924 karma · joined April 17, 2014
Oh, man... correlational studies... shame they didn't directly link to the article, too.
Anyway, it's not really a presumptions question. Or at least, it wasn't supposed to be: the fact that people are doing something doesn't imply anything about what they should do, and neither does describing their choices imply anything about either the socially preferred set of choices or the authors' preferred set of choices. So if young men were putting in less work hours so they could stay at home and play video games, that would be nobody else's business.
But the issue is that that doesn't to be the case, and the authors made no effort of trying to tackle alternative explanations. When I read an economics article, I expect that even if the authors won't try to address alternative explanations, they will at least acknowledge they exist. After skimming the article, that doesn't to have happened at all.
Don't know how the authors want me to believe that video games are to blame for the lower working hours of young males when they followed closely the working hours of older males up until 2008, either. Are they gonna pin it all on Halo 3?
Could be interesting to see what will happen to big media conglomerates, though. The day that any form of media is regarded as reliable as witness testimony, it will all start being treated as such. Suddenly, a video can't be taken seriously unless it is independently corroborated by some other organization. That could be a push towards diversity in news reporting.
On the other hand, the ability to forge events also enhances the impact of credibility, which pushes the whole sector in the opposite direction.
Plus, the faithful themselves were very skeptical of them, and lots of people were charged with impiety for expounding this kind of stuff. Specially so in the case of Spinoza and Kant.
Cue to Whitehead's "a series of footnotes to Plato" quip. Though I think he was a bit off the mark. People aren't merely talking about Plato, but unwittingly echoing him. It's kind of like that another quote, this time from Keynes, about practical men being "slaves" to the opinions of long dead economists.
But it's good that you mentioned the Hemingway article, because the difference between that article and this interview highlights pretty well what's my issue with trying to "reconstruct" Camus from quotes. A living person is able to perceive as well as react to context. What questions have been asked, who's asking them, what is the level of understanding of the world, where we are ... these all might be grouped into "context", and the point is that they're all relevant in conversation.
Now, when a person takes up the mannerisms of someone else, it doesn't really detract from their ability of adhering to context. But when they're trying to "reconstruct" a person from things they've said at some point for the purposes of an interview, while trying to preserve those quotes to some degree, there can never be such a close fit between question and answer because each was made in different contexts.
Another way to look a it: what the author did is essentially search the Camus corpus for continuous segments of text which most closely fit his questions. But the answer which Camus would have most likely given could depend on discontinuous segments of text. This is actually pretty common in academic literature: whenever people are trying to reconstruct the meaning of certain concept, like Aristotle's "entelechy" or like Kant's "noumenon", sometimes we have to refer to different passages of the relevant corpus in order to get a clearer picture of what it might have meant. And there's an interaction between these passages, because they don't just heap over one another as in a concatenation of disjointed facts, but instead build upon another. The interaction between different passages might actually change the perceived meaning of individual passages. If there were a living person to answer these questions, whether it be Camus or just someone who really knows Camus, he already has these higher degree interactions in his head. He doesn't have the excerpts of text, he has the model which generates them. So if there's any question which might warrant a more subtle or complex answer, he'll able to do it. Maybe even a question which wasn't previously considered by Camus and for which we can find no immediately relevant passages in the corpus.
My issue isn't that this is some bit of necromancy, but rather that it is a Procrustean bit of necromancy. I wasn't skeptical because there's some degree of uncertainty either (though I think that in between chopping text and answering based on some model there would be less uncertainty regarding the latter), I was skeptical because I think this is an awkward and useless approach. It doesn't "reconstruct" anything, it merely deconstructs the Camus corpus.
Link : http://www.chicagofed.org/digital_assets/publications/workin...
Which I think can be fine, specially if the experts don't have a great track record (e.g. economics and psychology). But it can also get absurd pretty quickly, like when people point out some huge snowstorm in their town in response to "global warming", as if that proves anything.
Also, I disagree that this is "The Rise" of anything in either case. Think tanks are recent, but they've been here for a while. But someone peddling some (seemingly?) shallow understanding of the world for money is probably old as the hills. Certainly older than the sophists, older than Mesmer and his animal magnetism, as well as older than any sort of quackery or intellectual sleight of hand in historical memory.
Talking about this as if it were something new, and with allusions to Gramsci to top it off, just strikes me as making it as unnecessarily ominous.
Also, I don't see why, for instance, there wouldn't be something like a population where everyone only tries to date as many people as possible. Are you assuming that people wouldn't ever date the same person again?
Actually, could be a nice quirky film - and profitable too. Romcoms are cheap to shoot. We're past peak American-romantic-comedy (I think) so the whole "ugh, not another one" factor might be actually pretty low in 2017. So yeah, could be pretty nice.
About the Roman bit, the real issue would be how much of any direct monetary gain from conquest ended up in the hands of the Roman state rather than in the hands of private citizens.
If he meant only that war currently has no financial value, I don't see why he'd make references to Assyria or Rome. Because whatever value those peoples derived from conflict wasn't most likely in increased treasuries, but instead in the extension of land and in the number of subjects, which in itself can be very valuable things to warlike societies as it improves their ability to wage war, either by increasing the defensibility and depth of their borders or by making them able sustain larger armies.
I've might have read him more generally than he meant, though. But still, I don't see the need for such a specific reading.
>There is no downside to this
I guess that whoever wrote this piece didn't consider that it also increases the likelihood that some poor white guys whose political positions are way farther to the right from the author's own than Ted Cruz's positions are get into Congress.
But short flight times don't really have to be the case, because it seems that they can fly for extended periods of time: one of NASA's balloons stayed up for 46 days [0]. The US air force also uses balloons as surveillance stations, though I don't know the actual flight time of these [1][2]. JLENS was supposed to stay up for 30 days at a time.
[0]: https://www.nasa.gov/centers/wallops/news/supertiger-record....
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tethered_Aerostat_Radar_System
If what's bugging you is why lighter-than-air vehicles aren't used for commercial transportation, that's an entirely different issue.
It's very much like saying that there would be no traveling without maps (or perhaps without navigation). At a glance, it is wrong. But it seems a fair and reasonable statement if it's interpreted as if saying that if people had no way of telling where they are or at least where they're going, then there would be no way of "traveling" from or to anywhere. There would merely be wandering.
Just imagine that the job becomes like a surrogate to the persons' actual identity. They identify with their own job and think it makes their lives meaningful even though they might intensely dislike it. For instance, the people I've met who work in medicine who were very much like that - one of my best friends went through med school. Where I live doctors often work long hours besides having extremely stressful jobs (and so take self-comforting addictions like smoking, caffeine abuse and drinking). It seems as if they're often led into the profession by rather unlofty motives like pay or prestige, but I also know that many give some inherent value to their work because they're helping people. Would they'd be better off in another job? I know it's not up to me to tell, I feel as if many would. Specially the ones very much sensitive about patient loss. Because it's a hard thing to deal with anyway, but it hits them the most.
So yeah, I think that someone might stay in a profession he might not actually personally like for some arbitrarily long periods of time. At least in principle. Don't know how it might apply to other professions though, because I don't see why people would keep programming for ethical reasons - unless they're deathly afraid of the coming machine revolution.
Can't say that you can really tell what's on his mind.
I've only seen the movies (and read the wiki too), so I could be wrong.
Suppose that automation can be automated. Not that implausible, really. Will we just sit in a corner waiting through eternity on the machines to appear on their own?
I like theorizing too, but we've gotta live in the meantime.