HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

unholiness

1,306 karma · joined August 20, 2013

submissionscomments
unholiness··on Hatetris – Tetris which always gives you the worst piece
I feel like there's some bug where it gives me S's when a Z would clearly be worse. I managed 3 lines, all of which were completed by S's and would have been thwarted by Z's.

In fact I'm not sure I got a Z all game, though it seems other commenters did.

unholiness··on In Singapore, Covid vs. privacy is no contest
Yikes. You're right. Added an edit to the top.
unholiness··on In Singapore, Covid vs. privacy is no contest
EDIT: I am incorrect: TraceTogether is now using its own, non-anonymized technology[1]. Thanks detaro for correcting me. I'll still leave the comment because I'm interested in the ending question – This same damning article could have been written if TraceTogether had done everything right, so how do we effectively motivate governments to get everything right?

--------

It feels wrong to loop in the anonymized TraceTogether technology with other genuinely egregious privacy violations of the Singaporean government.

The Android/Apple exposure notifications API[0] rolled out in the early days of the pandemic is a pretty solid example IMO of handling privacy correctly. The protocol generates you a new anonymous ID every 20 minutes and locally remembers the last ~30 days of ids. Through BTLE, it collects the anonymous ids of other phones that it's within range of (and for how long), and remembers them locally for ~30 days. When someone voluntarily self-reports as COVID-positive, the API broadcasts the list anonymous ids used during their likely contagious period, allowing other phones to locally recognize if they've been exposed, and for how long.

It's hard to imagine a more private version of this with any amount of usefulness. Unless I'm missing something (which I may well be!), the privacy loss the article refers can only happen if:

1. The police can legally and physically confiscate and unlock your phone

2. The police can legally and physically confiscate and unlock the phone of the person they suspect you of being/not being within 20 feet of

3. It was less than a month ago

4. There were no other eyewitnesses or evidence of the contact

The first one, of course, also gives them access to plenty of other data we think of as private.

Because this scenario exists, you can definitely make an argument that phones are a little less private with TraceTogether than without. But with the rarity and narrowness of the breach, I have a hard time putting it even remotely close to the other pieces of the article, describing 24/7 security cameras and exposing confidential lawyer correspondences.

The article concludes:

> What’s less considered is the sheer volume of data, and the variety of types of data that the state is collecting, allowing it to piece together people’s lives with much more detail than we might realise.

...and, well, I completely agree. That's exactly the context the article seems to lack.

It's also a broader problem: How do we effectively define and communicate a right to privacy when the volume is what's so important?

[0] https://www.google.com/covid19/exposurenotifications/

[1] https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/apple-google-contact-...

unholiness··on There’s Nothing to Do Except Gamble
In densely populated areas, the value of real estate has very little to do with what's built on the property, and everything to do with the land it is build on.

GPs point is that owning land is not creating value. It is, however, very profitable.

unholiness··on Unusual Stock Trading by Whales in US Congress
A lot of justified negativity in this thread.

On the flip side, are there any congresspeople who have publicly put all their assets in a blind trust? Any who have advanced bills requiring this of their colleagues?

The solution to problems like this is elections, and you would think "My opponent is insider trading while I literally can't" would make a great campaign ad.

unholiness··on HaveIBeenPwned adds yesterday's Facebook breach
> That would be a good time to let you disable public lookup of your email address.

https://haveibeenpwned.com/OptOut

unholiness··on HaveIBeenPwned adds yesterday's Facebook breach
You can't, because that specific breach has been marked as sensitive: https://haveibeenpwned.com/FAQs#SensitiveBreach
unholiness··on Parler drops offline after Amazon pulls support
> Normal, political speech is just fine. Incitement to violence, no

Right. Even the Post Office is not required to deliver pipe bombs.

The issue is that right now, that's not the standard. Amazon /hasn't/ taken down sites in the name of political censorship, but it /could/. The implications of that are important, and they're why I find it hard to be satisfied with justifications like "Amazon is a private company, they can do what they want".

unholiness··on Show HN: 3D-Parallax, labelfree 3D experience from a 2D image using parallax
Back in 2012 I did some building on ZSpace[0] and the that setup still feels like the sweet spot: Physical keyboard, physical pen (with virtual extension), physical glasses to detect head position for parallax, 3D environment to play and create in.

The _visual_ feedback from moving your head and rotating objects with the pen were extremely low-latency. Gesture detection is still nowhere near that level of fidelity but with peripherals, perhaps it's not necessary.

[0] https://zspace.com/

unholiness··on Britney Spears' Guide to Semiconductor Physics (2007)
Serious question: If I'm interested in getting a better understanding of the physics of semiconductors (starting around "atoms have protons and electrons" and ending around "...therefore an NPN transistor should act as a switch in this setup and a current source in this setup"), where would be a good, Spears-less place to learn this?
unholiness··on On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Years
Not all new users are beginners
unholiness··on On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Years
Glicko is just ELO with an uncertainty factor that speeds up down how quickly your rating changes if you've played fewer games. Actually, FIDE's implementation of ELO also has an approximate version of this, increasing its "k" value for new players and decreasing it for some thresholds of games played, ratings, and player age. Both these adjustments just affect how quickly your rating would change if your win rate changes. They do not your equilibrium rating at a particular skill level.

