HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

websites2023

263 karma · joined July 10, 2021

submissionscomments
websites2023··on Apple’s Mistake
>As far as I know Android devices do not implement the scheme that Apple is considering.

No, instead they just scan everything you upload to their service: https://support.google.com/transparencyreport/answer/1033093...

websites2023··on Apple’s Mistake
>If not, it will be an interesting test of how many users Apple will lose over this.

Lose.. to whom? PinePhone? Not trying to be flippant, but... there is no longer any option for the common user.

No, my elderly mother is not going to download and flash a custom de-googled ROM for her OnePlus 9 Pro. Pure fantasy that Apple will lose users because of this. This is a nonstory to everyone who lives and works east of Tahoe.

websites2023··on WhatsApp lead and other tech experts fire back at Apple’s Child Safety plan
Become an advertiser. "Selling your data" is a shorthand for what actually goes on: selling your attention based on data that those platforms have on you.

Google does this too. Any brand that relies on advertising instead of sales of its actual hardware is in this game.

websites2023··on One Bad Apple
This basic implementation fact has been misrepresented over and over and over again. Does anyone read anymore? I’m starting to get really concerned. The hacker community is where I’ve turned to be more informed, away from the clickbait. But I’m being let down.
websites2023··on The Problem with Perceptual Hashes
Presumably she wasn’t his wife then. But also people have various arrangements so I’m not here to shame.
websites2023··on An Open Letter Against Apple's Privacy-Invasive Content Scanning Technology
> Future US politicians could easily be blackmailed by the non-illegal content on their phones. This is a jeopardy to our democracy.

US politicians should not be using normie clouds full stop. This is a risk and always has been.

websites2023··on An Open Letter Against Apple's Privacy-Invasive Content Scanning Technology
> Partly it falls under the supposition of "if they can, they will".

Hm. But there are many millions of things Apple could do, but haven’t, because it would hurt their business model. So how would what you are proposing they will do help their business model?

> Which means they need some kind of tech to detect "naked" pictures, locally, across encrypted channels, in order to block them.

I know you know this is the case, but to make it clear for anyone reading: Apple is not blocking nude pictures in the kids filter. It’s blurring and giving a message. Again I ask: why would using this technology on non-nude stuff benefit Apple?

Are we worried about Apple or are we worried about the government forcing Apple to do things that this technology enables?

websites2023··on An Open Letter Against Apple's Privacy-Invasive Content Scanning Technology
I also believe Apple doesn't really want to scan your photos on their servers. I believe their competitors do, and they consider this compromise (scan on device with hashes) is their way of complying with CSAM demands while still maintaining their privacy story.
websites2023··on An Open Letter Against Apple's Privacy-Invasive Content Scanning Technology
>iCloud photos are encrypted, so scanning has to happen on device.

Is this true? I feel like Apple benefits from the confusion about "Encrypted at rest" + "Encrypted in transit" and "E2E Encrypted". It's my understanding that Apple could scan the photos in iCloud, since they have the decryption keys, but they choose not to, as a compromise.

I'm keying into this because this document: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202303 doesn't show Photos as part of the category of data that "Apple doesn't have access to." That's mentioned only in the context of the E2E stuff.

websites2023··on An Open Letter Against Apple's Privacy-Invasive Content Scanning Technology
>It's fine to be worried about the second one, but it's wrong to conflate the two.

Agreed, and just to be clear, I'm worried about that too. It just appears that we (myself and the objectors) have different lines. If Apple were to scan devices in the US and prevent them from sharing memes over iMessage, that would cross a line for me and I'd jump ship. But preventing CSAM stuff from getting on their servers seems fine to me.

websites2023··on An Open Letter Against Apple's Privacy-Invasive Content Scanning Technology
>They already scanning all of the photos up on iCloud already

I can't find a source for this. Do you happen to have one?

It seems to me that Apple doesn't want to host CSAM on their servers, so they're scanning your device so that if it does get uploaded, they can remove it and then ban you.

They're not scanning all photos on iCloud, as far as I can tell.

websites2023··on An Open Letter Against Apple's Privacy-Invasive Content Scanning Technology
> The obvious conclusion is Apple will start to scan photos kept on device, even where iCloud is not used.

Why is this the obvious conclusion?

websites2023··on Apple's plan to “think different” about encryption opens a backdoor to your life
Both the US government and Chinese government can get whatever they want from both iCloud and IMessage. Best not to use it for anything that could make you a target of theirs.
websites2023··on An Open Letter Against Apple's Privacy-Invasive Content Scanning Technology
It’s astounding how many very smart people are getting this wrong.

Perhaps I missed it, but does anywhere on this letter mention that that both of these features are optional?

