55 karma · joined April 11, 2010
2. easy, just select schools with good graduation, low crime etc. - just as people are selecting good schools now by relocating to a different(better) neighborhood. (check)
3. people switch schools all the time just as they switch jobs, granted you may have difficulties to do it in mid semester but this is not a serious obstacle. (check)
So, all the conditions are met, can we open the market to competition now?
I think this is very important part of his argument. A person who has just graduated from high school has very little first hand knowledge about how things work and can only parrot stuff learned mostly from media sometimes from books. You can dismiss Carmack's arguments only if you think that Carmack:
a) has a political agenda and is lying about his experience with government
b) has a low IQ and is incapable of seeing how things "really work"
c) has significantly less experience than you and your experience with government has been very much different.
If you just graduated high school a year ago and everything you needed to know about politics you learned from the Daily Show, at least give Carmack the benefit of the doubt. Maybe he's on to something.