HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wbeaty

112 karma · joined May 14, 2010

I run SCIENCE HOBBYIST, http://amasci.com/ , also http://trafficwaves.org/
submissionscomments
wbeaty··on Holography without Lasers: Hand Drawn Holograms (1995)
Something not in the original http://amasci.com/holo/ site is the discovery that if you scratch complete circles rather than arcs, then rotate the whole plate under the light, the hologram rotates around an axis normal to the plate. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UtmGgmhWBAc
wbeaty··on Holography without Lasers: Hand Drawn Holograms (1995)
So did lots.

Three people managed to automate, one even non-trivial. Also, it's mass produced from metal master: on a vinyl album release of Jack White 'Lazaretto' (with rotating angel by Tristan Duke of MIT Media Lab)

Here's a long youtube scratch-holo playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL60100E8F3572CEB1 Still nobody has found one etched on pre-Columbian pottery glaze. Or Egyptian scrying mirrors! :)

wbeaty··on Holography without Lasers: Hand Drawn Holograms (1995)
> Gunshot at 0:57

Lol, editing cut.

http://youtu.be/XUy8lELWhJg?t=34s

The really anomalous thing is the big 60/120Hz pulse at 0:37, click above. I was shooting out front of the house, and I reviewed the whole video while standing there, and found the 120Hz. WTF!? It had to be EM, there'd been no audio like that while filming. Was I painted by a uWave beam?

I'm right near airports, also a couple miles north of a Boeing mil black project building. But radar is clicks, not 120Hz. And it sounds like changing PWM during the pulse.

wbeaty··on Holography without Lasers: Hand Drawn Holograms (1995)
> fiddled

So did lots. Three people managed to automate, one even non-trivial. Also, it's mass produced from metal master: on a vinyl album release of Jack White 'Lazaretto' (with rotating angel by Tristan Duke of MIT Media Lab)

Here's a long youtube playlist of scratch-holo: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL60100E8F3572CEB1

Still nobody has found one etched on pre-Columbian pottery glaze. Or Egyptian scrying mirrors! :)

wbeaty··on "Invisible Electrostatic Wall" at 3M adhesive tape plant (1996)
The original report was a presentation at an ESD conference, not a rumor or FOAF.

I heard about it from a tech at an EMI testing lab in 1996, tracked down Dave Swenson's email at 3M, and posted the article on amasci.com.

Some extra info: Dave S. mentioned that the experience was a bit painful, since corona discharges were leaping from his whole body at the time. He said he was unable to turn around while near the "invisible wall," and had to walk backwards to get away from it.

Also, he described the whole plant having serious ESD hazards: tape on floor to mark pathways, and if you left the path, you might get zapped by a mini-lightning from some ungrounded machine.

wbeaty··on "Invisible Electrostatic Wall" at 3M adhesive tape plant (1996)
Note that the amasci.com article is about David Swenson's conference talk about the phenomenon, here's the copypaste:

http://web.archive.org/web/19961226041803/http://www.att.com...

   SESSION 7: SPECIAL SESSION, 17th Annual EOS/ESD Symposium
   THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 14, 1995, 8:00 am
   
   SESSION 7: SPECIAL SESSION: ELECTROSTATIC CONSIDERATIONS IN INDUSTRY
   
   MODERATOR: D. Swenson, 3M
   
   7.7 CASE STUDY - LARGE PLASTIC WEB ELECTROSTATIC PROBLEMS, RESULTS AND
   CURE, D. Swenson, 3M Company
   Tremendous static charge generation on a plastic web causes unique
   physical phenomena and special problems. Solution was simple and cost
   effective.
The real question ...was this "star trek physics," or really just a human-nerve TENS effect; temporary muscle paralysis caused by static discharges all over the victim's skin? They never threw a baseball down the tunnel to see if it halted.
wbeaty··on Google's Autonomous cars complete 300,000 miles without an accident
Yep: it doesn't happen, FAQ: http://trafficwaves.org/tfaq.html#five

- if truckers can maintain a bubble, how can it be impossible?