CSAM depends on using iCloud Photos. Don’t rent someone else’s computer if you don’t want them to decide what you can put on it.

Content filter for iMessages is for kids accounts only, and can be turned off. Or, even better: skip iMessages for Signal.

websites2023··on Apple's plan to “think different” about encryption opens a backdoor to your life
The US has a rather weak central government. The Chinese-style social credit system isn't necessary, because private corporations already do it. Scanning your ID when you return things, advertising profiles, etc.
websites2023··on Apple's plan to “think different” about encryption opens a backdoor to your life
I kind of agree with you there. Isn't it just another toggle? Surely if the entire feature is opt-in, the blurring could be a toggle, as well as the notification.
websites2023··on Apple's plan to “think different” about encryption opens a backdoor to your life
Parents cannot be notified when a child between the ages of 13 and 17 views a blurred photo, though children that are between those ages will still see the warning about sensitive content if Communication Safety is turned on.
websites2023··on Apple's plan to “think different” about encryption opens a backdoor to your life
Parents need to expressly opt in to Communication Safety when setting up a child's device with Family Sharing, and it can be disabled if a family chooses not to use it.
websites2023··on Apple's plan to “think different” about encryption opens a backdoor to your life
The feature is opt-in. So, Apple isn't forcing anyone to do anything.
websites2023··on Apple's plan to “think different” about encryption opens a backdoor to your life
Apple's battle is against Surveillance Capitalism, not against state-level surveillance. In fact, there is no publicly traded company that is against state-level surveillance. It's important not to confuse the two.

Think of it this way: If you want to hide from companies, choose Apple. If you want to hide from the US Government, choose open source.

But if your threat model really does include the US government or some other similarly capable adversary, you are well and truly fucked already. The state-level apparatus for spying on folks through metadata and traffic interception is now mode than a decade old.

websites2023··on NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings
> 2. You have fears about the privacy implications. If so, what are those fears? Perhaps your vaccination status can lead people to make inferences about your health?

That it won’t stop at this. That I’m going to have to entrust my medical information to a shitty app that requires access to my location and contacts to show a QR code that links to a poorly secured database that will get hacked, all because the government doesn’t trust me when I say I got the vaccine.

websites2023··on Life before smartphones (2020)
I think that was meant to call out the highly modified people that are shown on Instagram. I don't use Instagram, so that comment stuck out to me as well, but I see where the author is coming from.
websites2023··on Most People Don't Understand How Bad Climate Change Already Is
>Life isn't a constant slow march upwards towards prosperity, it is messy. There is change, there always has been change and there always will be.

This is really, really hard to understand for people today because the post-cold-war era, in the west, has been one of unprecedented stability and prosperity. That is ending, and what is happening is a reversion to the mean that looks a lot like catastrophe.

websites2023··on The coded words of job adverts that reveal important clues
As an interviewer, I always have the candidate’s resume in front of me. I read from it, and reference it directly. As an interviewee, I do the same thing with the job description. When it comes time for me to get my questions in as a candidate, I get clarification on what some words mean in the context of the role. I declined to move forward for a role at Amazon because it was clear the interviewers were not familiar with the JD and I consider this a major red flag, especially for a place like Amazon that has extensive interviewer training.

When I write JDs, I look at every word and ensure my HMs really mean what they say. I reject boilerplates when they don’t fit.

I consider these essential to preventing mishires, which are expensive to correct and a terrible experience for the candidate.

websites2023··on Duolingo reaches $6.5B valuation on day of IPO
Everything you say is true, which is why when I talk about language learning, I discourage people from setting fluency as their goal. Just knowledge of another language is good for the brain, and the fact that you can't become a native speaker should not deter anyone from trying it for fun.
websites2023··on WeChat suspends new user registration for security compliance
The registration is cut off for now. The point I was making was that this probably doesn’t have much impact on the usage. If you didn’t have it before, you’re probably reliant on someone else with it and that’s just getting extended by a few weeks.
websites2023··on WeChat suspends new user registration for security compliance
No idea why you’re being downvoted. This is 100% correct, China requires party members to be on the boards of companies and Xi is the head of the party.
websites2023··on WeChat suspends new user registration for security compliance
Well, luckily babies are are too young to use WeChat and won’t be old enough by early August for this to impact them.
websites2023··on WeChat suspends new user registration for security compliance
How many native Chinese don’t have WeChat already? WeChat has 1.2B users. China has 1.4B people. I suspect the rest are too old or too young. Basically, it’s impossible to operate in a city without it.
websites2023··on Sheriff’s Office letter targets residents for ‘increased accountability’
This is precisely why I voted against abolishing cash bail in California last year. Because they were going to replace it with some "algorithm." I hate cash bail, I think it's garbage, but this black box approach is worse.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →