HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tpeo

924 karma · joined April 17, 2014

submissionscomments
tpeo··on New paper: “Why most of psychology is statistically unfalsifiable”
Isn't this simply maximizing the probability of a successful reproduction? Seems almost obvious given the whole problem was low reproducibility in the first place.
tpeo··on Brain training exercises might just make you better at brain training exercises
>"If I ask one of these adult students a question involving negative numbers, and I phrase it in terms of money and debt, they answer it immediately. If I ask them using just numbers, they have no clue."

There's an even more extreme example with street kids in Brazil who had de facto knowledge of mathematics (they worked as peddlers) but weren't able to do the same thing they did during daily life in a school setting.

I wouldn't say that concept transfer is a skill, however. The two things that come to my mind when I think of the issue of transfer are: the feeling of a student being hung up on a particular problem, anxiously waiting for a solution to come up to his mind; people who seemed to try to tackle lots of different problems from lots of different angles (Wheeler, Feynman). So it seems to me to be more constrained by openess to experience on one hand (the willingness to try and fail) and creativity (willingness to look for and propose solutions) on the other, both of which are more like inclinations than skills.

https://www.maa.org/external_archive/devlin/devlin_05_05.htm...

tpeo··on Opposition to Galileo was scientific, not just religious
Well, at least for some populations [0][1] women do have fewer teeth than man, and this difference increases with age. So Aristotle could've been onto something.

[0] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17917610

[1] http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00784-010-0445-3

tpeo··on ‘Security Fatigue’ Can Cause Computer Users to Feel Hopeless and Act Recklessly
The phrase "security fatigue" makes me raise an eyebrow. Are these guys implying I should keep track of twenty or thirty passwords, but I just can't keep up?

Frankly, if it's not something I use everyday and care about, I can't be bothered to put a strong password in it.

tpeo··on The Next Industrial Revolution Could Put Millions Out of Work
Good point. It's quite possible that there's a fundamental limit to technological achievement and that we just haven't reached it yet.

On the other hand, I'd like to say that it's also possible that some particular processes can follow exponential laws without any restriction. It might be somewhat hazy, but what if outside of a few measures (infant mortality, life expectancy, etc) economic progress is nothing more than a subjective measurement of how present consumers value past output?

I'm not saying anything new here, both Easterlin's paradox and the idea of a "hedonic treadmill" support the idea that more income doesn't necessarily equate into increased happiness. And specially in the case of economic innovation, which might not actually be technically interesting or require any "new physics" at all - just mashing some current technologies into a marketable product - it might never ever stop, and will just degenerate into an endless chase of ever changing fads. Past economies wouldn't be particular poor, just particularly quaint, and a repository of dead fads.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Easterlin_paradox

tpeo··on The Next Industrial Revolution Could Put Millions Out of Work
Well, if it takes some time for workers to shift sectors and if "creatively destructive" technological innovation on the other hand happens to accelerate, it's conceivable that at a certain point, the absolute majority of workers will be redundant. There won't be an equilibrium, because the workers are trying to chase an accelerating point while moving at a constant velocity.

There doesn't need to be anything "fundamentally different" except that we finally reached the exponential part of technological progress, which up until now seemed like a linear process. Just like population growth until 1800s, or economic growth until the 1820s. Those two were pretty much linear and not very different from zero until they weren't.

I don't actually subscribe to this rationale, though. I'm just putting it out like this because it's pretty much what everybody says and I recognize that it's quite plausible, given the two first hypotheses.

tpeo··on 3-Mile-Long Nazi Resort Being Resurrected as a Luxury Getaway
Frankly, "extreme left" seems far off. But I also find personally that whatever "left" and "right" mean nowadays cannot be extrapolated past 20 years or so. Prior to the 20th century, otherwise "right-wing" governments were perfectly comfortable with pursing interventionist policies, because "right-wing" back then meant pretty much "whatever will keep the monarch in power", and entailed a respect for tradition. Bismarck, for example, didn't see any problem in creating the first social welfare system in the world so long as it politically undermined the socialists and it made the monarchy popular [0]. The overwhelmingly mercantilist policies of the Ancien Régime, seeking to impose price regulations in order to improve it's trade balance or to keep the monarch popular (one of the possible causes of the French Revolution was the havoc created by the deregulation of the grain market by the classical liberal Turgot [1]), is another example. It's only during the 20th century that the left-right distinction seems to have mapped itself onto overwhelmingly economic rather than cultural issues.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_Socialism_(Germany)

