HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tpeo

924 karma · joined April 17, 2014

submissionscomments
tpeo··on The Average Student Does Not Exist
>Out of 4,063 pilots, not a single one fell within the average 30 percent on all 10 dimensions.

I wondered about a very similar problem some weeks ago. I was bothered about the terms "ectomorph" and "mesomorph" because they seemed useless once you considered height: the vast majority of "ectomorphs" seemed to be taller than the average while the vast majority of "mesomophs" seemed to be of average height, so there's no point to these words. And so I wondered how would shoulder width would change given height (which seems to have some kind "decreasing returns"), and how the average measures would relate to actual average build. I mean, is the "average guy" really the guy with the average height and average shoulders? Because it's not as if the scale had just changed, like doubling the size of a cube, but there seems to be some deformation going on as well.

Anyway, didn't get past the wondering phase at the time. But I think it's too much of an important problem to be casually thrown as part of a pitch. I don't see an immediate reason why the average tuple should be the tuple of all averages, because some of the variables might be "dislocated" and thus not coincide with the averages of other variables. Some guy might be very close to average height yet still somewhere in the left-tail when it comes to body mass, shoulder width or any other measure. So there might be a typical student, but I don't think this is the way to find him.

tpeo··on Ask HN: What projects are 20 years ahead of their time?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Xanadu

I want to believe.

tpeo··on Infosys accused of racism
It cannot be a stupid question if there are hundreds of books on it. I know what you mean, but that's no way to get your opinion across.
tpeo··on Uber rolls out in-app tipping
Oh, I forgot about rating! It indeed should act in the same way as tipping, but not necessarily to the same degree. It's possible, for instance, that the change on a the driver's earnings conditional on any new rating is lower than the tip that he'd get from a new trip. Even more so as a driver's rating is the average rating from all his recent trips.

If pulls a 5-star service for 499 customers and a 0-star service for a single customer (for whatever reason) his rating drops from 5 to 4.99, which doesn't seem that relevant. Unless a 0.01 drop in his rating means a loss in earnings greater than that of a lost tip, the tipping system would provide better rewards for not dropping the ball.

Forgot about the social pressure, too (I'm not American). That could be a real issue, because if people don't actually consider not tipping then it's just dead as a incentive scheme. They'd have to make tipping anonymous.

By the way, I don't think pressure under anonymous choice is "social". You could attribute it to education and thus society and some way but ... that's rather roundabout. I think the more appropriate term is "consciousness".

tpeo··on A Pioneer in 'Flat-Fee Primary Care' Had to Close Its Clinics
What you're describing looks a lot like adverse selection.
tpeo··on Uber rolls out in-app tipping
Never thought about the economics of tipping before, but if having the customers being able to punish unhelpful staff increases the odds of having returning customers, that would increase the likelihood of Uber drivers being better paid under competition. The only issue is whether Uber drivers have a comparable outside option.

As for the bit on sincerity, can't say much as nowadays I just find it totally alien. People gotta live somehow, be it with others or just with ourselves. So getting hung up on the porcupine's dilemma and whether every interaction we make with another person is like a hundred tiny knifes running across their face is a great way to miss the point: sometimes their words hurt me too. But I don't show it, because I want to drop it and go back to the point.

Although I reckon this is more of a "honest" fakeness rather than the giddy fakeness which is sometimes found in customer service.

tpeo··on 'A reckoning for our species': the philosopher prophet of the Anthropocene
>complexity theory wiki

Wait, there's a wiki on complexity theory? Computational complexity or the complex systems kind?

I don't find the term as obscure as a I find it offensive: it just sounds wrong. But yeah, there are plenty of terms like that in any field, whether they be obscure or just irksome.

tpeo··on 'A reckoning for our species': the philosopher prophet of the Anthropocene
That word - "hyperobjects" - has deeply hurt my soul.

Why do people come up with things like this?

tpeo··on Ether Is the Digital Currency of the Moment
Is that what you meant by having to appeal to "soul"?

There still doesn't need to be an appeal to anything in material in order to define worth, not anymore than one needs to appeal to something immaterial do define weight in terms of mass. Have the utility of water be proportional to the thirst of the person, where thirst is also a definable physiological state, with "worth" being a scale factor. Thus "worth" would have a uniquely defined value regardless of person or situation.

Or at least that's one way to do it.

tpeo··on Ether Is the Digital Currency of the Moment
>Nothing has an inherent worth, unless you postulate the existence of "worth" as an immaterial label, like "soul".

It seems odd to me that if the utility of anything were a physical thing as measurable as the mass of any physical object that thing wouldn't still have an "inherent" utility/worth. Are you thinking about "inherent" in the sense of have some sort of Platonic existence? That would be a very odd way of using it.

Either way, since utility is unique up to scalling (e.g. Johnny could get as many times of it from a sandwich as Paul does from a near-identical sandwich), at least in choice theory "worth" is closer to having an "inherent" character than otherwise. Though this is somewhat of a stretch because these kind of comparisons are invalid.

tpeo··on Conglomerates Didn’t Die, They Look Like Amazon
"Conglomerate" is a latinate word for "put together", which is to say that it doesn't immediately refer to the idea of a parent company with controlling interests in several subsidiaries over different markets so you're bound to pick up different uses of the same word. For instance, "conglomerate" is also a technical term in geology. Just check out the hits from the 19th century.

Also, I'm wary of using n-grams to infer anything about the relevance of concept because there are such things as intellectual fads, and some expressions might suddenly hit public consciousness and later fade away without the idea it referred to ever becoming any less relevant. MacLuhan's media theory, for instance, became an intellectual fad in the 1970s and MacLuhan hit celebrity status. Later on, it faded away, but I don't think what he was describing became any less relevant. This kind of stuff is noticeable to anyone, though they might be hard pressed for examples: just try and notice how the buzzwords in your field changed over time.

The expression "multinational corporation", as well as the word "globalization", were also fads of the 1970s too. At the time, they were more like academic fads: researchers started taking notice of these things and suddenly they became "a thing" among academics as it was a frontier research topic. Later on they hit public massively, probably peaking around the late 1990s and early 2000s with the 1999 Seattle riots, the FTAA debates and just the overall shift towards massive multilateral agreements coupled with shrinking governments. Nowadays neither of the two is as "in" as it was back them either in political or academic debate, but the concepts themselves aren't any less relevant. Or at least that's my two cents on the whole issue.

tpeo··on Conglomerates Didn’t Die, They Look Like Amazon
>The conglomerate was supposed to be dead, a relic of a bygone of era of corporate America.

That's not even close to being true. How does someone get a job on a supposedly reputable newspaper writing such daft shit?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_conglomerates

tpeo··on Ask HN: What business can I create around avid readers and book lovers?
A little less dusty and more convenient alternative to a library.
tpeo··on How the Mid-Victorians Worked, Ate and Died (2009)
Guess I'm wrong about that then! It's hard to skim an article with this much noise-to-signal ratio.
tpeo··on Social Cooling – How big data is increasing pressure to conform
"Knowlesdgee"?

Anyway, I think you're forgetting one important dimension: whether the person in question would like that particular piece of information to be known.

tpeo··on How the Mid-Victorians Worked, Ate and Died (2009)
It's a comparison between people aged past 5 in both populations. It's not that unfair.

If you want to talk about unfair comparisons, you should look to all the people aged past 5 who wouldn't be alive without modern medicine (e.g. most terminal patients, some severe burn patients, some people with congenital defects, etc) and who inevitably lower the average health measures of our current populations. There's some seriously strong self-selection bias at work here: as medicine advances, the difference in health indicators between earlier and later adult populations would always be increasingly favorable to the latter.

tpeo··on How the Mid-Victorians Worked, Ate and Died (2009)
That's not what a 90% reduction in the incidence of degenerative disease means. If degenerative disease occurs to 1 in 1000 people, a 90% percent reduction would be from that to 1 in 10,000 people. There's no need to make that claim.
tpeo··on Death pools can bring financial security for the long-lived
The incentives involved are completely different. Pensioners don't directly benefit from the deaths of other pensioners, as their individual payments are unrelated to how many pensioners are out there. They aren't drawing from some collective pool of money that has been invested in some interest paying account, but are rather either drawing from their individual savings or are living off money raised through taxes in the case of state pensions. In both cases their own pension payments are independent of payments to others.

[Which IMO makes tontines sound even more sucky, because it encourages free-riding when it comes to how much people put in.]

tpeo··on In Praise of Boredom
Toys always have been around, sure. But their quantity, variety and complexity (note: I include video games here) has massively increased through economic development. A hundred and twenty years ago the median American child might have had a rag-doll. Seventy or so, a teddy bear. Twenty years ago, a whole collection of dolls and toy-figures.

In so far as simpler toys require more imagination than complex toys, I still think that the effective level of creativity required of children has fallen. But I think the issue you've put forward is fair enough: there's not much* reason to believe that the potential level of creativity of children has fallen. Children might have much higher creative potential than they're currently exploiting, in which case they'd be able to adapt.

*: If performance on tasks involving creativity is positively related IQ, that coupled with the Flynn effect would suggest that creativity has increased over history. I call this "not much reason" because I'm not to sure why the Flynn effect exists and I don't think the researchers are sure yet either.

tpeo··on Athens, Sparta and Rome: The Ancient Election
Maybe they "thought" it was "weird" retroactively after the Peloponnesian War. Athens was mishandled pretty badly after it's defeat by the pro-Spartan government of the Thirty Tyrants. That on top of being at war with Sparta for more than twenty years would have made them pretty averse to anything Spartan.
tpeo··on The hidden ways that architecture affects the way you feel
Diverse urban landscapes is something that I can get behind, but the issue (as I see it) is that there's something else at play here. Mixed-use, for instance, is already well justified as an urban policy by contemporary urban economics. Designing streets in such a way that they're easier to navigate is something that is already well motivated by contemporary behavioral agent-based modelling of urban landscapes (besides being an idea which is probably as old as urban planning itself).

It's the idea of some immediate psychological response to the environment like that of the stress level of a passerby to a facade that bothers me, because it reminds me too much of stuff which IMO hasn't been particularly useful in urban planning, such as the broken windows theory. There's no immediate inference that can be made from the immediate psychological response of a passerby to the behavioral response of a urban population to the same environment over long periods of time. There plenty of neighborhoods in this world that might look like shit but which aren't actually shit, and most often neither do the plainer houses in a given neighborhood house people any worse than their neighbors. But in so far as lots of money might be wasted trying to "solve" these issues, the whole idea to me sounds to me like a massive red herring.

tpeo··on In Praise of Boredom
I think that at least in some situation the opposite should be true, in so far a person's ability to daydream might depend on their creativity. Given a sufficiently high ability do day dream, the day dreamer is never bored, no matter how stimulus poor the environment is.

I think a good comparison would be how children have come to rely more on toy-play over imagination-play over the years (or centuries). Not long ago, kid might have had pretty fun day with nothing but a stick and a pool of mud (to use George Carlin's imagery). But if you took a contemporary child and blast them through a time-machine some fifty years into the past, they'd be massively bored once they got there (besides being somewhat shocked because of the whole being-kidnapped-and-shot-into-the-past thing). In this case, past children were more creative, but also less prone to boredom.

tpeo··on The hidden ways that architecture affects the way you feel
So, what I'm reading is: "Architects to phase in eye-candy as they find out bare walls to be unedifying".

Is this an overly cynical reading of the article?

tpeo··on The hidden ways that architecture affects the way you feel
When you're trying to put furniture in the room, trying to fit something with a rectangular base in a room with a rectangular plan is much easier than any other similar problem while minimizing the likelihood of having any wasted space.

Plus, it's also much easier to change the configuration of the room, or to transfer one piece of furniture from one room to another. So even if people weren't just lazy about how to fit perfectly pentagonal furniture in their houses, so long as they were trying and testing new shapes, furniture would probably evolutionarily converge to something squareish.

tpeo··on How some people stay motivated at work when they don’t love their jobs
Funny how the first thing that appears when you open the article is some guy pouring a drink.

Turns out it's not for him (I think) nor did the guys at QZ intend to suggest it was, but I just interpreted the picture in a whole different way.

tpeo··on An anti-ageing startup is offering transfusions of blood from young people
It's the future that you chose.
tpeo··on How to Own a Slave (2016)
I think you've understood those words in precisely the opposite sense in which he meant. A possible implication of "provided the company stayed around" is that it was around that time that they started going through a major phase of mergers, closures and downsizing. And, if this was his meaning, that's just Taleb obliquely and wryly stating that the 'company man' era was over.
tpeo··on CEOs Want Their Offices Back
Possibly because having cubicles for each employee creates the expectation that each employee will stay at their cubicle. Walking up to a colleague's cubicle to chat about a work-related project can be misconstrued by an uninformed observer as "not working". This incentivizes employees to stay in their own cubicles.

That is the simplest way I can think of by which we might come to the usual "cubicle hell" scenario where workers are stuck from 9 to 5 in their cubicles while being occasionally nagged by management (as in Office Space).

tpeo··on Why It’s Time to Stop Punishing Our Soils with Fertilizers
The issue with injecting nitrogen in the soil isn't about the nitrogen's source, but it's impact on the carbon content of the soil.

>There has been some research showing that these high nitrogen inputs are destroying the carbon in the soil. Because the microbes use up the extra nitrogen and then they really tear the carbon out, creating lots of CO2, rather than sequestering it in the soil. So there is evidence that excessive nitrogen actually causes more carbon to leave the system. Whereas we need more carbon in the soil rather than less.

tpeo··on Leonardo Da Vinci’s To Do List (circa 1490)
What makes you think they aren't as curious as you?

They might just be into different subjects. Plus, if there's nothing that suggests that you might be interested, they might self-censor comments about their own hobby subjects when talking to you.

← PreviousPage 9 of 14Next →