1,306 karma · joined August 20, 2013
The school of thought there is that closed timelike curves could be possible in many theoretical ways. You can imagine funky cosmologies, ways of making wormholes, ways of making tachyons... when you get specific enough with any possibility, theory has shown it is impossible. But the problems with each possibility don't seem to have a common theme. None of those reasons seem to lead to a fundamental proof prohibiting closed time-like curves. It seems instead that something (coincidence, nature's desires, a proof yet undiscovered) is conspiring to prohibit all of them.
The Gödel Metric, for instance, is just a toy universe. It has a cylindrical topology (unlike ours), a negative cosmological constant (unlike ours) and finely tuned cosmological parameters that don't match ours. Showing we don't live in this universe is trivial. Showing we don't live in that universe simply because it has time travel still eludes us.
I believe the right thing functionally is a child branch, updated automatically with either a merge or a force-push on new successful builds. But it feels not quite right conceptually, and it's harder to explain to new developers (who can already get overwhelmed with handling multiple branches). Is there a non-branch solution for having a moving unique label?
In order to derive those heat equations from the second law, we now know it requires an assumption: that you (or any entropy-containing component not modeled in the system) cannot have specific knowledge of the microstate of the system, only its macroscopic properties. For a long time it seemed absurd that such an assumption would necessary at all, for these seemingly universal laws, and there was no clear way to thermodynamically model the knowledge of the actor inside this system such that you wouldn't need such an assumption.
This article definitely isn't bias-free either but at least it's not picking stocks based on performance.
Such a loop of operations containing only multiplication, addition, and subtraction would work on activity complex numbers. Square roots would not.
Spoilers:
First note that, below 16, 11 is the only sum which explains S's first statement: all possible pairs of numbers adding to 11 have non-unique products, accounting for S knowing P would not know the numbers.
Then note that for 18 (9x2), 24 (8x3), and 28 (7x4), all other factor pairs for that product add to a non-11 number below 16. Those non-11 sums are ruled out by S's first statement, so P will know the sum is 11 by her second statement.
Therefore (9,2), (8,3), and (7,4) all look like valid solutions, and it seems likely there are more.
What am I missing?
Everettians and non-Everettians agree that 1) The state of the universe is fully described by a set of quantum fields 2) The quantum fields will change over time according to the Schrödinger equation.
So far, this is analogous to how classical physics is set up, but in classical physics the "state" is a bunch of particles with positions and momentums, and the "change over time" is F=ma (for all forces).
Non-Everettians would say those two rules alone do not explain experimental results. We need extra rules, namely: 3) When a "measurement" occurs, the state of the quantum field collapses into a single definite value, and 4) The probability of the outcome of that measurement is given by the Born rule
The main issues with non-Everettian interpretations are that 1) The definition of a measurement is vague, and 2) you need some theory of why the collapse occurs, and what exactly is happening as the measurement is being taken (there are many options here).
Everettians instead ask, what would happen if we just... didn't have those extra rules?
If so, the Schödinger equation on its own predicts the following evolution of quantum state during an experiment:
To begin we have an "uncollapsed" quantum state. Say, an electron in a superposition of spin-up and spin-down, not entangled with anything else
During the experiment, the electron becomes entangled with other particles in the measurement apparatus
By the time the measurement is complete, we have full entanglement, the new quantum state is a superposition of "spin-up and a small current induced in the top plate" and "spin-down and a small current induced in the bottom plate"
When the experimenter reads the result, we have even more entanglement into a superposition of "spin-up and the experimenter sees it's spin up" and "spin-down and the experimenter sees it's spin down"
There are cascading interactions with every particle in the universe until the whole universe is entangled into a superposition of "spin-up and the universe is as it would be if the particle were spin-up" and "spin-down and the universe is as it would be if the particle were spin-down"
At this point an Everettian would say: this is exactly consistent with what non-Everettians were trying to show with their extra rules! The quantum field has evolved into a superposition of two universes, and the Schrödinger equation predicts those two universes never interact with each other... so there's really no evidence that the Schrödinger equation ever needs to not hold true. Quantum collapse happens on its own when you just run the Schrödinger equation forward, and the extra universes are just an unobservable byproduct.The main issues with the Everettian interpretation are epistemic: I don't know what it should feel like to be in a superposition of two non-interacting universes with different states of knowledge, but to be an Everettian, you need to believe it feels like just being in one of them. Depending on your philosophy of consciousness, it's anywhere from trivial to impossible to prove that.
My (limited) experience with piezoelectric speakers is that they resonate at a single frequency very loudly, and are practically silent outside the resonant peak. Perfect for a microwave beeper, but never going to produce audible speech.
The "high-quality" descriptor makes it sound like they have produced a reasonably flat gain curve, which seems really significant! But without any explanation I'm skeptical.
It may even be as silly as using an unintuitive technical definition of "quality" - in a second order linear system, the "quality" of the gain curve is the ratio of the amplitude at the peak to the input amplitude... The exact opposite of what a reasonable person would consider high-quality sound.
