Yep. That's what people have been saying all along. If the intent is to substitute the original, then copying is not fair use.
But the problem is that the current method for training requires this volume of data. So the models are legitimately not viable without massive copyright infringement.
It'll be interesting to see how a defendant with a larger wallet will fare. But this doesn't look good.
Though big-picture, it seems to me that the money-ed interests will ensure that even if the current legal landscape doesn't allow LLM's to exist, then they will lobby HARD until it is allowed. This is inevitable now that it's at least partially framed in national security terms.
But I'd hope that this means there is a chance that if models have to train on all of human content, the weights will be available for free to all humans. If it requires massive copyright infringement on our content, we should all have an ownership stake in the resulting models.