HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

unholiness

1,306 karma · joined August 20, 2013

submissionscomments
unholiness··on Android 12 forces you to choose a default browser unless you disable Chrome
Developers have no trouble changing this setting though, right?
unholiness··on No one cared about my spreadsheets
If his signaling hypothesis is true, employers are reading the signal correctly.

Someone who doesn't finish high school, without a good reason, in our society which says finishing high school is important... simply failed to finish. They're more likely to fail to finish other things. The rational free market views that negatively.

If we lived in a society which expected people to get a 12-year hula-hooping certificate by the age of 18, you'd expect those with the certificate to be more employable. The employers in that world aren't irrational, the society is.

unholiness··on What to know about the stock market (2007)
The stock market is not a zero-sum game. Money-now is worth more than money-later to companies offering stocks, who know how to earn more money with that money. Long-term strategies simply take advantage of this fact to make long-term gains. Investments are just codified strategies on what ways you can put your idle money to work in someone else's hand.

Buying an index fund full of stocks at their current market price is no more illogical than running code you didn't write yourself. It's way way less work, it probably works better.

Better yet, trusting someone else's market price is much easier than trusting someone else's code because of the thousands of black-hat investors searching for profitable vulnerabilities in the market prices.

unholiness··on Guess the daily Wordle in one try using the tweet distribution
I believe in the actual implementation it's correct. You can confirm a letter is not doubled, when one of the two letters in your guess is gray.
unholiness··on A small guide for naming stuff in front-end code
In JS (and in any expression-inside-html front end framework) this leads to the hugely common bug

    if (this.finished) { ...
or

    <div v-if="showMainContent>...
With your convention, these could easily be functions, but they are never evaluated without parens. Nor is any error thrown. Instead, the fact that the function exists is truthy and you get the true case always.

In our teams's js code we even include "get" for "is" properties (getIsEnabled() rather than isEnabled()) so that it's perfectly obvious if you're ever using a function without calling it.

unholiness··on Euler’s 243-Year-Old ‘Impossible’ Puzzle Gets a Quantum Solution
To bring this problem into our kitchen, last summer my fiancee and I block-painted 100 colored and symboled canvases to manipulate around on a 10x10 grid of pegs on our wall[0]

The first solution to this 10x10 version was discovered in 1959, and Euler died believing it impossible... so our most likely expectation is that we won't find the solution in our lifetimes. Still, it's fun to solve progressively bigger sub-puzzles on the grid, and it's nice to always have a nut too tough to crack in your life.

I've set aside this paper to read tomorrow. Naturally, the quantum solutions are not valid on our kitchen wall!

[0] https://imgur.com/a/tPj0tZB

unholiness··on Website moves the “change cookie settings” button when you hover over it
Do you have JS diabled? For me they animate and swap.
unholiness··on Facebook said my article was false – now the fact-checkers admit they were wrong
Fact-checking sets up a seemingly-circular definition where "a trustworthy source is a source trusted by trustworthy sources"

It reminds me of a similarly recursive definition in Google's original pagerank algorithm: "A popular site is a site linked prominently by other popular sites". for pagerank, there was a nice way around the issue: apply popularity iteratively.

You can imagine starting with some initial guess (perhaps that every site is equally popular), then score sites which are heavily linked higher to update the score. Then, use those scores to weigh the value of their links (unpopular sites' links matter less, popular sites' links matter more) and evaluate popularity again, and again...

Of course, this is simply a matrix multiplication applied infinitely many times. If the matrix is not singular (which, if your system is sufficiently connected, is vanishingly unlikely), then the final solution will converge to the eigenvector with the largest eigenvalue no matter what your initial guess was. The definition of popularity which seemed which recursive, wasn't. It doesn't matter who you assume is popular to start with, if you apply the definition enough times, you will arrive at the same result.

It makes me wonder if there is a possible computational aid to some of these fact-checking dilemmas, where we don't need to trust anyone a priori to have trust in the whole network. In areas where we can't look at truth as some absolutely thing, that doesn't mean we should we throw our hands up and say "everything depends on who you ask". We can still have a goal of evaluating things that are incredibly likely to be true, false, misleading, etc.

Society has lots of imperfect tools for evaluating information from those who know more than us: We can look at their past performance, we can understand their incentives (e.g. brand harm if discovered), we can check if others disagree, we can use quality heuristics (e.g. superficial flaws can be a sign of deeper flaws), we can gain some small expertise to help evaluate the greater experts. None of these things are perfect signals but they are strong signals.

Currently fact-checking is cobbling together these signals informally, with responsibility spread out culturally among the organizations' internal hierarchy, the fact-checked victims complaining, some outsiders who bother to fact-check the fact-checkers, everyone's subjective trust of brands, etc. I wonder if there could be a more formal way to do this, where sources fact-check each other in a decentralized way. The ultimate score of trust would come not from one single source of authority, but from a global evaluation, which anyone could calculate, of this recursive definition of trust.

