HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wdaareg

319 karma · joined May 14, 2012

Neeraj Baid, CEO and Co-Founder of fixed fee money transfer service Atlantic Money.
submissionscomments
wdaareg··on Show HN: World’s first £3 flat fee (0% FX markup) money transfer service
FX Prices effectively converge to a single price, because FX is an efficient market with little to no arbitrage that would be visible (thanks to the proprietary trading firms that specialize in it).
wdaareg··on Show HN: World’s first £3 flat fee (0% FX markup) money transfer service
Check out CBOE FX (https://fx.cboe.com/) and EBS (https://www.cmegroup.com/trading/market-tech-and-data-servic...). Settlement and trading of FX may often be OTC, but that doesn't mean there aren't exchanges or aggregated marketplaces.
wdaareg··on Show HN: World’s first £3 flat fee (0% FX markup) money transfer service
Hi dotancohen, we currently support sending GBP from the UK into the following currencies: EUR, USD, AUD, CAD, CZK, DKK, NOK, PLN, SEK. Looking forward to supporting EUR outbound in the near future, and then we'll go from there.
wdaareg··on Show HN: World’s first £3 flat fee (0% FX markup) money transfer service
The business model is that our costs are fixed at much lower than 3GDP, and so we can offer that price profitably.
wdaareg··on Show HN: World’s first £3 flat fee (0% FX markup) money transfer service
Thanks for sharing your story and for the thoughtful feedback BukhariH! We thought a lot about the current players and offerings in the space, and came to similar conclusions about some of the pitfalls.

That being said, we have made two observations that we are looking to explore by launching Atlantic Money:

1. By deliberately going the super-app route, and trying to be something for everyone, super apps are crappy user experiences, and they aren't a very strong business (outside of south-east Asia).

We are looking to be a focused product, and are committing to not building a bunch of additional features into our app over time that customers probably don't want and are likely going to make the experience adversarial.

2. Super apps are not targeted.

We believe that costs can pile up if you don't have a target customer. Our thesis is that we want to be a very good option for customers moving larger sums of money, and we've explicitly focused on that segment in terms of corridors, and our fixed pricing.

We'll see how it goes with the launch, but would welcome any feedback - either here, or feel free to reach out directly.

wdaareg··on Show HN: World’s first £3 flat fee (0% FX markup) money transfer service
1. We follow a "trusted devices" model, where you 2FA using your phone number for the first login on a device. Future logins on that device aren't 2FA'd. I agree that using a code gen is a good improvement we can make over time. 2. Marketing opt-out is prominent in account settings. Any email that is very strictly not transactional is considered marketing by our team, and can be opted out of. Developing simple, focused products is core to our identity and we won't add irrelevant features that might upsell to 10% of customers. I assure you there won't be a "refer your friends" badge blinking on the home page of the app. 3. Unfortunately we're not on web yet - but we'd love to get there after iOS and Android. We hear from most people that iOS or Android are their preferred platforms, so we have to start there. 4. We share data as required to support financial transactions and other core parts of the business, but we do adhere to the GDPR. 5. I think VPNs are allowed - at least I don't think we block them in particular.

We're excited to bring a fresh perspective and better pricing to a landscape with a lot of providers doing approximately the same thing. We'd love for you to try out the app once it's available - if you decide to register on our site we'll be sure to keep you updated.

wdaareg··on Show HN: World’s first £3 flat fee (0% FX markup) money transfer service
On their standard plan, with the first £1k you're not paying for currency conversion, but you're paying a fee for the "international payment". I think that's a 0.3% fee capped at £5, but for a £1k transfer, that's a £3 fee right there. You can see this in their fee structure.

https://www.revolut.com/legal/standard-fees ("A fee applies for international payments on our Standard and Plus plans")

https://assets.revolut.com/legal/terms/International_Payment...

If you're a die-hard Revolut user that subscribes for other reasons or do all your global banking with them, it's possible you'll end up with better overall economics with them. That segment of customers is fairly narrow and we're excited to offer everyone else a world-leading service.

wdaareg··on Show HN: World’s first £3 flat fee (0% FX markup) money transfer service
Each leg of our transaction carries a substantially fixed fee to the business - which is unusual in currency exchange. Having achieved those economics with our partners, we summed them up, added costs for operations and compliance, and added a margin to run our business. That's how we ended up at £3!
wdaareg··on Show HN: World’s first £3 flat fee (0% FX markup) money transfer service
We would absolutely love to. We've started conversations with banks and hope to offer Japanese Yen soon.
wdaareg··on Show HN: World’s first £3 flat fee (0% FX markup) money transfer service
Our customers always get the live exchange rate, direct from the world's biggest currency exchanges. We add zero markup to the rate. So customers really pay just £3.
wdaareg··on Show HN: World’s first £3 flat fee (0% FX markup) money transfer service
Revolut has likely the most complex fee structure I've ever seen. I think their first 1k per month is free, but after that you get charged. They also charge additional fixed fees just for the international payment.

