HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

unabst

1,480 karma · joined June 2, 2015

I am dead.
submissionscomments
unabst··on Turing and Wittgenstein on Logic and Mathematics [pdf]
You can't be a philosopher and posit "most philosophy is non-sense" at the same time. If language is the product of ephemeral transactions between subjective people on a need to communicate basis, then does it possess the objective rigor needed to accurately investigate the true essence of the world? If philosophy can only be expressed with language, where does that leave you? Setting aside Wittgenstein while you work on your philosophy may do the trick.

I've been listening to a lot of George Carlin recently. I feel much of his late best work is linguistic absurdism. If we are to take Carlin's assertion that most of us are dumb and society is glued together by bullshit, then so would be our language. If that is the case, then Carlin's stand up is the perfect example of taking language for what it truly is and applying objective rigor and logic to it (which he explicitly claims to be doing in many of his routines), only to reveal the true essence of the world. If anything, Carlin proved that reality is just as absurd as the language we use to describe it.

unabst··on Ways to make a web component
In other words, HTML is unabstractable. I've been wishing to be able to type this since 1997.

<let mytag> <p>my tag!</p> </let>

<mytag/>

Same with css. There are workarounds we use because abstraction is a requirement to code. Somehow the web components spec even seems like a workaround, for which we have many workarounds... and around and around we go :)

unabst··on Extremely disillusioned with technology. Please help
It's the people. Driven to do bad out of fear.

Tech is capitalism at its best and worst, with the best being bad for a lot of people. Self imposed hardship and self sacrifice is the name of the pursuit. Everyone is a chaser. You then have VCs and angels and business partners with immense leverage over these struggles, often struggling themselves.

This brings out the bad in a lot of people. Cheating, backstabbing, and a general lack of integrity. Pervasive, regardless of status or level.

I didn't understand this at all, but it turns out much of it is driven from fear, as most actions inevitably are. And it gets worse with rising stakes, so its worse at higher levels.

Integrity is expensive. Kindness is expensive. Empathy is expensive. And competence is rare.

So good meaning, goodhearted, friendly people fail to sustain their good nature when shit hits the fan. And shit is always hitting the fan. People will act good until they cannot afford to. Or think they can't. Until they're scared. And that's the saddest part. They think they have to cheat. They then witness others do it, and think its just the way. Not me we tell ourselves, but sooner or later, the ultimatum presents itself: be good or survive. And we've seen the fallen. Chances are we've been a victim of one. Or work for one. Or deal with one. Or sit next to one. And the one thing they're good at is survival. No wonder there are so damn many of them.

Then what is the answer?

Don't trust anyone. Ergo, integrity is the luxury most often enjoyed alone.

But.

If you enjoy your own company, then that's a start. If you have an incredible product or service, then that's a start. If you don't need anyone's help, then that's a start. And if you have a warm home you can return to, then that's a start.

The one thing that will make your life easier is obvious.

Kick ass.

Just be so good, and run with it, or don't bother. That should be the motto of every entrepreneur. Or any endeavor, for that matter.

You're jumping into a snake pit. That's a given. Bring a flamethrower, or don't bother.

Every kick ass startup kicks ass.

If your ass is being kicked, you're doing it wrong, and you're wrong. You'd be right to get out as soon as possible.

unabst··on Weekend ‘catch-up sleep’ is a lie
For other's it may be, but I was responding to a blatant miscategorization which was attacking his identity, not his work. And this is just how I write.

If dissing someone is allowed then why isn't praising them? And praising them well?

Because I exaggerated?

But did I?

He continues to help millions of people. Can't say that about many people.

Regarding his work/words: He's right about the biological differences between men and women. He's right about social hierarchies and power structures being inevitable. He's right about the government's overreach on speech being dangerous. He's right about proper discourse on any matter being uncomfortable. He's right about the value of honesty and integrity. He's right about ways to piece your life and yourself back together.

And by right I don't mean binary true or false, because that isn't how science works. By right, I mean the most accurate knowledge we currently have on the topic that could be usefully applied to a problem at hand compared to other less accurate knowledge that is already being applied to problems at hand. Seeing this is why he stood up, and many stood up with him.

