HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

upquark

176 karma · joined February 2, 2012

submissionscomments
upquark··on Physicists To Test If Universe Is A Computer Simulation
If someone is running our universe as a simulation they still don't necessarily know of our existence. I have a hard time figuring out how you'd detect intelligent life or its byproducts in your simulation. Even if you do detect something alive, how do you interact with it in a non-destructive way? Also not trivial at all :) That "long-distance phone call" might be far less likely than us ever figuring out if we're indeed a simulation.
upquark··on Iran’s New Fake Inventions: Time Machine, ‘Islamic Google Earth’
I think we need more ridicule of this type of stuff, not less. Also, I'm all for public ridicule of western kooks and BS-ers in government, science, healthcare. I disagree this is why we don't get along, humor can be a powerful and positive weapon.
upquark··on TEDx talks discredited: Sheldrake speaks, argues that speed of light is dropping
As far as science is concerned, there's nothing beyond being able to objectively model a phenomenon and make useful predictions about it. If I can fully model the set of brain processes that humans typically call "love", and if I can make useful and accurate predictions based on my model, that's all that I care about as a scientist.

Now, it's entirely possible that reasoning about "love" scientifically requires several layers of new language / models on top of the currently established models in neuroscience, which is why I said it's _theoretically_ possible.

upquark··on TEDx talks discredited: Sheldrake speaks, argues that speed of light is dropping
A. Plenty of people are suggesting precisely that.

B. I was responding to the parent comment about empirically verified dog's-sixth-sense phenomena, and what I think about those.

upquark··on TEDx talks discredited: Sheldrake speaks, argues that speed of light is dropping
When did I say I want to be explaining what love is? I said it's testable in theory, and you don't seem to be arguing against that.
upquark··on TEDx talks discredited: Sheldrake speaks, argues that speed of light is dropping
If I create a device that predicts with 99% accuracy whether a test subject loves their mother (by looking at the subject's brain), without ever answering any of your questions about consciousness, would you retract the above statement?
upquark··on TEDx talks discredited: Sheldrake speaks, argues that speed of light is dropping
My issue with this sort of unexplained phenomena is that people are willing to jump to ridiculous conclusions that invalidate or at least poke a hole through physics/chemistry/biology/all the other layers of scientific knowledge, vs trying to look for explanations within the established framework of knowledge. The amount of scientific knowledge we've accumulated so far is huge. It's been very thoroughly tested through multiple independent experiments, quantitative relationships have been verified to ridiculous precision.

It's just astronomically more likely that a dog sensing their owner's arrival is going to be explained within the framework of established science, and not invalidate every layer of our model of the world from mammal biology to quantum foam.

upquark··on TEDx talks discredited: Sheldrake speaks, argues that speed of light is dropping
>I could love my mother or I could not love my mother. Can you test that?

In theory, yes. What happens inside your brain isn't untestable or sacred, we're just not there yet technologically (but we'll get there).

upquark··on My Dad's Underwear
> We've got it made.

That's one way to look at it. Another way is to ask yourself whether we could've been much farther ahead, as a civilization and a species, in terms of quality of life, human rights, technology and science, and so on, in 2013 given what we had accomplished already in say 1913, or even 13. I think the answer is a solid yes, we could've been 100 times ahead of where we are now. I wouldn't congratulate ourselves just because we have some professions where people don't suffer injuries at work, that's a pretty low bar we should've crossed ages ago. (I realize this is a tangent and I'm not really arguing against your main point...)

upquark··on The Idea That Launched a Thousand Civilisations (2012) [pdf]
> But in what they do, they seem push humanity forward, to give a reason, a hope.

I'd argue that the surviving religions are more like the strongest viruses of the mind, not really the most useful mutations for society. You could look at the progress of societies and religions as the co-evolution of hosts and parasites, rather than of a single species acquiring useful new features :)

