HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

weakfish

1,638 karma · joined April 8, 2020

jack @ weakphi DOT sh
submissionscomments
weakfish··on AI Is Not a Tool
Which is why I wrote

> My original comment may have been a bit sarcastic

Which in retrospect, the original comment was more dismissive than I intended.

That said, I stand by the replied being significantly more rude and aggressive than warranted.

weakfish··on AI Is Not a Tool
I would engage with this if it wasn't written so rudely. I have thoughts on the subject and would like to discuss them in good-faith, but this is not it.

My original comment may have been a bit sarcastic, I admit, but this comment seems to serve no purpose other than to jab and try to dunk on me, so I won't engage.

weakfish··on AI Is Not a Tool
Can you provide links, sources, anything? I genuinely would engage with it, but it's unhelpful to just essentially say "go read the thing I've read and stop being dumb"
weakfish··on Ask HN: If the models are so good, why doesn't OpenAI just start 100 companies?
Notion mail specifically wasn't killed because it got replaced by AI in its niche, moreso that the company is shifting their resources.
weakfish··on AI Is Not a Tool
sigh No, it doesn't have consciousness, nor have human thoughts, etc. We (humans) are just _really_ good at anthromorphizing and pattern-matching. We do it to our animals, assigning human feelings to their expressions, and so of course we'll do it to the tool that outputs in our language.
weakfish··on Ask HN: If the models are so good, why doesn't OpenAI just start 100 companies?
Instead of just making claims back-and-forth, can this thread provide sources? I don't believe either of you without proof.
weakfish··on What shall I teach my son?
Your first point is what I was trying to convey in my parentheses, which is that the world is more peaceful than ever before and yet it feels like it's closing in on us increasingly so due to the vast amount of information thrown at us with no viable way to process it. This, paired with the ever increasing amount of things we are expected to fit in with no reasonable way to do so leads to burnout _Fast_
weakfish··on The Decoherence Trap
They're not better than I am. Faster? Sure. Better? No.
weakfish··on What shall I teach my son?
Speaking as a member of Gen-Z (26) I can confirm that most of my anxiety is not from my hippy parenting, but from an increasingly chaotic world (I mean this in the sense of information overload, not ratio of peaceful times to war time) and dwindling economic opportunity.

I do think that millenial-style parenting has many flaws and is guilty of messing of kids in novel ways, but it's dishonest to say that it's more guilty than social media, stagnating wages, etc.

weakfish··on Anthropic logged net loss of over $80B in first half of 2026
Do you have evidence that Reuters is misleading? Please prove it, otherwise this is just hearsay
weakfish··on The Fatal Flaw of 911
I absolutely agree! Maybe the rest of my comment didn’t emphasize it enough, but that’s exactly where I was going with my point. The incentives and training (or lack thereof) are wholly militarized and not suitable for real community engagement.
weakfish··on How the Claude Code team does code review
That’s a fair interpretation, thanks for the clarification!
weakfish··on How the Claude Code team does code review
> No one cares about good code. It’s a means to an end.

I do, my coworkers do, my friends do, etc etc.

weakfish··on The Fatal Flaw of 911
I think you’re spot on about specialization. Police are chronically under-trained and unequipped to deal with such a broad swathe of what they’re expected to, from speeding tickets to mental health crises. As long as there’s a combination of ill training, high pressure situations, and bad pay, there’s going to be terrible outcomes.

I definitely think that there’s a ton of ways in which the American police state is a horrible shitshow that attracts power-hungry assholes, but I also think that the nature of the job as it is currently set up inevitably will lead to mistakes from cops who wouldn’t have violent behavior otherwise.

That doesn’t excuse it, of course, but it’s important to understand the circumstances that create horrible outcomes.

weakfish··on 90% of US working hours are spent on tasks not covered well by AI benchmarks
Are they free though? You have to pay for inference
weakfish··on 90% of US working hours are spent on tasks not covered well by AI benchmarks
I think you’re assuming the poster genuinely agrees with what they posted, whereas this quote seems to point towards a more devil’s advocate view:

> I'll take you up on that attempt to find a silver lining:

weakfish··on Claude reveals ECDSA curve origins
Video is meant as a joke, it’s common to edit the subtitles of this video to alternate ones
weakfish··on Steam Client is now faster than Epic's new vibe coded launcher
Oh my god I never drew the link between broken windows theory and AI but it perfectly describes the overall lowering of standards
weakfish··on Show HN: Petal, open-source CoScreen/ScreenHero finally free
Thanks for the honesty! I don't blame you, it's hard to write good copy.

Cheers and good luck!

weakfish··on Show HN: Petal, open-source CoScreen/ScreenHero finally free
I really wonder if it’s just me, but I have a deeply visceral reaction to AI copywriting that is largely irrational I’m willing to admit.

> The media server — traffic stays yours

The product looks cool! It’s just… reading that sentence makes me __immediately__ lose all interest.

weakfish··on AI is a tool and using it well takes skill
> As a parallel, once you learn how to drive you stop walking, as for the primary mode of transportation.

If I could, I would certainly walk everywhere.

weakfish··on AI coding agents generate more code, but not more software
> Your best coder is now Opus or Astra

No, that's our _fastest_ coder, which is a different thing than _best_

weakfish··on Meta and Microsoft take steps to reduce employee usage of Claude AI
I think that's a fair prediction, and you're right that there was a curve in 2026.

I do think their definition of profitability is likely skewed, but you're right that 2025 is out-of-date.

I did realize I forgot to link the article sourcing my claim in my above comment, and too late to edit, so here it is: https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/anthropics-ipo-pros...

weakfish··on Meta and Microsoft take steps to reduce employee usage of Claude AI
I'll check w/ archive.ph in a bit, thanks for the tip.

Is the hope for them that they'll outpace their run with a massive revenue growth? I believe that they have that, but numbers like a net loss of $46b in 2025[0] seem hard to overcome.

Re: self-reporting, I'd be inclined to think they're using non-GAAP practices to make it sound more favorable, but I am by no means an expert, so willing to believe I am wrong.

I'll read the article you sent; this is just my off-the-cuff thinking.

weakfish··on Meta and Microsoft take steps to reduce employee usage of Claude AI
Yep. The SaaS-is-doomed crowd are missing this part. It's the Red Hat model (debatable how well they do it, but they exist, so..)
weakfish··on Meta and Microsoft take steps to reduce employee usage of Claude AI
I don't have access to the article linked, but I am default skeptical of any self-reported numbers. They have a financial incentive to play it up.

If you're able to link something non-paywalled, I'd be happy to read thru.

weakfish··on GPT‑6 and Intelligent UI for everyone
I resent the implication that ambition hinges upon using AI for things easily doable without.
weakfish··on GPT‑6 and Intelligent UI for everyone
> THE DINNER LEDGER

> The Check, Please.

> TABLE OF FIVE · ITEMIZED BILL

This is one of my _least_ favorite AI behaviors, I am surprised they left it in the example. This behavior where it insists on putting text everywhere that over-explains the context.

weakfish··on Coding is not solved
I see subtle ones at least daily, misunderstanding a component or hallucination of a spec for something. I’m in blockchain.
weakfish··on Coding is not solved
No, but the authors of $LIBRARY are accountable if it fails
Page 1 of 20Next →