HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tpeo

924 karma · joined April 17, 2014

submissionscomments
tpeo··on Scientists discover the first brainless animal that sleeps
The only issue with this idea is that it really ... doesn't tie in with evolution. Because ultimately, the default state of any organism should be to be attempting to reproduce. But I stress "ultimately", because there's nothing which impels us to think that needs to be the case at all times. Idling can be a successful short-term strategy, even if not in perpetuity.
tpeo··on Anatomy of a Moral Panic
Contemporary journalism indeed doesn't have a monopoly on terribleness, as you've mentioned. But this is actually the point. Because if I'm really going after the heart of this criticism, it really doesn't matter if I understand the selection function over all stories in the newsroom as an actual algorithm meant to maximize clicks or as some hazy set or rules of thumb and prejudices meant to maximize advertisement revenue. The point is that neither maximizes either the informativeness of a story nor the likelihood of it being true.

Also, I don't actually "remember" the Spanish-American war. I understand what you mean, but this is an awkward way to put it.

tpeo··on Anatomy of a Moral Panic
To answer the second question, a financial journalist might not take up a hedge fund management position on the basis of the risks involved, career stability, hedonic factors, etc. besides the purely monetary gains involved. Understanding something doesn't imply that's also the optimal course of action.
tpeo··on Anatomy of a Moral Panic
I'm starting to believe that there isn't such a thing as reputation when it comes to news. Or rather, that low quality news has such little impact on readership due the strategic nature of news reading (e.g. even if you might not like a certain news organization, you might still want to read it, if only to know what other people are reading) that a news organization can coast indefinitely on a readership built on it's prior reputation.
tpeo··on Tulipmania: More Boring Than You Thought
I feel so glad that we finally live in the future. Such a shame how terrible it is, though.
tpeo··on Consciousness Goes Deeper Than We Think
No new words are needed. What you need is that people stop conjuring new words to explain the same things over and over again, using and re-using words under different meanings without ever bothering to either listen or read their predecessors properly, which only leads to feelings of ineffectualness and a strange sensation of déjà vu.

When authors in the philosophy of mind stops rehashing ideas that could and most likely have occurred to 17th century philosophers for the sake of attaching their names to a publication, then it will see some progress.

tpeo··on Centralization of Bitcoin Wealth: 4% of addresses own 96% of Bitcoin
Jesus, who thought that chart was a good idea?
tpeo··on We've failed: open access is winning and we must change our approach
When politicians mention "capping energy bills", that means trying to cap final consumer tariffs. What I mean by "price-cap" is a regulatory model which determines how governmental contracts for public utility might be written. It's also called the "RPI-X" regulation model.

It does not determine final consumer tariffs directly, but instead establishes a maximum revenue per KWh for the regulated firms. And this model has been in place in the UK's transmission and distribution sectors since 1990.

Also, you cannot choose who distributes energy to you. If you could, the sector wouldn't even need regulation. But you can choose who supplies that energy. These are two different sectors, and they're regulated in different ways. The distribution sector is a natural monopoly, while the energy generation sector isn't.

tpeo··on The Sorrow and the Shame of the Accidental Killer
None of this has nothing to do with what I said.
tpeo··on The Sorrow and the Shame of the Accidental Killer
Carriages were certainly dangerous, but the death rates from carriage travel wouldn't be immediately comparable to those from car travel since the rise of the latter changed the geometry of cities.

In so far as the city became more car-centric, they also became more dangerous to pedestrians. Wider streets and longer stretches of road encourage drivers do go faster than they would otherwise, as in a narrow lane or turning a corner.

But these also mean longer crossing and travel times for pedestrians, such that they are more exposed to accidents on average.

tpeo··on Kids Praised for Being Smart Are More Likely to Cheat
Reminds me of chapters eighteen and nineteen of the Tao Te Ching. Specially the third and fourth lines of chapter eighteen:

"When wisdom and intelligence are born,/ The great pretense begins."

