HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vigilantpuma

289 karma · joined January 3, 2018

submissionscomments
vigilantpuma··on The Mythical Man-Month in the Age of AI
Applying judgment is much harder when the amount of stuff that theoretically needs judgment is not actually processable by humans. I don’t want to throw my hands up and give up but I honestly haven’t found a middle ground that works.
vigilantpuma··on Microsoft offers mass buyouts for roughly a quarter of its workforce
Isn’t it odd to feel excluded when a female speaker addresses a group of women as “guys?” Whom is she including, if it excludes women?
vigilantpuma··on Microsoft offers mass buyouts for roughly a quarter of its workforce
I’m lumping you in with a broader movement, it’s true, but I think it’s disingenuous to pretend like no one out there is trying to eradicate “guys.” Maybe you personally aren’t, but a lot of people are agitating for not using it preemptively because you might make someone feel excluded etc.

What do you think of the scenario in which you ask someone to stop using “guys” when you’re around, and they comply but think less of you going forward?

vigilantpuma··on Microsoft offers mass buyouts for roughly a quarter of its workforce
Yeah, there are no efforts to curtail freedom of speech and get people to obsessively self-police in China.
vigilantpuma··on Microsoft offers mass buyouts for roughly a quarter of its workforce
I have not been able to bring myself to use y’all, it just seems so fake and performative. I am not a southerner, why am I y’alling people?
vigilantpuma··on Microsoft offers mass buyouts for roughly a quarter of its workforce
> I think if you want people to give you the grace to form your own opinions of others, you need to be comfortable with us forming an opinion of you.

This is both trivially true (I recognize that everyone has the right to form their own opinions of everything) and still counter to things I assume you believe (such as: people shouldn’t make assumptions about others based on their gender or skin color).

I do want you to think differently. I want you to think that people who continue to use a phrase widely considered to be gender neutral are not in fact your enemies. Some of them probably are your allies.

For what it’s worth, if I knew you in real life and you made that preference known to me, I would try to respect it, but that respect would depend on the closeness of our relationship. It’s hard to remember every preference of someone you meet once every two months, but I don’t like to be an asshole and try to respect the preferences of people I interact with.

The problem though is that somewhere along the line, continuing to use “you guys” became a sort of reverse shibboleth among a certain set of people who try to use things like whether someone uses “you guys” or whether they have their pronouns set on their profile to determine whether they are allies or, presumably, enemies. And yeah, I do object to that sort of mindset.

vigilantpuma··on Microsoft offers mass buyouts for roughly a quarter of its workforce
I would be concerned that if I ask them to take a bunch of small steps they will marvel at my chutzpah for asking them to take a big one.
vigilantpuma··on CorridorKey 2.0
What a dystopian view.

For what it’s worth, there have famous actors for literally thousands of years. As to “nothing but puppets,” the idea that actors bring nothing to the table and everything is just down to the director seems like a very self-aggrandizing thing to believe if you’re a director.

vigilantpuma··on Microsoft offers mass buyouts for roughly a quarter of its workforce
I think pursuing things like the eradication of an expression that is genuinely considered gender neutral by large swaths of people is the sort of thing that loses you goodwill for the big stuff.

I’m sorry that you find it exclusionary. What I find exclusionary is people telling me that it’s justifiable to think less of me for using that term, or comparing continuing to use the term to their grandmother who still uses the N word.

For what it’s worth I have stopped using “you guys” at work except for in “safe spaces” because I don’t want to deal with this sort of judgement. But I find the “it costs you nothing!” defense of word policing to be completely unconvincing.

vigilantpuma··on Microsoft offers mass buyouts for roughly a quarter of its workforce
This really feels like splitting hairs.

As a woman in this industry, being told that using “guys” to address mixed groups is non-inclusive/insufficiently considerate/worth thinking less of me for (just wow) is much worse than being addressed by “guys” when I’m in a mixed group.

Like… we have real problems with equality in tech, right?

vigilantpuma··on Microsoft offers mass buyouts for roughly a quarter of its workforce
“I wish I had spent more time on my business” is totally different from “my work gives me a sense of purpose and makes me feel like I’m contributing.”
vigilantpuma··on Microsoft offers mass buyouts for roughly a quarter of its workforce
There’s a difference between feedback regarding your work and language policing something like “you guys” which some people have just suddenly decided is offensive as of 2016 or so because I guess we’ve already solved the rest of sexism.
vigilantpuma··on What Adobe v ArtCraft teaches us
So many times you see reporting on a round of layoffs and it quotes the CEO saying “I take responsibility.” But… how? It seems like the actual responsibility is being borne by the people who just lost their livelihood. What exactly is this definition of responsibility where you experience no negative effects whatsoever?
vigilantpuma··on We should be more ambitious with the software we build
That’s pretty nonspecific.