It would come with its own set of problems (google-bombing was a common thing in that era for rarely-searched terms) but it still seems like a massively useful tool, and one I've never seen an attempt to formalize.

unholiness··on Show HN: Cleanvoice – Automated Podcast Editing
Interesting take. I saw Phillip DeFranco as more of a pioneer of that style. He really leaned into the cuts. At the time it was something no one else was doing so it was very noticeable, and he had a very crisp cadence with them where the jarring cuts were part of the presentation. It was clear his process was: Write a script, mark cuts everywhere it could make sense, go through the script repeating every phrase until you're happy with the sound, and when editing, always make the cuts where they're marked, even if it could be skipped.

The result feels something like pixel art: Clearly not the closest possible imitation of conversational speaking, but something else. A style in its own right with different considerations.

Now that it's par for the course to have jump cuts, I see them used more sloppily everywhere, where it's clear the narrator decided where to do the cuts after the fact. Cutting off the beginning or end of a phoneme, missing or repeating bits of a thought because they they liked one phrasing in recording but opted for another one in post, misordered cuts where something which moved in the background moves back to its old place, etc. Phillip's style looked lazy but it can't really be imitated with actual laziness.

These days I look back and really cringe at the substance of his show. But I still see the style as professional.

unholiness··on Mysteries the Standard Model can’t explain
Honest question from a physics novice: Would it be wrong to say the same is roughly true of all of the first 4?

I have heard it is plausible that Dark Matter is merely another particle that fits in the standard model. I've heard it plausible that Dark Energy is e.g. a WIMP or other new particle in the standard model. And, on more-matter-than-antimatter, I imagine _some_ explanations of baryon asymmetry could come from outside the standard model but others (boundary condition, mirror anti-universe) would be fully standard-model-compatible, right?

That would leave only #5 as a mystery: Why is gravity as we know it in general relativity so different (weaker) than the force that a standard-model graviton would predict?

unholiness··on All Applications for Nuclear Energy at COP26 Rejected
Are you really saying nuclear + renewables in a grid is less feasible than renewables alone? Please cite some source. At a surface level, the amount of battery capacity needed to deal with power droughts with renewables would be far less with nuclear power present.

Saying that fossil fuels + renewables works well doesn't really have a place in a dialog about the best way to eliminate fossil fuels.

unholiness··on Signed integers are asymmetrical
Floats still have an issue for this particular piece of code though! abs(-0) would return -0
unholiness··on Unsolved Problems in ML Safety
Some overlap here with the 2017 paper from Google Brain et al: Concrete Problems in AI Safety: https://arxiv.org/pdf/1606.06565.pdf

A nice video from the wonderful AI safety communicator Robert Miles outlines those problems: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AjyM-f8rDpg

unholiness··on Conterintuitive facts in mathematics, CS, and physics
I don't think that argument holds water. Imagine rolling it on the inside of the circle – the center of the circle traces a path with only twice its radius, yet it still rolls 4 times around.
unholiness··on Conterintuitive facts in mathematics, CS, and physics
My sister and I used to figure out who had more candy at halloween by lining up the pieces next to each other. The concept of bijection might be more intuitive than counting itself.
unholiness··on When users never use the features they asked for
One automated thing I've been really wanting to add to our code review process is copied code detection, where a piece of code is very similar to code somewhere else in the product (though likely not part of the current review).

Obviously there's cases where this is code smell, but plenty of times it isn't. It's not something that you would want to block shipping. But if you do want to ship code like this, you should do so with the reviewer(s) fully seeing where it came from, to make sure everyone agrees that's the best way.

No one has implemented a bot for us that would add such comment for use but I do think it would be a huge win.

unholiness··on A $10k poker win changed how I think
The chart is one from a game theoretically optimal solver for the whole game, one which assumes the opponent knows your exact strategy.

K4o is raised often by this solver because the hands that you'd otherwise raise with are lacking 4s. The computer doesn't want her to raise, then see a 4 (or two) on the flop, and have her opponent know for certain that she doesn't have a 4 in her hand.

To be honest this is not something humans worry about too much pre-flop. More likely a human would raise one of K4o/K5o/K6o/K7o 100% of the time and fold the rest. Your opponent doesn't know which so you're not exploitable like above, and you don't have to worry about the nuance of "Is this hand one of the 60% I should raise this?" on a critical hand, and you get to play better hands overall.

unholiness··on Work Hard (2007)
Seems to have the hacker news hug of death. Cached version: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:Tr5R5J...
unholiness··on The Polar Bear – Open-Source, Multipurpose CNC Machine with a Rotary Axis
It wouldn't be easy to secure a printed part, especially without adding slop. Also, is there any overlap between materials you can 3d print with in this thing, and ones you can mill (or even polish) without shattering the part?
unholiness··on How Bell’s Theorem proved ‘spooky action at a distance’ is real
Yes, the "altering" you're describing is what the theorem would call a hidden variable. Seems reasonable, but when you do the math it's exactly he kind of theory Bell's inequality rules out. There's no way to set the "polarization angle" (or any other set of variables) such that they obey the probabilistic laws we've observed (without violating some other assumption, like single measurement outcomes, statistical independence, determinism, or locality)
unholiness··on How Bell’s Theorem proved ‘spooky action at a distance’ is real
The fact that superdeterminism can violate statistical independence is what lets it violate bell's theorem, right?