- yes, aggressively weaving drivers sometimes jump in ...then they jump out again.

- at merge zones, the entire point is to let people into your lane.

- In theory, everyone else wants your precious bubble. In practice, not.

...and in a burning building, we all know the best way to escape, eh? EVERYONE AGGRESSIVELY PUSH FORWARD, DON'T LET ANYONE ELSE GET PAST, COOPERATION AND TEAMWORK ARE FOR LOSERS! Yep, that certainly won't trigger a huge clogged mess where everyone dies.

wbeaty··on How Airplanes Fly: A Physical Description of Lift
Don't miss their updated PDF version: http://www.allstar.fiu.edu/aero/Flightrevisited.pdf

---

Important but somewhat complicated point: flight in a 2D world is a venturi effect, and regardless of altitude, a two-dimensional airfoil remains trapped in "ground effect mode." The circulation extends outwards indefinitely, and so an instant force-pair connects the wing with the surface of the Earth.

In 2D, the airfoil circulation creates lift upon the moving airfoil, but it also creates an equal down-force against the ground. If the airfoil was flying higher, the force pattern on the ground grows wider, but the net downforce doesn't change. As a result, 2D airfoil diagrams do not describe normal flight. They describe a sort of "Flatland flight" where no net work needs be done to accelerate mass downwards. As an explanation of aircraft, they've been simplified until they cross the line into actual error.

In the 3D world we can launch a vortex downward and experience a reaction force upward. Or perhaps launch a vortex sideways (during turns.) No instant-force upon the Earth is needed. The Newtonian force-pair arises between the mass-bearing aircraft and the mass-bearing air entrained by the shed vortex. Hovering rockets have an exhaust plume, and flying airplanes have a descending vortex-pair, and both are essential to any explanation. Real world 3D flight is "vortex-shedding flight," and the explanations based on 2D airfoil diagrams leads to no end of confusion.

wbeaty··on Alternate Sleep Cycles
The real problem is that it's an amateur discovery, and the professionals are having none of it.

When something makes experts look questionable, expect irrational flamewars in response. Or derisive dismissal, at the very least.

wbeaty··on Alternate Sleep Cycles
Exactly. Pseudoscience has two sides: emotion-based mindless acceptance, and emotion-based mindless rejection. Wozniak's hotheaded web article demonstrates the latter type.

And the term "Anecdotal evidence" is often used as smear word to ridicule what otherwise would be called direct observation. It's an old dishonest politician ploy: if you can't rebut observations, try to discredit the observer.

In my own case I found (during school days, cramming for finals) that I'd fall into a weird fast-cycling sleep schedule with no hours-long sleeps and no apparent sleep debt over a term of weeks. I suspect that conventional sleep research would label this insomnia: needing constant catnaps of 5-30min duration, and complete inability to sleep nights. Most important: it took many days before the fast-cycling appeared, and once this rhythm took hold, no alarm clock was needed. When I required a nap, extreme grogginess came on suddenly and I almost had no choice. Immediate dreaming as soon as my eyes were closed. ~10 minutes later, bam, I'd suddenly wake up fully with no grogginess. Hours later the cycle would repeat. Also it took me days/weeks to escape it and regain the ability to sleep for more than a half hour. I found that strange mental effects did eventually appear, but only after many weeks. This wasn't 'sleep debt,' more like mild sleep deprivation psychosis.

wbeaty··on "Invisible Electrostatic Wall" at 3M adhesive tape plant (1996)
Cap discharge? One story was the Robert VandeGraaff got the idea for his generator from a Boston printing plant, where the metal body of an ungrounded newspaper press on a wooden floor would give dangerous shocks to anyone approaching closely. If a machine is many meters across, and charges itself up to many tens of KV, the body capacitance may store lethal (joules) level of energy, e.g. 50KV at 1000pF.
wbeaty··on "Invisible Electrostatic Wall" at 3M adhesive tape plant (1996)
Rather than a "force field," another possibility was Taser effect, where numerous tiny sparks to the skin will cause muscles to clench, making it impossible to walk. Search keywords: tetanizing beam
wbeaty··on "Invisible Electrostatic Wall" at 3M adhesive tape plant (1996)
Reasoning based on zero information? Heh. We could say "Pretty likely it was declared National Security and hushed up."

