HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tylerjwilk00

893 karma · joined September 24, 2016

submissionscomments
tylerjwilk00··on PBS Launching Streaming Service on Amazon Prime
Check and see if your local PBS station has implemented Passport. Passport is a streaming service specific to PBS and there is no tax aside from the $60 or more annual donation to your local station. Public media needs your help.
tylerjwilk00··on Experimental rejection of observer-independence in the quantum world
I like to use a record player analogy for this concept.

We are the needle. The needle responds to the environment of the record but can't see outside it's little perspective.

God on other hand sees the record from above all at once.

We are a consciousness needle scratching a path through 4D space-time.

tylerjwilk00··on Intellectual Denial of Service Attacks
You refuted his point but without anything supporting your claim.

What is your counterexample?

tylerjwilk00··on Moving from Go to PHP Again
Composer was a game changer. Instead of a monolithic framework you just compose your app with the dependencies it needs.

    composer require guzzlehttp/guzzle
Now you have GuzzleHttp available to your app. This way you include only what is needed.
tylerjwilk00··on What insects can tell us about the origins of consciousness (2016)
I disagree.

The problem is that we are convinced that any experience or object can be defined within language.

The truth is that somethings are undefinable. And as soon as you attempt to define it, label it, you have already lost it.

tylerjwilk00··on Humanity Has Hope: Pro-Gamers Win 1 of 11 StarCraft Matches Against DeepMind AI
Does the AI take a video input or is the AI still operating through a direct API into the game? If so, it's a bit like cheating. Pure data access and no visual noise to filter through is a huge advantage for it but still impressive.
tylerjwilk00··on FCC accused of colluding with Big Cable to game 5G legal challenge
The dream is over.

Corruption has seeped it's way to the highest office and some of the most important government organizations. What would be earth shattering 20 years ago is just business as usual these days.

Can we find our way back to the light?

tylerjwilk00··on Australia’s beloved kangaroos are now controversial pests
Not unlike the deer in North America. Deer management practices are largely driven by auto insurance industry lobbying.
tylerjwilk00··on Is the Universe a conscious mind? (2018)
Universes may very well self replicate.

It's has been theorized that our universe's Big Bang singularity is not unlike the singularity of a black hole. And they may be two sides of the same coin.

If a black hole creates a child universe and inherits physics from the parent that gives you self replication and possibly natural selection.

In the set of universes any universe that can replicate and pass on it's physics "genes" would be found to have more survivors in existence of it's type.

Lastly, if the physics required for black holes (and associated replication) are the same as those required for life then universes are naturally selected for life.

tylerjwilk00··on My PHP Development Setup
I am guessing the Makefile helps with "portability" aspect. Where as aliases would need to be "installed" on end user's machine outside of cloning a repo.
tylerjwilk00··on What’s Causing the Rise of Hoarding Disorder?
Sure. Perhaps we generalize them both and say that:

Modern capitalism exploits (perverts?) natural human behavior and can lead to maladaptive behavior in our current environment.

tylerjwilk00··on My PHP Development Setup
Glad to see modern PHP getting more coverage on HN. For anyone interested in how the latest version performance compares to similar languages checkout vs Python [1] and the vs Ruby [2] pages from the benchmarks game team.

[1] https://benchmarksgame-team.pages.debian.net/benchmarksgame/...

[2] https://benchmarksgame-team.pages.debian.net/benchmarksgame/...

tylerjwilk00··on What’s Causing the Rise of Hoarding Disorder?
Hoarding feels similar to over eating.

We need to eat but some people can't control the quality or quantity of food consumed.

Similarly, instead of collecting an appropriate amount of valuable and useful resources, they collect random nearly useless items and attach much value to them.

Could be a case of an ancient survival strategy that is no longer valid in the current environment.

tylerjwilk00··on U.S. proposes to allow drone operation at night, over people
I am not advocating loud motorcycles but as a rider I know from experience that cars on the roads will pay more attention and give more caution to a louder motorcycle.

A simple fender bender on a motorcycle can be fatal which is the reasoning behind the phrase "Loud pipes save lives."

Are some people doing it to be obnoxious? Probably. Are some people doing it out of the desire for increased safety? Yes.

tylerjwilk00··on Black Hole Evolution Traced Out with Loop Quantum Gravity
Agreed.

It's seems like it must be either Hawking radiation OR white hole bounce not both.

If Hawking radiation evaporates the black hole then there should be no matter or energy left for white hole to ouput in the future.

tylerjwilk00··on JavaScript Getter-Setter Pyramid
I'm sure the author knows more about the topic than me. However, it reads like someone trying to rationalize something that isn't quite rational.

IE: Walking into an old antique store and attempting to explain the genius logic behind it's organization. Shortly after the owner comes out and says, "No, I just throw shit wherever."

tylerjwilk00··on Neither PWA nor AMP are needed to make a website load fast
Author has good points about PWAs. I love PWAs because I hate giving native apps access to my phone's data but the emphasis on offline support for PWAs does seem off point. It has Web in the name. You probably need internet access!
tylerjwilk00··on 'Dark fluid' with negative mass could dominate the universe
That distribution being all the places that aren't normal matter particles. So primarily outside of galaxies.
tylerjwilk00··on 'Dark fluid' with negative mass could dominate the universe
Think of it as one pushes while the other one pulls.
tylerjwilk00··on When starting school, younger children are more likely to be diagnosed with ADHD
Agreed. The elephant in the room is that school is rather unnatural and modern kindergarten is overly structured and academic. [1,2]

Humans are just highly intelligent animals. Kids acting like animals when they are 5 years old is not unnatural.

[1] https://www.houstonchronicle.com/local/gray-matters/article/...

[2] https://www.scholastic.com/teachers/articles/teaching-conten...

tylerjwilk00··on Classic and contemporary psychology experiments replicated
The mind is mutable.

Psychology is different than other "hard" sciences.

I only say "results _may_ no longer be valid" and I'd say this study proves that.

If you go deep enough into the mind to the point where social environment no longer influences the behavior you may be getting closer to biology than psychology but point taken.

tylerjwilk00··on Classic and contemporary psychology experiments replicated
The thing with psychology experiments is that the fundamental thing being tested is not immutable.

This makes it different than many other science experiments where concrete parts of reality are tested.

Psychology really only tests the minds of humans in a global society at a point in time. If future minds change enough the results may no longer be valid.

tylerjwilk00··on Skill Stacking: A Practical Strategy to Achieve Career Success
Generalist because it's in my nature [1] "When environmental conditions change, generalists are able to adapt, but specialists tend to fall victim to extinction much more easily."

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generalist_and_specialist_sp...

tylerjwilk00··on The Strong Free Will Theorem (2009) [pdf]
Let's excuse that we have to invoke time travel, and that once the choice has been made it is now part of the past of our collapsed reality...

The point you seem to be making:

A) If I make the same choice everytime there is no free will.

B) If I make different choices everytime there is no free will? Or perhaps even there is no "me"?

Free will could entail the will to choose the same thing every time AND the will to choose something different.

If we can't accept that then perhaps an argument could be made that there is no such thing as "you".

tylerjwilk00··on The Strong Free Will Theorem (2009) [pdf]
That is exactly the point!

From the paper:

Some readers may object to our use of the term “free will” to describe the indeterminism of particle responses. Our provocative ascription of free will to elementary particles is deliberate, since our theorem asserts that if experimenters have a certain freedom, then particles have exactly the same kind of freedom. Indeed, it is natural to suppose that this latter freedom is the ultimate explanation of our own.

tylerjwilk00··on The Strong Free Will Theorem (2009) [pdf]
The only conclusion here is that you believe free will can only be explained by dualism. Quantum nonlocality [1] provides at least one other explanation as a place free will may hide.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_nonlocality

tylerjwilk00··on The Strong Free Will Theorem (2009) [pdf]
Even if it is correct to say that, "You are a state machine." and "prior state" is an input to the state generation function of the machine, this is _not_ incompatible with free will, and does _not_ require a pre-determined universe.

Simply put, current state as an input does not necessitate pre-determination.

I think the point user all2 was making is that if we remove the prior state modifier from the generate state function then the core piece that is left over is "your basest existence".

tylerjwilk00··on The Strong Free Will Theorem (2009) [pdf]
There is a lot to respond to here (and I think you're looking for responses) so I am just gonna stick with what I think are the key points and be brief.

> If you have a prior state that is in part systematic, and part random, is the randomness per se free will?

Let's please replace random with uncertain. If _part_ of an entangled system is uncertain the _whole_ system is uncertain [1].

> Does that encapsulate the notion of free will?

    free will [2] 
    the power of acting without the constraint of necessity or fate; 
    the ability to act at one's own discretion.
To me this subjectively means: Are my choices the result of something greater than the material sum of my parts? Yes.

> That is, I cannot make you change your choice, only you can.

Your free will attempts at influencing me to make a certain choice would seem to entangle my state with your's and perhaps change the probability I will make one choice over another.

> If an omniscient external individual cannot alter your behavior,

'omniscient external individual' is a quite an assumption here.

> Why should the non-omniscient individual seeking change be held responsible?

Free will is the _only_ way to hold the individual responsible.

> but I think at some point the notion of free will starts to lead to counterintuitive problems and/or becomes very poorly definable. At some level I suspect it implies not only autonomy but complete agency, which is suspect.

(I may be misunderstanding you here) Free will over a decision must ultimately collapse to a choice made. At that point it is determined reality and no amount of free will can undo it.

You either took the Red pill or the Blue pill. If the decision is never observed the choice was never made ergo it didn't happen, it is not real.

In the spirit of Spinoza [3] I actually find bestowing free will upon particles very intuitive. We then have free will because it is an attribute of our fundamental components. If particles have no free will and are pre-determined we have no free will and are pre-determined. If we have free will then particles must have free will.

Full disclosure, I am an armchair philosopher with an interest in the cross-section with physics.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schr%C3%B6dinger%27s_cat [2] https://www.google.com/search?q=define%3A+free+will [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethics_(Spinoza)

tylerjwilk00··on The Strong Free Will Theorem (2009) [pdf]
It's not random though - it is probabilistic. And even if it was an internal 'RNG' it is is still _their's_ not someone else's.
tylerjwilk00··on The Strong Free Will Theorem (2009) [pdf]
We are probably arguing semantics but the alternative to pre-determination is not free will as much as it is probabilistic.

Yes this _will_ happen verse this will _most likely_ happen.

Free will is the ability to influence the probability that a certain outcome is realized. Your decisions could be predictable as a function of probability.

Your definition of 'me' (your prior state) includes the quantum states of your constitute parts. Just because there is a degree of uncertainty in those states does not mean they are not of 'you'.

The degree of pre-determination is just a matter of scale (akin to classical vs quantum). The deeper you go the less pre-determined something can be.

← PreviousPage 6 of 9Next →