Then again, neither are American conservatives anything like Burkean conservatives.
16,839 karma · joined September 9, 2013
Then again, neither are American conservatives anything like Burkean conservatives.
This is assuming that substitution effects invariably or above sufficient thresholds dominate over income effects, which in the case of addiction is a dubious proposition.
EDIT: Appears to be a component of a larger "Prismriver" project, but still completely tentative.
Bill Mitchell's economics frequently take a backseat to his rabid quasi-conspiratorial rantings about the neoliberal order that are in turn instrumental to influencing his economics, unfortunately. James K. Galbraith is far less erudite than his father, who was actually a decent institutional economist, if disagreeable. Abba P. Lerner was a great economist, but his functional finance proposal proved theoretically untenable in light of public choice critiques and has yet to practically materialize anyway. He was also against unions, interestingly enough, in his famous paper "Money as a Creature of the State".
I'd overall rank MMTers are some of the lowest quality of the heterodox, honestly. The circuitists like Marc Lavoie are much better out of the broader Post-Keynesian school.
The primary standards of international trade during the mercantilist and merchant capitalist eras were silver bullion coins like the Spanish dollar.
Formal gold specie standards arose during the 19th century by royal fiat and soon displaced other currencies.
It is likely that free currencies would settle on precious metal convertibility because of prior art, but there's no reason to presume it has to be gold in particular, or to single out gold as being "special".
I'd be wary of the chartalist/state theory of money, since it's somewhat of a truism (state theory of money is correct for money chartered by the state). It tends to ignore that many local currencies have also emerged through different channels.
MMT as promoted by Mosler, Wray, Kelton and Tcherneva is also a syncretic and often uncredited mix of a variety of economic ideas, generally as a clout for the policy activism that its founders promote.
The gold standard was turned off far earlier than 1971. In fact, all commodity money standards have suffered subversion or suspension by financial institutions (suspending convertibility of notes) and governments at various times. Nor was gold arrived at by the will of market forces. It was imposed through bank charter, displacing the then-dominant silver in the process. Nor was the international gold standard well designed, for R.G. Hawtrey and Gustav Cassel presciently anticipated its collapse and resulting great depression thereof.
Monetary reform is definitely in order, but commodity money has nothing to do with it. Convertibility requirements can be satisfied with interbank clearinghouses and other means.
While demand is always applicable, production costs often dominate in more vertically integrated firms and there are large lags in adjusting to signals.
There was a time when the labor movement was strong, Eugene V. Debs was a serious presidential candidate (even being pardoned by the then-POTUS Warren G. Harding over his sedition charge) and radical syndicalists like the IWW were influential.
These proclivities were largely staved off through sleights of hand like Wilson's New Freedom and later the New Deal, which appeared to achieve socialistic ends, but largely through statist and corporatist means that didn't pose much of a threat to the establishment. An interesting example is that the National Recovery Administration part of the First New Deal was originally proposed by the then-president of General Electric, Gerard Swope.
Thus they are not so productive as they are symbiotic with the state. Tax laws are a complete red herring, serving mostly as a public show to incite people about whether or not someone is paying their "fair share," even though nominal balances are generally frictionless in absence of velocity of spending. Poor people have lower wealth elasticities of demand and will always bear the most burden from taxation.
Rothbard is much more lucid than Rand.
Upstart is much more readable even though it has various idiosyncrasies.
That said, I would be very wary of jumping to such endeavors simply because a particular branch of mathematics appears to supply a useful vernacular for a particular economic problem. More often than not, it leads to a situation where instead of offering new perspectives on problems, you simply repeat the same Walrasian equilibrium analysis or whatever orthodoxy, but in a more pompous language.
In fact, by far the most mind-bending and mentally invigorating economists have been those who have almost no mathematical analysis whatsoever. These include, for instance, GLS Shackle and Ludwig M. Lachmann. Their entirely verbal analyses has expanded understanding of real-world economic phenomena far more than papers on game theory, I'd argue.
Mathematical economics like the Solow-Swan growth model, Cobb-Douglas production functions, Walrasian auctioneer markets and Paretian static equilibrium models have sowed great confusion and unrealistic assumptions as much as they may have enlightened. A lot of misunderstandings on economic policy originate from taking comparative statics models too literally.
