HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

utopiah

1,986 karma · joined December 9, 2014

See https://fabien.benetou.fr for more, code at https://git.benetou.fr and videos https://video.benetou.fr
submissionscomments
utopiah··on Cyberdecks, going analog, and convivial technology
"Yeah I don't get it..." meanwhile me packing for holiday with my GrapheneOS Pixel with my 3D printed phone stand and my BT mechanical keyboard "Wait a minute!"

Also gave a workshop last weekends to kids and brought a "server" as a RPi Zero and a cheap (as in goodie level) tiny battery.

Damned, I'm part of the "movement".

utopiah··on Optocam Zero: a Pi Zero based digital camera made using off the shelf components
I've done that and I recommend it.

In fact I recommend doing that for EVERYTHING you can! You don't need to do it more than once in your life but it's worth going through the actual process to learn.

That being said I also have a FujiFilm Insta to print polaroid size photos for the fridge or to give to guests.

Those though are 2 different processes, one is about learning the other about convenient usage.

utopiah··on An Introduction to YOLO26
Despite having a very memorable paper on the topic I believe they now work at Ai2.
utopiah··on Renting a sewing machine from the library
Ah I see, then indeed we disagree about the point of a library. You see it as storage, I see it as a place for object, I see it as a place for people to meet, with the "excuse" o objects or via objects (e.g. books).
utopiah··on My Mathematical Regression
Comment as a song https://mariedavidson.bandcamp.com/album/work-it-soulwax-rem...

There is no easy way out, you have to rest but you simply can't stop. Your body will rot, your mind too.

PS: song isn't an ode to the grind culture or how to slave away in an office, as lyrics say "you’ve got to work for yourself - Love yourself, feed yourself".

utopiah··on Renting a sewing machine from the library
> The fact that libraries are not full of people doesn't negate their function.

Is this what I said or even implied?

utopiah··on Show HN: Teach your kids perfect pitch
Thanks! OP please consider linking their repo to "open-source CIM Trainer by Paul Ganssle" in your readme.
utopiah··on Munich 1991: The Roots of the Current AI Boom
The practical issue of academia is epistemological. It's about learning how a phenomenon came to exists. If you are looking for efficiency the field of academia related to learning how to do so is computational complexity and it works quite well.

The goal of academia isn't to be practical, "only" learning.

utopiah··on Deno Desktop
That's a whole can of worms, Micro$lop entangling its own browser with its OS, getting a (gentle) slap on the hand for its abuse of monopoly position for it, having to remove it claiming it's "impossible", etc.
utopiah··on Deno Desktop
If a Web View is not provided by a browser then it's an already installed browser then it's as they say "web rendering engine" that they ship along.

I'm trying to argue that it should already be available via Firefox, Chromium, etc on desktop.

utopiah··on The minimum viable unit of saleable software
I feel like my HN comments fall now into 3 categories :

- free software exists since the 80s, having software that costs literally 0, not even being "very cheap" is NOT new

- Goodhart's law where we get a new KPI only to make the entire process and ecosystem around it pointless

- the rest (but it's rare)

so... yeah this one is option #1.

utopiah··on Show HN: Teach your kids perfect pitch
Thanks OP, I was going to annoy you with a bunch of request, e.g. "Can I please just get the .apk because I use GrapheneOS without the PlayStore?" then I thought "looks simple enough, maybe I a Web page is enough... no app required" which lead me to https://eguchi.app ... so instead I'll just both you with : what do you think about this alternative? Is it any good?
utopiah··on Everything is logarithms
Indeed, you can get yours today https://www.instructables.com/Make-a-simple-paper-slide-rule...
utopiah··on Deno Desktop
Interesting but IMHO as we see on mobile providing WebViews work. Maybe instead of having Electron, Tauri, Electrobun, now Deno desktop but also plenty of alternatives then desktop browsers should provide WebViews on desktop with sandbox and permissions that make those applications usable. The alternatives listed here would just be fallback for a transition period until the WebViews are "good enough".
utopiah··on Deno Desktop
> look native to the OS

Is that a problem? A button with a legible label is a button. The host OS doesn't have to look exactly like the applications it runs.

utopiah··on Renting a sewing machine from the library
It's such an absolutely weird tension...

