HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

verylittlemeat

823 karma · joined January 5, 2017

submissionscomments
verylittlemeat··on 50M Facebook profiles harvested for Cambridge Analytica in major data breach
>I guess the other question is why this hasn't been any news yet. But the answer might be that 10 years ago Tech wasn't much in the news because it was just not interesting for most people.

This 100% untrue:

https://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/11/07/how-obamas-interne...

https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2009/10/exclusi...

These are only two links but let me assure you if you're interested google is full of articles from the 2008 election talking about how vital the internet and data was to the Obama strategy.

I very clearly remember these articles and many others at the time talking about the new "big data" strategies utilized in both 2008 and 2012. To me that is what makes this whole "we scraped data and stole the election for trump" narrative seem extremely suspicious.

verylittlemeat··on Cambridge Analytica Files ‘I created Steve Bannon’s psychological warfare tool’
Why do we keep getting these breathless articles about how secret geniuses used social media to "hack" elections? Do we really need a mass conspiracy to explain why large chunks of the population find populist/nationalistic leaders appealing? Motivating voters with this kind of rhetoric predates the internet, in fact it predates the United States.

As mentioned in the comments on the other hacker news post about facebook profiles being scraped by Cambridge Analytica:

1. Obama's 2008 election absolutely bragged about their use of social media to win. I vividly remember multiple long articles in the NYTimes talking about how they exploited new tech to reach voters.

2. During the 2016 election Clinton raised and spent nearly double trump. On top of that most of the money Trump got was towards the end of the election whereas Clinton had huge coffers from day one.

3. I read the guardian article linked and this is one of the few parts that seem to mention what exactly this "hacker" strategy was at Cambridge Analytica

>“And then I came across a paper about how personality traits could be a precursor to political behaviour, and it suddenly made sense. Liberalism is correlated with high openness and low conscientiousness, and when you think of Lib Dems they’re absent-minded professors and hippies. They’re the early adopters… they’re highly open to new ideas. And it just clicked all of a sudden.”

This is the insight that that apparently is being called a "psychological warfare tool?" You're telling me that Clinton's campaign didn't have sociologists and psychologists who were absolutely obsessed with exactly the same advertising criteria? This kind of psychological profiling is the kind of stuff you learn about in 101 classes at university. For the past 80 years (that I as a lay person know of, probably longer) people have spent their entire careers analyzing and applying propaganda and marketing to political campaigns. Why should anyone believe based on what's being presented in this article that not only was none of this stuff done before but that it somehow handed Trump one of the greatest election upsets in American history? The mental gymnastics people are going through to deny the fact that yes, many voters have conservative values, is getting out of hand.

verylittlemeat··on At My Lai: The Photographer Who Captured the Massacre
You would be surprised. Some of the most terrible people in the Nazi concentration camps were fellow prisoners tasked with being Kapos (prisoner overseers). The Kapos were spared some of the worst labor but in exchange had to show extreme brutality to the prisoners they oversaw so the Nazis wouldn't question their effectiveness.

This isn't the only example: Stanford prison experiment and the Milgram experiment. I'm sure there are others. When you value being alive many people will do anything to survive.

verylittlemeat··on At My Lai: The Photographer Who Captured the Massacre
During the Vietnam war that is what happened. Soldiers were treated like baby killers upon returning to the US.

There was a sort of rebranding of the American solider after that catastrophe. The American citizen is now supposed to see the American solider as a utilitarian third party cog in a system where soldiers don't make decisions they just execute them. So if you're unhappy with the war you take out your disapproval on the government not the lowly soldier who is "just doing their job/just following orders" etc.

Obviously this is very ethically questionable but I'd say it's the standard attitude towards the American soldier in my experience (in group social settings with ex-military people). The military is simply the hammer, the will of the people and politics. The hammer only acts when the hand picks it up hence we're supposed to hold the hand (government) accountable not the hammer (military).

verylittlemeat··on At My Lai: The Photographer Who Captured the Massacre
>I went through the US educational system and while we know about the Vietnam war, the protesters, this is definitely not the picture of the war that we were given.

