HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

utopiah

1,986 karma · joined December 9, 2014

See https://fabien.benetou.fr for more, code at https://git.benetou.fr and videos https://video.benetou.fr
submissionscomments
utopiah··on Building my own network stack
Maybe not an HTTP client but a modern browser with its JavaScript engine, encryption support, CSS engine, etc I think for most people really is a lot of work. If one does rely on the right libraries it's a weekend of fun (and pain) so I would argue between few hours and a lifetime, depending on how much you implement.

My point is that the essence, the core mechanism, is typically a 1-liner, but only with a pedagogical context, not a production (in the sense of anybody else using it reliably in realistic situations) context.

utopiah··on Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root
I'm missing something then, are you talking about the code your shared or an another slightly more complicated one you are just imagining now?
utopiah··on Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root
Did you actually try or are you provocatively speculating?

I do have non sudoers groups devices and I also have shared devices with non sudoers users. It works. It's not necessarily for everyone, e.g. not for powerusers who want to go fast very often, but it's definitely usable for most users still.

utopiah··on Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root
Just don't be in the sudo group.
utopiah··on Omarchy: Any User Process Can Escalate to Root
Funnily enough it wouldn't work for me as I use passwordless sudo thanks to PAM-U2F with a YubiKey Bio. I mean realistically speaking it probably would as I would just type it thinking "Hmmm weird" but still want to proceed forward ¯\_ (ツ)_/¯
utopiah··on Building my own network stack
> far from feature complete, but it did work

well that's the trick. If you look at implementing a Web browser or a physics engine you instantly give up, and you are right about it, it's just too hard. If instead you write a partial HTTP client which can display some text from a URL or have a 3D scene and in it an object Y coordinates get smaller each millisecond then suddenly in terms of the essence of each, you are 80% there really. Now if you want to implement the "rest" you might need an entire lifetime, or more. Still IMHO it's definitely worth doing very compact and limited versions of all those in order to learn, even if done only once in your life.

utopiah··on Tether: iMessage, SMS, etc. on Linux
Ah nice, I had no idea. Then if I was somehow forced into using iOS I'd probably try that first.
utopiah··on Tether: iMessage, SMS, etc. on Linux
Glad you brought that up, I was actually going to suggest not to replace KDE Connect but rather to become interoperable with it because AFAIR (but didn't touch an iPhone for few years now) there is no iOS client for it.
utopiah··on GUIs should be fully keyboard-driven
Yes, for efficiently of course but at the very least for accessibility.
utopiah··on “It works better in the app”
What's even more maddening is that I bet their "app" is actually a WebView and provides no native functionality.
utopiah··on Please stop flooding our projects with AI slop to furnish your CV
Fair enough not to want to get involved but seems problematic for 2 reasons :

- code gets re-regenerated over and over again, so waste of resources

- no signal back upstream that it is indeed a genuine need that is in fact so important some users did dedicate resources for it, maybe more users would benefit from it

utopiah··on Air Conditioning Is Not a Luxury, It Is a Necessity
Well that is a different setup that what I mention but thanks for indeed highlighting how they are not the same.

FWIW houses in Tuscany with very strict rules, e.g. you don't even get to pick the color of your own house, manage to get the entire place setup with full-size AC it's feasible. What's not feasible is trying to ignore laws on what a building must look like but that has nothing to do with air conditioning. For example if Belgium if you has is classified as notable (most old houses are) then you need a permit even for the window frame.

utopiah··on Air Conditioning Is Not a Luxury, It Is a Necessity
Very strange take, you can buy an airco unit in the EU today get it delivered tomorrow morning and, assuming it's the portable kind that just need to be plugged and exhaust outside, have it running right away. For more permanent ones you might need a professional to install it if you don't know yourself. There is absolutely 0 barrier if you need or even just want one.

Proof in Belgium : https://www.coolblue.be/en/air-conditioners/filter which ironically enough aren't even available anymore because they are out of stock, so clearly purchased showing people had no problem getting them. Alternative example 12000BTU A+++ energy rating delivery next week https://www.bol.com/be/fr/p/climatiseur-mobile-puissant-clim... To be clear I'm not advocating to buy these, or not, only that they are freely and conveniently available.

utopiah··on Microduck
for microduck I didn't find but their older reachy_miny was Apache 2.0 and hardware design files as Creative Commons BY-SA-NC
utopiah··on Microduck
This "with emotions like a living creature" should just not be allowed.
utopiah··on Mechanical Turk shutting down September 30
FWIW I tried it shortly after it launched so a bit after ~2005, maybe 2007 because I read about and honestly found the prospect, from a dataset creation or improvement, quite interesting. I think I heard about it from a research paper that distributed its work that way.