You can't be a quack and help so many people or be right about so many things. And at the end of the day he's just a lecturer that's really really good at his job -- at engaging his students and sharing the wealth of knowledge that already exists. And yes, using that knowledge to point out why you are wrong does make him offensive to a lot of people. You don't have to be one of them. And yes, he has turned activist. You don't have to turn into one, by why not? But if you have, then why against?

He isn't anti-scientific. He just isn't. That's a blatantly false claim.

unabst··on Weekend ‘catch-up sleep’ is a lie
Well, actually this is the publication record of an influential social scientist. JDP is the most influential social scientist of our times, bar none. This is his publication record. That makes this the publication record of an influential social scientist. Does that offend you?

Knocking him for collaborating is ignorant and disingenuous. Scientists collaborate. His record shows he is a real scientist. It doesn't have to show he is the best or that he deserves a Nobel Prize. At this point, he's probably a better candidate for the Nobel Peace Prize if anything, but this only goes to show what he's been working on lately, which is more activism than scientific research. More Neil deGrasse Tyson than Einstein, but that doesn't make Neil a fake scientist.

JDP's last book he did write for a broader audience. Great move. Even I read it. And he brought with him the scientists and the research that otherwise would not have reached his audience.

His book is maybe 75% work of other scientists, 20% story telling, and 5% what he draws from it. Basically his 12 rules. He demonstrates how to draw meaning and meaningful conclusions rationally, with well grounded premises. If you have low tolerance for the more abstract genre of ancient story analysis, then skip it. Or maybe there is some truth to it? Decide for yourself.

Did you read his book? Fine if you didn't but I wouldn't claim to understand him if I hadn't. Maybe you have issues with him, which is fine, but again, that is a separate matter than the substance of his lectures. Which are all highly specific by the way. So to say they're all based on weak papers or that he's selling snake oil is an immediate tell that, again, you either don't understand him or have other issues/motives.

(Thanks HN for not letting me reply, claiming I'm posting too fast, when clearly I'm not. Not sure how you're suppose to have a conversation.)

unabst··on Weekend ‘catch-up sleep’ is a lie
Why would you be offended by the science of a scientist? Let alone their opinion? Why does he offend you so much? I would put this person in the "has issues" category. Not saying that is bad. But it doesn't make you right. Instead, we should focus on the issue. What about what offends you so much? Btw there are plenty of videos of him confronting exactly this.

Nothing is indefensible. Challenge him all you want.

His views are his views. Most of his lectures are about other people's work. When he draws conclusions his logic is sound and his premises are transparent. Talk, think, debate.

Why hate? He continues to help so many people.

unabst··on Weekend ‘catch-up sleep’ is a lie
https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=wL1F22UAAAAJ&hl=en

See it. You could have just Google it.

unabst··on Weekend ‘catch-up sleep’ is a lie
Excessive maybe, but not false, and only to counter his blatant miscategorization to which I was responding. I underestimated the support for JDP here, which is my bad but I am happy to defend him. My mother is an anthropologist. The social sciences are flawed in many ways but JDP fully acknowledges and navigates this. If anyone has better ideas or conclusions than he does please share. He wants to know. We all want to know. But if there is one thing a man answering his calling deserves is respect.
unabst··on Weekend ‘catch-up sleep’ is a lie
How do you know he uses mostly weak papers? That is an overgeneralization. And why would he? Which papers should he have chosen?

And I never said all scientists agree. Typical straw man. But what I will say is there are plenty of climate change deniers that claim to be scientists.

unabst··on Weekend ‘catch-up sleep’ is a lie
Jordan Peterson is as scientific as a social scientist gets. He cites papers and describes the work of past scientists and his premises are evidence driven. He is a professor; a professional academic.

He has his opinions, positions and motives just like anyone else, but is open about them. If anything he is a rock star lecturer that exemplifies how informative, accurate, sincere, progressive, intimate, and inspiring science can be. He helps people for a living as a psychologist and a lecturer. If he offends you then you either have issues or don't understand him or both, but he would gladly engage with you either way.