But I'm not entirely sure if it's a permissible interpretation of the text.

tpeo··on We've failed: open access is winning and we must change our approach
If I'm not mistaken, the UK uses price-cap regulation in electricity distribution, which is one where government just sets a maximum per unit price for electricity. The standing charge only pays the cost of maintaining his own individual connection to the network, but the fixed cost of installing and maintaining the distribution network go into everything else in the bill. So an UK's consumer "variable" electricity costs are actually the firm's fixed costs.
tpeo··on We've failed: open access is winning and we must change our approach
Why do you say that you pay more for the variable part?
tpeo··on We've failed: open access is winning and we must change our approach
Zero marginal cost doesn't imply that the product or service in question has no value. Rather, it implies that producing has no value to the firm. But it can still have value to potential consumers.

As an example, take any market with natural monopolies. It costs nearly nothing to a company working with electric power distribution to serve an additional client in comparison to their fixed costs. But the client still wants their electricity.

tpeo··on Why do we keep using Facebook?
It's not like having and using Facebook is necessarily unfeasible for people who aren't crazy about it, which makes that a bad metaphor. Having a case of "sour grapes" over Facebook makes as much sense as having a case of "sour grapes" over pie. Just go out and buy some if you want. But what makes it a really bad metaphor is that the likelihood of someone using Facebook or not on a daily basis depends on how much value they attach to it. But why would anyone resent others for doing stuff that they don't care about?

Now, if you think Facebook provides with you with something of value, good for you. You're using a service and you're happy about it. But that says nothing about the preferences of others.

tpeo··on Why do we keep using Facebook?
How much does the average user actually use Facebook, specially nowadays?

I'd be rather surprised if the total amount of time spent on Facebook didn't have something like a power-law distribution. The only reason I have an account at all is so that, in the unlikely event that I might be notified of something that I actually care about or that someone might try to reach me, I'll know it. And I'm sure that is true of at least a portion of other users.

Having Facebook today is like having a landline seven years ago. I wonder if in seven years Facebook will only be used for marketing, too.

tpeo··on A Thought for Your Pennies: Micropayment and the Liberation of Content (2009)
I think saying that people might trade arbitrary portions of data instead of some specified standard is missing the point. People already can trade arbitrary portions of data in the absence of previously agreed standards. The real issue, specially for curation, is how to choose standards for what qualifies as "content" within a certain medium in order to maximize the likelihood of meaningful communication occurring within that medium.

Which doesn't seem easy.

tpeo··on A Social Network That Costs 10¢ to Post
Oh, now I see. I think that I should thank you instead, for clearing that up.
tpeo··on Fingerprints are usernames, not passwords (2013)
If a passcode is available in the world, it can be grabbed and intent can be feigned just as well.
tpeo··on Fingerprints are usernames, not passwords (2013)
I was really thinking in biometry as used in a more ordinary situation, like a laptop fingerprint reader. With the most likely form of malicious behavior here being that of identity theft by a small-time attacker. Having to dodge biometric sensors or trying to avoid having your photograph taken at protest are more an issue of surveillance, either by government or by private citizens.

Sorry for not making myself clear at first, but what I mean is that passwords aren't a sufficient guarantee of intent either. If anyone has access to them, they can spoof someone's identity. I reckon that this doesn't really fit a civil rights discussion, because we haven't (I think) reached such a point yet, but government-backed attacker might spoof someone's identity in order to either infiltrate or hijack a civil organization. Essentially, a virtual mole.

tpeo··on Fingerprints are usernames, not passwords (2013)
That's a very interesting perspective! But you must recognize that it's a very abstract approach, no?

I mean, when someone identifies themselves through biometry, there's clearly an element of intent. And if they write down passwords on sticky notes, or anywhere else really, it's about as available as a fingerprint is, if not more.

tpeo··on A Social Network That Costs 10¢ to Post
From observing the behavior of some people online, I think that there are people out there who just like to write stuff, regardless of whether anyone might read or care. This can be good or bad. I've read good posts from clearly forgotten blogs. I've also read in certain communities posts so inane and out of context that it's hard to even understand why they were written in the first place.

