HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

whoisyc

192 karma · joined May 6, 2025

submissionscomments
whoisyc··on Facebook is asking to use Meta AI on photos you haven’t yet shared
I haven’t used Facebook in years and I don’t think I will ever pick it up again. But I also don’t think “just quit facebook, bro” is an effective pitch to the average person.

Facebook (and other Meta properties) has sadly become the only popular channel for many sorts of offline activities. The average local sports group, DIY group, parents group, outdoors group etc around me are all on Facebook. The average musician and local business is on Instagram. Not to mention the millions in Europe and Latin America who only use WhatsApp for online communication.

Which is to say for many people the choice is not between Facebook and no Facebook. Their choice is between Facebook and inability to participate in their communities. Yes this sucks, but this is the reality. You cannot ask individuals to make expensive individual decisions to solve a society-wide problem. Instead you should look for regulations, and start building reasonable alternative to facebook and make it palatable to the average person.

You mentioned tobacco and gambling and I think they are actually apt examples of why the change must happen at the society level. Tobacco usage plummeted after decades of anti-tobacco education, smoking bans, advertising bans etc. And we also don’t just ask people to stop smoking, we prescribe nicotine patches to make it easier to quit. Similar for gambling. We don’t just ask people to not gamble, we regulate the industry (or outright ban it) and even in places where gambling is legal and prevalent there are still regulations like making it possible to ban yourself from gambling if it is becoming a problem.

whoisyc··on Why is the Rust compiler so slow?
Just like every submission about C/C++ gets a comment about how great Rust is, every submission about Rust gets a comment about how great Zig is. Like a clockwork.

Edit: apparently I am replying to the main Zig author? Language evangelism is by far the worst part of Rust and has likely stirred up more anti Rust sentiment than “converting” people to Rust. If you truly care for your language you should use whatever leverage you have to steer your community away from evangelism, not embrace it.

whoisyc··on Kid gamers to adult gamblers? Investigation of childhood gaming and YA gambling
The entire skin gambling scene is a big reason why I don’t touch the game anymore. It seeps into everything around CS and now you can’t watch a professional match without seeing a sponsorship from a skin casino, can’t watch a YouTube video without a sponsorship.

This is also why I don’t like the way some gamers treat Valve as the only ethical company in the industry. CS skin gambling is like what if you take the lootbox mechanism and pave it over the game’s entire ecosystem.

whoisyc··on Writing toy software is a joy
In the past you looking around documentation, SO answers etc would have hopefully helped you learn more about the tools and develop skills required to independently analyze the pros and cons. If you ask an LLM (or a search engine or a colleague) and take their words as the ground truth then you won’t develop the skills. Worst, sooner or later no one will have enough knowledge nor analytic skill to form an opinion on any sufficiently deep subject and they will all be dependent on corporate chatbots to spoon feed them information that may or may not be biased in a way against your interest. Now imagine if ChatGPT tells you to use azure and Gemini tells you to use GCP…
whoisyc··on Game Hacking – Valve Anti-Cheat (VAC)
There are countries that believed farming should not be profit oriented and curiously they happen to be the ones to have breadlines.

It is no coincidence that America and Japan, the two countries with the most draconian copyright protections, continue to be the dominant player in the game industry.

Profit motive and the ability to reinvest previous profits into future products is the greatest force multiplier in our planet’s history bar none. You can either suck it up like China did in the 90s and convert to a capitalist economy, or stay in the breadline forever. Oh, in this case, I mean play tux racer forever :P

whoisyc··on The magic of through running
Not in Tokyo. All but the first two of Tokyo’s subway lines run on overhead wires. In fact they had to build most of the subway lines to suburban rail standards because they planned on operating through services in the beginning.
whoisyc··on The magic of through running
Once upon a time you could take a train on the Chicago loop, ride it through the countryside at 90mph, and end up on the streets of Milwaukee like a streetcar.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electroliner

It sounds crazy to say now but America used to have the best passenger rail infrastructure in the world.

whoisyc··on From SDR to 'Fake HDR': Mario Kart World on Switch 2
I am not a Nintendo fan (I do have a Switch 1) but this article is the first time I learned Nintendo added HDR graphics the the Switch 2 and this thread is the first time I learned HDR was actually being marketed. I genuinely doubt most Nintendo customers know about these features. It isn’t like Nintendo takes pride in technically impressive graphics anyway.
whoisyc··on No Hello
This is why emoji responses on Slack are so useful. You can ask others to affirmatively confirm that they have read a message and they can make the confirmation without clogging up the channel with tons of text messages.

And no “read receipt” as it is usually implemented would not cut it, because it only means “this message showed up on the recipient’s screen once” not that they have actually read it.

whoisyc··on WhatsApp introduces ads in its app
Kagi has a little over 50k paying users.