Most that disagree with him disagree with the science, which puts them in the same boat as climate change deniers, of which there are plenty voicing their alternate facts online. But their voice doesn't validate their claims. Science is not a democracy.

unabst··on Ok-Cancel versus Cancel-Ok
Not just internally consistent, but externally consistent, at which point making this a matter of compliance.

External consistence isn't subjective. It's as objective to that system as any other fact, and is a matter of understanding, not feeling or choosing or designing.

If you're building an extension to MS Office, make your app comply with MS Office. Same with Adobe Photoshop plugins. And ultimately same with apps/programs for an OS.

If the OS does OK-left, do OK-left.

The UI that does not exist is the UI that is performing the best.

No one "uses" a UI. They just pass it. If you're thinking too hard about it, chances are you'll make your users think about it also. And trying to get noticed will always be at the expense of usability.

And finally, metrics such as consistency, obviousness/coherence, and simplicity are also objectively measurable, as are error rates, A/B tests, and step counts. What is subjective is user feedback and even developer feedback. By tallying what people think of an interface, you've already abandoned the goal of remaining unnoticed, and this is how Frankenstein UIs are built.

unabst··on How to be a Manager – A step-by-step guide to leading a team
"People. The hardest part of building a business."

If you're going to work and are having the hardest time with people, you should question the team. Anyone expressing an inkling of toxic, negative, or unprofessional attitude needs to be removed. Some people go bad, but it's just them telling you they want to go. Be graceful, but fire them.

Whatever you do, don't try to fix attitude. Everyone is entitled to their attitude in America, and it's the wrong battle. Let them have it.

They are not, however, entitled to contaminate your work culture, which must be upheld as sacrosanct. And, if it's you, then you've already burnt out.

A lot of old school management involves whips and dangling carrots. Managers are supervisors, and workers are presumed to misbehave without supervision. They are motivated with rewards, and put in check with punishment. Workers hate managers, and managers hate their job which would not exist if the workers would just behave. Good workers question their environment, their pay, then leave.

In reality, most ambitious professionals will behave when they take ownership of their responsibilities and opportunities, and will seek to build trust with others that do also. When handed, responsibilities and opportunities can quickly turn into dreadful obligations, so people must want them, and they will when they are aligned with their professional ambitions.

Once you have a team of such individuals, a manager is relinquished from behavior management. This holds true even at the lowest paying jobs.

Having this as the premise of your corporate culture will allow you to focus on managing work, not workers. And will allow your workers to focus on their work, and not each other. Trust will also naturally build among those showing responsible behavior. All this without "managing people". All this without "a leader".

Everyone leads themselves towards a common goal, empowered by a common philosophy, from the comfort of a common, sacred, positive workplace.

This formula took me five years, and it wasn't just the hardest part of building my business. It was five years of not being able to build my business. Today, I can say without reservation:

People are the best part of building a business.

And I am grateful to everyone, including those whom I fired, for teaching me this lesson.

unabst··on Underestimating the mind-warping potential of fake video
> fake videos are used to compromise the voices of those which deserve our trust

Which leads to what needs to be considered the greatest sin and betrayal of all: The creating and promoting of such videos.

No one creates a false video by accident. They know what they are doing, and their intentions are clear.

And this is not free speech.

Putting words in other people's mouths and manipulating voices is fake speech, and is the direct opposite of free speech.

unabst··on Facebook to ask everyone to accept being tracked so they can keep using it
But this is not the point. Once you have an account, you create a bucket, a magnet, and an entry in their database.

You exist.

They don't need you to participate. They need your email or your phone number that can link you to the rest of the matrix. With a mobile app, they get your phone number automatically.

Everything else you post is icing on the cake. They don't need your relationship status. They don't need your address. Maybe your phone number will link to one, but they don't need it to be accurate.

Now you're part of the data pool. You're one more audience member. You're fueling facebook and their profits.

You're being sold.

