HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

unwise-exe

179 karma · joined September 5, 2022

Computers are fun.
submissionscomments
unwise-exe··on ‘I witnessed war crimes’ in Gaza – former worker at GHF aid site [video]
>>> No idea why these posts are allowed to flourish here

No, they often get flagged off pretty quickly.

unwise-exe··on ‘I witnessed war crimes’ in Gaza – former worker at GHF aid site [video]
Israel's response was obvious as soon as the attack happened. "Oh, looks like they've got that excuse they've been wanting."
unwise-exe··on Find Your 2%Ers (2023)
>> I wonder if people would be more introverted/extroverted depending on the fit with the people they are around.

Personal experience says yes.

unwise-exe··on Find Your 2%Ers
Must be nice when everyone you need to know happens to be someone you enjoy knowing.
unwise-exe··on George Eliot's reflections on AGI from 1879
>> Functionally equivalent but no soul.

Something that predicts no observable differences is unfalsifiable aka bullshit.

unwise-exe··on George Eliot's reflections on AGI from 1879
If you want to know what life is like when society is run by beings smarter than you, ask someone who flunked out of high school.

If you want to know what life is like when society is run by alien intelligences, ask someone who lives under an economy dominated by megacorps.

unwise-exe··on Police arrest apparent leader of 'Zizian' group
Just because he has, um, interesting ideas about what's worth covering or what lens to view things through, does not change that he does in fact report things and is therefore a reporter.
unwise-exe··on Police arrest apparent leader of 'Zizian' group
> I do wonder how much it's people in the media trying to protect the rest of the trans community from association with this story, and how much it's just people writing stories based on the other coverage and not realizing that the trans connection even exists.

There is also the possibility that writers or editors feared being unpersonned.

unwise-exe··on Insurers Rely on Doctors Whose Judgments Have Been Criticized by Courts
<< To do so, court records reveal, the insurers have turned to a coterie of psychiatrists and have continued relying on them even after one or more of their decisions have been criticized or overturned in court. >>

...ok? Is ProPublica seriously trying to assert that they should be barred after a single decision ("one or more" includes "one") has been criticized ("criticized or overturned" includes "criticized but upheld")?

unwise-exe··on FTC orders 'gun detection' tech maker Evolv to stop overstating effectiveness
I thought advertising and marketing materials were expected to exaggerate things to the point of blatant falsehood.

Is that changing, or is this company being singled out for some reason, or are they really that much worse than everyone else?

unwise-exe··on FTC orders 'gun detection' tech maker Evolv to stop overstating effectiveness
Sure sure, the "one neat trick" for getting around the bill of rights by deputizing the private sector to do things that only get recognized as rights violations if it's the government doing it.
unwise-exe··on Human Civilization at critical junction:authoritarian collapse or superabundance
The "study" this is based on is paywalled and not on sci-hub.

A comment from the article:

<< "Industrial civilisation is facing 'inevitable' decline as it is replaced by what could turn out to be a far more advanced ‘postmaterialist’ civilisation based on distributed superabundant clean energy. The main challenge is that industrial civilisation is facing such rapid decline that this could derail the emergence of a new and superior 'life-cycle' for the human species", >>

I believe I recall hearing that originally, electricity generated from nuclear fission was predicted to be "too cheap to meter". The first part of this comment reminds me of that.

The "Findings" section of the linked abstract:

<< The paper develops planetary phase shift theory as a new collective forward intelligence framework for foresight study and practice, formalising the notion that humanity has arrived at an unprecedented historic and geological turning point. It finds that multiple global crises across both earth and human systems are symptoms of the last stages of the life-cycle of global industrialisation civilisation, which is the potential precursor either for collapse, or for a new civilisational life-cycle that may represent a new stage in the biological and cultural evolution of the human species.>>

This sounds like it's nonsense built on top of other nonsense.

unwise-exe··on Ask HN: What's Your Morning Routine?
I don't really have one.
unwise-exe··on Six transplant patients in Brazil contract HIV from infected organs
In-house workers can phone it in as well.

At some point, your recursive watchers of watchers watching watchers has to have a base case of "we trust this entity" (or maybe, "you, the public, trust this entity").

Outsourcing only matters for this if it provides a break in the chain of responsibility. That is, if the person selecting the outsource provider can (successfully) say "hey, not my fault" by pointing to... some entity that whoever they answer to doesn't already trust.

unwise-exe··on Six transplant patients in Brazil contract HIV from infected organs
>>> Any criticism or critique of this paradigm gets hated on without anyone really listening

I'm having a hard time following this. Could you perhaps reference some examples to illustrate what you mean here?

unwise-exe··on Apple study proves LLM-based AI models are flawed because they cannot reason
>>> I'm willing to bet this is within human baselines but either way, researchers really need to start including human baselines in these kinds of papers.

They should indeed, but is that "I've never seen this before" human baseline, or with prior exposure ("what do you mean I got that wro... oh I see what you did there") or explicit instruction?

unwise-exe··on Apple study proves LLM-based AI models are flawed because they cannot reason
>>> since on tests, there's usually an assumption that all information given is relevant

Maybe on grade-school tests, but the professional certification exams I've taken have questions about scenarios where part of the challenge is recognizing which parts of the scenario description aren't relevant. The one I had an in-person class for, the instructor specifically called this out and advised reading the questions first so we'd know which parts of the scenario we didn't have to think about while reading it.

unwise-exe··on Apple study proves LLM-based AI models are flawed because they cannot reason
Interesting. I would have thought that the training set (basically the whole internet AIUI) would have included various "teacher's version" exams with enough word problems with intentionally-distracting extra information, that the models would be able to ignore that sort of thing.