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flour_War

tpeo··on People are actually drilling holes in their iPhone 7s to make a socket
I get that you're probably using the word in a more popular sense, but I don't see what "logic" has to do with this. Correct inference has to start off from somewhere. If a person had literally no idea of what they were doing, they wouldn't be able to judge whether it's doable or not either. Teaching a kid logic wouldn't prevent him from believing Santa Claus was real, but teaching how implausible is it for someone to circle the globe on flying reindeer visiting every single child's house during a single day might.

I find it hard to believe that there are people actually drilling their iPhones, though. I mean, no matter how clueless they are, they could've still googled it, right?

tpeo··on Why You Need More Than Passion to be Successful
I've had some repeated discussions about this, whether to swim or float. I've so far defended the swimmers, but I'm not myself sure of what anyone should do.

Hiding the light might be a way to failure. But showing it might doesn't seem to be a guarantee of success either, specially if the light ain't that bright. And this is where the bottom line is for most people: "would I rather be rich and bored, or poor but living the dream?"

tpeo··on Two Out of Three Young Millennials Now Use an Ad Blocker
Ads can be completely acceptable so long they don't detract from the user's experience. If loading times weren't so ridiculously afflicted by adserving and tracking scripts, then things would be fine.
tpeo··on It Costs $30 to Make a DIY EpiPen
>This is the inverse of the anti-marketplace argument that capitalism leads to monopolies

I don't think I have heard such an argument, and I understand the parent comment just fine.

What he means is that, since pharmaceutical and medical supplies companies have large upfront research costs coupled with negligible marginal costs, they face a falling average-cost curve. However, a firm operating under competition has it output at the point where marginal and average costs are equal. The point is that for a firm who profits off research, reaching this point is unfeasible. What all this economic gobbledygook is that, in order to survive, firms have to charge above what would be otherwise the "warranted" price (like the price of the components and labor that go into a kit).

This is more obvious in the case of software, since the cost of copying any piece of software is pretty much zero, anyone trying to sell it for it's marginal price won't ever get what he put in by having written it in the first place. In such markets the socially efficient outcome, the one which makes both consumer and producer better off, is actually to have a single or few firms regulated firms operating under imperfect competition. And all this happens because of the cost structure of the firms, not because of the market itself.

Though I'm rather skeptic that pressing on the suppliers will push them near their marginal costs in this particular case.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_curve

tpeo··on Bad science persists because poor methods are rewarded
I don't think such a system would work out, or at least it would breed a huge amount of resentment towards it. Vaguely reminds me of Legalist philosophy: it attempted to "abolish penalties by the means of penalties", that is, through a liberal use of (capital) punishment not only for criminals but for their whole families, so that no one would dare commit a crime.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legalism_%28Chinese_philosophy...

tpeo··on A study on human behavior has identified four basic personality types
Well, these guys aren't psychologists: they are physics PhDs doing (judging from the name of their group, Grupo Interdisciplinar de Sistemas Complejos) some work with agent-based modelling and game theory. They seem more like econophysicists (or economists) than psychologists.

I don't think this categorization is gonna get popular enough to hit the tabloids (you won't be filling up quizzes to see whether your significant other is 'Envious' or not), but it might be relevant to social science.

tpeo··on A study on human behavior has identified four basic personality types
I wasn't previously acquainted with the term "operationalization" as used in this sense.

Okay, it may turn out that this categorization is no better than Humourism, which seem to have suffered of the issues of poor variable operationalization as you described: ancient doctors frequently heaped together distinct phenomena ("hot" meant anything which was hot to the senses, whether it was a glowing hot iron, a flesh wound or a bowl of Jalapeños). But I don't think it's quite the case here: they're grouping users by their choices in a game. That's well defined enough, isn't it?

The names don't arouse any suspicion to me, either. I think it's just a case of researchers trying to "sexy up" their findings. It's something that might happen almost involuntarily: either because they started with a sexier model in their minds, or because in seeing their findings, it just came up to their minds and stuck there. I'm actually rather hard pressed for real examples right now, besides calling the transfer of a quantum state "teleportation" (because I just readn about that today), but it's something that happens quite often.

tpeo··on A study on human behavior has identified four basic personality types
Well, all things have to start somewhere. Right now, it's just some curiosity thing, but maybe it will turn out useful.