Not only that, non-participation grants a false sense of security. As does the data they ask for; as if the data you post is all that they know or that is being shared. As do all their privacy settings. As does deleting your account. Facebook might mark you as deleted, but your data has already been used, sold, and transferred to 3rd parties, none of whom are inclined to delete your data.

If the data hasn't changed, and you haven't changed, then deleting yourself from facebook doesn't change anything.

unabst··on The Irreproducibility Crisis of Modern Science
Of course science flies in the face of democracy. Democracy gives all the power to individual subjective opinion. Hence the battle against emotional bias, fake news, and propaganda tactics which all work wonders in a democracy. This battle is fought with objective facts, which are only attainable by science.

Science is the only tool specifically designed to weed out falsehoods and reach an objective consensus based on how nature works.

How is this "subject to falsehoods just like any other human endeavor"?

There is no substitute for science.

We all seem to agree that democracy only works when the population is informed. Well, are we going to inform ourselves with the beliefs and tweets of those which we grant moral authority? Or science?

unabst··on Craigslist takes personals sections offline in response to FOSTA
Nothing should be demonized. Anything that hinders humanity should be regulated and monitored, proportional to the threat. That is all that is needed.

Out of sight and out of mind enables thriving dark markets. To eliminate dark markets, the open market must be all inclusive. There needs to be only one market.

For darker material, we need more aggressive inclusion tactics.

For example, pedophilia should be considered an extremely dangerous disease. Imagine if we treated Ebola or AIDS as a crime. No one would ever be protected or cured (or neutralized), and carriers would be hiding among us.

unabst··on The iPhoneX is Apple's underrated masterpiece
TLDR Despite all the praise and joy and everything amazing and underrated about the phone, the author prefers the Google’s Pixel 2 XL for its superior camera.

You don't say...

unabst··on Front (YC S14) Raises $66M
This.

I did extensive searching for customer support email solutions. I landed at Front. But, I haven't pulled the trigger yet.

Zen was an easy pass for us, but we arrived at Front because of what they do better than Zen. Consolidation.

But the commonality is that these services always charge more than Todo apps or even chat apps. Even G Suite is cheaper. For some reason Google's team mailbox was a joke. They seem to have every feature of every startup somewhere, but have it suck.

I doubt these guys would be similar in pricing unless they were competing for the same market.

Same with buffer.com. They are a bit pricey too, but they can target businesses that save money with their service. Pockets open immediately when that is part of your value proposition -- cost savings.

unabst··on Front (YC S14) Raises $66M
> email, chat or mixed of both in a one convenient place.

No, exactly. But you are always at risk of being just another channel. So you need to beat the rest. Or be above them. Or at least consolidate a few.

Front does a better job of marketing themselves as such (not the outlook argument, their inbox argument).

If you could pull in "channels" or have an open API for adding custom channels where users can participate in helping build your catalog, I think that would help.

The beauty of discord is with webhooks. Slack has "integrations" but they needed 1st party support. And I'd use Zapier to bridge the gaps. But most API sets have webhook support. And Discord allows for postings via webhooks. So I have a simple REST webhook processor page that takes incoming webhooks and posts to discord and everything else.

Not that webhooks are your answer, but just an example of a common chat app setup with a drastically better/easier feature set than their major competition.

> Firs time I hear that one. :)

It's the combination of white and the curves. Reminds me of boxer briefs every time. An easy fix would be to sharpen the rounded corners, but it's none of my business.

Either way, I have nothing but respect for you and your business. I wish you only the best ;)

unabst··on Front (YC S14) Raises $66M
If you had said you were replacing outlook, I'd be less surprised. You seem more email focused.

Front's front page slogan is "The shared inbox for teams." I'm always puzzled when they attack modern email in their PR. They should just stick to "universal team inbox".

When I see missive, I see "team email with chat." Well, we chat on Discord already, so that's not the pain point.

Front's main appeal to me at least was their multi-channel inbox. Customer support these days is not just email but social media and even texting. It can all be done through email, and even that can all be done through gmail, which is what we're doing now, and what I suspect a lot of people are doing.

But removing inefficiencies in this day to day process immediately cuts costs when you're paying people for this work. Hence zendesk and their no free plan position, except, they're not multi-channel, and I was never impressed by them being on the customer end of a zendesk using company. I'd always think "crutch" when I saw an email from a business that didn't bother to re-brand their zendesk (assuming it's possible, if not, I guess they did well for themselves and my impressions were unimportant).

PS. Your logo reminds me of men's underwear. I thought twice about mentioning it, and I know others would too. Not that I'd hold it against you, but (I do logo design, is my excuse for mentioning it).

unabst··on Front (YC S14) Raises $66M
They are expensive, and we'd be paying already had they been closer to 10 mo/user. But it seems they're going the customer service tool route, and this is a pain point businesses are willing to pay for. In this area I'd say their #1 rival is zendesk, which does a better job of justifying their pricing on their site (which had me return to Front for what they do better).

But Front won't be replacing anyone's free web mail at any price point. I can't believe they don't have a free plan.

unabst··on People leave managers, not companies
No.

Putting the organization ahead of individuals isn't what's happening. The individuals ARE the organization.

So if you put yourself ahead of the organization, you're putting everyone else behind you, including your boss. This is a challenge for millennials especially, who are used to always being put first, and having their emotions managed.

A good manager doesn't put themselves before their boss or anyone else. How often do you hear of programmers who enter management to hardly touch code again? A good manager puts the organization first, both above and below their pay grade.

But their performance also depends on the people they manage. If a worker is incompetent, they have every right to be hard on those mistakes. And the worker is fully responsible for setting things right. Work is not homework that gets handed back to you after its graded. It's something needed by someone else that needs it for something important. And nothing is redundant in a tightly run business.

When I think of Melissa Mayers, I think of bullets. Despite whether anyone agrees with "her" moves (which were clearly backed by her counsel), she was doing everything she could to increase market share and rebuild a failing business. She took on all the risk, and becomes target practice for those who despise her failures. When was the last time you were bashed on HN? And she does this so that everyone at Yahoo has a job. She is fighting for YOU.

Regardless of my word choice, to borrow your words, the CEO is a ridiculously inflated position.

unabst··on People leave managers, not companies
The manager is your interface to management. It's their job to tell you what you need to know and what to do. To an employee, they're the face of the business.

But at the end of the day, if it's the people that make up a business, then I'd question if they are not the same thing.

I asked a new acquaintance of mine about something bothering me.

I asked him, "so, how often do you fire people? How do find the right people for your businesses?"

"I hardly ever have to fire anyone," he said. "I ask them questions, and they leave."

Damn.

And the thing is, this pressure isn't faked or manufactured. This isn't anyone trying to fire someone. This is just someone needing work done, and answers.

No business wants anyone incompetent, yet, it happens, because of interviewees lying through their teeth and not knowing any better.

So they walk in and fail to do the exact job they won for themselves, then come the questions.

Now they lose their place and have to leave, knowing they got the job by accident.

There is plenty of real pressure to go around in a real business, and we avoid managerial roles because we know the stakes are higher. We know that having a manager is "safer" than being one, because having a manager is having someone responsible for you, and for your well being. It's how America figured out how to hire from the abundant talent pool of those who can't handle tough responsibilities and stay happy on their own, and those who'd rather have it easier. It's the luxury of being managed.

But above that, it gets even worse. Fewer luxuries, just higher pay. Just think of all the bullets the CEO has to catch with their teeth every day. And wen they fail, it's news.

unabst··on Why People Dislike Really Smart Leaders
I'm a smart leader, and I am disliked. And it's this exact tone that they dislike most.

They feel I lack empathy, but empathy is why I do it.

And when someone likes me, I know they know we know what's up. That's also why I do it.

I find those who work hard to be liked creepy. I also find managers and supervisors who are paid to be your friend disingenuous. And I'm not going to butter someone up before I tell them they made a mistake. The last thing I want is to spoil them or keep them in a bubble. But I'll also tell them to focus on the problem, and not themselves. Don't be part of the problem.