"Shitposting" in it's strictest sense is very much an example of the latter, because it's a repeated pattern of stupid behavior which doesn't even qualify as joking, and which is repeated regardless of whether people pay attention to it or not. It's like drawing swastikas on bathroom stalls.

tpeo··on A Social Network That Costs 10¢ to Post
Depending on the nerdy and tiny social network, I would pay way more than ten cents.
tpeo··on A Social Network That Costs 10¢ to Post
Having some limit to posts is an interesting idea. But I don't see much of a return on investment for the users in this approach. Why should I pay to have people see my post? Shouldn't I have to pay people to see their posts instead?

Anyway, all of luck to them. I'd like to know what might develop from this.

Though they really should have asked for two cents instead of ten. I mean, come on: how could you miss this?

tpeo··on Teenage Pregnancy in England: Do Parents’ Educational Expectations Matter (2014)
You can delegate their education to someone disciplined and with lots of willpower, if you're up to it. Mind you that, though you made a non-hypothetical question, this is a hypothetical and speculative answer. I'm not suggesting that you send your kids to military school. But it's interesting to think that a lot of parents might have already faced this problem in the past and that that might have been their solution to it.
tpeo··on Why Are Some Countries Rich and Others Poor?
Assume that all these countries have had different levels of exposure to slavery, meaning the total amount of GDP can be attributed to slavery, and that would be thus lost if they abolished slavery and refused to trade with companies or individuals which use slavery (e.g. place an embargo on American cotton unless it's certified).

I mean, it's a fair assumption: slavery was abolished in France in 1794, in the United Kingdom in 1833 and in the United States in 1865. Germany mainly traded with it's European neighbors, which didn't use slave labor in their territories.

Then how can all these different countries have similar levels of GDP per capita and similar growth paths, despite their different levels of exposure?

Furthermore, there currently poor countries which relied on slave labor for much longer. Brazil only abolished slavery in 1888. Morocco, in 1922. And if we include serfdom, Russia, in 1861.

Unless you mean metaphorical slavery.

I grant that it would take much more sophisticated analysis in order to properly exclude any confounding factors, but that's kinda the point, really. I don't think you really thought this through.

tpeo··on Why Are Some Countries Rich and Others Poor?
I think you give too much credit to economists as propagandists. Pretty much any other kind of social scientist receives way more space in the media than economists do. And an educated layman seems way more likely to be acquainted with the Milgram experiments or with the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis than he is to be acquainted with comparative advantage. Specially today. Back in the 1970s you could have seen Milton Friedman and John Kenneth Galbraith exchange passive aggressions through their own TV series (respectively "Free to Choose" and "Age of Uncertainty"). I don't know of a contemporary equivalent.

Unless you literally mean that they're making justifications for the ruling class and have them as their captive audience. Which, I'm ... rather tempted to agree. Unfortunately, people have a self-serving bias, and like paying people to say what they want to hear.

tpeo··on Why Are Some Countries Rich and Others Poor?
Well, the submission itself has a section entitled "Institutions". Institutional economics is a field of economics that studies the impact of the strength, stability and overall design of "institutions", in the widest possible sense, on economic activity. Stuff like the impact of the credibility and strength of property rights or the impact of minority rule, for instance, goes in here.

Growth theory, or rather development economics, studies how and why wealth grows. And here go ... pretty much any economic growth models. I really don't know how else to say it.

Finally, an institutional approach to development economics studies how institutions might cause nations either grow or not, depending on their institutions, and the guys who kick-started this approach were Daron Acemoglu of MIT and James Robinson, of Chicago University. They have a book on it called "Why Nations Fail", released in 2012, which has already been recommended by another commenter. Their main thesis being that certain patterns of colonialism induce certain patterns of institutions, which they call "extractive", by which a minority appropriates most of a country's wealth for itself, while setting the country on a low growth path. The classic example being a resource-based economy under either a minority or authoritarian rule.

If this all sounds really general, that's because it is. I haven't read much on institutional economics, much less on the economics of colonialism. But I know it's out there.

tpeo··on Why Are Some Countries Rich and Others Poor?
Yes, there was. It is literally called "The Great Divergence".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Divergence

tpeo··on Why Are Some Countries Rich and Others Poor?
I'm not sure what you think I suppose to mean. The economic impact of colonialism is already an active area of study. I'm just pointing out that it exists.
← PreviousPage 3 of 14Next →