It could already be for making simulations using agent based models with "realistic" hypotheses by feeding in the strategies and the frequencies corresponding to these personalities into the model. Could be useful to social science research already.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agent-based_model

tpeo··on Distant languages have similar sounds for common words
Ugh! 'Pirl', 'pirl'! What a nasty tinny sort of word.

But I do wonder how much of the similarity they're talking about here is accounted by phonoaesthetics, and how much of it might be simply due to some inevitable coincidence (like Zipf's law being applicable to gibberish texts). I mean, common concepts seem more likely to be referred to by short words, and there are only so many short words that can be formed with a given number of phonemes.

Shouldn't some repetition and similarity be expected from that alone?

tpeo··on In the current immigration debate, neither side is revealing the whole picture
I'd just like to point out that interest rates are really unlike any other policy instrument. Compare them with other policy instruments (regulations, taxes, social programs, public works) and you'll see that they're more easily changed and create much less hassle among voters. Plus, they have a much more obvious impact in people's pockets and welfare, at least from the viewpoint of the voters.
tpeo··on Show HN: Encouraging STEM Using Advanced Math in Music
Check out Dmitri Tymoczko's "Geometry of Music".

https://www.amazon.com/Geometry-Music-Counterpoint-Extended-...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NnvynOyZI-Q

tpeo··on Teen Creates “Sit with Us” App for Bullied Kids
Kids do judge, that's the point of bullying. They don't care about whether they might act inappropriately in a adult sense, but they still care about what others think of them.

The real difference, I'd say, is that kids are very easily bored. They get majorly annoyed if they don't have anything to do for more than three minutes, so they leave no time for awkwardness: they'll either pester everyone around them for attention until they either get a playmate or just get tired and start playing alone.

Plus, pretty much all kids know how to play pretend, so it doesn't take much for them to be playmates. Or at least it didn't take much in the far distant past of 2001.

tpeo··on Most Danish voters oppose government plans to cut the top rate of income tax
The situation you're referring to, where older citizens own more assets than average, might indeed seem obvious in Canada but it might not be the case at all in any country with a differently structured social security system, since the decision to save money for a rainy day or not is directly affected by the availability of social security.

In a country with an ageing population and with a pension system overwhelmingly funded by intergenerational transfer, then voting for tax cuts is optimal for young voters. In a country where pensions are mostly funded by private savings, then sure, taxes are nice.

tpeo··on Six big economic ideas [pdf]
Well, I don't know how much uninformed about economics you actually are, but I think that at least part of this perceived verbosity is due to you being acquainted with it through stuff aimed at lay people. The Economist is a sort of popular economics reporting magazine (a "pop-econ" magazine). The stuff they write is aimed at a general audience.

Though admittedly economic articles are do seem verbose when compared with math or physics articles. But there's a lot of variance in their verbosity, too: theoretical articles are pretty much just math. Empirical guys on the other hand are always somewhat verbose, as they like having some plausible stories behind the mechanisms they're testing or to explain why their instrumental variable is exogenous. The literature of subfields are/were almost entirely verbose, such as in the case of the old institutional economics.

I'd say that it all boils down to: how wide the intended audience is; how established is a field or subfield is; how do new articles fit in with the older literature. When all you've got in your head is some hazy philosophical point, trying to formalize it from the outset will probably just alienate you from the discipline. So older literature will be, on average, more verbose than current literature. On the other hand, if all people do is point out more and more new issues, and if every new article is "orthogonal" to each other, they might never produce a succint framework (in which case it all turns into philosophy). And this goes for other fields too: mathematics was a verbose field too until some of it's ideas became common sense, and so was physics. Economics is still undergoing a lot of changes, and will probably undergo a lot more as economists focus themselves on narrower issues and as more data is collected.

tpeo··on Many Kenyans refusing basic income experiment
I wonder if TV hinders economic growth and development. In so far as urbanization goes, the story that I was told in Urban Economics was that as farming productivity went up, the opportunity cost of time went down and so people took up other trades in addition to farming. When an hour less of farm work didn't mean starvation anymore, people had the time to sew, bake, build, etc. And over time, things which were probably hobbies developed from cottage industries to actual industries.