Hacker news has 5 million monthly unique users [1].

Given how hacker news constantly complain about google’s decline and the constant virtue signaling on the need to pay for software, you would expect a sizable chunk of the users (the vocal ones, at least) here pay for Kagi. And yet we are here. GP is absolutely right about it being all-talk.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33454140

whoisyc··on WhatsApp introduces ads in its app
Thanks to Australian customer protection laws, Steam has some of the most lenient refund policies among digital software stores. You can usually get a full refund if your play time is less than a few hours. Plus there are frequent sales. Don’t underestimate the psychological impact of making people feel “I have to buy this now or the deal will be gone.”

I genuinely do not know how to get a refund from the google play store or the apple equivalent.

(The downside of the Steam policy is it makes Steam unviable for games that can be played in full very quickly. Develops can also game the system by dragging out early game so the player is over the refundable time by the time they reach the rough parts. But this is for another discussion.)

whoisyc··on Studio Ghibli marks 40 years, but future looks uncertain
Shinkai is an one trick pony whose one and only plot is teenage longing and whose one and only visual language is coating everything in a shiny glittery glow so he can hide the emptiness of his movies under it. His works are nothing but one aesthetic remade and remastered over and over, but sadly plenty of people do not engage with works of art beyond their aesthetics and here we are. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
whoisyc··on Show HN: Meow – An Image File Format I made because PNGs and JPEGs suck for AI
> webp, jpeg 2000, HEIF, jpeg xl, farbfeld

I think you just illustrated how difficult it is to propose a new standard. Webp was not supported by many image related softwares (including the Adobe suite!) for years and earned a bad reputation, HEIF is also poorly supported, JPEG XL was removed from Chrome despite being developed by Google and not supported by any other browser AFAIK. Never heard of farbfeld before.

If the backing from Apple and Google was not enough to drive the adoption of an image format, I fail to see how this thing can go anywhere.

whoisyc··on Show HN: Meow – An Image File Format I made because PNGs and JPEGs suck for AI
This assumes people training AI are going to put in the efforts to extract metadata from a poorly specified “format” with a barely coherent buzzword ridden README file. Realistically, they will just treat any .meow as opaque binary blobs and any png as regular png file.
whoisyc··on Canyon.mid
This.

The same drive for betterment that made our species “kill such beautiful minimalism” was the one that lifted billions out of subsistence farming and 50% infant death rate, and will be the one to escape the destruction of planet earth by sun’s evolution. You cannot have one without the other.

whoisyc··on Waymo rides cost more than Uber or Lyft and people are paying anyway
1950: cars give you the freedom to go anywhere you want. Artificial fertilizer puts an end to hunger in industrialized world. Yeehaw!

2000: you are a second class citizen who can’t even get a job in many places if you do not have a car. Also the median person is overweight. But here is this new internet thing that lets you get everything you need in life sorted out with no need for human interactions. Yeehaw!

2025: the average person can no longer hold a conversation with a stranger for five seconds without having an anxiety attack. Oops!

whoisyc··on Next.js 15.1 is unusable outside of Vercel
They exert immense influence over the React ecosystem, even its documentation.

Example:

https://react.dev/learn/creating-a-react-app

If you are new to React and just figuring out how to get it running, you will likely end up on this page. The first recommendation is Next.js.

The real best way for a beginner to start is IMO Vite. Comes with everything you need to get started and lets you choose what to do next. Curiously, the link to Vite only appears at the very bottom of the page and is implied to be only for those not already served by other options. Wink wink nudge nudge.

whoisyc··on Dolly Parton's Dollywood Express
It is funny the author chose Denmark as an example because Greenland is technically a territory of the Kingdom of Denmark, and with Greenland included the Kingdom of Denmark has a population density of 2.68 per km^2.

Does this mean it is not worthwhile to build public transit in the European part of Denmark? If not, then why does the population density of the entire US matter in a discussion about Tennessee, a state 80% denser than the American average?

By the way, Finland has both a smaller economy and a way lower population density (18.4 per km^2) than Denmark and the US. Would railways be not useful in Finland because of that?

whoisyc··on AlphaWrite: AI that improves at writing by evolving its own stories
There is no answer to the question “what Joyce would have done…”. None. Nil. They are dead and anything done it their name is by definition not what they would have done, but what future generations who are convinced that they know better than the men themselves did.

It is better to leave unanswerable questions unanswered.

