HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

verylittlemeat

823 karma · joined January 5, 2017

submissionscomments
verylittlemeat··on Post-SESTA/FOSTA Self-Censoring for Twitter, Reddit, and Other Social Media
Well he did put emphasis on sex. Social norms regarding pornography, sexuality, prostitution and nudity are still depressingly puritanical in the US.

I think the ripple effects from being raised to believe sexuality and nudity are shameful or obscene are much greater than we appreciate.

verylittlemeat··on Elon Musk Deletes Own, SpaceX and Tesla Facebook Pages After #deletefacebook
>Reddit/HN are places where places that can make you feel like you are doing something or "contributing", without actually making any real impact.

Impact for its own sake is overrated. That's not to say you should navelgaze and philosophize about everything but you really do need a balance. The startup community in particular is in love with the image of hustle and whirlwind activity usually just for the sake of ingratiating a handful of egos.

Blogs and newspaper articles have been left in the dust. We can romanticize the long form journalist but really that's a step back. The pool of ideas is now open to anyone with a well worded comment. Rather than privileging a credentialed journalist to express an opinion for us there is a battle of contrasting ideas from many more (though never all) backgrounds to find consensus. To me this is the future. A handful of ivy league graduates pontificating back and forth in op-eds through limited newspaper and magazine space is the past.

You might argue that this will create an environment full of emotion and rhetoric but really that's business as usual. The well educated have just been schooled in how to dress up their opinions as though they were facts. Internet comment sections are about deciding how a problem or conversation will be framed not necessarily about solving those problems. Framing/rhetoric and analysis of virtues are a huge part of determining what "impact" will look like.

verylittlemeat··on Restricted by YouTube, Gun Enthusiasts Are Taking Their Videos to Pornhub
How is this "capitalism plain and simple." Youtube and reddit are only banning this content because of new regulation passed by the government.
verylittlemeat··on Rise in cancers 'caused by weight'
You might be interested to learn that one of the fathers of modern statistics believed this too

https://priceonomics.com/why-the-father-of-modern-statistics...

verylittlemeat··on The FBI Says It Can't Find Hackers to Hire Because They All Smoke Pot (2014)
Anyone who goes after weed as being the "life killer" before even making a casual mention to alcohol can usually be safely dismissed as moralizing.
verylittlemeat··on My daughter's disabled. Please don't look away from her
>Sighted

>adjective

>(of a person) having the ability to see; not blind.

Seems that his definition of sighted is non standard. It could be a neologism on the euphemism treadmill. Example: "neurotypical" not "normal."

verylittlemeat··on The health care toll today’s work culture exacts on employees
No phone? We need team players at this company. /s
verylittlemeat··on How Hard Is It to Get a Cartoon into the New Yorker? (2011)
This article mentions it but it's worth noting here:

https://contest.newyorker.com/

Pretty fun if you enjoy comics in The New Yorker.

verylittlemeat··on 'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Christian Europe
What's stopping you? In theory nothing but in practice many things.

Atheists still have to live in the real world. The real world doesn't run on people fearing god it runs on, among other things, laws and reputation. Most people wont steal from you because they don't want to go to jail not because god is watching. Most people don't screw over every person they meet because then they'll get a reputation as a person to not work with. Say you decide to play the long game and "pretend" to be good until you get your chance to betray everyone for your payday. Some might say that's just good old fashioned capitalist business, a system atheists and the god fearing alike participate in.

verylittlemeat··on 'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Christian Europe
There has been a lot of science coming out recently about how in an evolutionary context cooperation is more beneficial in some situations than any idea of individual survival of the fittest.

Based on your reaction though with "red in tooth and nail[sic (claw)]" you seem more interested in your own preconceived biases than any good faith argument from science or otherwise.

verylittlemeat··on 'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Christian Europe
The philosophy behind humanism seems like a decent place to start.
verylittlemeat··on 'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Christian Europe
What kinds of religious rules do you feel keep which types of behaviors in check? (the ones you see as most important for society)

I'm just curious what you consider, not looking for an argument or debate necessarily.

verylittlemeat··on 'Christianity as default is gone': the rise of a non-Christian Europe
"People can't be free to think for themselves because they'll make stupid decisions"

I know you're not making that argument specifically but that's sort of what it boils down to right? That bad systems which focus their power will win out over good systems which don't. It's like the argument that keeps coming up in the China VS USA threads where people worry about the US because it handicaps itself in science with its regulations and concerns over ethics.

