HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vishnumohandas

2,085 karma · joined November 23, 2016

v [at] vishnu.tech
submissionscomments
vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Hey, we do support the use cases you mentioned!

1. Album collaboration: https://ente.io/blog/collaborative-albums/

2. Photo collection: https://ente.io/blog/collect-photos/

Please let me know if I missed something. Sharing is an important feature for all of us, and we would love to get it right.

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Thanks for checking us out!

We currently keep 2 versions of a photo - one the original, and the other a downscaled copy to be rendered as the thumbnail.

Unlike non-e2ee providers, we cannot transcode and serve optimised images on the fly, when it's faster to downscale than serve the original image over network.

What we could do is

1. Intelligently preload original photos when their thumbnails are in scope

2. Store an extra version of the photo, whose resolution is between that of the thumbnail and the original, and perform #1 over those

Sorry about the flicker, will fix it.

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Filen is perhaps cheaper because they are storing lesser replicas. It is not financially feasible to provide 3 replicas at their price points, unless they're running their own storage infrastructure, which doesn't seem to be the case.

Now Ente could of course choose to keep lesser replicas and offer "lite" plans that are more affordable. But we would rather not complicate our pricing structure right now. Understanding buckets of GBs is hard enough, and adding tiers on top would worsen the experience for most.

All of that said, Filen does seem like a really cool project for storing files.

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Not yet, there's a discussion about this @ https://github.com/ente-io/ente/discussions/504
vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Comments were taken in the best of spirits :)

We do get your perspective. Privacy does not outweigh convenience for vast majority. We are hoping to find the balance.

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Friends and founders ("angels"), no VC.
vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
sorry for the eye sore, if someone can split the bullet points into multiple lines, please do, I'm unable to edit my comment
vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Hey, one of the folks building Ente here.

We have to pick our battles, and we currently aren't looking at serving customers on low-end devices. But if they access Ente on a laptop, the indexing will run there, and the computed indexes will sync to their low-end devices, e2ee.

Also, given that compute on smart phones is getting better and cheaper with every iteration, we believe it's best to bet on Edge ML for the long term.

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Not unless our existing providers provide a volume discount, or we start managing some of the infrastructure (1/3 replicas) ourselves.

The latter is very likely in the long run.

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Google has ways to monetize your data. If I were them, I would be attaching a price tag to cloud storage simply to not seem suspicious :)

Most of our costs come from keeping 3 replicas of your data: https://ente.io/reliability

We could perhaps reduce the replicas from 3 (2 hot, 1 cold) to 2 (1 hot, 1 cold), and lower our costs, but it's not something we've actively thought about.

Also, our prices are designed such that the business can run sustainably, and we believe that's the best way to build Ente, where the expectation is for the company to outlive its customers.

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Hey, details on how we're providing E2EE with links has been documented here: https://ente.io/blog/building-shareable-links/

Some bits of the blog post are outdated, since the feature has matured since then. But the implementation details are roughly the same.

TL;DR: The keys are added to the URL fragment (the part that follows the #), and these fragments are not accessible to the server.

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Takeout is malicious compliance.

Google Photos already has a public API. But you cannot consume it if you are building a competing service[1]. Also, the APIs will not serve you files in their original quality.

If they wanted to honor the intent behind GDPR's portability mandate, it would have been trivial for them to enable seamless migrations.

Now what's ironic is how Google is a "partner" in the Data Transfer Initiative[2].

[1]: https://developers.google.com/photos/library/guides/acceptab...

[2]: https://dtinit.org

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
We've spend time debugging this and talking to our service provider's[1] support, but haven't been able to figure out the root cause.

If there are any experts reading this, we'd be grateful if you could let us know what we're doing wrong here.

We're in the middle of switching over to SES because they are landing flawlessly into Gmail inboxes, but it would still be good to understand what we could have done better.

[1]: https://www.zoho.com/zeptomail

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Google Takeout downloads the images in full quality.

But it splits your metadata (like capture time, geo coordinates) and places them in a separate sidecar file.

This isn't an issue if you're migrating to Ente because during import the desktop app[1] will merge the metadata with their respective files.

If it's for you to keep a local copy, you will unfortunately need to write some scripts. There's in fact a paid product[2] that does just this.

[1]: https://ente.io/download/desktop

[2]: https://metadatafixer.com/

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Thank you for sharing the demo, it was simple to experience the product. This is a reminder for us to provide one as well :)

Ente now has everything except cross-platform face-recognition (it's desktop only right now), labels and EXIF edits. The first two are being worked on, we should have v1s ready by Q3. Polishing will take a bit longer.

