HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

up2you

13 karma · joined May 8, 2020

submissionscomments
up2you··on Google sued for secretly amassing vast trove of user data
Incognito Mode states plainly that it DOES NOT prevent the website you are visiting from tracking you.

Another commenter said that this wording implies that it DOES prevent Google Analytics, since it is not part of the site.

My argument was that drawing a distinction between a "site" and modules that are part of that "site" but are from other parties is dubious (also, likely impossible).

up2you··on Google sued for secretly amassing vast trove of user data
Incognito Mode states plainly that it DOES NOT prevent the website you are visiting from tracking you.

Another commenter said that this wording implies that it DOES prevent Google Analytics, since it is not part of the site.

My argument was that drawing a distinction between a "site" and modules that are part of that "site" but are from other parties is dubious.

up2you··on Google sued for secretly amassing vast trove of user data
Saying that "Google Analytics is NOT the website I visit" is the same as saying "React is NOT the UI I'm using" or "Stripe is NOT the store I'm buying from".

Modern day websites use readily available modules to build out functionality. Just because those modules were originally built by someone else doesn't mean that it's not part of the website you visit.

Full disclosure: I work at Google.

up2you··on The Cost of JavaScript Frameworks
With Static Site Generation, you can use React to generate plain HTML/CSS/JS that you then deploy as your actual website. Seriously, this tech is very very fast. Just check out how fast these websites are:

https://spectrum.chat https://vercel.com https://gatsbyjs.org