I don't particularly disagree with what you're saying because it feels true but it should be pointed out that it's an awfully nice excuse for people with power to see themselves as benevolent overlords.

verylittlemeat··on Facebook is planning to build a real community with parks, stores and apartments
I wonder if anyone has tried to do a 1:1 mapping of early 20th century robber-barrons and the current 21st century tech gods.

Seems like there would be a lot of aspirational lifestyle overlap.

verylittlemeat··on Researchers Learned to Use Facebook ‘Likes’ to Sway Your Thinking
I think this is an interesting perspective and worth looking into. For example, targeting democrats in 2016 by assuring them that the election is in the bag so they're less likely to show up to vote.

Though I still think it's necessary to fight the temptation to believe such a campaign is as easy or effective as our conspiratorial nature might want us to believe.

verylittlemeat··on Researchers Learned to Use Facebook ‘Likes’ to Sway Your Thinking
FYI I identify and vote as a liberal. Tilting at windmills like facebook/CA feels great for the ego but I'm trying to explain that it has nothing to do with why people vote a certain way. This is all a big sideshow to assuage the tender injury democrats are suffering from a Trump whitehouse.

So if you wish then let the sideshow be spectacular. Let facebook be the scapegoat and social media be regulated. When all of that and a smug attitude does nothing to stop global warming or another conservative president in the future don't be surprised.

verylittlemeat··on Researchers Learned to Use Facebook ‘Likes’ to Sway Your Thinking
I agree with you.

People seem to be equating a political profile and targeted advertising with a brain ray that makes people pull the lever for a funded candidate.

Just to take one high level example: Facebook was still "thefacebook" and closed to the public by the time George W. Bush was elected to the white house for a second term. How can we honestly winkwink/nudgenudge a "stolen election" at the feet of facebook or CA when clearly liberal politics were defeated in 2000/2004 with standard political rhetoric? Why are we giving facebook/CA credit for having so much political power?

I hate to use such a broad lens for the recent incident and I hope I'm communicating what I'm intending to here. I just don't see how somehow this incident "changed everything" or even changed much of anything when you look at the history how campaigns get people to vote for their candidate.

People don't want to hear this but targeted memes didn't make people anti-abortion or pro-nazi or whatever conserative boogey-man you pick. Conservative voters are people not a pathology. You may not like their views or the way they vote but this whole "people who don't think the way I do are brainwashed" thing has to go. You're buying that argument at your own peril because conservatives aren't going anywhere.

verylittlemeat··on China is now home to some of the world’s most powerful supercomputers
Why are you baiting another pointless US vs China nationalism faceoff?

China has had a huge population and economy for decades. Almost by definition they will play an important role in the future of the internet. Anyone who said otherwise was wrong then and is wrong now.

verylittlemeat··on Ex-Facebook insider says covert data harvesting was routine
An analogous example would be if the CA/FB breach had access to private facebook messages or information that was never intended for public consumption.

In the CA/FB case the information was either public (and could be scraped as such) or was collected in the form of facebook apps.

verylittlemeat··on Ex-Facebook insider says covert data harvesting was routine
Based on many of the comments in this thread I don't see how you could say it "sounds like exactly what happened with CA and FB." Debatable maybe. Clear cut, obviously not.

And as for your glib comment on editing the wiki article, you should read more carefully what I said. My argument was that the numerous examples of a breach in that wiki do not fit the CA/FB incident. Adding the incident to the list would do nothing to dispute that point.

verylittlemeat··on Ex-Facebook insider says covert data harvesting was routine
Why would the HIPAA standard of a breach apply here? Scraping public data to create a political profile is on par with getting access to private health data?
verylittlemeat··on Ex-Facebook insider says covert data harvesting was routine
I don't work for facebook. I don't have a facebook. I don't like facebook.

