HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

trutannus

1,118 karma · joined February 24, 2021

submissionscomments
trutannus··on Museum Starts OnlyFans Account After Its TikTok Is Banned for Posting Nudes
I was thinking the same thing. Plus they would have the backing of a state actor, so compliance, and ethics issues would be non-existent.
trutannus··on Museum Starts OnlyFans Account After Its TikTok Is Banned for Posting Nudes
This is how we end up in a world where cutting edge porn platforms are run by European art museums.
trutannus··on Conservation should be allowed to pay its own way on public lands
I think this article misses an important aspect of conversationalist thinking: a lot of them want the land to be completely untouched. Had a legal battel with conservationists trying to close of a section of property at some point, and part of the objective from them was to prevent the land owners from using the land and somehow harming it as a result. They lost, however it was enlightening to see a different mindset.
trutannus··on The day my script killed 10k phones in South America
True, I think I have something like that in multiple places for tests that are used to validate prod code. But our code won't lock people's devices down with no recourse.

I think what made me scratch my head is that they didn't consider that generating random phone numbers might lead to collisions. I've been hesitant to publish fake datasets that have randomly generated and validly formatted SIN/SSN numbers in it for that exact reason.

Even if the risk is low, I'd still think keeping indefinite logs of that would be a good idea.

trutannus··on The day my script killed 10k phones in South America
> extremely negligent look at the issue

Yes, the part about them overwriting the data from each cycle struck me as odd. I don't think that's good practice even if testing.

trutannus··on Stop Equating “Science” with Truth (2017)
> there are many trained scientists that have never read a bit of philosophy

Not only not read a bit of philosophy, but it's almost as common to find trained scientists who scoff at the field as a whole. Of the trained scientists I've met, only two didn't immediately respond with condescension when I brought up philosophy as a subject worth paying attention to. Several have actually tried to tell me that science and philosophy are "opposites", or went with the the tired line of "philosophy is just science that does not have any proof for it". That last one there fundamentally misunderstands the point of it all. An ignorance philosophy in general I think is a problem right now.

trutannus··on Obsidian – A knowledge base from a local folder of plain text Markdown files
> It does not show the date created of the document

You could use/write an extension for that! Obsidian is very extensible. I think there's template extensions you can use to put the datetime in the title, or in the filename.

trutannus··on Psychonetics: A nerd's toolset to work with mind and perception
In that respect you are correct. I thought I had specified in the comment, but it appears I deleted it by mistake while editing. I was specifically talking about people who are not unwell in some way. I was replying to a comment specifically poking another to justify their lack of desire to try this "technology" out.

My point should be taken as "nobody needs to explain to you why they don't want to try your 'psychotechnology', you're not visibly an expert in this, nor is this author". This is more a case of someone on the street offering you a powered substance, as opposed to case, a pharmacist handing you tablets from Pfizer.

trutannus··on Psychonetics: A nerd's toolset to work with mind and perception
Because we don't know what the full implications of training with untested, pseudoscientific 'tricks' from some website will be? Because for some people alterations in perception might be destabilizing? Because someone does not fully understand it? Because it's possible to train your mind to do the wrong things as a healthy person with no idea what you're doing?

Your assessment of site's content is just that -- an assessment by a random person on the internet about a subject they can't concretely demonstrate expertise in. A subject that, if misapplied, can ruin people's lives. If someone says "no I'm fine", that's enough.

Like I said before, I don't think anybody needs to justify to anyone else why they don't want to tamper with their mind. It's baffling to me why this isn't sufficient.

trutannus··on Psychonetics: A nerd's toolset to work with mind and perception
>What makes you think that even if you're sure your mind is stable, that it's not left in it's local minima of abilities?

I don't think anybody needs to justify to anyone else why they don't want to tamper with their mind. This is by definition a subjective topic. If this person's intuition is that tampering with their mind will destabilize it, that's legitimate. Nobody is in a place to question someone's intuitions about their own mind. Other minds are alien experiences -- unknowable. Not everyone can, wants to, or needs to push their consciousness to the theoretical idea maximum of its capacity as defined by another fully isolated subject. It's deeply irresponsible for anyone to suggest, or aggressively advocate, otherwise.

trutannus··on Real-world data show that filters clean Covid-causing virus from air
I'm not really sure what you're trying to say here. I don't really think there's any real reason to think that 1/3 of Canada wants the American system. That's certainly never something I've seen any evidence for. My impression was always that it was a point of general pride that the Canadian system "wasn't' like the American's". Only a small fringe want otherwise from what I can tell. It's not even in the platform of any small fringe parties as far as I can tell. I would suspect if a niche issue like Albertan separatism finds political expression, this would too.