Good luck!

https://assets.revolut.com/legal/terms/International_Payment...

https://www.revolut.com/en-GB/legal/standard-fees/

wdaareg··on Show HN: World’s first £3 flat fee (0% FX markup) money transfer service
Hmm this is a good point. To be honest I was in that bucket for a while too. I think you're right, we'll just need to figure out how to prevent US app store users in the US from getting confused. I would recommend you sign up on the website for now and we'll make sure the app is available in the US app store when the service launches!
wdaareg··on Show HN: World’s first £3 flat fee (0% FX markup) money transfer service
<3
wdaareg··on Show HN: World’s first £3 flat fee (0% FX markup) money transfer service
You can certainly send to companies as well.

Our outbound payments are all domestic bank transfers, so if your Colombian bank can receive a USD ACH payment by routing and account number it should work.

But I'm guessing your USD to Colombia is delivered by international SWIFT wire? The cost of a SWIFT wire is orders of magnitude higher than a domestic bank transfer, and we wouldn't be able to support that in our fixed fee.

wdaareg··on Show HN: World’s first £3 flat fee (0% FX markup) money transfer service
We're fixed fee because we'll charge only £3 regardless of how much you send. If you want to send £2000 on Wise, that fee is doubled. But with us, it's still just £3.
wdaareg··on Show HN: World’s first £3 flat fee (0% FX markup) money transfer service
We're starting with offering services to residents of the UK sending GBP outbound to 9 currencies. We're actively working on our EU license, which will allow residents of UK or EU residence to send GBP or EUR to the currencies we support. We're starting with a particular set of currencies as we're building our network from scratch - it's why our fees are so low!
wdaareg··on Show HN: World’s first £3 flat fee (0% FX markup) money transfer service
We sure aren't! We're tired of seeing traditional players hiding fees in the rate - and we're not about it. Our rate is the interbank rate directly from the world's biggest exchanges. Customers really are paying just £3 to move any amount all the way up to £1 million.
wdaareg··on Show HN: World’s first £3 flat fee (0% FX markup) money transfer service
Global money transfer has to be the place where some companies offer the most opaque fees. It's absurd - and we want to compete hard with those businesses by offering cheaper, simpler, and more transparent services to customers.
wdaareg··on Show HN: World’s first £3 flat fee (0% FX markup) money transfer service
:)
wdaareg··on Show HN: World’s first £3 flat fee (0% FX markup) money transfer service
We're operating a hub-and-spoke model. Our spokes are domestic bank transfers in and out of the currencies we support. And our hub is a centralized counterparty where we convert currency. Then we receive the converted currency in our local bank accounts. That currency conversion counterparty is world-leading in the services they offer to institutions, and we're excited to offer it to consumers for the first time.

We support the fastest possible domestic rails (GBP Faster Payments, EUR SEPA Inst, USD ACH Same Day, etc). Unfortunately most domestic rails aren't instant (like USD) - and we can't make them any faster - but for those that are (like EUR) we support instant transfers.

Our default delivery speed is two business days - this incurs no cost of capital to the business. But we know customers are sometimes transferring money urgently, so we offer an Express delivery. This is instant for EUR and as fast as the schemes support for other currencies. Express incurs a cost of capital equal to the currency forward rate, which is a true uncapped variable cost. So we have to pass that on to customers through a separate fee (0.05%), as it's something our signature fixed fee just can't cover. But it's always optional - and customers can always make a transfer regardless of size for just £3.

wdaareg··on Show HN: World’s first £3 flat fee (0% FX markup) money transfer service
We're starting with GBP → 9 currencies but can't wait to add more corridors. Inbound EUR is next with more coming after. We're starting with a smaller set of currency corridors because we're building this network from scratch - that's why our fees are so low.
wdaareg··on Show HN: World’s first £3 flat fee (0% FX markup) money transfer service
We're hearing average people are most interested in transfers of fiat currency between bank accounts. In our research, we could use crypto in our central treasury for conversion or cross-border transactions, but the fiat ⭤ crypto onramp and offramp steps remain so those transfers are not quite instant or free. But if there's a way to use crypto to make our transfers faster and cheaper, I'm all ears :)
wdaareg··on Show HN: World’s first £3 flat fee (0% FX markup) money transfer service
Great question! We hold rates for customers for up to an hour and customers can only hold one rate at a time, so the risk is minimal - but we do price that risk into our business model.
wdaareg··on Show HN: World’s first £3 flat fee (0% FX markup) money transfer service
We've set up extremely efficient bank transfer and currency conversion infrastructure and we're profitable on every transfer, so i can assure you it's sustainable :)
wdaareg··on Show HN: World’s first £3 flat fee (0% FX markup) money transfer service
We also support instant transfers into EUR - but transferring money across borders instantly requires capital buffer to be held somewhere, which is a true variable cost that the business can't cover with a fixed fee. So there's an additional 0.05% fee for instant transfers. With Wise you're effectively forced to pay that fee. With us, you just pay if you need the urgency, which people don't always need.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2