Or we could say "Pretty likely that D. Swenson installed electrodes to quench the effect ...which task he was called in to perform." And Murphy's Law for experimental replication is that the desired phenomenon refuses to emerge except under identical conditions using only the original equipment.

wbeaty··on In-Car Algorithm Could Rapidly Dissolve Traffic Jams
Prizewinning 2004 research by LC Davis of Umich showed that stop/go traffic jams were eliminated by adding in a certain percentage of cars with Adaptive Cruise Control (ACC.) It only took a little less than 1 in 5 cars.

http://www.ur.umich.edu/0304/July19_04/19.shtml

http://www.google.com/search?q=%2Btraffic+jams+%2Bdavis+%2Ba...

What does ACC do? It imposes proper safe driving headway distance, as well as providing near-instant reaction time for braking. No tailgating, no accumulation of 1-sec human reaction times.

But couldn't human drivers do the same by simply padding out their 2-sec spacing to 3-sec? And only a few need to do it.

wbeaty··on In-Car Algorithm Could Rapidly Dissolve Traffic Jams
Actually he may be forcing the lanes-full optimal mode to arise.

If one or a few drivers in the empty lane start pacing the cars in the full lane, cars will build up behind them. When they arrive at the end of their lane, the drivers in the full lane won't be so ready to block merges (since nobody was cheating by racing down to the end.) Perhaps this could trigger an outbreak of zipper-merging.

wbeaty··on In-Car Algorithm Could Rapidly Dissolve Traffic Jams
Rather than 100 automated cars, just use one daily commuter.

If you commute along a stretch of highway every day, then you know exactly where the "stop waves" tend to appear. That's the place where you stop driving like a Wolf, and instead drive like a Shepherd: stop speeding and tailgating, and instead open up a large buffer.

I've found that this works well in some places. The other drivers seem to know what you're doing, and sometimes you'll even see others using the same technique. But in other spots everyone seems clueless, and they'll race to fill up the tiniest hole.

Also, as with the Koshima monkeys washing potatos or Blue Tits & milk bottles, in the last ten years the trick seems to be spreading. Some of our "clueless" regions have experienced a state change, and the daily jams seem to appear less often.

I wonder if the articles below have a simple cause:

http://blog.tstc.org/2010/09/23/u-s-traffic-fatalities-plumm...

http://cityroom.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/01/27/2009-traffic-de...

http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2010-09-09-1Aroaddeaths0...

wbeaty··on Scott Adams: Crazy Eyes
Probably depends on how far the believers drift from "normal" mental state.

While working for long periods with poly sleep schedule, and getting into that hypomanic idea-spewing region, I'll scare myself by looking in the mirror: my eyes are WIDE, with eyelids not touching iris. Is that how I really look to everyone? Yep. But my eyes feel normal at the time, if a bit cold. If I force them to look like a normal person's eyes, they feel warm and half-closed as if I'm sleepy. That's it! In high creativity "flow" mode, I'm really really awake and I'm paying attention to my entire visual field. Perhaps it's akin to looking frightened. In order to see possible approaching dangers, you pull your eyelids back so they don't block peripheral vision as much. You don't necessarily roll your eyes, but when your eyelids are so wide open, any glancing to the side exposes the whites of your eyes. Very noticeable to onlookers. (So then when I go out in public, I have to make sure to squint and pretend to look sleepy!)

Sheer speculation: ancient tribes might survive better if their members evolved to display certain unconscious instinctual facial expressions. The look of feverish sickness says "stay away, infection danger." But the wide-eyed crazed/fearful expression also gives the community warning to back off and avoid unexpected behavior. When I've put myself into an extreme creative state, I'll notice that my eyes feel cold w/wide open lids exposing more surface. I think to myself "Yep, automatic craziness-warning system been triggered."