Well it did work, in the sense that I managed to complete some tasks. I don't think I ever collected the money/credits back then though (simply because it amounted to so little). What I can attest though is that... it was debilitating. If you think your office job is boring then splitting it in way smaller tasks where you have no autonomy is absolutely terrible from a worker standpoint.

I initially was hoping to use it in order to work on providing a service over a dataset but understanding first hand what it takes to make it happen made me stop. It radically changed how I saw supervised learning since, and sadly not in a good way.

utopiah··on France reaches 94.9% fiber coverage in 2026
Yep... was on the countryside for the Summer in places so small they didn't even have a bakery, which in France matters.

What did they have though? Optic fiber, high bandwidth, low latency, reliable and for a very low price.

Honestly I think ADSL was already enough for most people, I mean non professionals, but now I think France has the infrastructure for a good enough Internet for the next few decades. I can't fathom normal usages that would need higher bandwidth and lower latency.

utopiah··on Starbase, LA
Hmmm is it though? Quite a few articles like https://futurism.com/future-society/elon-musk-stiffing-contr... make me think they better ask to be paid upfront.
utopiah··on Nitter and XCancel receive cease and desist notices
Fiction would led us to believe they look ugly or gorgeous... history has shown us they look very banal.
utopiah··on Nitter project received cease and desist
Sad for the project but unsurprising knowing how much SpaceX (sigh) relies on xAI which it mostly a shelf for a neocloud bootstrapped precisely from Twitter/X as a dataset. I imagine they will legally fight to close as much as possible in order to make it look like a valuable dataset that is exclusive.
utopiah··on How much of HN is AI?
Upvoted obviously just to counterbalance how often I got downvoted for stating how popular posts from OpenAI, Anthropic, Google, etc are just ads.

The author is most subtle or diplomatic than me and thus call them "AI vendor press releases" or "AI vendor marketing" but we know.

utopiah··on US data centers tripled annual water consumption to 17B gallons
> modern facilities can reuse

Can, but do they? Feels a bit like Musk's Colossus that "could" use nuclear power but has been running on "temporary" natural-gas turbines for years now.

utopiah··on Bookshelf – Self-hosted eBook library that runs on object storage
Might want to look into OPDS support, cf https://opds.io , to make content available to e-readers.
utopiah··on I built a low-latency AI companion that plays Skyrim with me
I get it is fun to play for an hour or so then you inexorably encounter behaviors that are too complex to handle, e.g. you try to sneak in on an enemy but get spotted because the dog started talking or barking randomly, then suddenly wonder how much "it" actually gets it. You then start with less and less complex plans... until you realize that direct commands or shortcuts are more reliable.

I do think it is an interesting exploration but the jagged frontier makes it really challenging to know what will consistently work and what will not, to the point that I bet (maybe pessimistically) one will be gradually less daring with creative plan with their "companion" simply because they can't trust it.

utopiah··on Andreessen Horowitz is investing billions into a bleak future
So... nothing new? /s

You naively thought Silicon Valley was just a funny TV show about people wanting to make money, a lot of it, but even that was an idealized version.

utopiah··on I were 17, I'd learn how to build LLMs from scratch
he does mention that it would later on be about building a startup, which is about making money
utopiah··on I were 17, I'd learn how to build LLMs from scratch
... and it would be totally pointless.

I mean first that is already what plenty of 17yo are actually doing, because that is what they do at school or in parascholar activities. There are already countless of such tutorials where you can do that in an afternoon.

The pointless part though is precisely why Amazon and others are hunting for rare books, all the low hanging fruits have been picked already so just training a bigger model will simply mean burning more energy and money. Sure training a small one for the basic principle is a great pedagogical thing, training another one, medium, then maybe a large one, is also good in term of learning the process and architecture, but one should not expect it to be useful out of that context.

Pure players are precisely doing everything they can to corner the market by making their own scale unreachable by others. Smaller players with access to lesser infrastructure are thus betting on different market, e.g. embedded systems.

17yos should definitely build their (L)LMs from scratch and whatever bigger model they can train for free, or for cheap, but they should not expect that to bring them any riches.

utopiah··on typ.ing
First time I notice the error as superscript, very nice.
utopiah··on Ask HN: What's your daily driver keyboard?
Bastard Dilemma 36 keys, twilight switches, touchpad

my keyboard journey is on https://fabien.benetou.fr/Tools/Keyboards

utopiah··on Why your local LLM feels dumber than it is
Comments are mostly showing off M5s and 5090s without addressing the article.
← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →