HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

unclebucknasty

4,691 karma · joined February 1, 2013

submissionscomments
unclebucknasty··on Demolishing the Fry's Electronics in Burbank
And each one of those items would somehow have a dead pixel.
unclebucknasty··on Elite Pentagon Tech Unit Resigns En Masse After Clashing with Doge
Only question is the size of the upcoming contracts for some newly formed firm(s) or existing firm(s), adjacent to this administration.
unclebucknasty··on Elite Pentagon Tech Unit Resigns En Masse After Clashing with Doge
https://archive.is/pjuNe
unclebucknasty··on Harvard's response to federal government letter demanding changes
>The argument isn't that Harvard should never draw from its endowment, like it's saving for retirement or something

The argument I was replying to was actually of exactly this form.

That argument also implied that any endowment spending to cover shortfalls would necessarily be of the principal, but that is also incorrect.

In fact, the White House just responded with a $2.2B funding freeze—an amount that would have been covered by last year's endowment return.

unclebucknasty··on Harvard's response to federal government letter demanding changes
>You can certainly do it, in a true emergency. But you certainly don't want to make a habit of it.

Harvard's endowment returned 9.6% last year, growing the total by $2.5 billion. In the previous year, the endowment returned 2.9%, though the total endowment decreased as the gain was offset by contributions to operating expenses. [0]

In other words, Harvard already operates somewhat from their endowment, and can realize net endowment gains in spite of that.

[0] https://www.harvardmagazine.com/2024/10/financial-report-fis...

unclebucknasty··on Harvard's response to federal government letter demanding changes
>Your job exists more or less at the whims of the currently governing administration.

Perhaps in theory, but not in practice as a historical norm. And, certainly not for "standard" non-appointed, bureaucratic roles.

It's important that we don't normalize what we're seeing here, in terms of quality or degree.

unclebucknasty··on Trump exempts phones, computers, chips from ‘reciprocal’ tariffs
No, it's not 4D chess, and neither is extorting companies with tariffs, extorting law firms with threats of executive orders, or hammering universities by withholding funds.

It's all blunt-force checkers that any simpleton with power can easily understand.

unclebucknasty··on Trump exempts phones, computers, chips from ‘reciprocal’ tariffs
It's exactly what it is. And, the seemingly haphazard, unpredictable nature of it is a feature, serving as perfect cover:

"Why these exemptions?"

"Who knows? None of it makes sense."

But, of course, it does.

It's also consistent with other, publicly-wielded cudgels, like the law-firm extortions under threat of executive orders.

unclebucknasty··on Google to pay $28M to settle claims it favoured white and Asian employees
>But again, why call out specific groups by gender or race and not call out others?

History. There is an undeniable legacy of gender and race-based discrimination. This discrimination was absolutely laser-focused on gender and race, so is it fairer to simply ignore this and call it a wash?

For instance, some estimates of the value of free labor provided by slaves in the U.S. are upwards of $100 trillion, with an amplification effect (including an inverse one), compounding over generations.

>Do people really think that a white guy from some poor area has more privilege...

No. There are programs for people in rural areas, poorer areas, etc. To the extent that these are inadequate, they should also be addressed.

But, it's not just about economics. It's also about culture, socialization, etc.

unclebucknasty··on Google to pay $28M to settle claims it favoured white and Asian employees
>Like what?

The Disability Alliance Network (DA)?

I'm assuming that's a good example, because I've yet to see an outcry around disabled people getting unfair advantages.

But, it's really down to any group that has not been socially or politically charged. So, I'd also say things like women's groups, given their historic underrepresentation in tech. However, that's also become charged recently.

So, what we have is this thing of defining what's OK by how people react to it or, maybe more accurately, how people are encouraged to react. That seems potentially unhealthy and infinitely abusable.

>Because it's been a tool of social division.

Exactly. But, it's not just division in the sense of splitting people in half. There's also a historic inequity that corresponds with one side.

Some make the argument that you can't heal division by "dividing further". But, I think it's a little unfair to simply not acknowledge those who have been negatively impacted. The other part is that the existence of a group doesn't have to be divisive in itself. In fact, seeking to understand and support them can be quite the opposite.

unclebucknasty··on Google to pay $28M to settle claims it favoured white and Asian employees
>offering development resources based on race, an immutable characteristic, is deeply unsettling to a lot of people.

