HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ulyssestone

8 karma · joined July 18, 2011

submissionscomments
ulyssestone··on Spotify bitrategate: 320kbps premium quality not there yet
Yes I understand, actually I know quiet a bit about how dinosaur like RIAA/IFPI make their lives:P

But as I quoted in my article, Spotify staff admitted that they got music in lossless from labels, and have the rights to convert and stream them in HQ.

To be frankly I know how this will end: most users don't care and the story sinks into nowhere. For my own interest I don't even want to do this, @Spotify tweeted about my blog about eight times since last year, and I'd assume it won't happen again after this post. The US launch tripled the traffic of my site, a post like this will only bore the new visitors away. I did this because I believe it's the right thing to do, and I still have faith in Spotify. That's all.

ulyssestone··on Spotify bitrategate: 320kbps premium quality not there yet
So... You are suggesting me to write this entire report based on "from what I heard, about 70% of the 100 tracks I auditioned are probably not at 320 kbps"?...
ulyssestone··on Spotify bitrategate: 320kbps premium quality not there yet
I think the ever-ongoing war between audiophiles and "nobody can tell 128/192/256/whatever kbps lossy files from CD" supporters is irreverent here. I am not suggesting Spotify to give us a better quality that maybe doesn't mean too much for some other users, I am asking them why they didn't deliver the goods they promised more than two years ago.
ulyssestone··on Spotify bitrategate: 320kbps premium quality not there yet
Thanks for all the comments.

Personally I don't think licensing is the problem. Why would the labels let Spotify stream the new Paul Oakenfold and Beyonce album as exclusive pre-releases and, at the same time, not allow them to offer HQ streaming for those albums? What's the point? To force the audiophile users to buy 320 kbps mp3s or CDs? Many of the premium users don't even know it's not 320 kbps.