HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vitessa

4 karma · joined March 13, 2023

submissionscomments
vitessa··on America Has Replaced Capitalism with Cronyism
You can’t. You have three options:

1. A violent revolution against capitalism that destroys it.

2. You slowly contain capitalism and wind it down, making the elite increasingly irrelevant, as it appeared the US and Europe might have been on track to do from 1933-73, until you’ve basically achieved socialism without necessarily calling it that.

3. Capitalism continues to corrode the restraints put in place to contain it until you have an oligarchic nightmare like the US.

3 is completely unacceptable; 1 is a bit better but still involves people getting killed. 2 is probably best if you can pull it off, but the problem is that it requires society to do the right thing for decades whereas an overthrow of capitalism can be done in weeks.

vitessa··on America Has Replaced Capitalism with Cronyism
This was capitalism, a beacon of hope for people who are smart, hardworking, and comfortable with risk, promising a greater share of the spoils to them than to those who are not.

Wrong. That’s not what capitalism is or means. Capitalism is an economic system in which private investors run the economy in search of personal profit, while those who lack capital rely on wage labor to survive. You can debate whether this is a good or moral system, but it’s important to get terminology right.