I understand, but I'm trying to provide a point of view that might make it less unsettling. Otherwise, we're just kind of saying that people find it unsettling, so it must be wrong (BTW, we also can't overlook that there are people who want to make it more unsettling, for reasons).

Anyway, it really comes down to backing up a little to consider why race became a factor. Else, if we simply start the clock at the inception of these groups, then I suppose it should be unsettling.

Interestingly, there are other immutable characteristics that do not trigger that unsettledness. If nothing else, this gives us reason to question why this particular characteristic became so charged.

unclebucknasty··on Google to pay $28M to settle claims it favoured white and Asian employees
>Asians have an ERG.

Google doesn't exist in a vacuum, but in a broader culture (e.g. America). If you're coming from an Asian country, you might still feel alienated or simply want to connect with people who intrinsically understand your culture.

That said, the Asian makeup of Google has increased significantly over the years. I wonder how that has impacted the participation rate in its ERG versus when it was originally established.

>* What is special about Whites that they must be prevented from doing the thing that literally all others have done?*

The dominant culture is essentially the "default" and is somewhat "self-reinforcing", so generally has no need of an identity-based support group. Thus, when the dominant culture does establish an identity-based group, it tends to take on a different meaning.

unclebucknasty··on Google to pay $28M to settle claims it favoured white and Asian employees
>If Swiss and white were the same thing, that would make a lot of sense

We all have multiple identities. We relate to those identities and others relate to us by those identities—at times, unfortunately. So, you can substitute any identity here, and it still makes sense.

>it might feel extra-alienating if the company suggests you could join the Asian or Indian employee support groups

Not necessarily. There's certainly some overlap in experience, as they are all working to integrate into the same culture.

What you may be missing here is that it's not strictly about which specific group, but also about the fact that the group is not the majority / "culture-defining group".

>OTOH, for the same reason, skin-color-based groups don't really make sense to begin with.

Oh, if only they didn't, my friend. What a world this would be. It's worth noting that it's generally not those "skin-colors" who made these groups necessary. Part of it is just the complicated tribalism of humans. And, yes, another part of it is that some people have taken advantage of that tribalism.

unclebucknasty··on Google to pay $28M to settle claims it favoured white and Asian employees
>ERG groups provide mentorship and support.

Yes, and Google offers a wide range of mentorship/support programs, from those for community college students to upskilling to new hires to tailored programs and more.

>The assumption that all white people, males or in this case Swiss don’t need support

I don't think anyone assumes that. I certainly don't. I'm sure Google provides other means of support to its employees, and ERGs represent just one approach, which address specific needs for specific employees.

What you have to understand is that people are tribal and that can have effects on "outgroups" in any given context. If we're out at lunch and all but one of us is in the same frat, we may unintentionally exclude that person. It's not necessarily intentional or malicious. That's obviously a simplification, but you can extrapolate.

So, ERGs aren't meant to be punitive or exclusionary. In fact, according to OP, Google encouraged all employees to join whichever groups interested them.

unclebucknasty··on Google to pay $28M to settle claims it favoured white and Asian employees
>Straight white men, or even just white people, is in no way the "default" at Google, and very far from the 90% in your allegory.

It's not supposed to map statistically on to Google. It's an analogy, intended to remove the problematic political context.

That said, Asian+White does make up 90%+ of Google's workforce, split roughly in half. Interestingly, there's an Asian ERG.

unclebucknasty··on Google to pay $28M to settle claims it favoured white and Asian employees
Not surprising. There are different ways to view identity, and none of us are any one thing. Your observation underscores my point that providing support along the lines of identity can be completely benign sans a political context.

That said, feel free to substitute a more homogenous country if that helps to clarify my point.

unclebucknasty··on Google to pay $28M to settle claims it favoured white and Asian employees
>There was a ERG for literally every single race except White people. "Just join one of the others" was what they told me.

Imagine moving to say, Switzerland, to work for a massive corporation. 90% of the employees are Swiss. The other 10% come from a smattering of other countries from around the world. To help those employees acclimate to a new culture and find support, the company sponsors country-based ERGs.

Of course, there is no Swiss ERG, as it's the "default", because the entire company is essentially a Swiss ERG. But, the company encourages its Swiss employees to join the others as a show of support and cultural exchange.

