903 karma · joined October 16, 2015
There is surprisingly little tech going on in "tech" today.
Edit: misread the specs, point still stands.
We see this all the time in software development, where excellent engineers are borne of trying to build a video game at age x, where x is a relatively low number.
Similarly, there's no reason that someone initially motivated to eradicate "evil" can't become a great security mind, and I suspect Moxie and many like him are of this ilk.
That said, understanding how the red team does things is extremely useful for formulating one's own defense.
I think fixing development will be more optimal than fixing users. There is no legitimate reason that OWASP top ten or lack of buffer bounds checking should still be in the wild in 2016, whereas users will always fall for scams, phishing or otherwise.
This is certainly true. But competitive pressures will always force quick hacks over software robustness. The only real solution is a sort of developers' guild -- whose membership includes over 90% of all worldwide professional developers -- wherein an oath is sworn to always include security robustness as a required feature during the software estimation cycle. Or perhaps an analogue to the Hippocratic oath.
Which of course will never happen.
Both are unpopular hypotheses, however, because all bodies are beautiful and sex positive porn has zero externalities.
Sometimes (oftentimes, in my experience) they really do hate you.
Here on HN, where people ostensibly require the weight of evidence to accept a concept, I would expect nearly 100% of people to reject this evidence-free, baseless emotional concept immediately out of hand. Yet somehow, this community of rationalists buy into handwaving without any critical thought.
We nerds appear to be just as dogmatically religious as those whose ideas we reject on the basis of lack of evidence. A little saddening.
We're definitely in the minority, but some of us in hiring positions actively discriminate against the didn't-learn-until-college demographic for software developers.
As for exploitability, privilege escalation and shellcode injection is still very much a thing, internet-facing or not.
This is a blue-sky project. Completely new, with no legacy dependencies.
AND YET THE DEVELOPER CHOSE TO WRITE IT IN C. WHY FOR THE LOVE OF GOD, WHY?
Could someone explain this to me? Is it developer hubris, believing in one's own infallibility that a single exploitable stack frame or buffer overflow couldn't possibly happen "on my watch"?
If you need a native binary, your options are endless. Rust, Go, Haskell, hell, even C++ with smart pointers and runtime bounds-checking would be a step up.
Please, someone educate me on why people still choose to write inevitably-vulnerable software in 2016, when there is no legacy reason to do so.
[META] Not due to the content of the response, but the fact that dang, who is rightfully vigilant about enforcing standards of civility all over HN (with detachment, warnings, and bans), willfully ignores blatant violations of said standards where ideology aligns.
We live in a world of asymmetric warfare in which attackers can screw up thousands of times, but defenders only need to screw up once. Dramatically increase the payoff of compromise, and the risk increases accordingly.
I know this smacks of security by obscurity, but in the real world, incentives for attackers are absolutely part of the risk calculation.
EFF may actually do more good by funding FOSS alternatives to commercial solutions than by funding lawyers.
They do appear to have caved to the demand for irrelevant nonfunctional details like chassis colors.
OP's request is arguably far more important (read: functional) than rose gold tint.
Doubt this. Remember that VC is only available to those who already have an "in" with the social proof network of the VCs.
We, like many many others, bootstrapped our business out of necessity, not out of choice.
Speaking for myself, his apologia of The State also irritates me quite a bit, but I try to keep my mouth shut because he contributes so much to the community.
According to dell.com, it seems there is no option for ECC ram on this device.
The sadness continues...
Are you seriously suggesting that throwing one of your own citizens under the bus for mean words affecting the fragile feelings of a foreign Head of State is proper and correct diplomacy?
Or, better yet, eliminate payroll deductions entirely and ensure everyone has a liability come April. Pretty hard to defraud a liability.