Imagine what might happen if heavily-armed and mentally unstable tribe members DIDN'T display any signs that they'd consumed alkaloid plants or mushrooms or alcohol ...or had just gone without sleep for two weeks!

wbeaty··on Xkcd: Airfoil - So what's the right explanation?
Hilarious! This is the usual problem with rigorous physics/engineering: we don't understand it ourselves, and rather than being honest about it, we quote math at you. It's like doctors in 1700 falling back to Latin in order to hide their embarrassing ignorance from the public. In reality, "If you can't explain it to your grandmother, then you don't understand it yourself." (A. Einstein.)

Similarly, if you asked me some eletronics questions about a piece of complicated circuitry that I didn't understand, I could baffle you with BS. It's simple, I just pull out the equations from the SPICE component models. (As if owning the printout of the software can tell us anything about the behavior of the simulated circuit!!)

So, whenever you see an expert pull this crap, give them the above Einstein quote.

wbeaty··on Science Misconceptions in Textbooks and Popular culture
Those titles look too large? OK, they're now changed to H3 instead of H2. Better?

Also, the text was written in the Lynx browser era before the <i> tag existed, so italics terms instead are all-caps. I've updated that.

wbeaty··on Science Misconceptions in Textbooks and Popular culture
Ah, you hit on my central philosophy: all content, no esthetics. Whenever I have free time, I add more content (hand-written in HTML, via a telnet terminal from wherever I happen to be.) See the FAQ:

This site looks like something from 1994!!!!!! http://amasci.com/faq.html#1994

NEVER TRY TO PLEASE EVERYONE! YOUR GOAL SHOULD BE TO BECOME THE HATED ENEMY OF CERTAIN KINDS OF PEOPLE. :)

wbeaty··on Science Misconceptions in Textbooks and Popular culture
On the other section of that site I say this below:

"Sorry if the following is a bit contentious at times. I wrote it in an attempt to get some things off my chest. If you keep watching this site, I'll probably clean it up and make it sound a bit more professional"

But then I received constant numerous requests to keep it just as it is. Only a tiny percentage of responses were hostile. I decided against any change. Also note that this was a 1996 page written for Lynx text-only browsers.

wbeaty··on Traffic Experiments -- How to clear traffic jams
Google on "Fundamental diagram" of traffic, or http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_diagram_of_traffic_... It's a set of graphs. Density plotted against speed, etc. It's old stuff, empirically derived. As flowing cars slowly get closer together on average, drivers slow down a bit for safety, yet with more cars passing per second, so the flow increases. But then as they approach even closer, drivers must greatly slow down because of reaction time issues, even though more cars are packed onto the roads ...and so the slowing dominates the extra cars per mile, and average flow decreases. The peak flow ends up being 30MPH - 40MPH. That flow will most rapidly drain out the backups. I hear that it's a different value in different countries.

But worse is the problem that once everyone slows past the 35MPH hump, traffic becomes unstable, and you get oscillations or standing waves which slow things far more than you might expect.

Rule of thumb (but I've never seen it stated anywhere) 35MPH=51FPS, 3 seconds between cars, gives 150 FEET BETWEEN CARS. Closing up gaps will wreck the max. flow pattern. During congestion, if you start trying to stop others from "cutting you off" or merging ahead, then you're the one causing the jam. (Or to be fair, 30MPH and 2sec gives 90ft spacing, perhaps the bare min.)

Another issue: in 1998 Helbing and Huberman discovered the existence of distinct 'phases' in simulated multi-lane traffic. When all lanes seem to lock together like a moving crystal, that's now called "Synchronous Flow," and gives maximum throughput. But it's on the edge of collapse, and "condensations" are triggered by anyone who tries outrunning neighbors by switching lanes, or who approaches too close and has to tap the brakes. http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v396/n6713/abs/396738a0...

wbeaty··on Traffic Experiments -- How to clear traffic jams
But note that there aren't any slowpokes here, instead, every single car is blocked by the car ahead of them. The people behind you think that you are the slowpoke driver. But nothing is blocking the traffic, instead the average speed of the long column of cars is determined by the spacing between cars, and that spacing is determined by psychology.

