HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wdutch

293 karma · joined December 13, 2018

submissionscomments
wdutch··on How I program with LLMs
I no longer work in tech, but I still write simple applications to make my work life easier.

I frequently use what OP refers to as chat-driven programming, and I find it incredibly useful. My process starts by explaining a minimum viable product to the chat, which then generates the code for me. Sometimes, the code requires a bit of manual tweaking, but it’s usually a solid starting point. From there, I describe each new feature I want to add—often pasting in specific functions for the chat to modify or expand.

This approach significantly boosts what I can get done in one coding session. I can take an idea and turn it into something functional on the same day. It allows me to quickly test all my ideas, and if one doesn’t help as expected, I haven’t wasted much time or effort.

The biggest downside, however, is the rapid accumulation of technical debt. The code can get messy quickly. There's often a lot of redundancy and after a few iterations it can be quite daunting to modify.

wdutch··on A Student's Guide to Writing with ChatGPT
I imagine maths teachers had a similar dilemma when pocket calculators became widely available.

Now, in the UK students sit 2 different exams: one where calculators are forbidden and one where calculators are permitted (and encouraged). The problems for the calculator exam are chosen so that the candidate must do a lot of problem solving that isn't just computation. Furthermore, putting a problem into a calculator and then double checking the answer is a skill in itself that is taught.

I think the same sort of solution will be needed across the board now - where students learn to think for themselves without the technology but also learn to correctly use the technology to solve the right kinds of challenges and have the skills to check the answers.

People on HN often talk about ai detection or putting invisible text in the instructions to detect copy and pasting. I think this is a fundamentally wrong approach. We need to work with, not against the technology - the genie is out of the bottle now.

As an example of a non-chatgpt way to evaluate students, teachers can choose topics chatgpt fails at. I do a lot of writing on niche topics and there are plenty of topics out there where chatgpt has no clue and spits out pure fabrications. Teachers can play around to find a topic where chatgpt performs poorly.

wdutch··on The English Paradox: Four decades of life and language in Japan
> The notion of “fairness” dominates English education policy in Japan. Because of the importance of educational credentials in Japanese life, any policy that seems to favor one group or another—the rich, the urban, children with highly-educated parents, or children who happen to have acquired English fluency on their own—will attract popular opposition.

I teach ESL in Vietnam. The above quote boggles my mind. I've taught disadvantaged rural students and urban students with educated parents. Of course I tried my absolute best for the rural students, I worked a lot harder for them than for the privileged students. However, it would be madness to hamstring the students who happen to be privileged. Holding the whole country to the lowest common denominator doesn't benefit the country at all.

I thought Vietnam was very Confucian and uniform but Japan seems even more extreme. Maybe Vietnam also applies Marx's doctrine of "From each according to their ability, to each according to their needs" to offset it.

Thanks for your great write up on this topic. This was a very interesting read for me.

wdutch··on What happens in a mind that can't 'see' mental images
I agree that it's a disorder. I have aphantasia and wish I didn't. I have low resilience due to having no ability to go to a "happy place" or recall pleasant memories. I wonder if other aphantasiacs have a similar experience or have figured out other ways to keep their mental health up.

I'd love to see research into if self-reported aphantasia correlates to depression or anxiety.

wdutch··on What happens in a mind that can't 'see' mental images
I have aphantasia. I relate to what you say about how "feel" a face when I remember it. I'd compare it to a neutral nets embedding. I'm not storing every "pixel" of an image but instead a "vector" that corresponds to the key features (although I'm not consciously aware what those features are). I couldn't describe on demand the faces of my colleagues I see every day but I know them when I see them.
wdutch··on A new term, ‘slop’, has emerged to describe dubious A.I.-generated material
I think you're right. Since LLMs went mainstream, I've seen a lot of my colleagues' presentations and thought "was this written by ChatGPT?" but I've come to wonder if it's just given me the frame of mind to identify low-effort slop that lacks any original insight but uses all the right sorts of words and phrases, regardless of if it was authored by a human or not.
wdutch··on Funimation End of Services
They ask themselves the difficult question for every anime: which character will be voiced by Vic Mignogna.
wdutch··on Show HN: I wished for a site with a growing list of math problems, I built it
This is a nice idea, in the past I worked as a maths tutor and was always on the lookout for good problems for students. (Maybe this is possible, I didn't make an account but ...) Seems like the scraped problems are a great starting point for a social platform where users can submit their own problems and upvote/downvote ranking mechanics like reddit, HN etc
wdutch··on Show HN: Interactive AI Resume/LinkedIn for better networking/job hunting
This is a neat project! I did find the UX a big confusing. If I ask "What was your major?" the start of the answer is "Ian Woods graduated ...". But If I ask "What was Ian's major?" I get "no results".

In responds in third person but can't comprehend questions in third person?

wdutch··on China is flooding Taiwan with disinformation
Ah yes that event that famously took place on the island of taiwan....
wdutch··on China is flooding Taiwan with disinformation
> Is it not entirely a chinese matter?

