HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wcarey

494 karma · joined August 26, 2010

submissionscomments
wcarey··on Can 1/3 and 1/3 = 2/6? It seemed so
The idea that "when you extend that" is something human beings can do is an absolute revelation to young mathematicians. The idea that our notations are, at least in some sense, choices that we make that come with tradeoffs is a huge point of mathematical maturity for them, and usually causes my students to look back with either deep awe or deep suspicion when they realize that even our choice of base 10 is a choice among many and we can make other choices.

As von Neumann said, very much something to get used to.

wcarey··on Can 1/3 and 1/3 = 2/6? It seemed so
As you say, the artistic use of cross-object synthesis and analogy definitely distinguishes the advanced students from the mechanical. Advanced students develop a sort of dialect that harmonizes the mathematical objects they encounter in a way that illuminates them all.

More than any of that, though, I think what you can see (even here in this thread!) is that, while we pretend that mathematics is a single cultural practice of rational humans communicating with other rational humans, it's really many smaller communities of mathematicians, all of varying skills trying to communicate with each other. My mathematical language as a teacher of 12-18 year olds is very different from my mathematical language when I did computational geometry for a living.

Because you have many communities of mathematicians producing new notation, you end up with dialects that all sort of meld together in the same way that reading Shakespeare is very different from reading Hemingway or Eco (in translation).

The closest programming analogue would be C++, where you have several mutually unintelligible dialects spoken by different communities of programmers with different concerns.

wcarey··on Can 1/3 and 1/3 = 2/6? It seemed so
I also didn't encounter it until I was relatively older. Our school has been pushing to introduce more rigorous language and definition in our 7-12th math program. For some students, it really seems to help. For others, it's really hard.
wcarey··on Can 1/3 and 1/3 = 2/6? It seemed so
I mean, the general case is certainly trouble for kids. But 15% and 20% look very similar to 15x and 20x. That the two (sometimes!) operate using different rules causes confusion for many students. The implicitness of the fractions conceals something important that's explicit if you write out the fractions. For example, multiplying percents does not do what most students intuitively think it does.

15% of 8 times 20% of 10 isn't 35% of any nice arithmetic combination of 8 and 10. That's hard to communicate to many students.

wcarey··on Can 1/3 and 1/3 = 2/6? It seemed so
Is that commonly done?
wcarey··on Can 1/3 and 1/3 = 2/6? It seemed so
Absolutely terrifying. How did he communicate with other peer mathematicians?
wcarey··on Can 1/3 and 1/3 = 2/6? It seemed so
Indeed. And if they're cartesian vectors, you're good. But if that second number is an angle measured in radians, you use yet a different set of rules for the addition.

The conversation with 16 year olds when you explain that their previous teacher who told them that you couldn't add points wasn't lying, but was, perhaps oversimplifying things to make their life easier, is a fun and fraught one.

I've had to reason kids through the fact that a^2 + b^2 is not equal to (ab)^2 or even (a+b)^2 more times than I can count. What's particularly difficult is that, confronted with the fact that 25 and 49 are manifestly different numbers, many still cling to the rule that a^2 + b^2 = (a+b)^2, because of the "law of distribution", which they haven't learned as the "law of distribution of multiplication of monomials over addition, and only that".

wcarey··on Can 1/3 and 1/3 = 2/6? It seemed so
How would you explain that successfully to fourth graders? (Or, for that matter, seventh graders?)
wcarey··on Can 1/3 and 1/3 = 2/6? It seemed so
> I have a lot to say about notation in math, but this isn't the forum. There are a lot of crimes committed, agreed, but some of the things people pick out are only bad because they don't know the context where they redeem themselves.