In light traffic, some people go far faster than average, but nobody tries to stop them. When we arrive at heavy congestion, don't we suddenly decide to close up ranks to prevent aggressive drivers from passing, stop them from "cutting us off?" If everyone habitually blocks the speeders, then it means we've compressed the traffic pattern past the peak of maximum flow, and pushed it into the unstable realm of stop/go oscillations and standing waves or "ghost jams."

Want jams to vanish? Then do as the pro truckers do and just freaking back off. Happily encourage other cars to merge ahead. (They're not "cutting you off," there's no such thing as "cutting you off." They're just trying to merge into the adjacent lane!) If traffic momentarily slows way down, everyone just make sure to keep an open space that allows merging, and you'll find that it speeds right back up again.

wbeaty··on How transistor really works, an alternate viewpoint
For an interesting experience, ask a group of EEs if bipolars are inherently current-controlled devices. This tends to create long-running flamewars (similar effect to asking pilots how airfoils create lift.) The ones who know that bipolars are current-controlled will nearly come to blows with the ones who know that they're voltage controlled. Very strange, but not unexpected when considering the poor jobs textbooks do with the non-math intuitive explanations. See sci.electronics.design for multiple examples of such fights, also wikipedia discussion history.
wbeaty··on How transistor really works, an alternate viewpoint
> cannot simply redefine "current"

Instead, authors of educational articles aimed at the public should stick to proper usage because it avoids misconceptions. "Flow of charge" is proper, "flow of current" is not. Unknown to most readers; I'm also using a further technique to reinforce certain concepts: always avoiding jargon (e.g. don't hide "charge flow" behind the word "current," instead don't define current at all. Remove the word entirely, and replace it with "charge flow.") Note that the intended audience here is little kids and grandmothers. In years of working with electricity misconceptions among the general public, I find that "flow of current" is one of the top learning barriers preventing easy grasp of electricity concepts. It connects to many other mistaken ideas.

Example: "batteries send out current," versus "batteries cause the conductors' charges to flow."

wbeaty··on How electricity doesn't work
> Many of the textbooks he was reading... were using the pedagogical technique of Lie-to-children

Wrong, the textbook authors fully believe those misconceptions themselves. I discovered this sad fact during my K6 education consulting work back in the 80s. Lies-to-children are very different than author misconceptions: they must be carefully constructed so that they don't install permanent major misconceptions in student's minds.

For example, the idea that atoms are like tiny solar systems is a "Lie" which simply explains atomic structure in classical terms, and which turns out to be relatively harmless. It doesn't form any enormous learning barrier which entirely derails our later ability to understand orbitals and quantum chem.

Good articles on the author-misconception topic: R. Feynman's "Judging books by their covers" and S J Gould's "The case of the creeping fox terrier clone"

wbeaty··on How electricity doesn't work
>This is quite discouraging to read...

It's quite discouraging to see criticism from someone who didn't read what they're attacking. The article plainly states that electrons in metals are hopping all the time, even when the current is zero. Go read it. That's the whole point of that section. A bit hard to miss, unless you leapt to a wrong conclusion after only reading the title.

> because electrons "fill in" the gaps

The article specifically describes this effect. It's probably not wise to criticize things you haven't bothered to read.

That section is a simplified introduction to the concept of "electron sea" and "drift velocity." It debunks the common grade-school textbook error that electrons in metal wires only start hopping between atoms if someone connects that wire in a battery circuit (where the electrons also are supposed to remain stuck to individual metal atoms when current is zero.) This is a serious textbook misconception because it teaches kids that the electron sea doesn't exist, and it prevents them from grasping the "full pipes" fluid analogy of electric circuits as well as later concepts of metallic bond, metal reflectivity, lack of brittleness, etc.

← PreviousPage 4 of 4