The libraries in Belgium at least are absolutely amazing!

They are filled with :

- books (obviously) beautifully curated

- comics

- magazines

- sometimes even audiobooks in the form of CDs

- sometimes also events with authors on absolutely important topics like ... what it means to be human

and they are also

- basically free (few Euros per year, at most, and if you cannot pay)

- staffed with people who absolutely love the mission

... and empty.

It's totally nuts. They are basically full of top materials with dedicated staff, but nobody goes there. We even have toy libraries and... it's the same. Sure during some moments of the week it's relatively busy but mostly empty. Meanwhile we can order online any book or toy or video games for very little money... but also we don't use them for very long.

It's a very strange tension that we somehow manage to setup a very inclusive infrastructure for knowledge in few centuries, or arguably decades, yet in few years we totally cancelled ALL that effort.

Now libraries are looking for events because nobody "needs" content anymore.

utopiah··on When I reject AI code even if it works
Fallacy or scapegoat. If management ask for revised KPIs where PRs must be 10x and AI is the "excuse" for this (unrealistic) new demand.
utopiah··on Developers don't understand CORS (2019)
I definitely understand CORS in theory, then when it's time to solve a CORS related error, anything goes. /s
utopiah··on GPT-5.5 hallucinates 3x more than MIT-licensed GLM-5.2
Listing things that couldn't be done by tools until now but since then can is entirely unrelated to intelligence. I don't know even understand why it's being mentioned. A ruler can measure infinitely better than I can, nobody ever thought of it as intelligent. You can keep on giving more (genuinely) impressive examples yet it's not helping at all.
utopiah··on GPT-5.5 hallucinates 3x more than MIT-licensed GLM-5.2
>> it is clear that actual intelligence has plateaued significantly.

> These are wild claims -

Indeed, it is not clear there was any actual intelligence at any point.

A lot of generated content sure, sometimes even useful, but not necessarily anything more.

utopiah··on Norway imposes near ban on AI in elementary school
Computer literacy.
utopiah··on Norway imposes near ban on AI in elementary school
I just had a discussion with 10 to 12 years old kids today. They are not using AI to learn, they are using it to cheat. It's not a moral judgement, it's what they, themselves, told me today in front of their peers. Initially they claimed it was an aid to get homework done, then their own peers asked few questions to clarify and they themselves came to the conclusion (after quite some pushback and mental gymnastic) that it was indeed to cheat.

So... ask kids themselves, see what they do and what they say, it's fascinating.

utopiah··on Building a robotics research setup that lives next to my desk
Thanks! I did have fun tinkering at the intersection of both media.

I would have liked to explore a bit for but doing innovation readiness on technologies related to XR I basically had to move on to the next project. This though happened mostly because, as pointed out by the essay by Brooks, dexterity is hard, on both ends. Namely yes one can get a basic robot "arm" for cheap... but doing a robotic arm with a hand is something else, one with fine motor control is ... well I'm not an expert in the field but basically it doesn't exist yet IMHO. Sure we have grippers but that has basically nothing to do with a human hand. It's amazing how much flexibility we have at our disposal in such a compact and efficient form, sensors for touch obviously but also heat, proprioception of course, part that are smooth and flexibly while other are hard. The range of craftmanship we can do is... mindblowing. If you don't believe me just look at a basic magician, not even a good one (like me, I confess), doing sleight of hand, it's just amazing.

So that was on the robotic part, discovering what it could do, amazing, but more importantly for my work what it could NOT do.

A seemingly simple project was how to remove a 3D print from our 3D printer in order to free it up and move to the next job. This sounds trivial ... until you try to actually do it. I won't get into details but we didn't manage. It's of course feasible in the ideal scenario, e.g. successful print that is mostly rigid with attachment and support to the plate that requires just the right amount of force. It can be done. Now doing that in a realistic set of scenarii that a 3D printing house would do... well maybe it's feasible but I professionally didn't know (and still don't know) how to do with a realistic set of constraints (time wise, economically speaking too).

Moving on then to the other end, or hand (sorry for the pun) tracking in VR is good, honestly. It's quite fun for games... then trying to do so in a professional scenario then 1mm difference or occlusion for .1s is not acceptable anymore.

TL;DR (sorry I have to run and it might be longer than what you even asked for!) : the concept itself is obviously good, especially from a programmer standpoint. We are expert at automating, in fact I'd argue that's the 1 thing we excel at. The implementation though, in real life, is much harder that we naively consider, even with a LOT more computing power.

TL;DR (short): quick wins, yes, harder wins... not intractactable but at least beyond my own ability.

utopiah··on Building a robotics research setup that lives next to my desk
Ah nice I've tinkered a bit with robotics few years ago, e.g. https://twitter-archive.benetou.fr/utopiah/status/1760260544... and it's pretty empowering... but also showcases how amazing the human body is. Our dexterity, ability to sense, etc.

Reminds me of https://rodneybrooks.com/why-todays-humanoids-wont-learn-dex... which is basically a stark warning against the hype.

utopiah··on Gribouille 0.3.0: A Grammar of Graphics for Typst
I'm not sure either matter to be honest.

It's cool sure, powerful also... but when anybody has access to both vector-based editor and raster-based editor ... but also tools that incorporate them, e.g. rich text editors ... but also entire toolchain going from compilers to libraries all the way to Web based notebook with their editors and running environment that can then output printable artifacts, I don't think there has to be "the" way. They might be a more popular way within a certain zeitgeist but... does one project has to "replace" another one?

I guess I don't really get the passion some people have for "perfect" rendering. I'm fine with just text, then just readible equations below it, then an OK looking graph. I don't actually care if any of those are pixel perfect. I don't get it.

IMHO in terms of actual knowledge transmission reproducibility and interactivity are way more important. They might not look as good and in fact introduce a TON of complexity but I believe it's better than yet another system that is slightly better looking while being slightly easier, for those people with a specific mindset, to setup and use.

PS: still both Gribouille and Typst are cool projects! Just want to make sure I'm not sounding critical against those efforts.

utopiah··on I hacked into the worst e-bike and fixed it [video]
You and the person you are replying to are both using dimensions (price, fun, maintenance, availability of public transport, physical health) that are important yet apparently the other one does not value.
utopiah··on CrankGPT
Nope, I literally did as I said namely look up "USB Hand Crank Phone Charger".
utopiah··on SteamOS Linux 3.8 released as stable
Obviously correct, what I meant is that they don't mention the Steam Frame which is what I'm interested in and had in mind due to the recent "leaks" on Steam getting shipments in the US.
utopiah··on Why thinking out loud with someone beats thinking alone
My own efficiency ranking :

- genuine dialog between 2 peers with overlapping knowledge on the topic, both being kind, patient, open-minded yet critical, able to point flaws in reasoning or provenance without being hurtful

- genuine dialog between 2 peers with overlapping knowledge on the topic

- genuine dialog between 2 peers

- genuine dialog between 2 persons

- thinking out loud in front of someone listening

- thinking out loud alone thinking of someone listening

- thinking out loud alone

The "trick" here, and that's why I wanted to write it down, is that having an actual person, real or imaginary, does force one to actually explain. A typical fallacy is the "proof left out to the student" which actually happens to be terribly complex or even infeasible.

I believe trying to explain to someone forces you to identify the gap into their knowledge and your point. It's precisely mapping where knowledge does NOT overlap. So instead of making a lot of assumptions they have to be laid out, at the very least made in part explicit. Doing so forces you to stop skimming parts that are challenging for you. The part that you might not feel so sure.

Obviously the whole problem is that this peer, who is both knowledgeable and kind is good in their field and popular, thus busy. Consequently their time is very VERY precious. Hopefully you yourself are that peer. That means that often we have to go down the list and find the next best person.

So... I do think duck debugging is better if you genuinely trust in the kindness of the duck, not see it as a piece of plastic ;)

utopiah··on SteamOS Linux 3.8 released as stable
I imagine it's for the upcoming hardware.
← PreviousPage 12 of 34Next →