If you had attended one of those groups, you might have found yourself feeling extraordinarily welcome, and even learned a few things about your fellow employees.

>A few of these people were totally inept technically at their job and I saw them convert into better jobs. It must have been nice.

If "totally inept" people are being promoted with any frequency, then that's a problem for any company. I think we have all seen this occasionally but, in my experience, it has very little to do with race (or other identity) and more to do with the Peter Principle and the fact that hiring and HR management is notoriously hard to get right.

I'm not suggesting anything about the earnestness of your observations, but you should be aware that assuming every non-white person you see at a company is the beneficiary of preferential treatment is a bit of a canard. And the idea that a disproportionate number of those are inept is yet another.

As such, whimsical people might draw rather nasty conclusions from your statements, that are other than what you intended.

unclebucknasty··on Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it to generate it
Understood. Thanks for clarifying.

Yeah, I've been in the game for "a while" myself. The example you gave with garbage collection reminds me of stories I've heard about Assembly language programmers back in the day, declaring that devs who use high level languages (like C) don't really know how to write good code.

There's probably something to that, but it does beg the question "what's the right tradeoff?" Not only do we not have to deal with memory management, but also data structures and common algorithms, etc. I do think understanding those things made me a better coder, but perhaps progressively less meaningfully so, as time marched on and the lower level stuff was abstracted away by more and more layers on our move up stack to solve harder problems.

So, the emphasis on writing code from scratch lessened over the years, and development became more about integrating other people's code (frameworks, libraries, API's, etc). So, I think that kind of teed up this AI approach to writing code, in that it's just more code to integrate that you didn't write.

But, it is qualitatively different from the "natural progression", in that they're not writing code at all. In that way it feels like the last stop on the coding continuum. I suppose that makes sense, since we're told that we soon won't need human coders at all.

unclebucknasty··on Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it to generate it
>the whole reason for the "AI epidemic" is that people are avoiding effort like the plague.

I think AI is being driven most by those interested in the "promise" of eliminating workers altogether.

But, if by "AI epidemic", you more mean the increasing uptake of AI by workers/devs themselves (versus the overall frenzy), then I think the characterizations of "avoiding effort" and "laziness" are a bit harsh. I mean, of course people don't generally want to take the path of most resistance. And, there's value in efficiency being an "approach to life".

But, I think there's still more from the human side: that is, if the things you're spending your time on have less value of the sort emphasized in your environment, then your interest will likely naturally wane over time. I think this is especially true of something tedious like coding.

So, I believe there's a human/social element that goes beyond the pressure to keep up for the sake of job security.

unclebucknasty··on An investigation into egg prices
Have no idea why this was downvoted.

>from serious outlets about how price gouging won't work

I think you meant to say "price freezes", "anti-gouging regulation" or similar.

unclebucknasty··on The Demoralization is just Beginning
>I'm judging it in comparison to your statement that it has promoted and protected democracy around the world

The point I'm making here is that this doesn't always look like we think it should (though it also frequently has). The world doesn't just cooperate. It's a nasty place filled with competing, often hostile ideologies. And sometimes nastiness is required.

>There is no evidence at all...

Of course there is. If I give you examples, you might wave them off as the U.S. merely promoting its interests versus democracy, but these are frequently directly linked. The U.S. does have an interest in promoting democracy in the world, even if there are counterintuitive scenarios wherein we must take a short term approach that reads anti-democratic. For instance, if a candidate were democratically elected, then ruled as a dictator, removing that democratically elected president would conceivably be a democratic action.

Beyond this, the U.S. must protect its interests (and power) if it is to continue wielding influence in the world.

But, it's true that there have also been grave missteps along the way. I want my country to be perfect too. But, alas. Still, I don't believe it's so binary (though I once did).

In any case, we seem to disagree and I'm not sure that this goes much further without us simply repeating ourselves. Thanks for the chat.

unclebucknasty··on The Demoralization is just Beginning
You are judging the U.S. in the context of an otherwise utopian world that doesn't exist.

Yes, it gets messy. And, yes, United Fruit Company et. al. happened. We've absolutely had government capture and promotion of special interests. But, even these aren't always so neatly separable from U.S. interests, which are not always so neatly inseparable from promotion of democracy. For instance, a weak economy would make it nearly impossible to have influence in the world.

There's a simplified world view that ignores the good, measures each discrete misstep on its own (or interprets every difficult choice as a misstep), then tallies a final score. But this is not realistic in a world where lesser evils are frequently the viable option. America does not operate in vacuum and you have to look at the entire arc.

You'll not see me defending every egregious thing this country has done or endorsing the instances when it has truly veered from its creed. But, to measure us by only that metric and declare the country evil or completely non-democratic is to exonerate other bad actors on the planet.

Worse, adopting such a simplistic point of view makes it impossible to recognize when we've entered a truly treacherous phase, wherein an authoritarian regime comes to power and eschews democracy entirely. Everyone would just throw their hands up and declare "we were never democratic anyway, so it doesn't matter". And, by the time they're shown the difference between our imperfect democracy and frank authoritarianism, it's too late.

unclebucknasty··on The Demoralization is just Beginning
The U.S. hasn't been perfect, but I'll take it over the alternatives.

And, I'd say protecting democracy for "white countries only" is a simplification. If you're talking about Europe, then we have to consider that the U.S. has also pretty famously fought against European nations and that our subsequent "protection" there was to serve as a bulwark to maintain a world order that benefited the U.S. and democracy.

And, you have to consider that we later "protected" the non-white Japan, Korea, and Vietnam at great cost.

In some of the countries wherein the U.S. could be said to have propped up dictators, there tended to be other geopolitical realities. For instance, many of these were in the Middle East and the U.S. elected to align with the most pliable of the available alternatives. And, in spite of this, the U.S. has also promoted democracy in the region.

You have to also consider the sentiment in many of the countries or regions is/was decidedly anti-American and the choice to support regimes less hostile to U.S. interests is a practical one. Many do not want democracy and the alternative for the U.S. is frequently to topple regimes and attempt to stand up completely new governments (i.e. nation-building). This is an extraordinarily costly endeavor with a high failure rate.

And, all of this in the context of adversarial nations doing the same to promote their own interests.

Again, we're not perfect but the world is a messy place.

unclebucknasty··on The Demoralization is just Beginning
>there is more to an economy than manufacturing

I don't agree with all of his premises or conclusions either, but I believe he's exactly right about the financial engineering and outsized rewards that frequently accrue to non-productive activity in general.

I see the manufacturing fall-off he notes as a proxy for that. It's not the only evidence, but it's one piece.

unclebucknasty··on The Demoralization is just Beginning
What you're missing is the role the U.S. has historically played in preserving and protecting democracy in the world and, particularly, Europe.

If America was suddenly no longer a hegemon, it would be qualitatively different. There are other hegemons in the world that would step into the void left by the U.S., and it would be their influence that would be felt most the world over, including by the countries you named.

unclebucknasty··on The Demoralization is just Beginning
>Do you think people in Sweden or Denmark are upset their countries aren't hegemons?

Funny that you chose those two countries. Denmark is a founding member of NATO. Sweden is one of the two most recent admitted, almost a year ago.

My point is that it's U.S. hegemony that has protected its own democracy and that of liberal democratic Europe to a large extent.

Sweden and Denmark haven't been hegemons because they haven't needed to be.

unclebucknasty··on Executive wealth as a factor in return-to-office
>Not sure why you are being downvoted

Not a downvoter, but I suspect it's because we all know that people have a tendency to act in their own best interest.

But, we also expect leaders to consider the best interests of their charges, as a function of good leadership.

unclebucknasty··on Substance in broccoli, celery inhibits graying of black hair
>what's the ultimate benefit against just using hair dye?

Permanent hair color generally contains PPD to penetrate the hair cuticle so the dye can actually bind to the hair. That stuff is notorious for causing wicked allergic reactions and sensitizing users over time.

unclebucknasty··on Kaspersky exposes hidden malware on GitHub stealing personal data
But, truly, what is the solution?

I mean, you can use static analysis or similar, but you generally can't check every line of code for every open source lib you pull in, let alone its dependencies.

Seems that, once you decide to use open source, you are actually making a choice to trust to some extent.

unclebucknasty··on Hallucinations in code are the least dangerous form of LLM mistakes
Exactly. And, if correction is required, then you either re-write it or you're stuck maintaining whatever odd way the LLM approached the problem, whether it's as optimal (or readable) as a human's or not.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →