HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

viczsaszbo

20 karma · joined October 21, 2021

submissionscomments
viczsaszbo··on Starlink Aviation
SpaceX pays for service of ~14k terminals out of 25k and wartime service uses a lot more resources than regular business or residential grade.

https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1582523481345835008

viczsaszbo··on Musk’s SpaceX says it can no longer pay for satellite services in Ukraine
$4,500/month is a bit less than Starlink maritime at $5,000/month. I can't imagine it's cheap to provide the support needed for a warzone. There aren't any similar services with public numbers to compare this cost to that are in an active warzone.
viczsaszbo··on Modeling Starlink Capacity
The beam hopping (TDM) part of the article is similar to satellite handover. There's a lag before a beam returns to a location or a new beam is over a location, and the beams can't overlap (nco=1).
viczsaszbo··on U.S. paying millions to send Starlink to Ukraine, contrary to SpaceX claims
Well Shotwell said on on March 22nd France and Poland donated, but the US didn't. Several days later on April 5th USAID announced a US government deal, so she was right at the time. The headline is extremely deceptive. Wapo is owned by Bezos who's building a Starlink competitor, Amazon Kuiper, that stands to gain from bad press about the competition.
viczsaszbo··on Starlink now over 1M user terminals manufactured
They are at 700k subscribers according to an interview.

https://www.lemonde.fr/economie/article/2022/09/12/internet-...

viczsaszbo··on Starlink now over 1M user terminals manufactured
On the light pollution point, twilight is the worst time for satellite brightness, but as the satellites enter the Earth's shadow their brightness rapidly diminishes. Some estimates are 10%-30% data loss during twilight for Vera Rubin observatory and 2% for vlt. A problem for Vera Rubin, but not so much for other observatories.

https://www.economist.com/international/2021/11/25/vast-sate...

https://www.economist.com/img/b/640/356/90/sites/default/fil...

viczsaszbo··on Globalstar SEC filing, Apple to use 85% of its satellite network capacity
The speeds Starlink will deliver are 2G speeds/device. They said 2-4Mbps/cell, and a cell is a wide area. I think it will have continuous coverage once the constellation reaches a certain size. AST SpaceMobile is planning 4g or 5g speeds/device with their 40 Gbps capable satellites.
viczsaszbo··on Starlink Could Be an Ecological Disaster
A study was done on alumina in the atmosphere and 5,000 tons/yr doesn't seem dangerous. The study notes that because of the 3.8 g cm−3 density it falls quickly compared to other particles. The density is much higher than the chlorofluorocarbons that stick around and damage the ozone layer. It assumes ~4,000,000 tons/year that causes 3.7% ozone depletion. 5,000 tons/year might have effects, but it doesn't look like a show stopper in terms of cooling and ozone depletion. Hard to draw firm conclusion since they studied a purposeful geoengineering plan, but it doesn't add up with a sanity check.

https://acp.copernicus.org/articles/15/11835/2015/acp-15-118...

viczsaszbo··on Satellite images of damage done to Saki airfield in Crimea
And of course their MoD claiming in this attack "Aviation equipment at the airfield was not damaged" when satellite images show they've lost multiple aircraft. On the small scale, they've been caught moving the wreckage of a Brimstone missile from months ago to new location and claiming another missile was faulty when it had the same serial number/scratches as the old one.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vJVfddkn5M4

viczsaszbo··on SpaceX’s monstrous, dirt-cheap Starship may transform space travel
It's deceptive to compare the two since the shuttle really is good almost exclusively for ISS missions, Hubble repair, etc (unique Canadarm capability) while F9 is the cheapest there is for Satellite launches at $2,720/kg. It isn't so great to require a crew for a satellite launch. The shuttle can only stay docked to the ISS for about 14 days while crew dragon can stay for over 180 days.
viczsaszbo··on 15 of 23 Monkeys with Elon Musk’s Neuralink Brain Chips Reportedly Died
The report is about research done 3 years before the Neuralink pig demo.

[0] https://www.dropbox.com/s/y1htsprat2iup04/2022-02-10%20PCRM%...

viczsaszbo··on Starlink lost 40 satellites to a geomagnetic storm
Both those videos use wildly wrong numbers. There are no plans to use F9 for the entire constellation. SpaceX told the FCC they will use Starship (launch 200-400 sats at once) for the gen 2 constellation, which is 30k satellites. Thunderf00t uses AWS data transfer cost instead of actual backhaul costs. Average household uses 435GB/month and that is $52/year in backhaul cost using .01 per GB. His $10bil/year backhaul numbers imply they have 191mil subscribers to get to that cost... There are a bunch of other issues, but it's too tedious to go through it.

Someone did a write-up on all the problems with the CSS video.

https://littlebluena.substack.com/p/common-sense-skeptic-deb...

viczsaszbo··on Starlink Premium
Premium is 20-40Mbps and regular is 10-20Mpbs. https://www.starlink.com/account/legal/documents/DOC-1002-69...
viczsaszbo··on Starlink satellites hindering detection of near-Earth asteroids, study finds
Actually, it is. It's expected to launch around Q2 2022. The NEPA FAA PEA is going to be decided upon on February 28th then if they get the greenlight a launch attempt will happen a couple months after that. For commercial launches, they are targeting 2023. Even if Starship gets delayed to 2023-24 it will still play a big roll in getting Starlink satellites up since they haven't started launching the gen 2 constellation yet.
viczsaszbo··on Starlink satellites hindering detection of near-Earth asteroids, study finds
Right now nobody claims it's making money. Musk himself said gen 1 is "financially weak". They have 600k+ preorders and geo satellite people are very happy with it, which is a couple million users mostly in the US just from that. With 400 satellites per launch using Starship, Starlink looks much better financially. They plan on starting to launch Starship with Starlink this year. This reasonable analysis says about 3mil subscribers are needed without factoring in Starship.

https://littlebluena.substack.com/p/common-sense-skeptic-deb...

viczsaszbo··on As SpaceX plans a natural gas plant, environmental concerns take a backseat
The author says they don't mind rocket emissions. The problem is with the 250MW power plant that is allegedly being added to the PEA without many details and incorrect emission numbers. No mention of a gas pipeline even though that is required to run a 250MW plant.