I’m not trying to be contrary, just that doesn’t say a lot.

vigilantpuma··on We should be more ambitious with the software we build
Yeah, I can never get in the zone with LLMs either. It’s like operating in constant interruption mode. And I always thought I was good at multitasking (even though I know formally it’s an illusion)
vigilantpuma··on We should be more ambitious with the software we build
What are you doing?
vigilantpuma··on The Importance of Limitations for Creativity and Learning (2023)
Are there any games that are not “walled” games?
vigilantpuma··on Diablo 2 Survivors
Eh, maybe, maybe not. We’re obviously past the age of “everyone tunes in to see Friends at 7 o’clock on Wednesday” or whatever, but humans tend to share things they like within their networks.
vigilantpuma··on Blood cells from 80-year-old donor become stem cells with molecular age under 20
I’d be pissed as I was dying if it seemed like we were on the cusp!
vigilantpuma··on Kevin Kelly's 2016 AI Predictions, 10 Years Later
> But I just realised English letter frequencies have 54 % of the probability mass in the first half of the alphabet

But what about English first-letter-of-the-word frequencies?

Edit: asked ChatGPT to analyze this for me. Without verifying its work, looks like ~60% of English words (taken as a list of unique words) start with a letter in the first half of the alphabet, but if you look at a corpus of writing, it’s closer to 51%.

vigilantpuma··on I would like the value of my home to rise, while my property taxes fall
PP literally says “I just don't see how people go like "My house needs to sell for more than I bought it for years from now"” That is basically not understanding why people expect the number to be bigger.
vigilantpuma··on I would like the value of my home to rise, while my property taxes fall
Is “inflation” not a valid answer? Or at least component of an answer?
vigilantpuma··on The value of not getting to the point (2015)
Why do you assume the person you’re responding to has kids?
vigilantpuma··on The value of not getting to the point (2015)
That’s funny. For me, when I eat with others who talk about food, I feel like I’ve found my people. But I love food! Cooking it, seeking out outstanding examples of it, reading about it. I’m guessing you don’t?
vigilantpuma··on The dawn of the age of the exoskeleton
Ideally they would enable an elderly person to no longer need a stairlift.
vigilantpuma··on The value of not getting to the point (2015)
If you have kids, you’ll probably be happy that they want to talk to you for 30 minutes as freshmen in college!

The only real surprise here is that this was the author’s first experience of such a thing.

vigilantpuma··on The dawn of the age of the exoskeleton
Definitely right now. But maybe with time and next (or next-next) gen materials, it’ll become more viable.
vigilantpuma··on The dawn of the age of the exoskeleton
Ha, to some degree couldn’t we all? But assuming you can negotiate a flight of steps and stand up from the dining table without trouble, your benefit strikes me as less pressing than, say, that of my mother-in-law.
vigilantpuma··on The dawn of the age of the exoskeleton
Industrial and military applications are one thing, but I’ve often wondered if exoskeletons would someday become a viable mechanism for helping older people continue to be able to navigate their environment. Maybe it’s something we’ll see in our lifetimes?
vigilantpuma··on How Singapore's government-run dating service works
> Are you saying women can't understand the basic arithmetic of demographics relationship pairing, on their own? That they don't understand they can't all realistically settle down with the top % of men, if they don't want to end up alone?

No, that’s what you were saying and I was responding to that. I’m genuinely baffled at this response. Did you lose context? Do you really think I am saying that? Are you unfamiliar with sarcasm, or do you assume everyone being sarcastic always labels it with /s? Genuine question because I thought my meaning was pretty clear.

Similarly with the other point you quoted (out of context). Yes, women are happier living by themselves than with men who feel only contempt for women. The worst thing in life is not to end up alone, it’s not ending up selected out of the gene pool, the worst thing in life is to end up chained to a bad partner.

By the way I did chatGPT your claims and, unsurprisingly, they range in accuracy and substantiation. The claim about childless women over 40 being particularly unhappy is especially badly substantiated (particularly since it mixes those who are willingly childless with those who wanted children but couldn’t have them). In fact, older men who are childless seem to be unhappier than older women who are childless.

It’s interesting to see the narrative in men’s spaces about how dumb women are and how they’re going to end up dying alone surrounded by cats and how the men pushing this narrative don’t realize how supremely unattractive this makes them to women.

I don’t know if you’re capable of actually hearing this, but I will repeat it for you again. Talking about women like they’re idiots and expressing this kind of contempt towards them makes you supremely unattractive to women. And yes, they absolutely can tell that this is what you think, no matter how well you think you hide it in person. I hope that, if not today, then maybe a year from now or five years from now, you will sit with yourself and really consider that idea.

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →