The point isn't whether you "knew" the stocks would skyrocket. It's whether they could with some reasonable/acceptable probability. I remember these stocks being in the doldrums in each of those years and thinking that they could explode with a little execution. I was thinking of buying the stock (but didn't). If I was thinking along the lines of the call option (adding more asymmetry), I might have pulled the trigger. This isn't a "hindsight is 20-20" example.