What I do like is honesty.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_breach

Look at this very robust list of data breaches and tell me how the CA/Facebook incident this week looks anything like any of them.

verylittlemeat··on Ex-Facebook insider says covert data harvesting was routine
We all know what a data breach is, calling this a data breach is playing fast and loose with the term.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_breach

Look at all the examples of a data breach in this wiki. The CA/Facebook incident looks nothing like them.

CA either paid facebook to collected data through apps or scraped data from public profiles. Maybe the CA/facebook incident will change what we consider "breach" to mean but right now "unauthorized collection of public data to create a political profile of users" is not a data breach.

verylittlemeat··on Ex-Facebook insider says covert data harvesting was routine
>protected data

What data was being protected? The data was created when the user chose to engage with the facebook apps. CA pays facebook to put something in front of users faces and then CA gets back information on user engagement. How is that different than any other kind of advertising on the web?

We can argue that there needs to be more transparency on facebook but a breach? That's torturing the word.

verylittlemeat··on #deletefacebook
Facebook's raison d'être is to be a reflection of your real life identity. In that way it is unlike all those other social media sites you mentioned. Sure you could use your real identity on those sites but it's not required and many people opt not to and it has no impact on their ability to use the platform.

Let's not throw the baby out with the bathwater here. I know black and white thinking is very appealing but we don't need to go back to living in a yurt in the wilderness just because facebook is a net drain on society. I've been participating on forums all over the internet for the past 20 years and it's been the catalyst for some of the greatest things in my life.

verylittlemeat··on #deletefacebook
Yeah but I get the feeling that current data is worth way more to facebook and data brokers in general than old data. Having data to make projections is nice but being able to experiment in real time with active data is probably the dream facebook is built on.
verylittlemeat··on #deletefacebook
Well think of it this way: all of that data facebook put time, effort and money into collecting from you will become less and less relevant as soon as you delete your account.

I wouldn't be surprised if from facebook's point of view they'd rather collect 1/100th of your data as long as it's current data vs just a bunch of irrelevant old data. Pull the plug.

verylittlemeat··on 50M Facebook profiles harvested for Cambridge Analytica in major data breach
I agree. So why keep up this naive and demonstrably false act that 2016 was the year persuasion and behavioral psychology was put to practical use in politics to manipulate voters.

Every presidential election cycle I can remember was full of rhetoric and outright lies persuade voters. Does no one remember all of the hilariously terrible chain letters from past elections that claimed all sorts of nonsense? I just don't understand why people are running away with this idea that somehow facebook/twitter have changed the game when it comes to brainwashing people to vote conservative.

Politics is and always has been a no holds barred competition where anything goes that isn't straight up illegal. History books praise JFK for utilizing the television in 1960 to win his presidential election. I'm starting to think that if they had today's political climate he would be remembered as a manipulator rather than being savvy.

verylittlemeat··on 50M Facebook profiles harvested for Cambridge Analytica in major data breach
How easily or willfully we forget the past:

3/14/2008

>The Obama campaign's chief strategist is a master of "Astroturfing" and has a second firm that shapes public opinion for corporations

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2008-03-14/the-secre...

verylittlemeat··on Cambridge Analytica Files ‘I created Steve Bannon’s psychological warfare tool’
The Obama campaign's chief strategist is a master of "Astroturfing" and has a second firm that shapes public opinion for corporations

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2008-03-14/the-secre...

>One way the campaign sought to identify the ripest targets was through a series of what the Analyst Institute called “experiment-informed programs,” or EIPs, designed to measure how effective different types of messages were at moving public opinion.

https://www.technologyreview.com/s/508836/how-obama-used-big...

>Among the insights that were shared are the fact the people like conform to social norms, both in their community and their own past behavior. So telling voters that their neighbors have already voted or reminding them about their previous support of a candidate, makes those voters more likely to take action.

https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2012/11/meet-ps...

>The real drivers of an effective social media campaign, however, are based on the psychology of social behaviors not the current technology.

http://mprcenter.org/blog/2013/01/how-obama-won-the-social-m...

← PreviousPage 7 of 12Next →