Lichess ratings are inflated not because of Glicko but because of the player pool. New players start at 1500 ELO in both Lichess and FIDE, but Lichess's pool of "new players" is a lot wider and has a lot more amateurs than FIDE's new players. The amateurs' points ultimately get spread around the player pool while they descend from 1500 to a more realistic rating, inflating the ratings of other players on the way.

unholiness··on On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Years
chess.com ratings are much less inflated than lichess ratings (partially because its new users start at 1200 ELO, not 1500). Not sure if there's a more exact conversion to FIDE ratings, especially because it looks like he's playing exclusively 3+0 blitz games, which play out much differently online than they do over the board.
unholiness··on Better Git diff output for Ruby, Python, Elixir, Go
A much bigger set of improvements to the git diff output is also easy to add: https://github.com/so-fancy/diff-so-fancy

This makes your git diff highlight the actual different characters between two lines, makes file names easy to see (and easy to copy, due to no a/ b/), makes renames and blank lines clear and readable.

It is so nice to get all this without a separate GUI diff visualiser when doing anything git-related from the command line.

unholiness··on Chess’s Cheating Crisis
This comment has strong "why does <your field> need a journal" vibes...

Online chess areas like lichess and chess.com absolutely have automated cheat detection which they consider along with with reports in automated banning of accounts. They consider not just whether the player is playing the excellent moves (something common at any level and very common at high levels), but also how a deep search is needed to evaluate that move, whether other obvious moves were available, how long was taken to play the move, if the position is common, etc. When these serial cheaters are banned, the sites even refund rating points to everyone who lost to them.

However, the issue of isolated cheating incidents is still a big deal, even if the serial obvious cheaters can be detected.

unholiness··on There's another right to repair fight brewing in Massachusetts
These are definitely valid points. Unfortunately your last example (3rd party web services easily discovering when I need an oil change, or what days I've been driving aggressively) is the kind of hypothetical I would want laws actively preventing.

Arguably, it's not this law's job to introduce such a protection! But best I can tell, no other law covers it in MA. It is perfectly legal for 3rd parties to sell this and other data without my explicit consent or even an opportunity to opt out (I think only CA has such an opt-out [0]).

Granted, manufacturers already have and can sell this data with no recourse. But at least manufacturers have national brands which could be hurt by selling or leaking massive amounts of data about their customers. Perhaps some brands could even make privacy a selling point. It seems like this law erodes that thin shell of protection.

[0] http://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml?...

unholiness··on There's another right to repair fight brewing in Massachusetts
MA voter who's genuinely torn here.

The thing that bugs me out about this law is that, AFAICT, this data is _already_ required to be available to any 3rd party manufacturer through a physical "non-proprietary interface" (so far, an OBD-II port) after a similar ballot initiative from 2013 [0]. This law essentially just makes the data available wirelessly.

I care about security holes and I care about consent. Having a physical interface makes it easy to provide data with consent to repair shops who need while trivially making sure no third party manufacturer or insurance company is leaked a massive database of everyone's driving data. I really don't see how the "wireless" addition gives me more of a right to repair, but I clearly see how it forces manufacturers to significantly increase their surface area of possible data leaks.

I'm all for Ben Franklin's liberty/safety argument, but with the 2013 law already in place, I honestly don't see the upside of the 2020 law.

[0] https://malegislature.gov/Laws/SessionLaws/Acts/2013/Chapter....

unholiness··on A-Levels: The Model is not the Student
Source?
unholiness··on Ireland donates contact tracing app to Linux Foundation
Sadly, no. It's been left to the states, and almost none of the states are planning on using apps[0].

This boggles my mind. Sure, it will take a reasonable effort to get widespread use of these apps. But the impact would be huge. Even low rates of app use have a real chance of lowering the reproduction rate significantly, and reasonably broad usage bring it less than 1.0.

The technology is designed in the right way, where anonymous data is being collected with no app required. People can download the app right after they get a positive test and report themselves positive retroactively. Same on the other side, you can download the app and know how much contact you've had with positive cases retroactively.

I'm no longer surprised the US federal government is doing nothing to push this. But I expected more out of the states.

[0] https://9to5mac.com/2020/07/13/covid-19-exposure-notificatio...

unholiness··on Most US states do not plan to use Apple and Google's COVID19 contact-tracing API
I genuinely don't understand why this is.

There's a protocol running on almost every smartphone in the world right now, locally recording the necessary anonymized proximity data with BTLE[0]. All states need to to is produce an authoritative way to declare you have COVID, and release an app that provides notifications if a new case is broadcast that matches your history.

The fact that this protocol allows reporting your recent data even if you've installed nothing before realizing you have COVID is critical for success. The fact that the data doesn't include GPS or any long-time persistent key is critical for privacy (and, thus, adoption).