The long-press-to-skim-through albums is very neat, will add this.

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Fixed, thank you for pointing this out!
vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Thank you!

I've scribbled a bit about the story behind the name and the mascot here: https://ente.io/blog/ducky/

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Hey, are there any specific features in Photoprism that you liked better?
vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
For self-hosting, there's Photoprism[1] as well.

Ente's strength lies in end-to-end encryption[2] and its cloud[3] offering so you don't have to worry about reliability.

So if self-hosting is what you're after, Immich, Photoprism and Damselfly (TIL!) are perhaps better designed to serve your needs.

[1]: https://github.com/photoprism/photoprism

[2]: https://ente.io/architecture

[3]: https://ente.io/reliability

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Thank you! We're fans of Immich!
vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Hey, one of the reasons Ente is expensive is because we maintain 3 copies of your data across 3 clouds.

You can read about our replication strategy here: https://ente.io/reliability

We could in the future offer cheaper plans at the cost of additional replicas.

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Hey, you can use Ente's desktop app[1] to import the archives you export via Google Takeout. The app stitches together metadata with their original files so you'll have your library in one-piece.

[1]: https://ente.io/download/desktop

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Hey, one of the folks working on Ente here. Our clients were always open source, we published the code to our server[1] into a monorepo[2] just yesterday.

[1]: https://ente.io/blog/open-sourcing-our-server/

[2]: https://github.com/ente-io/ente

vishnumohandas··on Ente: Open-Source, E2E Encrypted, Google Photos Alternative
Hey, Ente's CEO here.

We had opensourced our server[1] yesterday, which is perhaps why we are on the front page. Stoked to be here

Ente had launched on HN[2] a while ago and has been sustainably growing since.

We took the feedback from our Show HN seriously and have since

- undergone a cryptography audit [3]

- published our replication strategy [4]

- added requested features (family plans, collaborative albums and links, ...) [5][6][7]

- made progress with Edge ML [8][9]

- built a CLI for incremental data exports (our desktop app supports this as well) [10]

- and in general matured as a company [11]

Also, apart from our source code, our Figma[12] is public as well.

If you've feedback on what we could do better, please do share, it'd be very helpful.

And if you've any questions, do ask, I'd love to make myself useful.

[1]: https://ente.io/blog/open-sourcing-our-server/

[2]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28347439

[3]: https://ente.io/blog/cryptography-audit/

[4]: https://ente.io/reliability

[5]: https://ente.io/blog/family-plans

[6]: https://ente.io/blog/collaborative-albums/

[7]: https://ente.io/blog/collect-photos/

[8]: https://ente.io/blog/image-search-with-clip-ggml/

[9]: https://ente.io/blog/desktop-ml-beta/

[10]: https://github.com/ente-io/cli

[11]: https://ente.io/blog/reflections-on-trusting-trust/

[12]: https://www.figma.com/file/SYtMyLBs5SAOkTbfMMzhqt/ente-Visua...

vishnumohandas··on Ente – Open sourcing our server
Before implementing SRP, our authentication flow relied on email verification.

The general inconvenience of waiting for emails aside, this flow also had the potential to lock out customers who were using Ente Auth to store their email's 2FA credentials. So it was important that we fixed this.

Once OPAQUE becomes more mainstream, we will very likely adopt it.

vishnumohandas··on Ente – Open sourcing our server
Hey, one of the folks working on Ente here. We weren't ready to land on HN today, but happy to be here.

If you've any questions, please do ask, I'd love to make myself useful.

vishnumohandas··on Show HN: Struct – A Feed-Centric Chat Platform
That's one of the best landing pages I've seen recently. Congratulations on the launch!
vishnumohandas··on YC: Requests for Startups
Related: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39369766
vishnumohandas··on SQLite vs. ObjectBox vs. Isar
Update: https://ente.io/blog/tech/sqlite-objectbox-isar#update

TL;DR: Removing Protobuf and directly serializing the list to a blob helped!

vishnumohandas··on SQLite vs. ObjectBox vs. Isar
Type-conversions with FFI turned out to be non-trivial, so `{"embedding":[...]}` was a way out at the cost of a small performance hit (when compared to the time spent on inference).

We'll take another look.

← PreviousPage 4 of 12Next →