Indeed - I wish we could conceal those notations until the redemptive context became more apparent, in the same way that Latin teachers can conceal Sallust's inconcinitas until students are ready for it.

wcarey··on Can 1/3 and 1/3 = 2/6? It seemed so
What isn't really true?
wcarey··on Can 1/3 and 1/3 = 2/6? It seemed so
Perhaps an argument for arithmetic followed by geometry using Nicomachus and Euclid. We sit on that until 9th grade, but I wonder how young you could go with it?
wcarey··on Can 1/3 and 1/3 = 2/6? It seemed so
And + is overloaded in a bunch of ways students encounter in high school, and much time is spent talking about when you're allowed to add and when you're not and which rules apply when. Examples:

1 + 2 - fine. 1/2 + 1/2 - one set of rules. 1/2 + 1/3 - a subtly different set of rules.

1:20 + 0:45 - yet another set of rules. Modular. 30° + 350° - fine? But maybe modular.

15% + 20% - who knows? 15% of what? 20% of what?

(1,2) + (2,4) - can't be done.

a^2 + a^2 - fine. a^2 + a^3 - nope. a^2 + b^2 - nope.

It would be lovely if mathematics were taught as a strongly typed language without overloaded operators, alas all our corpus is in the language it's in.

wcarey··on Can 1/3 and 1/3 = 2/6? It seemed so
And so it is.

edit: I suppose, what I'm trying to get at, perhaps too glibly, is that audience matters terribly much in mathematical writing. In the same way that Latin students don't start with Tacitus or Sallust, famous for their idiosyncratic grammar, math students shouldn't jump into the full context-dependent mess of the notation that experienced mathematicians use.

But I think we often thrown them in unintentionally because we're so used to it.

wcarey··on Can 1/3 and 1/3 = 2/6? It seemed so
Thanks! I hadn't seen the retraction. That's really interesting.
wcarey··on Can 1/3 and 1/3 = 2/6? It seemed so
Right.

Of course, if you write x(3), other mathematicians should frown at you because you're making bad notational choices.

It's a bit like explaining to students that the real way to know which 3rd declension nouns are i-stems in Latin is to say the genitive plural both ways. The one that doesn't sound wrong is correct. But you have to have a lot of time in the language for that to work.

wcarey··on Can 1/3 and 1/3 = 2/6? It seemed so
The more I've taught math, the more convinced I am that getting people to "think about what they mean", and to think about what mathematical words mean is 90% of the project.

I remember reading long ago (I'd love to find it again) about a CS department that gave a quiz to incoming students that was very predictive of their success. The answers they wrote didn't matter; what mattered was whether their answers evinced consistent meaning applied to terms and operations.

wcarey··on Can 1/3 and 1/3 = 2/6? It seemed so
This is a lovely (edit: having been in similar shoes, also terrifying-in-the-moment) example of a broader problem in teaching mathematics: the language we use to describe mathematical reasoning is a natural language, like English or Latin, and therefore full of the sorts of bizarre irregularities you'd find in a natural language. Mathematics is also a language about rigorously and precisely defined objects. The conceptual shear between those two things is murder for lots of students.

Just like Tacitus omits his verbs (!), when we describe fractions we often omit the implicit definition of the whole. Turns out that's a problem for many students.

It's a bit like trying to learn a context-dependent programming grammar with an inconsistent API, but worse, because it's your first "mathematical" language so you're also trying to learn what the abstract objects the language manipulates are.

Some other lovely examples:

3(5) means three times five. 3(x) means three times x. 35 means three times ten plus five. 3x means three times x. x(3) means that x is the name of a function taking, in this instance, 3 as its input.

x^{-1} means \frac{1}{x}, but f^{-1}(x) doesn't mean \frac{1}{f(x)}.

\sin{30}. Radians or degrees? Probably the writer means degrees, but there's no way to tell.