upquark··on "River" detection in text
Actually math and stats applications are very common, developers could really benefit from knowing more math, recognizing known problems and applying known solutions. People just do things the dumb way more often than not, and then spend months if not years fixing the mess they've created.
upquark··on That Daily Shower Can Be a Killer
With the disclaimer that I've watched the documentary and haven't read the book, the reasoning seemed faulty and unsound to me. It was definitely too deterministic and did not really go into non-environmental factors. For example, it boiled down the state of development of Papua New Guinea civilizations to the primary source of starch being palm trees vs grains, or something to that effect. It feels like picking one contributing factor and focusing on it at the expense of everything else.
upquark··on Pixels don’t care
I'm not sure it's gotten worse in every aspect, particularly in terms of acceptance of foreign ethnicities and races. People do have an unrealistic model of the real world, and that model is being currently skewed by mass media, etc, but previously it was skewed by local cultural attitudes, religious doctrine, etc. I don't think people were ever objective in judging each other based on merits vs appearance.
upquark··on The Human Brain Project
I'm not a neuroscientist and may be missing something, but on the surface this seems like a pretty poor argument: citing feasibility as a justification for not going with the (overwhelmingly) simpler organisms first, and going after humans with several orders of magnitude more complex brains. If I were to guess, I'd say that building the unified model of the simplest organisms would be tremendously relevant in helping to model higher-level organisms including humans.
upquark··on Show HN: My Weekend Hack - Stack-Ed: Learn from the best on StackOverflow
Excellent work, thank you for sharing.
upquark··on Calcutta girl who fled home & marriage at 17 returns as millionaire US innovator
> And by the way if you work hard 'enough', your dreams will come true anywhere!

Why do people keep repeating this? What is the empirical evidence for this statement outside of some anecdotes? I have seen so many counter-examples in my life...

upquark··on This is How Wrong Kurzweil Is
Out of curiosity, why would you take that as an axiom? Do human minds possess some qualities above physical reality? Are they unknowable in principle? If you answer yes, how did you arrive to that answer? Isn't there a physical experiment or demonstration that will change your mind?

I think the box analogy is flawed. We have certainly come a long way in understanding our own brains and bodies, even in the past couple of decades, and you could've said the same thing about boxes when people were first venturing into e.g. neuroscience.

The model doesn't have to be entirely contained in a human mind either, that's why we have a series of tools to aid us in modeling new tools, layer after layer. A human mind cannot contain a complete specification / working model of a modern computer either (if you think of all the layers involved), but modern computers do exist.

upquark··on What is the enlightenment I'm supposed to attain after studying finite automata?
This is factually incorrect.
upquark··on JPL director: Curiosity may have found organic, not biological molecules
Fascinating discussion. A couple of thoughts:

1. I was wondering if we could apply an anthropic type of argument here? We are having this argument at this time and place because we predate the colonization by self-replicating bots / other end-of-world scenarios. Multiverse version: any time we're having this discussion, we are on the surviving branch predating self-replicating bot colonization that renders the planet unlivable. I realize this type of argument can be extended to reach absurd conclusions, but nonetheless it's an entertaining thought.

2. What is life? What is civilization? What are their goals? Why do we assume a society of relatively independent individuals? Is it even a sustainable model for a post-human level civilization? Aren't we anthropomorphizing aliens a bit too much? What if a civilization either dies out at human-level stage or necessarily reaches a mental unification point and all its further activity is inward focused? I think we're on the first stages of self-awareness compared to rocks and jellyfish, imagine the level of self-awareness experienced by a far more advanced civilization. Would it necessarily be resource and space-greedy and try to colonize the galaxy? At least it's not immediately obvious to me why it would.

3. Another point is, what scales are we looking for? Doesn't our scale essentially depend on the planet / star system we evolved in, and the scale at which original life started? What basic building blocks / resources does alien life use? Maybe they rely on physical resources we haven't yet explored (dark matter, etc). Essentially I'm agreeing with the people saying "we don't know what we're looking for".

upquark··on Why becoming a data scientist is not easier than you think
Not disagreeing with your second paragraph, but just wanted to point out that Machine Learning has matured way beyond the "unprincipled hacks" phase, and as was correctly pointed out above, can be seen as a direction in applied statistics. If you look at a modern course in multivariate statistics, there's a significant overlap with ML (http://goo.gl/GTDUC).

I think people's expectation of a new scientific or engineering discipline to be "sexy" or "magic" is simply a sign of widespread ignorance of the field, so it's a good thing when something becomes less "magic" and more "real". I bet airplanes were "magic" until we learned how to fly them consistently and safely :)

upquark··on Why Smart People Are Stupid
The rest of your personality traits that allow you to accomplish great things (diligence, perseverance, focus, empathy, etc), as well as external factors such as being born at the right place and the right time, are also arguably a genetic / environmental dice roll.
← PreviousPage 4 of 4