HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

utopiah

1,986 karma · joined December 9, 2014

See https://fabien.benetou.fr for more, code at https://git.benetou.fr and videos https://video.benetou.fr
submissionscomments
utopiah··on The disappearance of Japan's animators
A note on programming languages : you can program with any language in VR.

There are few languages that make it easier, e.g. JavaScript as in my case, or any other language with a VR library, e.g. Lua LÖVR or also tooling like Godot which does have an in-VR live reloading mode (sorry discussed in French only at https://video.benetou.fr/w/g111LSRGfj6HmNxa91au3q ).

If your favorite language isn't very convenient for VR you can get a WASM build via e.g. QEMU. If that's not practical you can get the heavy load in a container then communicate to it via ssh or a Web API.

My point being that you can program in any language in VR quite conveniently and the power of the device itself is typically not relevant. For example I started some simulation for swarm robotics from the HMD to explore the result in VR but the runs themselves where not done on the device.

TL;DR: your HMD can host everything or can be a thin terminal to your heavier workload.

utopiah··on Show HN: OpenKnowledge – open source AI-first alternative to Obsidian/Notion
Good to see CodeMirror and yjs in there.

Rant warning (sorry OP but I have to vent somehow) : AI-first is the proof that things didn't change that much. It's a bit like "Roomba-compatible" flat. If somehow you have to changes your ways for a tool to work then clearly that tool isn't that flexible. It's perfectly fine but to me it's quite tiring when it's about the most hyped industry ever funded.

utopiah··on Libre Barcode Project
Damn, yes please.

Another cool font, but less original, I stumbled upon recently is Marelle https://marelle.forge.apps.education.fr/ for cursive.

utopiah··on The disappearance of Japan's animators
I did try the Valve Frame ... and I'll give recommendation only when it's officially out, but I can freely repeat what everybody else already said, the ergonomics are on point. You basically forget you are wearing an HMD. Sadly AFAIK they won't officially support WebXR and their focus, which is fair, is on their own store, Steam. So I wouldn't wait on it unfortunately.
utopiah··on The disappearance of Japan's animators
There are dozens of us!

I clarified a bit in a longer post. I do actually like the Vision Pro... but even though I own one I barely use it. It's a good device but it's just too many hoops for what I do. I find a much affordable Quest, even older generations, with adb and a proper WebXR support (including with AR support, which Apple refuses to implement) fits better my need. I have 0 problem popping a Quest 2 in my backpack without even thinking about it, only protection being a literally piece of cardboard on the lenses. I can work with it anywhere and give demos to total stranger with no worries about them dropping it or heck even running away with it.

FWIW I'm also not in the Apple ecosystem so all the wall garden hoops just tire me. I want the device I own to let me do my work.

I find that, probably counter-intuitively, super high resolution and refresh rate matter... but only up to a point. As I mentioned in the longer post if you are "just" looking for a monitor with another form factor, sure, maybe it's OK-ish, but to me it's very uninteresting and not worth all the challenges, including social, of having an HMD strapped to your face. Only when it's properly immersive does it shine, and then resolution and refresh rate don't have to be that high to be usable.

utopiah··on The disappearance of Japan's animators
Ah my bad I probably created false hopes here but let me clarify :

I program in VR for VR, and I help kids (and adults) learn programming thanks to VR.

What I do NOT do is writing my bash scripts or things unrelated to VR in VR. I technically can but I just have so much tooling and habits outside of VR it wouldn't make sense.

I'll answer your question as the end, you can skip to the last paragraph if you do not need the context.

Still do program in VR I can explain a bit more, or even show with a 1min video https://video.benetou.fr/w/iuJUP5oNnRAfH2xC3AW9s4 . Basically you can see ~20s that using the left pinch I can execute code in VR. Those specific code snippets are part of triad with querySelector() to get an element, setAttribute with it's attribute name then the last the value, e.g. here querySelector('a-sky').setAttribute('color', 'black') which sets the sky color to black. The idea here is to make a small change with a big impact.