That said, there might be some use of theoretical CS. I've had the impression that process algebras like Hoare's CSP for modeling concurrency can be used for some microfoundations and thought experiments. I don't think any economist has done this yet.
Again, I don't see how the New Deal can be couched in such heroic terms. The principal influences for the New Deal were Foster and Catchings, who looked it at from the lens of economic output.
Theory of the firm has many variants. Coasian, Alchian, evolutionary, etc. Again, what type of neoclassicism? What is neoliberalism, anyway? [1] It's used as a snarl term rather than a particular set of ideological convictions. I've seen it used to describe various forms of economic liberalism, but also more esoteric Foucaltian analyses.
The Golden Age of Capitalism was still a time of imperialism (Truman Doctrine in effect), one of seven times less regulation than today (as measured by size of the Federal Register) and all sorts of other statuses that are nowadays attributed as being unique to neoliberalism. There was no sudden "jump" in the 1970s, it's been an ongoing process since mercantilism.
The purpose of the New Deal was not empowerment, but emergency restructuring. Some of the initial programs (AAA, NRA) were deemed unconstitutional and it was built into a corporatist model for maximum expediency. There weren't any McJobs in the 30s, and the New Deal was certainly not about "decent benefits and pay". Nor would a contemporary minimum wage JG be.
Marshallian analysis was not a purely comparative static approach. It did allow for dynamism and fluctuations as actors converged between states. That Keynes spoke of homogeneous investment functions and "marginal efficiency of capital" shows that he was still rooted in that tradition.
You're moving the goalposts, though. IS-LM is still his.
Granted, issuing currency is not a magical bullet for misallocations in real capital. Though it just might speed up the process of finding new complementary uses of it. Political constraints like being vetoed by a higher authority still exist.
That said, Marxian economists have evolved significantly and a lot of them have since converted to some form of Post-Keynesianism.
Certainly some systemic cooperation would be in order to maintain reflux, but it's more reliable than deposit insurance when people's equity is at stake.
Social safety nets can be ensured from a myriad of techniques.
The Bolsheviks never tried decentralization. Quite the contrary, they were all devoted to having a single top-down vanguard force the program on the citizenry. They nearly destroyed their country between 1918-1921 with their policy of "war communism" and had to introduce capitalist reforms in the NEP just so the peasantry didn't starve to death. Their doctrine of international revolution was a separate idea altogether.
Also, how does relinquishing monetary monopoly mean you have to retire the army? They're two completely orthogonal things.
OWS was a joke from the start. It had no identifiable goals to speak of.
Actually Hayek himself was somewhat confused on the subject. He didn't favor free banking. Lawrence H. White later wrote a paper in 1999 entitled "Why Didn't Hayek Favor Laissez Faire in Banking?" that clears up some misconceptions.
Your definition of "currency" is too narrow, though. It includes much more than monetary certificates for bank deposits. See the history of local currencies, Silvio Gesell's Freiwirtschaft, etc.
Even within a free banking system, there would be inherent limitations in that banks would have to adjust their reserves so as to make full use of their lending capacity and profit on interest, because of the clearinghouse mechanism acting as a reflux. You're aware of the free banking theories of Selgin, White and Dowd, I presume.
Once you extend "currency" to being much more than bank money, though, I think your concerns become severely diminished.
Monetary policy is one of the main reasons. Instead of letting a secular deflation emerge with growths in total factor productivity, central banks still do price level stabilization instead. The monetary disequilibrium economists have written much on this. George Selgin has a great and relatively accessible essay called Less Than Zero that discusses this.
No one in modern economic theory belieces the Marshallian tradition is identical to modern neoclassicism - never mind neoliberalism.
But there is no single "modern neoclassicism," that's the point. Yet to somehow deny that Marshall was a neoclassical is to make the term meaningless. The approaches of Marshall, Menger, Walras and others all had important differences despite being ultimately lumped as "neoclassical".
Neoliberalism isn't even an economic idea. It's a political term used by people opposed to it to describe what they perceive as a shift into corporate rule since the 1970s. Yet this narrative is full of holes, not least of which is the history of mercantilism, imperialism and later corporation-state cooperation. I'll be writing a book on this subject at some point.