I just want to be one anecdotal voice to disagree with this statement. I went to a city university and my American history class 1945-present included a curriculum with media such as:

A People's History of the United States

The Fog of War (documentary)

Hearts and Minds (documentary)

Last Night I Dreamed of Peace: The Diary of Dang Thuy Tram

Gary R. Hess, Vietnam: Explaining America's Lost War.

Nick Turse. Kill Anything that Moves: The Real American War in Vietnam.

I know some of my friends took courses where the Vietnam War was referred to pejoratively as the American War. We learned about My Lai in high school even. Where did you go to school that the Vietnam War was glossed over in such a pro-American way? Maybe it's a regional thing? I was educated on the east coast.

verylittlemeat··on The Coffee Cannabis Connection
Feels good, tastes good, is good. Can't fight with that.
verylittlemeat··on A billion reasons never to buy IBM services
I've spent time in countries all over the world and my experience was not like yours at all. There were so many more important factors in guessing a foreigners personality than what their nationality/ethnicity was. What is their education level? What is their occupation? What is their economic background? If you want to stereotype then those were much better questions to ask than "chinese, japanese or korean."

Now if you want to argue that certain countries produce way more of one socio-economic class than another and that you're more likely to be exposed to people raised in that culture then maybe I can agree. But to just say, for example, all Nigerians are loud mouthed tricksters? No I don't agree with that kind of stereotyping.

verylittlemeat··on Wikimedia director on commercial use of Wikipedia
I agree with you that what youtube is doing now is not censorship by any standard definition and I don't think it's a bad thing. You might be able to argue that it's a form of "positive censorship" in the sense that a wiki on a video would be a scarlet letter but even that seems like very weak censorship.

I included the example of copycat attacks to show good faith that I'm not ignoring examples I know of that counter my own argument. What I'm trying to understand is the role of radicalization and conspiracy in violent acts. We know there are large communities of radical conspiracy theorists and yet physical violence or violent harassment is only a small subset of that community. How safely can we presume that "radical media" is the main cause of the latter violent groups? It's definitely an appealing narrative to imagine these people groom and reinforce their own beliefs until they "boil over" into violence but is that really how it works? We act as though people can be almost brainwashed into doing terrible things just by mere exposure. I'm arguing that at the very least it's more complicated than that and we should inject a little bit of nuance into the rhetoric of what conspiracy theories mean for society.

verylittlemeat··on Wikimedia director on commercial use of Wikipedia
>I am relatively confident that there is good evidence to support the claim that an individual being increasingly surrounded by media espousing a radical or fringe belief is correlated with that individual becoming increasingly radical.

I get where you're coming from but I have some issues with that perspective. Would you agree that a conspiracy theorist who uses physical violence and/or threats of physical violence is strong indicator of a dangerously radicalized person? Then how can we explain the large number of people exposed to radical media but only a small handful performing radical violence? Are conspiracies and radical beliefs always some kind of treadmill where you take a nibble and then inevitably go deeper and deeper until you become so delusional that you feel the need to take violent action? To me that feels too much like a just-so narrative.

Also, I think we should be concerned about what some people consider "radicalization." Everyone is against radical violence and media that contributes to that end. But what about media that makes someone a Trump voter? Rhetorically some argue that they are just as dangerous as any shooter because they create a social environment that precipitates violence, even though the causation isn't direct.

It's difficult to talk about these things without coming up with false dichotomies or bad generalizations. Really what I'm trying to get at is a "throwing the baby out with the bathwater" understanding. It's easy to get rid of the baby when it's not your baby or the baby is casually stereotyped in an appealing way.

verylittlemeat··on Wikimedia director on commercial use of Wikipedia
I watched about 3/4ths of that conspiracy video for fun and I don't even get it being restricted under "hate speech." There are parts that are obviously either untrue or exaggerations but the whole thesis of the video is "american fascists are behind everything and world war II was invented to be a profitable enterprise for industry captains."
verylittlemeat··on Wikimedia director on commercial use of Wikipedia
I have a controversial and maybe stupid question that is probably unanswerable one way or the other.