Could you be conflating talks about "privatization" (allowing private clinics to exist and take OHIP) with private healthcare payments (you don't get OHIP) by mistake? Those two are not really the same at all, but get conflated in the media often.

That last part there about Ottawa or Ontario, not sure which one, doesn't really make much sense, sorry. It's unclear what you're getting at. Nothing there really sounds related to what I'm talking about.

trutannus··on VSCode deprecates Enable Telemetry, auto-enrolls you in Telemetry?
A lot of the people who care this much also use Linux, so this is somewhat of a moot point.
trutannus··on Real-world data show that filters clean Covid-causing virus from air
> Have you lived any length of time in Canada?

Yes, I am a Canadian. I lived there for 25 years. I have Canadian citizenship. Most of my family still lives there. I also ended up stuck in Ontario for most of COVID. I have family in Ontario, in Quebec, and elsewhere in the country. I don't think Ontario had a very good handle on COVID. It's also no secret that Canada is suffering a major staffing, and funding shortage in the healthcare sector right now.

While most of your reply is about dentists (I'll get to that later), I see you're comparing Canada's healthcare system to the USA. I'm not. Compared to other systems in NA, yes, it's much better since it's free and somewhat fair. But that's the problem. Canadians should be looking to other developed nations with public healthcare. Not to the United States which operates on a completely different paradigm. My comment that you're replying to is entirely contrasting Canadian healthcare with EU systems, not Americans.

> dental office reopened

The majority of dentists are private entities, and are not subject to the same funding rules as hospitals. They're not licensed through the same entities, funded, or managed in the same way at all. Likely why they were able to adapt so quickly. See: https://www.cda-adc.ca/stateoforalhealth/servicescanada/

> [..] they checked vaccination status and accepted the mask she walked in with.

I'm not really sure what you're getting at here, this does not really relate to funding, or anything I'm talking about really. This is more about safety policy, not funding, which is what I'm trying to discuss.

Don't get me wrong, I've had some good experiences with the system as well, but that does not mean it shouldn't significantly improved.

trutannus··on Real-world data show that filters clean Covid-causing virus from air
Most likely. Canada also has a habit of under-spending on healthcare in general. The system is also hypersensitive to political whims and can end up getting neglected as a result. This is because the provinces have direct control over every aspect of the healthcare system, and set the budget for them directly.

Unlike other nations like Germany and Estonia, Canada's healthcare system is fully dependent on the provincial government to exist and be funded. If I'm not mistaken, in the two countries I mentioned, clinics can get private funding while providing universal access in most cases, which means they have a larger buffer between the political whims of the state, and their ability to provide service. If the state under-provides, the clinics can seek investors to cover the new costs, all the while maintaining universal coverage.

That's not something Canadians can do. Talk of any private involvement, or restructuring in general, in Canada's healthcare system is often very politically charged and not particularly honest, so change is not happening any time soon.

I suspect the issue here is that the hospitals know that having HEPA filters would be a good idea, but political will isn't there to give them what they need. Canadian politics on both sides lately has been more about the appearance of progress through large gestures, rather than careful consideration of long term solutions. It's very unfortunate.

trutannus··on The Uncertain Future of Ham Radio
> If you're reading HN, you're probably the kind of person that would find stuff to enjoy in ham radio

Agreed. Plus if you want to just explore the ham world without going the license route, there's an abundance of cheep software-defined radio dongles (rx only) you can hook up and listen in with. There's a lot of weird and cool stuff on the air that'll keep you occupied for hours.

trutannus··on Americans' Trust in Media Dips to Second Lowest on Record
Yes, a fair point. This person is a former reporter for CBC. For me I think it's fair to say that this is coming from CBC as the general tone of the article appears to endorse their former employee's viewpoint. Employees who are hired on, and then later brought back to discuss their views, to me at least, do shed light into the views of the organization.
trutannus··on Americans' Trust in Media Dips to Second Lowest on Record
For someone who said they're open to having their views challenged, the tenacity with which you respin other's arguments suggests the opposite. I see little to no engagement with the argument's content, a lot of objections to form, and a lot of interpretation.