There are many more.

wcarey··on Snow Crash: HBO Max adaptation of Neal Stephenson's 1992 cyberpunk novel
An interesting take for sure. I too read it as a coming of age story - also strangely comforting - but see the part after the plot proper begins as an allegorical coming of age story as well, recapitulating (and I think I can say this without spoiling the back half) the development of our understanding of mathematics and the natural world post-Newton. It's a bit like he transitions from a personal coming-of-age story to a societal coming of age story: what happens when you grow up and realize that the world is incomprehensibly weird?
wcarey··on Snow Crash: HBO Max adaptation of Neal Stephenson's 1992 cyberpunk novel
How far into Anathem did you make it? Anathem has a glacial beginning - the introduction is perhaps 200 pages long. But once you've survived that and the plot starts, it's quite compelling and pays off the glacial introduction. That said, it took me three tries to make it through the introduction. World building a society of mathematician-monks on another planet is tough going indeed.
wcarey··on Six Signs of Scientism (2009) [pdf]
Right - do you draw the distinction between the cases you propose philosophically then? I'm on board with an a priori commitment to the idea that we are not actively deceived in our observations of nature, but I think without the same a priori commitment to the idea of causal regularity in nature we'd have the same problem.

I suppose I don't see how "actively deceived" defeats science, but "universe not governed by causal regularities" doesn't? In both cases, we seem to be able to identify patterns and regularities in nature that are illusory.

wcarey··on Six Signs of Scientism (2009) [pdf]
How would you distinguish using science-qua-epistemic-method between a world where all claims of causal regularity were false and a world in which scientist were actively deceived?
wcarey··on Don’t Be Fooled by America’s Flattening Curve
The do have several articles of the sort you're interested in:

https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/16/business/economy/coronavi...

https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/13/business/coronavirus-econ...

are two examples.

wcarey··on Tell HN: C Experts Panel – Ask us anything about C
C++ is the language with which I’m most comfortable, having used it professionally for the better part of a decade. I’ve gone back and forth on using it in HS. It’s abstractions are so opaque if you don’t already have a well developed model of programming.

For the arduino, I’m really interested in teaching control systems. So we will start with finite state machines and go from there to implementing PID controllers. I’m intrigued by the idea of avoiding the IDE, so will totally pick up that book!

wcarey··on Tell HN: C Experts Panel – Ask us anything about C
Thanks! Definitely an interesting tool. Two of my students are fascinated by the idea of undefined behavior right now (having run into it in practice; the idea that off-by-one errors sometimes crash their program and sometimes behave "normally" is really odd to them), so I'll point them at this to play with.
wcarey··on Tell HN: C Experts Panel – Ask us anything about C
I haven’t - is there a good tool chain you’d recommend me checking out? What’s the enduring idea in ada?
wcarey··on Tell HN: C Experts Panel – Ask us anything about C
Thanks!
wcarey··on Tell HN: C Experts Panel – Ask us anything about C
I've been doing the same! It certainly helps for strings. Pointer block diagrams (like K&R use) seem to help too. Mostly what melts their brains is the idea that an identifier can be "in two places at once" - for example, you can have a variable x declared in some scope and a function one of whose arguments is named x, and those are two different things.
wcarey··on Tell HN: C Experts Panel – Ask us anything about C
It's a three year rotation: Python, C (Unix), C (Arduino). My goal with the class is to teach ideas that will stand the test of time. C (and Unix) certainly fit that bill.

Happily, the tooling is the easiest part. Every student has a rasberry-pi running debian, no mouse, no window server, and no extraneous software. You can spool kids up on a nano-based C toolchain in one class period with remarkably few sharp edges. There's even some fun accidental learning the first time they nano their executable file.

wcarey··on Tell HN: C Experts Panel – Ask us anything about C
I'm teaching C to high schoolers as their first language, which is quite the adventure. Do you have any good advice or resources on how to introduce the way C treats the function stack and heap allocated memory? Most of my students struggle (naturally) with making sense of function scoped identifiers and pass-by-value semantics.
wcarey··on Jim Lehrer’s Rules of Journalism
Fascinatingly, a verdict means “a speaking of the truth”. Courts at least, consider the aim of the jury to speak the truth. So whether John did punch Jack would be an element of the truth of the matter being adjudicated.
← PreviousPage 5 of 6Next →