Being liked is work in business. In our private lives it's personal preference, but you can also choose your friends. Professionally, it's a strategic decision, because it will inevitably involve people you may struggle to like personally.

The prevalent anti-intellectualism does intellects injustice more than anything else. Many would rather be spoiled than informed. They'd rather protect their ego than gain competence. They'd rather be forgiven than corrected for their mistakes. And they'd rather be paid for being who they are, than be told they need to work or put in the work.

No one is paid for being who they are, not even celebrities. We're all being paid for our work. Our image is part of our work, even for non-celebrities.

Anti-intellectualism is also at the root of anti-professionalism. And it's a huge issue in America.

Out of pragmatism, out of optimism, and out of empathy, I am sorry, but I choose to be unapologetically professional.

I am the apologetic asshole.

And that's what's up.

(didn't expect this comment to turn out this way, but I'm submitting it anyway)

unabst··on A Type of Road Junction that Kills Cyclists
This doesn't happen, at least from my limited experience in Beverly Hills.

I ride several blocks to work sometimes and I take local streets which all have 4 ways stop signs.

9 out of 10 cars yield and refuse to go. I get the pedestrian treatment.

unabst··on What does code readability mean?
I've understood "simple" in coding to mean "with the fewest abstractions possible."

This. Is. Hard.

It does help when the language is simpler. But as I code, when I find the need to deal with more exceptions, more functions, and more words just to get something to work... I just assume I should do it differently.

Unfortunately, that's most of the time I spend coding.

unabst··on The growing body of evidence that digital distraction is damaging our minds
I was thinking about this the other day.

There is nothing "smartphone" about games. A board game, a video game, or even sports is a game that is fun and engaging that anyone can do together, as is any smartphone game.

There is nothing "smartphone" about the news or social media or email. These have all been here, and just moving them to our pockets alone can't be that damaging.

And there is nothing "smartphone" about ads or paid content or even facebook likes.

What's "smartphone" is the immediacy and the frequency of the connectivity. It's the bond that is stronger -- and hence the more of us more strongly bound to our phones.

But this alone can't be damaging. It's just amazing. What is damaging are the businesses, and people mind you, that abuse this bond. Ourselves included.

So what we really have is a new tool that just gives us more of what we want faster.

Of course this is game changing. Of course this is dangerous. But whether we let this damage us is still a choice. And at the end of the day, a lot of it is just people abusing and damaging people. It's clear we can't help ourselves. But we can also help ourselves, which is what most of these articles appear to be about.

The point being, demonizing smartphones is just shifting blame. Getting rid of them is getting rid of the problem, not finding a solution. With the overarching point being, they themselves are not that dangerous.

They can't be.

Or maybe I'm still missing something...

unabst··on Teens Aren’t Partying Anymore
Ironically, kids now have GPS trackers and cell phones. You'd think it'd be easier to let them loose.
unabst··on Teens Aren’t Partying Anymore
I have a 3 year old. The ads absolutely get to him. And many are inappropriate.

Any game that he likes, I remove the ads. It's usually a dollar or two. I also consider it a tip to the developers for entertaining my kid.

I usually play together when I can. And he also enjoys watching me play. I actually can't wait for the day when he beats me at street fighter.

But I think the key is finding things he enjoys just as much as playing video games or watching tv. It's hard, but they exist. And exercise should be one of them. Solving puzzles another. Going outside on the scooter is another. Cooking is another. They aren't hard to find.

If he loves something too much, I'd limit it with a reward system. That's how the world works anyway.

unabst··on Humans are Liars
You will find dishonesty between managers and workers. This is because workers try to get away with things, and managers are paid to catch them.

You will find dishonesty between executives and shareholders. This is because executives are paid to lie about performance, and share holders exist to punish them.

But this is just as systematic as it is human.

Dishonesty is rarer among workers. Their gossip is honest, and hence cathartic.

Dishonesty is also rarer among the executive team. For running a company can only be done with facts, and in almost all cases of corporate scams, the executives were all in on it. And even the whistle blower would have had to known the truth.

← PreviousPage 5 of 20Next →