If you are not a developer, it feels pretty cool (from the feedback I received) but if you are a developer there are 3 things you can notice :

- this is all done in a browser, as you can see from the beginning of the video, despite being properly immersive. I'm relying on eval() to provide a no-install no-build programming environment

- the black plane on the right is the browser console, literally. There is some visual feedback with green for console.log() yellow for console.warn() and red for console.error()

- the black plane on the left (hard to notice, ~34s in) is the code of the page

- the code snippets can be combined

- there is some syntax highlighting in order to hint that different attributes and there values are not compatible, e.g. scale black does not make sense or color 2 2 2 is also not correct

- the modifications are saved server side (but can also be done solely on device via local storage) so that others can build on the modifications you saved

and things you can't notice

- if you plug a keyboard, bluetooth or just USB-C, you can type code directly, it will become floating text snippet

- there is page reload code snippet at your feet, if you mess up you can recover from a proper state

- there is a non immersive console via eruda that is richer and expandable in case your changes break immersive mode, you still have a way to try to recover

- you can self-host that immersive Web on the device, it's just a Web server with HTTPS, if you want work properly offline, which is good when traveling, e.g. train or planes (that's how I do it on the go)

So... yes IMHO it's a good way to program in VR, today. It's also a good way to learn programming. If you program in VR chances are you quickly get frustrated by having to put the headset, work, hit a bug then remove the headset, try again, etc. That cycle can be frustrating so trying to find ways to do the spatial things in VR makes sense. The non spatial work though, e.g. backend, that can be properly tested outside of VR, IME should not be done in the headset, even when it can be done. Of course it depends on your workflow.

Finally which is a good headset depends on what kind of programming you want to do. If it's nothing spatial and you "just" want a 2D screen ... honestly I don't think it's worth it. I did try a lot of headsets. I worked with Varjo and Quest Pro, have a Vision Pro, Lynx XR1, Quest 3, Quest 2, Quest 1, Oculus Go, Valve Index, etc. I never spend 8hrs/day in any of those. It's short sessions or while on the move. I don't expect any headset to be "good enough" compared to a basic 4K 32" monitor, ever. What I also don't expect is any monitor, no matter how fancy (and same here, I worked with Looking Glass 8K, ~15k EUR monitor) to provide any proper sense of depth supporting manipulation. So if your programming work involve 3D work... then VR headsets are amazing. If so which one to buy? Depends on your programming language. If you are into JavaScript then any of the Quest will do but the latest generation (Quest 3) has color passthrough and higher resolution. It's also Android based so you can put termux to setup NodeJS, Python, etc and serve the content as notebooks. If you are into the Apple wall garden then obviously the Vision Pro but you'll have to go through all the usual hoops to publish anything.

TL;DR: high res with WebXR support and adb (or equivalent), e.g. Quest 3 (ideally rooted but that's hard to come by)

utopiah··on The disappearance of Japan's animators
Neat, I didn't know for Ghost in the Shell, I'll be watching it in few weeks then! Thanks for sharing.

PS: so weird to watch the trailer while working in XR. I never imagined as a kid I'd be programming in a headset but now it's banal. I even buy 2nd hand HMDs for 100 bucks. Weird times.

utopiah··on In memory of the man who put red and green squiggles under words
Anyway, apologies for the whole thread, I'll be more mindful both of the guidelines and how to provide a better avenue for meaningful conversations, thank you for trying to make this a better place.
utopiah··on In memory of the man who put red and green squiggles under words
Honestly I think labeling the comment (which is justified and involves a pun, sure might be dad-joke level but still) as "lame" is more toxic, or bring the forum down, than mine but OK, maybe I have a bias.

Strike through all this and see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48673613 instead

utopiah··on Cloudflare launched self-managed OAuth for all
Indeed, a self-hosted compatible fallback is a great failsafe.
utopiah··on Half-Life 2 in a Browser
Tricky to block WASM. A lot of useful Websites use for genuinely good usage. Can be for syntax highlighting, chess engine, etc and the same goes for WebGL or WebGPU, they are used for responsive UI in dashboard, for data visualization, for video rendering with effects e.g. blurring a background behind a person thus privacy, etc. Blocking either of those would break a lot of modern useful Websites.
utopiah··on The Xteink X4 E-Ink Reader
Oof... I just ordered the x3 and plan to add CrossPoint on it. If hesitating to cancel my ordered as it didn't ship yet. I have plenty of other e-ink screens and it has never happened. I specifically enjoy e-ink in directly sunlight or at least outdoors ... so I'm not sure if that's still a good usecase for me anymore.

Thanks for for sharing.

utopiah··on In memory of the man who put red and green squiggles under words
I'm not going to blindly follow guidelines if I believe they are unjust. I'd rather be banned from a forum that has oppressive guidelines than be a "good" netizen of a bad place. If I can't openly criticize corporations then maybe HN isn't for me.
utopiah··on Half-Life 2 in a Browser
That's also the kind of Website, beside the impressive technical result, that reminds me nothing can be blocked.

It's not about bypassing VPN or deep pack inspection, rather it's about how once anything, including a very complex video game (like here) to an entire OS with a host machine (like QEMU on WASM, or a random InternetArchive link about emulation) is "just" a Web page that can be hosted... on anything (including a 10 bucks Rasperry Pi Zero which can also be an AP, a phone obviously, heck even a e-cig!) then it doesn't matter what is "blocked" as it can be brought to anyone with no installation.

utopiah··on Markdy: Like Mermaid Diagrams, but for Motion
Interesting, I do a bit of animation in XR for pedagogy. I can easily recognize patterns, e.g. stacking animations one after the other, classic parameters like duration, easing.

I'm wondering though if, compared to what I already know (e.g. https://aframe.io/docs/1.7.0/components/animation.html ) how this is better. Maybe a "renderer" there could be outputting AFrame animations instead (itself based on AnimeJS, quite popular).

It could be useful to discuss scenarii but storyboard is usually sufficient.

I'd be curious how newcomers take it up. I think for (JavaScript) the syntax is pretty straightforward but for others I'm not sure.

utopiah··on In memory of the man who put red and green squiggles under words
My phrasing might be off putting and even against guidelines but, even through jest, the idea itself still remains : Microsoft does have a history of claiming a lot more than they did. It's a brilliant, albeit illegal, series of business decisions but it has not invented as much as it claims it had.
utopiah··on OAuth for all
It's a good move for them but it's problematic for anybody who cares about a decentralized Internet.
utopiah··on OAuth for all
Classic Cloudflare, for all, works well, not too expensive... but, and consequently of all those positive attributes, positioning itself at the center of everything.
utopiah··on The Xteink X4 E-Ink Reader
Damned... I already have few e-readers, some e-ink screens (for IoT), some reMarkables and a PineNote. When I saw the new reMarkable Pro Move I was very tempted by the form factor.

Now that I see the X3 and X4 with unlocked firmware it's very VERY tempting.

Before I do buy it, did anybody manage to use it for phone mirroring? Get input e.g. BT keyboard? Does it fit and snap on the back on a Pixel 8?

utopiah··on In memory of the man who put red and green squiggles under words
Hmmm guidelines do exist and I don't think toxicity is a good thing so thanks for pointing that out. Still here I'm not attacking an individual but a large corporation that's been punished multiple time for terrible behavior and now with a founder and former CEO entangled in terrible affairs so I admit I'm not sure how wrong a bit of sarcasm truly is. I do genuinely believe Microsoft is a terrible company which entire business model is going against open source, locking IP down and thus truly claiming that they did "invent" more than they did. Is it more justified with this background than random sneering?
utopiah··on OpenAI unveils its first custom chip, built by Broadcom
Strawberry was too complicated as a codename.
utopiah··on FUTO Swipe – A new swipe typing model
Docs https://github.com/pytorch/executorch/tree/main/examples/was...
utopiah··on FUTO Swipe – A new swipe typing model
Apparently ExecuTorch has a WASM backend, could work to load the model this way.
utopiah··on FUTO Swipe – A new swipe typing model
Ah nice they do have a VR demo https://swipe.futo.tech/vr-swipe-small.mp4 ... now I'm wondering if there is a WASM version so that it can be used in WebXR.
utopiah··on What we call "age verification" is actually mass surveillance
Ah! My bad I didn't properly track authorship. I thought you were https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48645333
utopiah··on Mistral OCR 4
Guess you haven't met management yet. Clearly nobody should do that but that official warning is not going to stop them from trying.
utopiah··on What we call "age verification" is actually mass surveillance
Indeed but you are the one who claimed it was not a hard problem.

I don't think any one of us pushing back here on those claims do so for the heck of NOT finding a "solution", rather genuinely asking because so far it seems nobody did find such a solution without compromises that is in the end not worth it due to the flaw in said solution.

The point isn't to be critical of your process, only of the claim that it's a trivial problem.

utopiah··on What we call "age verification" is actually mass surveillance
> UUID card is non-identifying.

Kids aren't going to trade Pokemon cards in the playground anymore...

utopiah··on Mistral OCR 4
"A note on out-of-scope use. OCR 4 is a document-understanding model, not a decision-maker. It is not intended for medical diagnosis, legal advice or judgment, high-stakes financial decisions, safety-critical systems, real-time/latency-sensitive processing, or non-document inputs (raw audio, video, etc.). "

Can't wait for the "oh so innovative" manager who will suggest during the next meeting "Ok... but what if WE used it for high-stakes financial decisions on non-document inputs like a photo from my phone?"

I guarantee you somebody on HN is going to comment about this "idea" next week.

utopiah··on Steam Machine launches today
Wondering how it’d benchmark against https://www.tuxedocomputers.com/en/TUXEDO-Nano-Pro-Gen14-AMD... in an even smaller form factor and similar price range for specs.
← PreviousPage 11 of 34Next →