HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vbs_redlof

63 karma · joined March 13, 2013

submissionscomments
vbs_redlof··on Steve Jobs threatened Palm’s CEO, court documents reveal
This would never happen. The market for programmers and athletes are wildly different (winner take all markets).
vbs_redlof··on P values are not as reliable as many scientists assume
Please re-read onetwofiveten's explanation. All I've done is paraphrase it. Alpha is just an arbitrary cutoff p-value corresponding to a threshold t-value for a given null hypothesis.
vbs_redlof··on The Star Trek Economy
You raise an interesting point on 'work'. The value of work is increasingly less atomic in context of a knowledge economy. Ideas, research, art, sports--these are typically either completely ignored or wildly successful. Marginal differences in 'work' and effort are inconsequential. This is unfortunate because like you've noted, many skilled people will never get what they deserve in winner take all markets on the off chance their choices do not work out. The incremental differences between the top 0.01% and 0.02% are negligible but often lead to disparate rewards.

I disagree with your arguments that we lack a system for competition. Markets do (did) a pretty job of deciding whether an idea or invention is truly valuable. The problem is that most markets are relatively zero-sum, and people are dictated by myopic concerns like bills, quarterly earnings, etc. What this means is that ideas tend to cluster along similar branches as players react to one another rather than engaging in truly 'free-form' exploration of ideas. Basic income will help in this respect, however for every ambitious dreamer there is a gluttonous, entitled individual who blows his money on himself and contributes very little. Coming from a econ/finance background, I can tell you that people can be very selfish in contrast to the comparatively idealistic tech and research community. Unfortunately, current economic systems are obsessed with the stability of quantifiable targets such as inflation, unemployment, etc; i.e. we have a system that promotes incremental growth rather than a system that is more likely to experience creativity/innovation shocks.

vbs_redlof··on The Dawn of the Age of Artificial Intelligence
Not before they trick 641 hipsters into falling in love with them.
vbs_redlof··on P values are not as reliable as many scientists assume
This is the clearest answer I've read so far. The p-value is the minimum probability of ending up with a test statistic that lies in the rejection region (for a given null hypothesis and critical value).
vbs_redlof··on P values are not as reliable as many scientists assume
Less wrong, but still off. The p-value is the probability of committing a type-1 error (false positive: we declare X to be president when he really isn't) given a sample and a null hypothesis. P-values are not the 'chances' of seeing the given data, it is a test-statistic that describe how reliable your probability estimates are for a given sample and null.
vbs_redlof··on P values are not as reliable as many scientists assume
P-values are not comparable across different null hypotheses, they are a property of a particular sample given a null hypothesis. You can compare p-values only by making very strong assumptions that the samples come from the same data-generating process. In almost all cases this is unlikely.

A frequentist usually builds a more descriptive model by adding more variables (accounting for obvious factors that contribute to differences in observed frequencies) and increasing sample size to increase statistical power (reduce false negatives). This is not applicable in this case because there is only one president and the tests have low power. The test is bogus because you can't 'sample' and determine to probability of X==president effectively.

vbs_redlof··on Economics Simulation
Lesson learnt from the comments: beware of modelling economics if you have a background in a hard science. As a profession, we are incredibly envious and defensive of our position as the quantitative social science.
vbs_redlof··on News is bad for you
Maybe Dobelli's ghost writer messed up.
vbs_redlof··on Startup Investor Rankings
Coming from a finance background, calling this measure of startup investor performance "portfolio momentum" is very confusing.
vbs_redlof··on Is The Economist left- or right-wing?
I don't want to be an asshole, but…instead of prancing around like you actually know something why not correct what you think is "certainly categorically incorrect".
vbs_redlof··on Quantitative Economic Modeling in Python
Stachurski's book goes into the underlying theory more deeply with code examples. It's also got a very good/practical introduction into real analysis and measure theory. Great resource for modern computational economics.
vbs_redlof··on The Ph.D.-Industry Gap
How do you "stumble" through the PhD system?
vbs_redlof··on John Carmack: Thoughts on Haskell [video]
This book is starting to show it's age, lots of the examples are broken.
vbs_redlof··on Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer to retire within 12 months
Share price is up ~6.5% haha.
vbs_redlof··on Bridging Economics and Data Science
Structural models are more 'insightful' than generative models in machine learning. Econ guys are more interested in Pr(y|x) than reproducing the data.

That being said, I really hope computational work gains more traction... this might be a marketing issue.

vbs_redlof··on “Right click and save as” needs to go away
Too bad the font rendering quality is a little subpar compard to the other pdf viewers.

Yellow is not an issue: https://code.google.com/p/sumatrapdf/wiki/CommandLineArgumen...

vbs_redlof··on What does one trillion dollars look like?
Another "mother" http://demonocracy.info/infographics/usa/derivatives/bank_ex...
← PreviousPage 2 of 2