HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tpeo

924 karma · joined April 17, 2014

submissionscomments
tpeo··on How Economic Gobbledygook Divides Us
As far as I know, IS/LM hasn't been the keystone of anything since the 1970s. They've been mostly replaced by DSGE models for the purposes of macroeconomic policy. So I'm curious about what "standard macro models" you're referring to.
tpeo··on Crocker's rules
I did read the article, thank you.

What I meant is that I find it unlikely that in such a group there would even be a strong moral reaction to any issue in the first place. I don't know about the extropian mailing list, but take LessWrong members, for instance. They are quite shameless about the topics they choose. And they're not much given to non-cognitive criticism either (e.g. calling someone an ass). So calling on "Crocker's rules" would be just redundant.

What is the point of ignoring something that doesn't happen?

Edit: On the other hand, it relies on the assumption that there's a trade-off between civility and informativeness which just might not be there.

tpeo··on Crocker's rules
Who calls "Crocker's rules"? The guy who wants to start the discussion about the economics of slavery? The guy who thinks it's viable? The guy who thinks it isn't viable and anyone who thinks so should be shot? How does it work?

Furthermore, what's the point? I mean, if you're in a discussion group where there's a non-zero probability that one of it's members will pick slavery (or something else equally apalling) as a discussion issue, but group members are self-selected (which is a reasonable supposition for groups in general, and even more so for obscure mailing lists) then it's likely that all members are amoral enough for discussion purposes such that this "Crocker's rules" thing would be redundant.

tpeo··on How to get the wine you really want
If this whole process is dependent on your tastebuds, it will probably stop after a while.
tpeo··on How to get the wine you really want
I don't quite understand why you winos take your critics so seriously in the first place.

Critics are just people with opinions. Sometimes they can provide good justification for why whatever they're reviewing is good or bad. But not one of them is impartial enough that their opinion can be taken at face value, specially if you're not into the stuff they're pushing.

This is more obvious with film and videogame. It wouldn't matter at all if a critic I liked ever said that there's this one Adam Sandler movie that everyone should totally watch. I'm not into that crap.

tpeo··on Smoking “causes hundreds of DNA changes”
Well, this largely explains the vague cardboard smell and taste of commercial tobacco.
tpeo··on Why Do Millennials Hate Groceries?
Doesn't sound like it would work, because there are at least two problems with that.

The first problem would be a kind of rendez-vous game [0]. Given the available information, seller and buyers have to choose their location such that they maximize the likelihood of finding their couterpart. Whereas people might think "Oh! Don't mind if I do!" if they see an ice cream truck, that's much less likely with groceries. Generally, people walk into a supermarket with a general idea of what they're going to buy, if not with an outright list. If the seller has higher costs of moving around than his customers, he'll just pick a place as a fixed permanent position at or near his warehouse (a.k.a a "store") and make it known so that customers might come to him. An ice cream truck, on the other hand, will just move to where the crowds are.

The second problem is that grocers seem to compete on variety and price. While you could sell a large variety of products from a truck, you'd be able to get a higher return on your dollar if you increased scale (suppliers might give you discounts, for instance). So a fixed shop could offer as much variety as truck, but at a lower price.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rendezvous_problem

tpeo··on Why Do Millennials Hate Groceries?
You mean "opting out" without ever leaving the system.

Everyone can always opt out if they're willing to drop enough things. A trivial way to opt out is to commit suicide. But are other ways too, such as moving into the wilderness and trying to make it there on your own. And that's comparatively much "cheaper" in poorer societies, since there is less to give up.

For instance, whereas in Medieval times serfs might have ran away from their lords and into the wilderness in order to avoid law and taxes, the majority of present-day criminals are found and captured in their own towns, while disgruntled citizens consider themselves to have little option but whine when it comes to taxes.

"Late stage capitalism" does indeed produce enough goods and services that people have the option of opting out. There's some pretty neat survivalist gear for sale nowadays. But they never really do.

tpeo··on Argonne researchers posit way to locally circumvent Second Law of Thermodynamics
I'm no physicist, but isn't the cold a result of the second law? Or is the second law a consequence of the dissipation of heat?

Also, is thermodynamic entropy applicable to organized matter?

tpeo··on Argonne researchers posit way to locally circumvent Second Law of Thermodynamics
"There is no Dana, only Zuul."
tpeo··on The Benjamin Franklin Method: How to Be a Better Writer
Well, good writing is unlike mind control in that it's an actual thing. But I get the point: in the end, you've got to question yourself about what you're really trying to do here. What is it that you're trying to convey with your writing.

Which is why I've mentioned literature: if you do try to keep it all short and avoid anything but periods, all you'll manage is to sound like Hemingway. And there's more to literature than Hemingway.

tpeo··on The Benjamin Franklin Method: How to Be a Better Writer
Well, some think it was to show off their writing. Personally, I think it was feature of a more oral age, because run-on sentences and otherwise odd gramatical structure are way more tolerable when read out loud.

And if you're dictating to a scribe, or writing something which is intended to be a long spoken exposition of some subject (like a sermon or a lecture), then it's less likely that you'll pick on how odd they seem when read. More even, if the majority of readers does read things out loud (which might have been the case) then it won't seem as strange to them too.

tpeo··on The Benjamin Franklin Method: How to Be a Better Writer
These are good exercises, but you'd think that Franklin would have figured out some principles to writing beyond just trial and error.

If there's one thing which can vastly improve writing, it's knowing how to write in simple manner. And by "simple", I mean "keeping your parse trees[0] short". I don't know how computationally intensive parsing is on an universal computer. But I know from experience that trying to read a text with long run-on sentences or with obnoxious grammatical features (like an overuse of subordinate clauses) can feel like pure suffering.

And I think this advice largely emcompasses those recommendations like "keep it short", "be direct" or "always use a period, never a semicolon". Because if you keep away from baroque parse trees, at least you won't be a bad writer.

In the popular sense, at least. If you're writing literature, you can do it freestyle. You can do a whole page of flow of consciousness, have footnotes on footnotes on footnotes, whatever.

[0] : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parse_tree

tpeo··on Anti-Intellectualism and the “Dumbing Down” of America
Hitler wasn't democratically elected. The Reich Chancellor was appointed by the President. It just so happened that then president Paul von Hindenburg was convinced by people on his staff to form a coalition government with the NSDAP, which had around 40% of the popular vote.

Point is that, although people often point to the Nazis as some failure of democracy, they didn't sweep into power by a landslide election (Hitler ran for president against Hindenburg and lost). They were strong, but nowhere that strong. It took a lot of political maneuvering and dirty tactics until they finally seized power by exploiting the Reichstag Fire [0] in order to pass two decrees [1][2] which essentially made Hitler a dictator.

Furthermore, although Nazis were anti-intellectuals, I don't think that was the key to this whole process.

[0] : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reichstag_fire

[1] : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reichstag_Fire_Decree

[2] : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enabling_Act_of_1933

tpeo··on Why the Industrial Revolution Didn’t Happen in China
You mean your particular sect of christianity.

Christian Gnosticism and Catharism are just two historical christian sects who denied the reality of sense-perception, and who were purged for that. Not to mention christian mysticism, specially that of Meister Eckhart, or Spinozism, or any Neoplantonist interpretation of christian tradition. Christianity isn't a single theological or even metaphysical tradition, but a multitude of ones pinned to a more or less single oral tradition embodied in the bible. Specially, christianism doesn't entail physicalism.

Furthermore, I don't see what's exceptional about "the world" being "real". Even the Eleatics and the Neoplatonists would've agreed to that, granted that "the world" be their "One", even though they asserted that sense-perception is illusory. If these words are taken in their most general sense, then this proposition becomes a platitude. You might as well say that "whatever is, is". And no one has ever seriously argued that nothing exists (Gorgias of Leontini did only in jest).

tpeo··on Why the Industrial Revolution Didn’t Happen in China
I am not a historian, but the Romans seem to have grown at the expense of weaker and more disorganized foes, who either didn't have any form of centralized leadership prior to contact with the Romans (like the Gauls and Iberians) or who were pitched against eachother in civil war (like the Egyptians). When fighting against similarly sized centralized states, like Parthia (or Carthage, in the early republic), they had a much harder time winning anything out of them. I think they mainly exploited a preexisting assymetry.
tpeo··on Seattle: Highest Minimum Wage, Lowest Unemployment Rate
You're right in pointing out that there might be unnacounted variables which might confound the impact of the minimum wage hike. But the majority of people running around saying that higher minimum wages cause unemployment do so on the basis of an overly simplified model (the standard partial equilibrium from Econ 101, where they're looking only at supply and demand curves for labor under complete information).

Once you start weaking some conditions (using a search and matching framework instead of contracting under complete information) and adding confounding variables (like economy wide-effects or consumer credit restritions), not only your conclusions might change, but you might actually get a better model. Academics have some grasp of this and are much more subdued in their conclusions, specially when coming from pure theory. Pundits, however, are paid to be clueless. And I think this is the true insight of this submission.

tpeo··on Why It Took So Long to Invent the Wheel (2012)
Streets and roads aren't useful only for wheels. Try taking a mile-long walk through a (seemingly) flat field and through a paved surface as an experiment.

The first one will be much bumpier and tiresome than the second for any given speed, and you'll be at a higher risk of injury due to careless step. And the benefit of having a flat surface is greater the more rugged is the terrain that must be crossed. This is why, though the Incas didn't use the wheel, they had roads nonetheless. And the Romans, too, built their own roads mainly for the speedier movement of their armies while on the march.

tpeo··on Soylent halts sales of its powder as customers keep getting sick
I mentioned power poses and psychology because it occurred to me as an example since you happened to mention psychology. I don't personally have any knowledge regarding your attitudes towards psychology nor did I intend to frame what you said in any way.

Prior findings must be indeed critically evaluated. That's not the issue. The issue is refusing to even acknowledge them or to acknowledge current field wisdom due to some unwarranted sense of superiority. Taking the dangerous and daring approach to crossing expertise fields instead of being careful is fine, of course. Everyone is free to do whatever they want! But if the daring do fail, they will look like complete asses. They had been given plenty of warning before hand.

And, this is the key and the real reason why I'm saying all this, the daring will fail more often than the careful. The most frequent reason why people try to enter a new field is because they think they might have some superior insight on the matter, whereas the development of each field is chiefly constrained by the amount of data available to it. Ideas are never in short supply relative to data. This isn't to say that outsiders can't make meaningful contributions, or that cross-field collaboration is useless, far from it. But that there isn't much that can done beyond what's warranted by the data.

I'll pass up the opportunity to talk about Musk, because I don't feel I'm qualified to do it.

But as for your nitpick: I don't see why top performers incorrectly gauging their own ability would be "okay". They would pass up great opportunities because they perceive their ability to be lower than what it actually is, and they might experience unwarranted anxiety and feelings of inadequacy (something like an impostor syndrome) if they incorrectly perceive their ability to be lower that that of their peers. There are many ways in which this might not be "okay".

tpeo··on Soylent halts sales of its powder as customers keep getting sick
There's a difference between "thinking for yourself" and "uncritically discouting past work". And that's the difference between asking yourself whether power poses really work and and coming in kicking doors, yelling that psychology is bullshit. First one is engaging in very much reasonable level of critical thought, whereas the second is just thinking "Dunning-Kruger is okay, when I do it".

On a side note, I don't quite get what Elon Musk has to do with this. Isn't hea millionaire paying big bucks for expert engineering talent to put his rockets up in the air?

tpeo··on American Children Are Drowning in Self-Esteem
"So common" compared to what?
tpeo··on Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015)
That's a great example of a mutually beneficial but morally repugnant trade, but markets generally don't coerce people in this sense. Markets more often reach the fairest possible solution given an initially unfair situation (say, where one side has a gun and the other doesn't), and the fairness or unfairness of the whole thing depends on how property rights were initially allocated.
tpeo··on The “432 Hz vs. 440 Hz” conspiracy theory
I wouldn't say that's the case for most songs, but rather only for simple melodies. But yeah, a graver voice would sound better in most cases.

Consider the beggining of Bach's "Little" Fugue in G Minor (BWV 578), where the subject of the fugue is first introduced by a soprano voice and then repeated by an alto voice, while the soprano voice does the coutersubject. I'd say that, played in isolation, the melody sounds better when sung by the alto voice. But lowering the whole Fugue by a half-step wouldn't make it much better.

tpeo··on The “432 Hz vs. 440 Hz” conspiracy theory
Well, I'm assuming that the ease or difficulty of recognizing the difference between two notes bears some proportion to difference between their frequencies (the frequency of one minus that of the other), and not just their relative frequencies. The intervals in the 432Hz are "tighter" in the sense that, because the interval they correspond to in 440Hz is smaller for every possible interval, there are more notes in 432Hz tuning in any given arbitrary frequency range (say, from 100Hz to 1,000,000Hz) than in 440Hz tuning. And this makes the problem of recognizing them harder. I should've made this out clearer.