Well, no. It also includes Taiwan.

wdutch··on Japan starts release of Fukushima’s treated radioactive water
China are making a fuss about it but it's just an excuse for geopolitics.
wdutch··on New study measures grammatical complexity of languages
I am familiar with a few south east asian languages and none would have any issue expressing "I will be going to the barbers while I'm in town" ... I think even in English if a second language speaker said "I go to barber while I in town", it's still possible to understand.

Regarding redundancy, I so think that it's important and other languages have other ways of handling it. I know that Vietnamese for example very often doubles up the verbs for example for "help" it's common to say giúp đỡ together although both these words individually also mean help.

wdutch··on Some problems with 'first name' and 'last name' fields in data
Funnily enough, I have the same problem and I'm from the UK. I now live in Southeast Asia where officials will call me by my middle name which is a really weird experience for me.
wdutch··on Learning needs to be effortful to be effective
Thanks for taking the time to write this. Could you recommend any reading material for someone interested in theory of learning?
wdutch··on The kingdom of Bhutan has been quietly mining Bitcoin for years
I'm not sure why they'd be fazed by Taiwan in particular?

I've met several Taiwanese people who have been to Bhutan for tourism and have a favorable view of the country.

wdutch··on Rise of generative AI will be comparable to the rise of CGI in the early 90s
> No first-world company will break the law to save money on artists

If the future of copyright law in the west moves to outlaw use in training data then the west will lose out to companies from China, Vietnam and anywhere else that doesn't care at all about western copyright. I think it will give them a competitive edge.

wdutch··on TikTok has an open computational chemistry position
I wonder if they would leverage users devices for computations, similar to folding@home[0]

0: https://foldingathome.org/?lng=en-US

wdutch··on On the cheap, like a local, and without a lot of luggage
> When I decided to go to Vietnam, everything and everyone told me to go to Ho Chi Minh City. It had better food. More art. More high culture. Less government. So I went to Hanoi.

I'm not sure why the author acts like those are the only 2 options. I spent a year living in Ho Chi Minh city and the vast majority of the city of is not aimed at international people but at the 9 million Vietnamese speakers living there (districts 1, 2 and 7 being the exceptions).

That being said, both HCM and Hanoi are subcultures of their own and don't give any impression of a 'typical' Vietnamese person's experience. If I were to look for a completely ordinary city, I'd pick a random city with a population of around 500,000 and nothing notable on Wikipedia.

wdutch··on The road to Zettalinux
Hi GPT3, I didn't expect to see you here.
wdutch··on I figured out how to get GitHub Copilot to run in the terminal
Thanks for the explanation!
wdutch··on I figured out how to get GitHub Copilot to run in the terminal
Thanks for the explanation!
wdutch··on Worldwide Rail Network Map
Thai is so inconsistently romanized you still might not understand anything! for example bangkok could be Baanggaawk.
wdutch··on I figured out how to get GitHub Copilot to run in the terminal
Could someone explain how? I don't grok the command. My best guess is this relates to hexadecimal.
wdutch··on Ask HN: How do you discover music?
I make extensive use of the Spotify algorithm to discover the music I want to listen to based on my own idea of what it should sound like. For example if I want some music with a house beat but folky feel to it, then I'll create a playlist and 'seed' it with some house music and some folk music; about 10 tracks total. Then I'll scroll to the very bottom of the playlist and go through the Recommended Songs. Spotify is often pretty good at finding an 'average' of the different songs added to the playlist. I add the songs that fit my expectations to the playlist which further refines the recommendations. After I've added about 10 songs I'll remove the songs I used to seed the recommendations.

Sometimes this method doesn't work because maybe the 'average' you're looking for doesn't exist or Spotify hasn't connected the dots. Sometimes a track in the 'seed' can dominate the recommendations so try removing tracks that seem to skew the results or adding more from the opposite genre.

wdutch··on Evaluation of TikTok vs. Instagram Reels
Tangentially related but when I have lived in countries where English isn't the first language I'm amazed how many big companies ignore the language set in my web requests (English) and serves me content in the county's native language. Google for example and they really hide the button to chsngethe language.

I suppose they assume a lot of people have devices incorrectly configured to English but its very frustrating for a tech literate person who travels a lot.

wdutch··on Ancient civilisation under eastern Turkey estimated to be 11k-13k years old
Tangentially, I wasn't aware of Turkey as an exporter of TV until I recently traveled in Cambodia and everyone I spoke to went on about the Turkish dramas they were watching. Thanks for the recommendation! this sounds like a good starting point for me to get into Turkish shows.
wdutch··on How did I get so unhappy working in tech?
Serious question: could someone explain what "framework" means in this context? From context I'm guessing something like a daily routine?
wdutch··on Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will'
> spend the 5 mins dallying on venmo trying to look up their handle, with terrible cell service, and hope you don't misclick on a total stranger who won't return your money if its missent.

I think all your other points are valid but this one is odd to me; it just seems like bad Venmo UI. I've never used Venmo and I live in East Asia where most systems use QR codes to identify the vendor. The chances of sending money to the wrong account is slim to nil and it takes less than a minute. I'm currently sat in a cafe where I can see 5 QR codes lined up on the counter for different apps.

wdutch··on How South Korean TV took over the world
Whether intentional or not this was a great move by Korea for soft power. Where I live people are obsessed with everything Korean; learning the language, buying the fashion and idolizing the idols.
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →