HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

umberway

54 karma · joined January 17, 2017

submissionscomments
umberway··on Researchers have found more evidence that butter is heart-healthy
Butter is good for you provided you don't fry with it. If overheated it supplies more than the usual amount of inflammatory compounds. Instead, fry with ghee (clarified butter) or tallow.
umberway··on A glitch in the human psyche that equates repetition with truth
Repetition of a true message to a variety of audiences may be valuable because one gains a better understanding of the common misconceptions and opposing arguments. Which leads to subtly improved arguments and rhetoric. Also there's always the possibility that the message is in fact wrong and that this may be brought to light by new criticism or fresh evidence.
umberway··on A glitch in the human psyche that equates repetition with truth
Having heard this idea many times I remain unpersuaded so far (!) because I haven't heard an explanation for it. Anyone know one?
umberway··on UK Teen Hacked 150,000 Printers
The principle battle with printers as I see it is getting them to accept a third party print cartridge.
umberway··on We may have reached peak “gig” economy
The idea is to give companies an incentive to make tough stuff by increasing their revenue for such products. But let's do both!
umberway··on How To Write With Style (1999)
'7. Pity the readers' follows from the curse of knowledge, namely that's it's hard to imagine what it's like not to know what you know. This applies in novels as much as in technical writing. For example, descriptions of landscapes are often ambiguous because the writer already has a picture of the landscape in mind.
umberway··on Depression Classic
I agree. Yet scientific and/or moral discussions of depression and other mental disorders are becoming increasingly taboo.
umberway··on We may have reached peak “gig” economy
It's about shared negative emotional experiences, of which their are more when one is young e.g. school, leaving home. It follows that if you wish to befriend adults you need to share a rock climbing accident, get stuck together in an airport for 72 hours, or similar.
umberway··on We may have reached peak “gig” economy
Increase sales tax on status/luxury items. Decrease sales tax on long-life products.
umberway··on How Children Lost the Right to Roam in Just 4 Generations
Yes, more than that: if robot cars could be made incapable of hitting pedestrians, then children might start to roam again. It would be a marvellous unintended consequence...
umberway··on Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016)
This is the common sense view. But I think it's mistaken, which is what makes the article surprising and interesting.

People can learn and adapt to alcohol consumption and use it to get more work done, especially unpleasant work, just as they do with coffee. Not necessarily their best work, but work nonetheless. Some function very effectively on it, even intellectually e.g. Christopher Hitchens.

umberway··on Wanted: Factory Workers, Degree Required
Prediction: in the distant future people who want to join an organisation will be evaluated by how interested they are in the work.
umberway··on Saudi Arabia builds 600-mile border wall equipped with Airbus radar and helipads
Jan 2016 interactive map of worldwide border walls and fences:

http://www.economist.com/blogs/graphicdetail/2016/01/daily-c...

umberway··on Succeeding Against the Odds Can Make You Sick
And now CRISPR technologies are being developed I trust that in addition to eliminating Huntington's disease, Tay-Sachs, Fragile X, and what have you, we will fix the GULO gene so that our bodies can recommence Vitamin C production.
umberway··on Split Brain Does Not Lead to Split Consciousness
I agree. The best that can be said is something about communication of information between different parts of the brain. But my reason is more fundamental: we don't understand what consciousness is yet. Hence we can't know what questions about 'it' are meaningful let alone what conclusions to draw.
umberway··on Why Your Best Thinking Is in the Shower (2014)
Yes, it has to be a familiar route so that you are relaxed and undistracted by navigation, e.g. Darwin's Sandwalk:

https://goo.gl/y61qvc

umberway··on Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants. (2007)
It's complicated. If I gave an obese person a bag of sugar or a kilo of lard she probably wouldn't enjoy these things. On the other hand some folk can eat luxury foods regularly without ill effect. It depends on personality and intent as much as upon specific foodstuffs and substances.

And are you sure about protein? Personally I experience a strong desire for meat if I haven't had any for a few days. The fulfillment of that desire creates a visceral pleasure. Furthermore I can't imagine giving up apparently innocuous items like tomatoes, either. For a few months perhaps but after a few years I'm sure I would pine at the memory of fresh juicy tomatoes.

umberway··on Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants. (2007)
The 'facts' that I referred to are the results of correlation studies as published in science journals. The diets you mention are mainstream fads.

You're right, though, it is frustrating! My personal opinion is that it is the way we use food for pleasure and comfort that it is to blame. We are literally getting high on what we eat, which is deleterious for health if performed without break for long periods. But there's no obvious way for a scientist to address this idea at present; it would be considered too subjective and thus ignored by the majority.

umberway··on Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants. (2007)
Nutrition, medicine, psychology are beset by empiricism: trying to find facts without having theories to support them. Journalists then make hay with the results, hinting at conclusions and advice for the public, using the authority of Science, but really bringing it into disrepute. An awful lot of research money has been wasted in this way and of course much of the work is not reproducible.
umberway··on Lessons Learned from “On Writing Well”
The ability to do anything well co-evolves with finding good reasons to do it. In the case of writing it would be having things you strongly desire to write about.
umberway··on Calling Yourself ‘Humbled’ Doesn’t Sound as Humble as It Used To
I'm more humble than they are!
umberway··on Why Medical Advice Seems to Change So Frequently
http://www.goodreads.com/quotes/6894316-never-trust-an-exper...
umberway··on Unexpected Consequences of Self-Driving Cars
Yes I'm sure this sort of thing will happen however I imagine the overall social consequences would be beneficial. Children are highly confined at present and the ability to roam and talk to different people, walk to school, etc, has been lost. Largely for fear of their being run over by traffic.
umberway··on Unexpected Consequences of Self-Driving Cars
If and when all cars are computer-controlled another consequence may be that children will be free to roam about. This assumes that those same cars are built to be incapable of hitting pedestrians. Is this possible?
umberway··on How I got my attention back
Yes, the ability to direct one's creativity is valuable and a hallmark of freedom. But the direction, if it is to be fruitful, is determined by what one finds genuinely interesting. This is in turn an impersonal property of those new ideas.

The guy who is hooked on a video games is less intentional. He thinks he ought to be able to will himself into doing other stuff which he thinks he should be doing. He blames the game or phone or whatever for his failure. But what he really doing is avoiding certain other problems. When he is ready he'll face those unmentioned problems and maybe find a new direction.

umberway··on To Obama with Love, and Hate, and Desperation
>Queen's head is stamped on the back of our coins

Exactly. She's a symbol :-)

umberway··on To Obama with Love, and Hate, and Desperation
It seems to me (as an outsider) that people in the U.S.A. now more than ever judge the President for what he symbolises. Perhaps this explains the power of constitutional monarchy (not advocating one system over the other; just an observation).
umberway··on Why we should all have a basic income
By 'hard' problem I mean that it has depth, not that it's unpleasant. A stream of easy problems could work but it's less reliable because when there's a dry spell then outcome (1) will be scratching at the door.

"We choose to go to the moon in this decade and do the other things, not because they are easy, but because they are hard" -- JFK

umberway··on How I got my attention back
This is a tricky topic because a free and creative person is mostly acting spontaneously so he cannot predict where his attention is going next. Go figure.
umberway··on Why we should all have a basic income
It seems to me that basic income could make me either (1) fall victim to depression, addiction, or some other mental disorder, or (2) find a hard problem to work on which keeps me occupied and satisfied for a lifetime.
Page 1 of 2Next →