The upside is potentially significantly lowering the reproduction rate of COVID while businesses reopen. The downside is... what exactly? Why has almost every state (not to mention the federal government) not committed to implementing these apps?

[0] https://covid19-static.cdn-apple.com/applications/covid19/cu...

unholiness··on Micromort
I'd argue adding is the right calculation in many situations, since in most cases you wouldn't receive the benefits of the next risk if you die the first time.

So for example, if working in a coal mine is 10 micromorts per work day, and you choose to do it each day, it seems pretty reasonable to call that 10 * 5 days * 50 work weeks = 2500 micromorts per year. You're "paying" that cost each time you decide to go to work, and if you decide to work next year it won't somehow "cost" less micromorts – the possible yous who died last year won't be around to make the decision.

unholiness··on Intermittent fasting works – not only for weight loss but also for heart health
The only significant contributors to calories and mass of any food item are water, proteins, carbs, and fat. They are respectively 0, 4, 4, and 9 calories per gram. So, foods that are waterlogged (fruits and veggies) are very low calories per gram and foods that are fattier will be denser.

Honestly curious: Is there more discussion to be had than that?

unholiness··on Thought-Terminating Cliche
In my experience, it's pretty common for people to bring up the fact that something is legal to avoid the question of whether it's right.
unholiness··on “Just walk out” technology by Amazon
I'm curious, how does this technology deal with items that aren't individually packaged? Is there a place for vegetables, meats, bulk foods, etc, or is the technology limited to acting like a giant vending machine?

I hope that stores like these will one day be hubs where we can refill all our bulk products and actually save on shipping and packaging. I fear that stores like these will just sell me individually wrapped apples because it's not worth the effort.

unholiness··on Lego Launches Braille Bricks for Children to Learn Braille
Almost everyone who is legally blind is partially sighted. The two legally blind people I know both tell me those were most screwed over were the ones who learned to read braille in school instead of printed text. In this world, it's invaluable to simply be able to pull a sheet of paper up right up to a thick lens over your eye and slowly read it. If you only know Braille, you're helpless to solve this predicament, and Braille documents are extremely rare.

For digital media, screen readers are an enormous accessibility feature, but having (impaired) vision and knowledge of english is a helpful fallback for the plethora of poorly built sites and applications that have, say, text in an image. Braille is not helpful in a world of flat screens.

unholiness··on Scissors Congruence
I've been into _hinged_ dissections in woodworking for a while. This algorithm _isn't_ hinged, but it is cool to directly see the Wallace-Bolyai-Gerwain theorem in action.

Here's a video with more context! https://youtu.be/ysV6iF3Rmjo

unholiness··on Verb-Noun vs. Noun-Verb
At Onshape we're considering doing this for our language FeatureScript[0], as discussed here[1]

This would make the call e.g. v1->cross(v2) syntactic sugar for the call cross(v1, v2).

The main reason it's not just an obvious win for autocomplete and readability is that it provides for multiple ways to do one thing, and is one more thing you need to know when learning this new language. Rather than having some code call plane->yAxis() and other code call yAxis(plane), it might be nicer to have only one way.

The other counterargument: the OOP-like syntax could support the expectation that polymorphism works like e.g. Java, where e.g. v1.cross(v2) would only considers the type of v1 when deciding which overload to call. FeatureScript has multiple dispatch and will consider the types of all arguments when choosing an overload.

All that said, the change it seems like a win overall, but we're waiting for the language to mature more to see if clearer arguments emerge.

[0] https://cad.onshape.com/FsDoc/

[1] https://forum.onshape.com/discussion/comment/33495/#Comment_...

unholiness··on We shouldn’t take peer review as the ‘gold standard’
You're not the only one to comment this, but from what I know per review is a long iterative process, wher reviewers raise objections and submitted respond with edits.

So, what you're suggesting seems a lot like shipping code before code review, and seems to have many of the same problems. What do you do in the long period before critical issues have been addressed? What do you do if the submitter just says "fuck you, my code works, I have more important things to do"?

unholiness··on Twitter clarifies special rules for tweets by world leaders like Trump
It seems like by doing this, Twitter is increasing the size of their voice as a non-neutral platform, simultaneously displaying the popular tweets and their own message that, hey, this is hate speech.

I do wonder, though, if this will have the opposite effect. There is plenty to criticize about these tweets, and the stable genius behind them, so it's not surprising that many have called for these messages to be banned. But, they still seem like a legitimate use if the platform, so my main reaction reading the messages is "Wait, _that_ would be ban-worthy?". This policy may end up undermining the credibility of the platform more than the author.

unholiness··on Cambridge's Ambitious Protected Bike Lane Law
Cambridge has a fleet of sidewalk plows (About 30" wide) that are also used for plowing paths and bike lanes. In the winter they are a godsend.

In a snow emergency (i.e. when cars are forced off one side of the street for plowing), the vertical barriers can be manually removed.

← PreviousPage 7 of 11Next →