For instance, a half-tone from 432Hz is 457.69Hz, which gives out a difference of 25.69Hz; but a half-tone from 440Hz is 446.16Hz, which gives out a difference of 26.16Hz. Between 432Hz and 864Hz we can fit a whole scale, while in the same frequency range we'd be missing a note with 440Hz tuning.

Of course, this is a slight difference and it might not be noticeable at all. I personally don't hear much difference between the two tuning. Instead, I'm playing devil's advocate.

tpeo··on The “432 Hz vs. 440 Hz” conspiracy theory
Well, I'm not a sound engineer, but I think it's conceivable that 432Hz tuning might sound better due to entirely non-mystical reasons. From the perspective of harmonic entropy, or at least I think so, the tighter differences between each notes' frequencies and that makes the problem of fitting intervals into ratios harder.

I recognize that this bit is entirely personal, but I think that can make otherwise "simple" music more enjoyable. But my enjoyment of music is almost entirely dependent on the careful management of the "Wall of Sound" effect and by how much noise (in the form of timbre, attacks, number of different voices) is introduced or removed from the track. And I think that's the key difference between, say: a library piece, or a movie score; and pieces meant to be listened on their own.

Also, the expression "cargo cult numerology" pretty much made my day.

http://sethares.engr.wisc.edu/paperspdf/HarmonicEntropy.pdf

tpeo··on To influence people don't try to persuade them, use ‘pre-suasion’ instead
I did read the article. But I didn't consider the first bit as a throwaway, and this might be the key issue here. If there's a situation where priming might work, it's when the person being primed has either no particular opinion on that issue or when they're in agreement with it.

I personally have strong priors against the effectiveness of advertisement and propaganda. I don't think the effects of these things are robust to different behavioural patterns and to increases in public awareness. So I didn't think of the first paragraph as a 'throwaway' bit.

tpeo··on To influence people don't try to persuade them, use ‘pre-suasion’ instead
And it has the potential to fail catastrophically for the guy doing this, too.

Can anyone still take the other side in a negotiation (or any other situation, really) seriously if it becomes know that they're trying to pull this parlor trick? Whoever is found out doing this would seem both ridiculous and repellent.

Like a pickup artist.

tpeo··on Primary Model Predicts Trump Victory
Care to supply examples?

But yeah, ideally the media should as unbiased as it is realitistically possible. If things are truly bad, then they'll be recognized as such without the need to distort the truth. The media can only hurt itself by willfully manipulating the message, since that undermines the public trust on journalists, whose impact on the public is crucially dependent on that trust.

It's a "boy who cried wolf" kinda scenario, or sorta like how everyone rolls their eyes when an "X causes cancer" headline pops up. If journalists choose to trade their credibility for anything else (eye-popping headlines, ads revenue, or subserviency to whomever is bank rolling them) they're paying it with their relevancy in the minds of the public. And if journalists really conceive themselves as on a moral mission, that's the last thing they should do away with.

tpeo··on Facial Recognition’s Threat to Privacy Is Worse Than Anyone Thought
Just (adverb):

1. Exactly.

2. (ironic, oblivious) Used to imply that an otherwise impossible task is just the opposite.

Time travelling is possible. We just need to get our hands on some of that negative energy.

tpeo··on The power of prediction markets
This doesn't seem useful. Innovation has an always unpredictable character, in the sense that it might occur in unlikely places. Unforeseen consequences might make workers no better than chance in predicting the outcome of the majority of product changes.

On the other hand, if something which is obviously wrong is being pushed by management despite all evidence and opposition, in all likelihood, that's because neither one has any bearing on the it's advocates ability to push it nor it's willingness to push it. It might be less an issue of right or wrong, and more one of shameless corporate politics.

I'll look a Taleb reference for the innovation bit.

← PreviousPage 11 of 14Next →