What entertainment does is drive the opportunity cost of time back up by increasing the pleasurableness of leisure time. Now, that probably isn't much of an issue for actual underdeveloped countries. I don't think anyone would prefer to sew their own clothes when they can buy perfectly fine ones for a lower price unless they're obsessed with self-reliance, and no one is missing out on these homemade goods either. But in a society where it's plausible that a hobbist might produce some really neat stuff on their own, encouraging passive entertainment might mean some less neat gadgets in the long run.

tpeo··on Revolt against 'rich parasites' at Burning Man Festival
I don't recall where, but I once read that the largest number of people that can be gathered in a group without splitting into factions is something like 7.

Quite a harrowing thought.

tpeo··on Nero’s Rotating Dining Room [video]
Well, revolving restaurants [0] were somewhat fashionable in the 1960s. Still, I don't think they quite compare with something made in the actual 60s (early christian era). The tech behind Nero's revolving diner was probably pretty bold at the time. But it doesn't sound so cool for someone who has motion sickness.

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolving_restaurant

tpeo··on Thinking at the Margin: It's Revolutionary
Exactly. It doesn't make sense to compare the top individual of one ability's distribution to the average individual of another. There's a world of difference between a top football player and the average football player. I'd expect ability to be distributed along a power law, just like wages are.
tpeo··on The Complexity Barrier (2003)
Open standards and modular design, I'd believe. It's easier to handle a mechanism with recognizable and well-known parts. Proper documentation would help too.

I'm not so sure hardware has gone this way, though.

tpeo··on How Trolls Are Ruining the Internet
I'd say it's very improbable to starve trolls by not giving them attention. So long as the community is receiving new members and the new members aren't acquainted with it all works, there will always be someone there to feed the troll. Think of it as a corollary to the Eternal September.

That being said, I think there are people post garbage regardless whether they're given attention or not. Kinda like the people who carve dicks and swastikas at bathroom stalls.

tpeo··on The worst predicted impacts of climate change are starting to happen (2015)
I find it hard do believe that most would argue that the market will solve this issue, unless they're deeply ignorant of mainstream economics. Pollution is a classic example of a negative economic externality [0], and markets generally don't "fix" externalities unless:

- merger costs are low enough that the people afflicted can buy out the polluter;

- transaction costs are low enough that they can reach a mutual beneficial bargain (as per Coase)[1];

Both of which are impracticable. I won't even talk about the first solution. As for the second one, Global warming affects everyone across legal boundaries, so bargains are off the table.

But I don't think the third solution is currently applicable either, which is the government stepping in. Who would step in? There isn't a world government yet, and the interests of national governments are much more likely to align with the polluters located in their territory than with with an Indian peasant whose crops just died because of the heat. Even if several governments committed to an agreement, it could be profitable to deviate from the agreement by enforcing and requiring lower environmental protection standards in order to attract investments from polluting industries.

It's kind of a hard problem.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Externality

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coase_theorem

tpeo··on FBI chief Comey: “We have never had absolute privacy”
>We should not expect more privacy from law enforcement than we would from any other stranger.

I don't understand THAT statement. I'm pretty sure that the degree of privacy I expect from strangers is far greater than the one currently expected from the FBI or from any law enforcement agencies. I don't expect strangers to tail me or to run profile checks on me, much less call to try to get into my phone to check whether or not I'm really up to something funny.

tpeo··on Traffic Wouldn’t Jam If Drivers Behaved Like Ants
Wouldn't a surprise "lane reduction" due to an accident alone be enough to account for the traffic jam?

Imagine that there's an accident in a single lane. The remaining lanes now have to take in all the other drivers from the accident lane, while these drivers decelerate and attempt to take the remaining lanes at speeds lower than the average speed. Yet single car cutting in line could trigger the deceleration of the entire remaining lane (like in "traffic wave" models). The cars in this lane then try to cut into another lane, and so on, such that the whole traffic is impaired. And this keeps going on for every cohort of cars reaching the accident area, producing the traffic jam.

This is my intuition of it, at least.

← PreviousPage 12 of 14Next →