So, the prior which is strong/weak is the probability distribution of probability distributions. There is a <<1% chance that I will ever believe there is a >90% chance of flipping heads. But there is a much greater probability that I will one day believe there is a >90% chance of life on Mars.
What terminology would you use to describe that, if not strong/weak priors?
A couple factors make the current system powerful: - Each decision-maker is roughly motivated to seek truth and behave honestly by the judgement of the next level up, so i.e. impeachment of judges should be rare - The hierarchical structure makes enforcement exponentially cheaper than every human voting on every contract outcome.
Neither government contracts nor smart contracts can offer 100% correct validation of every contract. All they can do is attempt to set up a structure which tries to motivate the right thing and tries to make litigation somewhat cheap.
It seems a bit silly, though, to think there's no room for improvement there, both in performance and correctness. 1) By making all decisions public, you can make judging those decisions easier 2) By making all decisions public, you can easily reuse a single judgement in many decisions 3) By using machines instead of humans, there is dramatically more bandwidth for a much broader range of contracts 4) The topology of this network only really lets people vote at a single point – where a governor is elected every n years, which is hardly robust feedback. etc.
I mostly agree with your conclusion on most parts of crypto but we shouldn't thing that "government is a solved problem" is a sweeping rebuttal of all smart contracts.
https://mathoverflow.net/questions/366070/what-are-the-benef...
Every vision of a low-carbon future requires many things to change. You're saying we should let the current slow movement on electricty generation be an excuse for not moving on EVs (despite the fact that they're an improvement regardless). You could similarly argue that the slow movement on EVs should be an excuse from not improving electricity generation (despite the fact that there are improvements regardless).
Whataboutism about one vision is worthless until you have a better vision, where we can compare the practical and political tradeoffs between them.
Are you proposing that replacing ICE vehicles with EVs is not an essential part of a long-term, low-carbon future?
Cap and trade is fundamentally different from offsets in that there is a central authority who decides precisely what caps every company gets before trading starts, so every transaction which increases one company's cap by 1 ton is guaranteed to decrease another's.
Offsets are a decentralized attempt to quantify how various actions would lower the world's carbon output compared to some estimate of what would happen otherwise. The cheapest offsets prey on this ambiguity in the various ways the article suggestions.
The other big difference is that cap and trade is mandatory while offsets are optional. There is so little offset-buying happening now that the markets are artificially cheap. Companies currently claiming to be "carbon neutral" would certainly be unable to afford doing so if it was required of every company (similar to if the "cap" was universally zero carbon, a clear non-starter today).
Obviously, if everyone read everything, and read it with the same temperament, it should be useless. How could something you can attach to any argument be persuasive? But people skim and skim with bias.
It's really significant effect on places like reddit, where "this will get downvoted but mediocre insight" will get far more upvotes than "mediocre insight". It can be used and abused.
It's a naive view, but a common one. It deserves the counter-argument it's getting.
The many worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics, for instance, provides clear math on how to reason about quantities as the universe splits into more universes: we integrate after multiplying by the probability of each branch. No credible physical theory is proposing we double the amount of mass and energy in the universe whenever we measure the spin of an electron.
Calling that split universe "two universes" instead of "two half-universes" is fine for a casual explanation, but if you want to do correct math with this result, you need to start with the correct math too! Once you make that adjustment, all this talk in about "finite benefits don't matter compared to infinite benefits" can be translated as "benefits with probability zero don't matter compared to benefits with non-zero probability". Much more palatable.
There are still interesting conversations about benefits which could last for infinite time. But there, the crux is in the "could". These thought experiments always bake in assumptions at dozens of levels which say "this factor in my model will last for infinite time". When you consider in our ignorance about what the future will hold, I've yet to see a convincing example where we could truly consider a finite action as having infinite utility. I'm certainly open to it, I just haven't seen it.
As a DM, if I reach my hand in my bag of unfair chessex dice, make a biased choice of which which biased die I unfairly throw... From my perspective, the odds of a 20 are still 5%, because I don't have good enough memory to know what direction any of those biases go.
If one of my players, who have much less to do than a DM, rolls their same d20 every session, they will eventually pick up on its tendencies and know their die is more likely on average to crit.
If a cheating player understands the velocity of their roll, they can toss in such a way that 20 is much much more likely to appear.
The DM I describe can roll the same die as the player I describe but experience different probabilities because of ignorance. A fair player I describe who rolls their die in the same way as the cheating player I describe is experiencing different probabilities because of ignorance.
Situations we think of as random are just good at quickly spreading ignorance. A tiny change in velocity for the cheating player will spoil his plans, and the dice numbers are spread nearly equally so that this small ignorance about velocity quickly becomes large ignorance about the probability distribution of the result. Knowing half the bits of the seed of a PRNG quickly decays into nearly zero info about it's probability distribution. Knowing the seed of a PRNG precisely and the number of cycles imprecisely quickly becomes worthless, by design.
Dice, PRNGs, other things we think of as random are only different from any other piece of knowledge (future election results, whether the 1000th digit of pi is odd...) in that they are decent at quickly turning what knowledge you have into ignorance.
The skew dice faces are all identical but none are even parallel.