If you're going to murder your parents over a conspiracy theory is there any reason to assume you wouldn't murder them for a dozen other reasons? How justified is censoring a platform for millions of users because of one mentally ill user?

Is there any evidence that being exposed to certain ideas "pushes someone over the edge" any more than what they can come up with in their own head or without technological assistance? I've read some stuff about school shootings that suggests media coverage encourages "copycat" attacks.

I'm not just trying to be a contrarian or apologist for a murderer but the causation here seems rhetorically appealing but realistically sketchy to me. People have been killing each other over politics since as long as recorded history.

verylittlemeat··on Wikimedia director on commercial use of Wikipedia
Maybe youtube is unhappy with their current solutions?

Some videos* are already walled up behind warnings and disabled features.

* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U1Qt6a-vaNM

verylittlemeat··on Why do entrepreneurs engage in self-sabotage?
They probably know they're acting crazy and don't care because they believe that's part of the ethos of being a founder, to be outrageous and misunderstood.

I'm sure for many of them being despised or criticized is just as much a benchmark of success as anything else.

It's sort of similar to the "there's no such thing as bad press" but more personality based.

verylittlemeat··on Reddit and the Struggle to Detoxify the Internet
Why not just engage in conversations on the principle of charity and good faith. There's also the concept of steel manning other peoples arguments to help extend good faith.

Not every conversation has to become a burned bridges and salt the earth affair. If the other person is just trying to "win" then disengage from the argument. If the other person is arguing with you in good faith then maybe you're wrong or have something to learn from a new perspective.

verylittlemeat··on How Your Returns Are Used Against You at Best Buy, Other Retailers
Running a business on the assumption that customers will share your morals and ethics is a recipe for failure
verylittlemeat··on Reddit and the Struggle to Detoxify the Internet
just fyi I enjoyed your comment and anecdote but the word you're looking for is "segue" not "segway."
verylittlemeat··on Reddit and the Struggle to Detoxify the Internet
I think emotional maturity is more important than critical thinking. People in our culture have this life or death anxiety over being right, especially in social groups. You see it all the time on social media. Person 1 makes a throwaway facebook post which contains some kind of factual error. Person 2 points this out. Person 1 feels personally attacked and becomes emotionally invested in "winning." The more pushback person 1 gets the more stand their ground and will scorch the earth to save face. Where is all this intellectual insecurity coming from?
verylittlemeat··on Reddit and the Struggle to Detoxify the Internet
One more opinion for heap?

People are too sensitive about seeing their snowflake opinions validated. Upvote and downvote do not map to right and wrong. What makes an opinion popular has as much to do with rhetoric and appealing to a million fallacies as it does to facts or logic. This is human nature, not an inherent problem with the internet.

verylittlemeat··on Reddit and the Struggle to Detoxify the Internet
In the past month I've had 2 comments accuse me of being a Russian bot or a shill on hacker news. People really do just see what they want to see.
verylittlemeat··on Reddit and the Struggle to Detoxify the Internet
- moral panic over video games in the news again

- florida legislature declares porn a health risk rather than debate guns after school shooting

verylittlemeat··on Coronary heart disease is a chronic inflammatory condition
Talking about nutrition on the internet is nearly impossible because diets encourage cult followings and attitudes.

Benford's law strikes again: Passion is inversely proportional to the amount of real information available

verylittlemeat··on How to write an IRC bot
bitchx
verylittlemeat··on Volkswagen will kill the Beetle, squashes plans for a successor
I just want to add to this that many older people with hip issues really appreciate higher sitting positions. Might not be market-making but I'm sure it's a factor in many purchases
verylittlemeat··on Fitter, happier, and other fantasies of modern life
Not to be flippant but try introspection.

Why do you believe or desire the things you do? Be honest with yourself and try to keep in mind at all times the role of moral/social pressure. Think about history and the different forms of status and normality that came before.

Go ahead and read books by great thinkers but don't let that be everything. The most valuable form of learning is when you can untether yourself from appeals to authority in conversation and speak intelligently about your own conclusions.

verylittlemeat··on Fordlandia
Captains of industry who liked to play simcity in real life were not unusual for the time. One of the worst strikes in American history started over "company town" issues.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pullman_Strike

This is really the ongoing story of organized labor vs their corporate overlords. If you want to see real interviews and video from what living in company town with secret police is like check out the documentary Harlan County, USA.

verylittlemeat··on Pixar's Rules of Storytelling (2013)
Movies are escapism.
verylittlemeat··on Austerity and the rise of the Nazi party [pdf]
RE: Austerity and economic analysis in general

>How Seriously Should We Take Economics?

>Economics is a science—it proceeds via hypothesis and empirical testing—but it’s a soft and squishy one, and any argument to the contrary should be treated with great suspicion. Especially in macroeconomics, hard-and-fast laws are hard to find. So are stable parameters and reliable empirical studies. Often, about the best we can do is isolate general tendencies, and then look carefully to see whether they apply in the case under consideration.[0]

[0]https://www.newyorker.com/news/john-cassidy/the-reinhart-and...

I encourage anyone interested in austerity to read this article. It's relatively short and insightful.

verylittlemeat··on Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison
It certainly doesn't help. A web designer wouldn't like being told by a lawyer what their job entails either.

When you're dealing with professional egos sometimes it pays to tread lightly. Shkreli learned this the hard way.

verylittlemeat··on Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison
I think you're going for the low hanging fruit by judging HN that way. The more interesting thing is that the majority of comments are shocked by the 7 year sentence rather than the minority who think he was "an ok guy."

I keep seeing this naive understanding of the law over and over again in tech circles. The justice system is made up of several people with a ton of leeway on how laws are applied. The letter of the law is just a small part of what "illegal" means. Being clever or cute about only breaking the spirit of the law will not save you in court, in fact many times trying to only break the spirit is what will get you convicted on the letter of the law. I hate to say it but I think Aaron Schwartz fell victim to this fallacy and in recent memory so did those flight sim guys who put a keylogger in pirated software.

I've spent a lot of time around lawyers and judges and I can tell you they have absolutely no tolerance for the kind of "well, actually" smart-asses that the tech community excels at churning out.

edit: I just want to add this exchange from the movie Blow which I think really sums up how I feel about the whole thing.

>Judge: George Jung, you stand accused of possession of six hundred and sixty pounds of marijuana with intent to distribute. How do you plead?

>George: Your honor, I'd like to say a few words to the court if I may.

>Judge: Well, you're gonna have to stop slouching and stand up to address this court, sir.

>George: [stands] Alright. Well, in all honesty, I don't feel that what I've done is a crime. And I think it's illogical and irresponsible for you to sentence me to prison. Because, when you think about it, what did I really do? I crossed an imaginary line with a bunch of plants. I mean, you say I'm an outlaw, you say I'm a thief, but where's the Christmas dinner for the people on relief? Huh? You say you're looking for someone who's never weak but always strong, to gather flowers constantly whether you are right or wrong, someone to open each and every door, but it ain't me, babe, huh? No, no, no, it ain't me, babe. It ain't me you're looking for, babe. You follow?

>Judge: Yeah... Gosh, you know, your concepts are really interesting, Mister Jung.

>George: Thank you.

>Judge: Unfortunately for you, the line you crossed was real and the plants you brought with you were illegal, so your bail is twenty thousand dollars.

verylittlemeat··on What is Money? (1913)
I don't quite see your point both of those pieces of legislation were repealed 3+ decades ago.
← PreviousPage 8 of 12Next →