I think that free competition alone is responsible for having cheaper and better internet access: in Romania I pay 10$/month for a 1gb, unlimited traffic, internet connection. I think we have this for about 3-5 years.
In a country with very few companies that are bigger than 1% of what Google or AOL or AT&T are.
In a country where an entrepreneur doesn't even dream of having access to the big investor money needed to start an optical fiber ISP.
What you're paying in US is 10x-100x more expensive than that. One can only imagine the margins your ISPs make and the profit opportunities other entrepreneurs have in this space.
If it's not about the incumbent's overwhelming power, what can it be? Lack of entrepreneurial spirit in US? Lack of technological knowledge?(you invented this whole internet thing ffs) Lack of desire for easy profits?
I doubt.