This sounds like they're inspecting existing models. Maybe a model trained specifically on "word problem" question-answer pairs (as in, the sort of things that show up on tests and always pretend that the sort of complications a domain expert would know about just don't exist) would do better?

unwise-exe··on LHC experiments at CERN observe quantum entanglement at the highest energy yet
The only way to not leave out critical details is to just learn the math behind it.

The problem with doing this is that getting an extra graduate degree is a lot of work.

unwise-exe··on LHC experiments at CERN observe quantum entanglement at the highest energy yet
>> Nobody is ever going to say "I'm sure glad we spent two trillion dollars on the F-35."

Nobody cares about your server backups either. Unless something goes wrong and you need them.

unwise-exe··on LHC experiments at CERN observe quantum entanglement at the highest energy yet
A few billion here, a few billion there, pretty soon we're talking real money.

>> The idea that there's a fixed-sized pie for science and every project takes away from something else is, frankly, defeatist.

What fraction of the workforce should be diverted to "forward-looking" (ie, no idea if or when it will result in anything useful) research?

Or how about what fraction of the much smaller part of the workforce who are capable of getting an advanced STEM degree? If we pay those people to switch to speculative research, what happens to whatever they're doing now that has enough proven value that private industry knows it's worth paying them to do?

unwise-exe··on Smashmallow, Silicon Valley's Failed Marshmallow Startup
The actual comparisons from TFA:

> That meant he had to grow fast and figure out the engineering on the fly — the classic entrepreneurial strategy of Silicon Valley. When it works, you get Tesla; when it doesn't, you get Theranos.

> But if Theranos taught us anything, it's that a business model won't work if it hinges on a technology that doesn't exist. Sebastiani wasn't an Elizabeth Holmes-style grifter. Marshmallows are real! But he did ignore the experts, and proceeded without having the necessary technology in place. If there wasn't a machine that could mass-produce his marshmallows, he would just build one. How hard could it be? In Silicon Valley parlance, he would fake it until he could make it.

The article is severely whitewashing the Theranos fraud. That's why it sees the comparison as legbitimate; it doesn't actually understand what Theranos did that was wrong.

unwise-exe··on Smashmallow, Silicon Valley's Failed Marshmallow Startup
I read that as B.I. taking the problems at Theranos as being entirely that the tech didn't work out, and ignoring the whole thing about lies and fraud.
unwise-exe··on The Rise of Technoauthoritarianism
Kind of odd to see the guy who provided proof of the coordinated censorship that everyone knew was happening, being held out as the one named example of unregulated tech companies becoming more illiberal.

.

> Technocrats are right that technology is a key to making the world better. But first we must describe the world as we wish it to be—the problems we wish to solve in the public interest, and in accordance with the values and rights that advance human dignity, equality, freedom, privacy, health, and happiness. And we must insist that the leaders of institutions that represent us—large and small—use technology in ways that reflect what is good for individuals and society, and not just what enriches technocrats.

Restricting innovation to only things approved by people with the right values and goals has quite a track record of backfiring spectacularly.

unwise-exe··on There's So Much Data Even Spies Are Struggling to Find Secrets
Here's a few you can have:

    717ea633-a296-49ca-8895-425eb0aa61e5
    87a636ef-24d1-49a8-90cf-75deead14181
    06c1817a-dfbc-43ee-85e8-885737db1e2d
    48a3e739-12f5-44a1-9265-7c3a41748cb2
    da55983d-5143-4e14-8e87-d53fc91211c8

More seriously, this sounds vaguely similar to the Eternal September problem, where more stuff means lower SNR.
unwise-exe··on How to do things if you're not that smart and don't have any talent
> This is a blog post aimed at people who want to do important work or make meaningful contributions to work, but **feel** they aren’t that smart and don’t have any talent.

So yeah, it's not for people who truly are not smart, it's for people who limit themselves as a result of mispercieving their own abilities.

unwise-exe··on What Happens to Europe If the US Withdraws?
If the US stops offering as much free military help, the EU would just have to provide more of their own defense, yes? Maybe even make a stronger military side to their current mostly-economic union.
unwise-exe··on How the brain responds to reward is linked to socioeconomic background
I do not see how your mechanistic description actually conflicts with my description.

> their brains reward them less

The reward centers show lower activity. This does not have to be some inscrutable thing only noticeable with a fMRI. It could perfectly well be that they're not used to turning extra money into things they like, and so because of that don't show as much activity in the "I just got rewarded" area.

unwise-exe··on Confirmation of ancient lake on Mars
I read this less as "this makes it more likely that there was life" and more as "if there was life, this makes it more likely that we'll have found it".
unwise-exe··on How the brain responds to reward is linked to socioeconomic background
> fMRI

https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/scicurious-brain/ignobe...

> “If you’re in a highly resourced environment, with many rewards available, your brain gets tuned in a certain way. If you’re in an environment in which rewards are more scarce, then your brain accommodates the environment in which you live. Instead of being overresponsive to rewards, it seems like these brains, on average, are less responsive, because probably their environment has been less consistent in the availability of rewards,” says John Gabrieli, the Grover Hermann Professor of Health Sciences and Technology, a professor of brain and cognitive sciences, and a member of MIT’s McGovern Institute for Brain Research.

So, "Kids aren't as excited about getting things they're not familiar with."?

>"Here you got a thing"

A>>"um cool I guess"

B>>"oh nice I know something I can do with that!"

that ^^ sort of scenario?

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →