HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

w0000t

75 karma · joined August 17, 2015

submissionscomments
w0000t··on Warp speed travel is theoretically possible, says astrophysicist
I read the real( peer reviewed ) paper, and it contradicts your ideas.

Your final conclusion is a strawman argument. Those quotes are referring to normal travel through space.

w0000t··on Warp speed travel is theoretically possible, says astrophysicist
You are clinging to light cones because that is what you know about relativity, but you don't understand it intuitively. I didn't get any new information from you last comment, just what has already been said. Warp and light cones clearly don't work. Does that mean that warp couldn't work at least in theory, no.

Learn more about relativity( it is really interesting ), otherwise you will always be stuck in your frame of mind.

w0000t··on Alibi Routing
Does it matter to avoid USA if someone is taping into the cable in a different country.
w0000t··on About size_t and ptrdiff_t
Article republished by the author’s permission.

I guess that is one way to write articles.

w0000t··on Warp speed travel is theoretically possible, says astrophysicist
The light cone only matters if you actually move. The accepted idioms from relativity don't apply here.

I think we are just not talking about the same "warp" drive. The version that doesn't violate causality works like this. You are not allowed to accelerate( using normal rockets ) to near c velocity and then warp to a stop to some distant location. This would cause problems. Instead you will end up there with all of your accumulated velocity before the warp. Then you have to come to a stop the same way you accelerated.

In other words, warp will change your location but not your velocity in spacetime.

w0000t··on Warp speed travel is theoretically possible, says astrophysicist
You assume that warp drive actually moves you trough space, it doesn't. Problem solved.

Here is a practical example: I decide to travel to Alpha Centauri, and I'm there. Time passed for everybody is the same. You cannot cause any problems.

Note that you are not allowed to change reference frames, by doing this. This does sound illogical, since you move to some other location, but if you assume you didn't move, like we did, then it isn't. Actually the space moved, and that might cause some other problems we don't know about.

w0000t··on Warp speed travel is theoretically possible, says astrophysicist
> Too much energy.

Right, you would need those rare, stable, dilithium crystals.

w0000t··on Warp speed travel is theoretically possible, says astrophysicist
I was referring to sub c speeds and what happens by using real confirmed physics. I didn't realize you were talking about warp drives in that case.

As far as I understand from popular science, warp drive doesn't actually move the occupants of the vehicle, it moves the space around the ship so in that case there is no time dilation. It takes the same amount of time for people, in and outside, the ship. If your warp drive is limited to 20c then yes it is a problem, but I don't see why would it have to be limited in the first place. Make it go 10^10c and the problem is solved.

w0000t··on Warp speed travel is theoretically possible, says astrophysicist
If by those you mean people who are actually traveling in the star-ships, then it is a short time. It is only a long time for people staying stationary relative to the travelers.
w0000t··on Warp speed travel is theoretically possible, says astrophysicist
Well that is clearly not true. Thanks to relativity, colonization is very possible in a short time span.
w0000t··on An (Important) Disproof of the One-Time Pad
Yes. They don't know if the string ONETIMEPAD was produced by the key AAAAAAAAAA or GHASDIJAWE. And thus they don't know if ONETIMEPAD is actually the plaintext or not.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2