HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tpeo

924 karma · joined April 17, 2014

submissionscomments
tpeo··on Italian doctors successfully transplant a kidney in the place of the spleen
The issue with spleen and black bile in humoralism isn't that it overproduces it, which it doesn't, but rather that it overaccumulates it.

>“The gall, placed in the concave of the liver, extracts choler to it: the spleen, melancholy; which is situate on the left side, over against the liver, a spongy matter, that draws this black choler to it by a secret virtue [emphasis mine], and feeds upon it, conveying the rest to the bottom of the stomach, to stir up appetite, or else to the guts as excrement.”

~ Robert Burton, Anatomy of Melancholy

tpeo··on Rents are plunging in the most expensive U.S. markets
I'm sorry to say it, but you're mistaken. The opportunity cost of time is decreasing over income, since the marginal utility of income is also decreasing, and these things should be equal in equilibrium.

It seems somewhat counter-intuitive, because the high income worker might be much more highly paid than a low income worker, and thus gives up much more in monetary terms than the low income worker. But the value of an additional dollar isn't the same for these two workers, since it's also a function of their present income. An hour work missed could mean a low income worker this week's lunch or his kid's medicine, whereas for a high income worker it often means just a little less money in his savings account.

I won't touch the issue of having children, because I don't think anyone has quite yet successfully tackled human reproduction. But when it comes to commuting, all workers in an would be interested in reducing their commutes. Richer workers can afford higher rents because their wages are higher. But that still doesn't mean that their marginal utility of income is higher than thay of lower paid workers.

It's somewhat unintuitive, because often people go through Econ 101 without trying to understand what a decreasing marginal utility of income means. But in Urban Economics, the falling opportunity cost of time is the mechanism which allows cities to form, first from cottage industries, as the agricultural productivity grows. So it's a standard argument.

The whole overall effect is that queues benefit the richer among the eligible for whatever they're queueing for.

tpeo··on Low social status 'can damage immune system'
Given how seniority (older being more dominant) was supposedly the major predictor to dominance ranking, it doesn't seem as if the macaque's ranking criterion reflected any kind of genetic fitness.
tpeo··on Low social status 'can damage immune system'
I'm skimming through the study, thanks to Sci-Hub. The researchers did account for the impact of grooming and harassement on the immune system.

We next investigated the behavioral mechanisms that give rise to social status effects on gene expression, focusing on NK and helper T cells where the observed effects were strongest. Mediation analysis revealed that rates of received harassment—a measure of the agonistic, competitive element of social status inequality— contributed to these effects for 17.3% (helper T) and 7.8% (NK) of rank-responsive genes, respectively. However, in rhesus macaques, dominance rank also influences affiliative social interactions (15). Grooming rates mediated rank effects on gene expression levels for 17.6% of genes in helper T cells, comparable to the results for agonistic interactions. In contrast, grooming behavior was more important than harassment for rankresponsive NK genes (n = 560 genes, 33.4% of all rank-responsivegenes; chi-squared test P = 1.33 × 10e−74)(Fig. 2, D and E). A lack of positive social interactions may therefore be equally or more important than social subordination per se in shaping social status effects on gene expression, consistent with the known effects of social integration on health and mortality in both humans and other primates (16–18).

tpeo··on Rents are plunging in the most expensive U.S. markets
Price controls in competitive markets are usually a bad, bad idea. Rent controls, for instance, are famous among economists for managing to both disrupt rent markets while failing to achieve their desired outcome, which is helping poor tenants.

The effect of a price ceiling is often just to shrink the supply of any units whose price would be above the price ceiling, while consumer queue themselves. It would be the same as rationing. And since the opportunity cost of time of richer folks is lower, not to mention that they're more likely to be socially connected, they end up displacing poorer consumers.

tpeo··on Don't Lower Corporate Taxes, Abolish Them
It's easier to convince people who have no priors. The majority of people doesn't ever consider the temperature at the polar ice caps unless they are climate scientists, so they'll take accept it easily. But lots of people with a folkish understanding of local weather, specially after some huge snow storm, will mumble something like "so much for global warming".

Even if you put all methodological issues (and citations from Richard Feynman) aside or even whether corporate taxes work or not, lots of social science findings would seem dubious simply because they deal with human behavior, which is something which is almost impossible to not have an opinion on, specially because it attempts to describe our own behavior.

The problem is that, if I were to understand reality through my own behavior, it would be through an unwarranted generalization of my own conditions to the population as a whole. It's like that joke of "why don't they just buy themselves some money?".

That's one of the issues, at least.

tpeo··on Our Favorite Narrative Cliche: A World Filled with Idiots (2013)
It took me a while to get what you're at, but I think you're up the wrong tree. Because when Brin used the word "institution", what I understood was something like "layers of abstraction" that you're referring to. Because that's what institution means in economics (or at that's least one it's senses, since it's an incredibly wide concept). That is, rational organized collective behavior. And not some arbitrary top-down bureaucratic structure.
tpeo··on Our Favorite Narrative Cliche: A World Filled with Idiots (2013)
Transcendence, Interstellar and Gravity. I haven't actually watched neither Interstellar nor Gravity, but from what I know neither of them portray technology in a bad light. But Transcendence does overall portray technology in a good light, though the majority of the movie is just the movie makers playing with the audience's luddite fears.

Still, it's a damn bad movie.

tpeo··on Inside a Fake News Factory: ‘This Is All About Income’
If you see that much of a difference, you weren't being cynical enough.
tpeo··on Urban Train Track Doubles as Shopping Alley in Thailand
This probably already is a huge violation of many safety regulations in Thailand.
tpeo··on 'Millennium' is full of gratitude for the staggering advances of 1,000 years
I don't think it does. For one, people have an intuitive understanding of basic arithmetic regardless of whether they're educated or not and this can be improved through practice.

On the other hand, it supposes that humans are somewhat innately helpless and just stood by while mathematics was being developed, without making practical use of it. But humans, as animals in general, are rather restless and will try until they succeed. Is is how, for example, people eventually discovered how to make boats despite having very little knowledge of how they actually worked.

Furthermore, tracking expenses isn't that new. Accounting is much older than the Renaissance [1]. What the Italians did invent was double-entry bookeeping [2], and this IMO had less to do with household management than with the development of finance in 14th and 15th century Italy. I say this because, on one hand, double-entry bookeeping makes it much easier to track who owes what to whom; on the other, Italian city-states were the first to issue public debt, to have moden banks [3] (after the banca) and had money-lenders weaseling themselves into power (the Medicis).

[1] : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_accounting#Early_de...

[2] : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_accounting#Double-e...

[3] : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bank

tpeo··on I can’t just stand by and watch Mark Zuckerberg destroy the internet
There are strong network externalities both to Facebook and to Google services. The more people use them, the better they are, and so much more higher are the opportunity costs of switching to other websites. Pleas won't change the incentives involved.

That being said, I think tech journalism overstates the amount of control which either Google and Facebook can actually exert over their users.

tpeo··on Wikipedia Editor Says Site’s Toxic Community Has Him Contemplating Suicide
You're doing a bit of hyperbole there. Depression is, according to the current theories, due to a imbalance in neurotransmitters in the brain. Now, a physiological constraint is much more binding than a behavioural constraint, as nobody can be talked or conditioned out of it. It might be dismissive, but saying that it is as dismissive is too much.

I think you do have a point, meaning that this still might be a serious issue for these people. But if they're really compulsively checking a website which often does nothing but make them feel bad and just can't ignore the damned thing, they need help. From an actual therapist.

tpeo··on Toast sandwich
Trying to get the most out of stale bread was a probably big deal until the early 20th century. I mean: toast, french toast, soup (really a dipping sauce for stale bread), bread puddings, crumbled and fried (as in migas), crumbled and mixed into eggs and then fried (as in some spanish tortilla recipes), crumbled into a variety of recipes. And all of these are quite edible, or at least they used to be back when people didn't have Wonder Bread.
tpeo··on Why squared error? (2014)
I'm sorry, but what do you mean by "decay"?

You're talking about fat tails?

tpeo··on I, Pencil (1958)
Though he's indeed wrong in saying that the "invisible hand" acts only as to hamper trade, he isn't far off. The only use of the expression "invisible hand" in The Wealth of Nations occurs amid the discussion of why investors and traders might be biased towards their home country, which is still a discussed issue [0][1] and is considered a kind of market failure.

But nowhere in the same passage does Smith's use of the expression suggest that the "invisible hand" would act merely to hamper trade, but that this simile generally describes an unintended outcome of a decentralized process. The action of the invisible hand might not be necessarily beneficial, as it isn't in this case.

[0] : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Home_bias_in_trade_puzzle

[1] : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equity_home_bias_puzzle

tpeo··on 4-bit calculator made from cardboard and marbles
The particularities of cardboard and marbles would likely prevent it from being "self-aware", in so far as "self-awareness" requires that the machine be fed a large amounts of information regarding itself, through itself. How many kinds of sensors can you build out of cardboard and marble? I don't know. But probably not many, and not as good or abundant as those receptors present in mammals, like those which constantly feed data into our nervous system.

But yeah, if this isn't an actual problem, you'd probably have something self-aware.

tpeo··on Alien life could be so advanced it becomes indistinguishable from physics
Personally, 2001 (the movie, haven't read the book) was the only depiction of aliens I actually like. IMO, FTL travel might require harnessing such crazy physics (negative energy, for instance) that any civilization advanced enough to do it would be completely different from anything we know, or might be even past the need of actually going anywhere.

But instead science fiction often makes spacefaring civilizations exactly like our own, but with spaceships intead of trucks.

tpeo··on Battling the Gods: Atheism in the Ancient World
Sort of.

Christianity is a mixed bag. Popular christian imagination is still filled with miracles and supernatural beings acting on human life. On the other hand, many christians don't hold such views and have a much more deflationary account of divinity. But when I think of early christianity, I think of visions of angels, and curse tablets.

Nothing is known for sure what Plato really thought, specially when it comes to his unwritten doctrines. But his dialogues often put a strong emphasis on piety, and he also makes references to magical practice (think Charmides' charm). He's also been heaped by ancient interpreters with groups strongly associated with mystic practices, namely the Pythagoreans and the Eleatics. Neoplatonists, on the other hand, were associated with Julian I's attempt at revitalizing traditional roman religion and with ritual magic (i.e. theurgy), despite their adherence to the idea of a highly impersonal deity.

None of these guys (Christians, Neoplatonists) were quite free from the traditional practices of their times.

tpeo··on A Black History Museum
This "racism is a system" always sounded to me a bit a rhetorical voodoo, because it allows people to claim that there's still "racism" even if they have no evidence beyond what's in their heads besides the difference in socioeconomic outcomes between different races.

This, however, is absurd. In economics, there's a crucial distinction between historical processes (e.g. accumulation of wealth or economic development) and general economic processes (e.g. the pricing of a good) in that historical processes are not mean-reverting. They're subject to certain rules (e.g. preferential attachment, positive feedbacks, increasing returns) which make them generally path dependent[0]. As a result, initial differences will perpetuate themselves for an indefinately long time.

For example, a familial lineages might remain poor or rich for an arbitrarily long time purely through inheritance. New York might remain more populous than Dallas for an undefined amount of time since the economic benefit of moving into any of those two cities is a function of their population (through economies of agglomeration[1]). And Peru might remain much poorer than the United States for an eternity, because how much capital and labor countries draw to themselves if proportional to how much innovation going on there, which is itself a function of those variables.

History, even as completely blind process, will still produce self-sustaining inequalities. But none of this has anything to do with "racism", but with the fact that the past matters and we live in a world of crucial events. In a mean-reverting world, in all likelihood, there wouldn't even be such a thing as an European colonization of America. In a sense, you might be right in thinking that non one wants all this. But calling these process a result of "racism" is beyond stretching the meaning of the word.

There's no way to maintain a reasonable expectation that different entities (nevermind races) should attain equal outcomes unless the "Just World Hypothesis" is assumed.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Path_dependence

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economies_of_agglomeration

tpeo··on Bouncing bomb
Which, incidentally, is a quote attributed to Louis XVI of France.
tpeo··on The 14 Characteristics of Fascism (2003)
Heaping the likes Pinochet and Franco with that of Mussolini is conflating authoritarianism with fascism, and that can only debase the meaning of "fascist". No wonder the word is thrown around so often.
tpeo··on China’s ‘Artificial Sun’ achieves fusion breakthrough
Apparently, back in the 19th century people credited Berthold Schwarz [0] with the inventiom of gunpowder. I remember reading Beyond Good and Evil and reading in the preface that "the Germans invented gunpowder" and being rather puzzled, but it turns out that that was considered a fact at the time.

Though I wouldn't be surprised if gunpowder was discovered independently in Europe, or at least partly so because nobody walked out of China with a recipe for it.

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berthold_Schwarz

tpeo··on Why Twitter Must Be Saved
By the definition of what? "Bias", "own bias", or "human"?

I don't know about "human", but being "biased" is something like "consistently straying from the truth in spite of available information", but there's nothing right there that says that everyone must be biased. In so far as someone is biased, they cannot be free from their "own biases" only in the same sense that I cannot think anyone's thoughts but my own. Still, nothing stops them from trying to improve.

Now, if you mean that we cannot avoid living in some particular information bubble, that's not a bias (at least in the psychological sense). That's an issue of incomplete information.

tpeo··on Emergent Gravity and the Dark Universe
I wasn't previously acquainted with the term "modal realism" (been avoiding contemporary philosophy for a while now), but there doesn't seem to be an immediate connection in this case. There aren't actually many worlds being simulated here, as each computer simulates the same world and they all get the same results. Leibniz does introduce the idea of many possible worlds (§53), but as a set of designs for this whole thing (computers plus the stuff running inside them) from which God draws one particular design to be the actual world.

He might be closer to modal realists in other regards, though. I don't know.

tpeo··on Emergent Gravity and the Dark Universe
Frankly, I'd be surprised if anything ever suggested that Leibniz's colorful metaphysics was correct, even or incorrect.

Leibnizian monads are unextended and unable to act on one another (from §1 and §7 of the Monadology), which is to say that they're non-physical. On the other hand, as they're somehow supposed each to have a complete picture to the world (§56), they imply some form of non-locality. Which is to say that they're some very spooky things.

The thing that comes closest to Leibniz's monadology is the idea that the world is a simulation running inside a computer. But Leibniz's idea was more like that there is an arbitrarily large number of computers running the same simulation, while some of them also run artificial intelligences which just watch the simulation unfold.

Which is an idea I think can be fairly described as "completely nuts".

tpeo··on Emotions You Don’t Feel
Well, "not feeling an emotion that you're experiencing" would be just a plain contradiction if experience either required or were identical to feeling.

I can see how it would seem impossible.

tpeo··on A machine learning approach to identifying thought markers of suicidal subjects
The problem of suicide isn't so much whether killing oneself is "wrong" or not, or the possible impact of someone's death on their social circle, but that it's extremely unlikely that any boundedly rational agent acting under imperfect information can truly commit to an irreversible choice. The "permanent solution to a transient problem" quip is very much true: way too many who wake after a suicide attempt take it as an opportunity to regret what they've done, and try to turn their lifes around.
tpeo··on Emotions You Don’t Feel
There's indeed a difference. An emotion which isn't merely not perceived, but not perceptible, couldn't ever come anyone's attention.

On the other hand, why do you think it would be impossible that there might be someone who might not feel certain emotions? Some people are born without a sense of pain, or blind to certain colors. There might be people out there who are born "numb".

tpeo··on How Economic Gobbledygook Divides Us
Personally, I don't think something as old and as widespread as DSGE can be called "cutting-edge".

Introductory macro, like any other introductory course, is always at least twenty years lagging behind standard theory, as used by large economic organizations (e.g. central banks, international agencies), and at least some twenty five to thirty behind the cutting-edge stuff. At least, that's the rule of thumb that I was taught. It's unfortunate for undergraduate students, who really don't get a taste of the hardcore econ. But I guess that's just how it is.

But about Ricardian comparative advantage: it's a bad model. It's a gem of economic thinking, just like Ricardo's differential theory of rent. But as model, it just ignores so many things (pretty much all that you've pointed out) that it really isn't useful beyond a "first-order approximation" (much like IS/LM models).

Ironically, it's a fine short-run model. You've asked about what the long-run is. Well, the long-run is when all inputs can be changed by the firms, whereas the short-run is when they can only change some of the inputs (e.g. labor and raw materials, as opposed to machinery). It doesn't really have a direct relationship with time, but the idea behind is that the varible inputs can be changed in a shorter time scale than the fixed inputs. But when everything but labor is fixed, that's just when comparative advantages kick in.

On the other hand, comparative advantage simply can't handle stuff like technological advance, resource exhaustion, or pretty much anything which might change the productivity in any of the countries we're looking at. It wasn't conceived to deal with any of that, either. It was pretty much Ricardo's counter-example to the issue of whether trade would be profitable in the presence of absolute advantage, and one of his pet arguments against the Corn Laws.

← PreviousPage 10 of 14Next →