that, in aggregate, they can innovate more and worry less about making ends meet. Notwithstanding the fact that this is something we can do, for somewhat cheap and would help a lot of people.

totony··on Delta CEO wants U.S. to put unruly passengers on 'no-fly' list
Essential business. So now that person needs to rely on other people for groceries?
totony··on Facebook loses users for the first time
Yeah, I "log in" a few times a day to answer messages. I don't think that should be considered a user since I'm not consuming anything facebook-related, just responding to messages because everyone is on facebook
totony··on Facebook loses users for the first time
>walled garden

>links medium blog post which can only be accessed behind a login

totony··on The truckers shutting down Canada's capital
Have you read that link? I'm not familiar with all the intricacies, but from a cursory look these seem relevant:

>Certain areas of government action - some of which have become priorities over the years - are not specifically identified and assigned to one or both orders of governments in the Constitution Act, 1867. The courts have found that these areas come under various legislative powers, some federal, others provincial. Two such areas are the environment and health.

Federal:

>Regulation of Trade/Commerce

>Quarantine

This also doesn't seem to be set in stone as mentioned in "5. Court Interpretation of the Distribution of Legislative Powers." Neither does it seem complete, as e.g. it doesn't mention human rights as being either federal or provincial, while there is a lot of precedent of it being a federal matter.

EDIT: Also AFAIK most mandates are provincial bylaws that stem from the emergency act (which is a federal act)

← PreviousPage 4 of 30Next →