If so GP's statement is just backwards: Super-determinism is a kind of forgoing statistical independence

unholiness··on How Bell’s Theorem proved ‘spooky action at a distance’ is real
Sure. There are assumptions you need for Bell's Theorem to apply. Statistical independence, single-outcome measurements, locality, determinism... All of these feel right to our scientific brains, but something's got to give.

So yes, you can throw out Bell's theorem if you're willing to throw out statistical independence with super-determinism. It's a tough leap to make, though. Super-determinism implies that there aren't really any laws of quantum mechanics. The fact that billions of quantum interactions have been observed in labs to obey consistent probabilities over time is pure coincidence. The fact that two entangled electrons always have opposite spin is pure coincidence. Nothing about the laws of the universe say you couldn't observe the other thing, it's just that the initial conditions of the universe prevented us from making measurements any time we would have measured otherwise. It's a tough pill to swallow.

My comment above is just saying you can't throw out Bell's theorem by saying "maybe there's a fifth dimension". I don't think GP meant a fifth dimension plus superdeterminism.

unholiness··on How Bell’s Theorem proved ‘spooky action at a distance’ is real
Bell's theorem is strong: No local hidden variables can explain quantum entanglement.

Your proposed fifth dimension is exactly such a variable – there is no set of values it can take on that explains the quantum phenomena we can easily and reliably observe.

The fact that you think of it as a distance itself isn't important to Bell's theorem. Such a theory is cannot even obey relativity in our existing 3 dimensions (obeying the speed of light in your extra dimension would be even stricter!)

unholiness··on Alphafold
> The sequencing part is pretty much solved.

DNA sequencing is still slow and very expensive. On the scales you're talking about it's just not worth it.

I think I agree at a high-level that there is a huge reservoir of demand for this technology. But it's also possible that solving protein folding and similar research will simply cease to be a bottleneck for that demand, and people will be out of jobs.

unholiness··on SafeDollar ‘stablecoin’ drops to $0 following DeFi exploit on Polygon
But it's so much worse than that, right? Bugs in a smart contract are immutable. Those are just the terms everyone agreed to. There's simply no path to deploying a fix that every good actor agrees is beneficial.
unholiness··on What Is Voter Satisfaction Efficiency?
An outcome where 30 strategic B voters win over 70 unstrategic A voters is one I would expect VSE to rate very poorly. That is not a value judgement, and is directly related to the outcome.
unholiness··on What Is Voter Satisfaction Efficiency?
These results aren't passing the sniff-test for me.

If I understand, "honest" voters in the score-like systems stick to some magically-shared mapping of their own utility to scores on the ballot (totally unreasonable, but let's grant it). Strategic voters, meanwhile, just use the ballots to maximize their own utility.

Let's take the simplest, common scenario of two clear frontrunners. In score voting's one-sided strategic scenarios: - Honest voters who support candidate A will put down magical normally-distributed numbers. Their scores for A end up perhaps 10-50% higher than their scores for B. - Strategic voters who support candidate B will maximize B's chance of winning by putting down the highest score for B and the lowest score for A. Score for B will be uniformly 100% higher than scores for B.

In this scenario it takes perhaps 2-10 honest A voters for every strategic B voter for A to win. Yet somehow, the VSE for 1-sided strategic score scenarios are all much better than plurality, and equal with approval?

This is a commonly-discussed downside for any score voting system, where it gives strategic voters extra power, and, in these 1-sided scenarios, is worse than plurality. The downside is appearing nowhere in this data.

unholiness··on Rotations with quaternions
If you want to intuitively understand why this particular 4D construction is the right representation of a 3D rotation, then I highly recommend 3blue1brown's explorable interactive video series on the topic:

https://eater.net/quaternions

The interactive videos alone are quite the technical feat, but after going through it, it's honestly hard to imagine fully understanding this topic with less technology (or with a less incredible teacher!)

unholiness··on Hatetris – Tetris which always gives you the worst piece
With some more fiddling I got 5: హقຽࡐԚقଖݹ३ΤໃςԎРಊݶɺටງђञසໃל௨ೱІJলظІŧԥගƖݹƔقWђવටܢݹԪmЄࡧԥฃໄڝরߩງוభ൜ϾঊஶϺळॾԫԉІݶݬΟไࢲذ൜షaஜشНܥಒකСݤЬඝܘƎࢶ૫Ɣڍகnബॠ
unholiness··on Hatetris – Tetris which always gives you the worst piece
All right I'll bite. Here's my replay with 4, can anyone do better?

ИටໃݎஐقไҮԩঘໃݹݫඖϾח௨ࡄໃτઊටณɕ௨ഖVݹୠΟไଌ௨ȷКڍமƣະߛ௨ڄलܤɶѺഉZ௨කܘŧۑഠܗђ௧૫ง๐௬ࡄଘݪjധȣӶஐටםܥಈడƇђحڌࠋ

← PreviousPage 6 of 11Next →