You don't come off as someone who wants to have good faith discussions. Instead you come off as someone who wants to bait people into replying, then go word-for-word through their reply to find any gotcha moment you can to match your spin.

In this reply chain for example, you've:

- framed me as thinking CBC is far left (a lie)

- put words in the mouth of another commenter,

- removed critical points from my comment,

- simplified my argument to a straw-man,

- tried to convert an opinion into a statement of fact by accusing me of just using "weasel words",

- inferred my motive, and

- accused me of leaving out other arguments.

This topic is inherently opinion based. I've been clear that's what I'm offering. Multiple times now you've accused me otherwise. You're free to respectfully disagree with my opinion, but this is neither respectful, nor a discussion of opinion with you at this point.

I'm not going to go any further with you down this line of conversation. Have a nice day.

trutannus··on Americans' Trust in Media Dips to Second Lowest on Record
I don't think you're being honest here in the way you're construing my point. It looks like you've re-framed it, made stuff up to make me fit the form of a right-wing malcontent.

Can you point to where I said this was an indisputable fact? If you can't, then that's likely because I said the opposite, which you can see in the line you yourself quoted me on:

"which is arguably a career limiting move dressed up as virtuous political posturing."

Basically, all this says is that "I think publicly denouncing your employer for political, social, or other reasons might not make you look good in future job applications", and that someone telling you to do so on a highly political podcast might be motivated by more than just warning everyone about a bad boss.

When you remove the stuff I didn't say, my point is less easily shoehorned into the right wing perspective you want it to be. It's pretty clear here that this is an opinion, not a retelling of fact. If you don't think this podcast is a little on the hard-line left side, and you don't think encouraging people to publicly quit is a risky move, that's fine. You could argue for that like I argued for this.

trutannus··on Americans' Trust in Media Dips to Second Lowest on Record
I won't be able to find a specific example, but there has been a lot of air-time given to interviews about disrupting, quitting, and publicly shaming your workplace if you don't ideologically align with them. For example, there's a segment called Battle Tactics for your Sexist Workplace which CBC airs some Sundays. There was a segment on how to properly "go public" about why you quit, which is arguably a career limiting move dressed up as virtuous political posturing.

They don't produce the segment, but they give it air time which does imply some agreement with the content. I disagree that they're center-left, or far-left, but they definitely ride the outermost left boundary of the Overton Window, and sometimes spill a little over.

trutannus··on Americans' Trust in Media Dips to Second Lowest on Record
I'd agree unless AT&T published your remarks in their publications, yes. Do you really think there is no connection between what op-eds get approved for publication, and the organization publishing them? Do you also think that former employees being published in their former employer's news publication does not indicate some level of ideological aliment? I think that it does. If you don't, that's fine, but the conclusion I've come to is not unreasonable when you consider all the context.
trutannus··on Americans' Trust in Media Dips to Second Lowest on Record
Maybe do some further research then, she is a former CBC reporter:

"Prior to her academic work, Candis produced, wrote, and reported for television, the Internet, and radio in Canada (CBC, CTV)"

Source: https://jwam.ubc.ca/profile/candis-callison/

Also from the same article:

"However, Candis Callison calls objectivity "the view from nowhere" and considers it potentially harmful. She has worked as a journalist in the United States and Canada for television, the internet and radio, including at the CBC."

trutannus··on Americans' Trust in Media Dips to Second Lowest on Record
I'm not sure why you have state run media in scare-quotes. CBC is state owned and run: https://cbc.radio-canada.ca/en/vision/mandate

"the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation, as the national public broadcaster"

Further:

Minister Responsible: Steven Guilbeault, Minister of Canadian Heritage, see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadian_Broadcasting_Corporat...

trutannus··on Americans' Trust in Media Dips to Second Lowest on Record
Except it's not. They're trying to redefine what the point of journalism is. They want to add interpretation as a goal. If you read deeper into the article, you see this:

"There's a limit to how much you can put yourself in, but when you begin to think in terms of your place in society, what your relative privilege is, what social orders have benefited you and where they have not benefited you, I think this is where you're thinking about a news story. [It] shouldn't just be about a news story as an event, but how it's an intersection of systems and structures."

To me, this isn't what the news is about. This is option and interpretation. News should report facts, not try to apply social theory to interpret them for me. I'm not quote mining like you suggest. The context of the article does not make it any better. Further:

"It's been a very interesting few weeks on social media. And especially on Twitter, where you have Indigenous journalists and Black journalists talking about what's happened to them in the newsroom. Those kinds of narratives really illustrate the ways in which journalism is absolutely a work of interpretation, and recognizing journalism as contributing to a social order is a first step in seeing it as a tool that might do good in the world."

This is even more alarming. They're essentially saying the news is by its nature an interpretation of events and can't be otherwise. This is false. There are plenty of news sources which report short, concise segments of information without interpretation (ie: Reuters).

trutannus··on Americans' Trust in Media Dips to Second Lowest on Record
The blend of activism and journalism is the crux of the problem. In Canada the state-run news organization CBC knows they have low trust, however can't admit their role in it. About once a year they write an op-ed talking about the best ways to use legislation to fix the problem. This is the same state-run media company that said objectivity is "potentially harmful": https://www.cbc.ca/radio/sunday/the-sunday-edition-for-july-...
trutannus··on How to permanently delete your Facebook account
No need to get hostile. You've made an unsubstantiated claim, I'm asking for some proof of which there's still none. Remember, I tried the exact same test with the login as you, and couldn't reproduce.

Like I said, there's a number of reasonable reasons why your account didn't get deleted, all of them pass the Occam's Razor test a little better than "Facebook just didn't delete my account/is not deleting accounts in secret".

You're making a statement which, if true, is huge -- that Facebook is secretly retaining accounts after deletion, despite multiple credible sources (IE: TIME) running detailed articles to the contrary. On top of that your anecdotal evidence is contradicted by my anecdotal evidence. So I hope you understand if I don't take this at face-value.

trutannus··on How to permanently delete your Facebook account
This is a bit hyperbolic, and a little unbelievable. Is it possible that you experienced a bug in Facebook? Or that someone else had access to your account, which prevented the deletion? You've essentially asserted that you've caught Facebook lying about the account deletion process, while not showing us any proof outside of your comment.

Not located in US/UK/Europe, however my deleted account is fully deleted. Can't even 'reset' the password on it since there's no email found when I try to use the reset.

I don't like Facebook, but I don't think there's a point in getting riled up by one person's comment on HackerNews. It reminds me of the thread where someone was claiming they were under surveillance for using ProtonMail.

trutannus··on What Happened to Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp?
The stock market is a fine comparison. It's something that's run by, or at least heavily controlled and regulated by the federal government of many nations. Telecom services run on the telecom company's infrastructure. The government just happens to pay for them to build it where I live. The purpose of the analogy is to highlight how the state is pretty bad at managing things, even when it pours billions of dollars into doing so.

> Telecom systems have likely had lesser downtime than Facebook in the last 30 years

I've had a handful outages in the past few years for my telecom services. Rogers' network failed in Canada in 2020 for a full day, crippling communications across the country. I've had one outage with Facebook since 2008. At worst, they're just as reliable. Regardless, the argument here really is "should the state step in and take control of Facebook's uptime because a lot of people chose to use it and it goes offline for a few hours a decade"?. I still maintain that none of this is an affirmative argument.

trutannus··on Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids and democracy
The world isn't Texas. I'd rather not give Facebook extra data to play with because "well, Texas already sells Texan's data".
trutannus··on Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids and democracy
Right, see here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contemporary_history

"[..] a subset of modern history that describes the historical period from approximately 1945 to the present."

trutannus··on Whistleblower to Congress: Facebook products harm kids and democracy
This isn't even remotely close to the gambler's fallacy. This isn't an issue of statistics, or probabilities being skewed 'this time'. Really what the question being asked is if you want to force people by law to hand more information over to organizations like Facebook. Legislation or not, Facebook and their ilk will abuse this data. Give it time, and so will any government. Your argument is basically "yeah, well it's so bad at this point we might as well not even try to stop it".

In addition:

> policing the horrible things being done behind anonymity

Anonymity isn't something you can just do away with and have a happy ending. In some parts of the world, anonymity is the only thing standing between people and their government. That's not something I'd like to see done away with. The Afghan people need anonymity now more than nearly anyone else in the world. As do the Chinese, the Turkmens, Eritreans, domestic violence victims, and anyone who lives in a world where being identified could lead to a swift, brutal death. What are these folks to do? Hide forever? If that's the result, then we are not just seeing social cooling, we're looking at a social ice age.

← PreviousPage 6 of 14Next →