I am not against LLM technologies in general. But this trend of using LLMs to give a seemingly authoritative and conclusive answer to questions where no such thing is possible is dangerous to our society. We will see an explosion of narcissistic disorders as it becomes easier and easier to construct convincing narratives to cocoon yourself in, and if you dare questioning them they will tell you how the LLM passed X and Y and Z benchmarks so they cannot be wrong.

whoisyc··on Online sports betting: As you do well, they cut you off
While I am generally against gambling and would like to see more social and legislative action against it, I would advise against forming opinions based on news pieces like the one you mentioned in the beginning of your post, because news has a bias towards reporting only the most extreme events without giving you the full picture of how prevalent (or not) they actually are.

If anything news is like a mirror image of gambling. People vastly overestimate how likely they will hit a jackpot the same way they vastly overestimate how likely they will die in a plane crash.

whoisyc··on Mario Kart designers had to rethink everything to make it open world
What’s the reason for Need for Speed Underground 2 (2003) to be open world?

What’s the need for Forza Horizon (2012) to be open world?

whoisyc··on Mario Kart designers had to rethink everything to make it open world
The complaints are likely coming from heavy gamers who are more exposed to game prices because they buy more games and are also way more vocal online. Nintendo sold 151 million switches but only 1,391 million games [1], meaning on average a Nintendo switch user bought less than ten games. I doubt spending maybe an extra $20 a year would be considered unacceptable by the average Nintendo customer especially considering these games are never cheap to begin with.

[1] https://www.nintendo.co.jp/ir/en/finance/hard_soft/index.htm...

whoisyc··on My five-year experiment with UTC
IMO the best argument for time zones is it keeps calendar days roughly[1] aligned with “natural” days, such that day changes happen when it’s dark outside and most people[2] are asleep and most people won’t be entering a new day during a work meeting.

Why? Because it is confusing if most people’s natural days are divided into different calendar days. If I wake up and the calendar says Tuesday, then I can be sure that I don’t need to worry about the dental appointment on Wednesday afternoon. But if Wednesday starts midday, then I have to spend extra brain cycles to work out which parts of my natural day belong to Tuesday and which parts are Wednesday. It’s a lot of hassle avoided by having days change over when I’m asleep.

If you want real life example of such confusions, look up “early morning flight confusion” on your favourite search engine. It turns out a lot of people are confused by flight times like “Wednesday 1:20am”, because if you are catching an 1:20am flight, you are heading to the airport on the previous day before midnight, and mentally the flight feels like a part of the previous “natural” day. What sometimes happens is people will book a flight on Wednesday 1:20am, head to the airport on Wednesday evening because they think “well the flight is on Wednesday right”, and find out that it is actually Thursday after midnight.

By the way, one successful attempt at addressing this problem is Japanese late night anime schedules. If an anime is aired on Wednesday 1:20am, the TV station will instead write “Tuesday 25:20” on the schedule. It makes no sense from a technical point of view, but feels right for the human because what is the early morning of Wednesday if not just Tuesday night prolonged?

[1] Even extreme cases like Spain are only a couple of hours out of sync, it’s not like the sun shines on Madrid during “midnight”.

[2] the article mentions remote workers and frequent travelers, which I am willing to wager are a tiny (but over represented in nerd spaces) fraction of the society.

whoisyc··on Using lots of little tools to aggressively reject the bots
1. I fear you may be underestimating the volume of bot traffic websites are now receiving. I recommend reading this article to get an idea of the scale of the problem: https://thelibre.news/foss-infrastructure-is-under-attack-by...

2. Not all requests are created equal. 20 requests a second for the same static HTML file? No problem. But if you have, say, a release page for an open source project with binary download links for all past versions for multiple platforms, each one being a multi megabyte blob, and a scraper starts hitting these links, you will run into bandwidth problems very quickly, unless you live in a utopia where bandwidth is free.

3. You are underestimating the difficulty of caching dynamic pages. Cache invalidation is hard, they say. One notably problematic example is Git blames. So far I am not aware of any existing solution for caching blames, and jury rigging your own will likely not be any easier than the “solution” explored in the TFA.

whoisyc··on Why old games never die, but new ones do
You are proving GP and OP’s point. CS 1.6 was an exceptionally popular game in the GoldSrc days and that is why it survived and was chosen by you as an example. That is an exception not the norm. Plenty of FPSs from the same generation have been forgotten. How many people out there are still playing Day of Defeat? Or Counter Strike Condition Zero? Or any of the old Delta Force games? Or Daikatana (except for the lol factor?)

I don’t even think you can easily find people to play on pre-1.6 versions of CS these days, even though when I played CS on LAN I had friends who believed CS 1.5 to be the better version and insisted that we play that instead.

whoisyc··on Gandi March 9, 2025 incident postmortem
A quick whois lookup of ycombinator.com returned the following:

   Domain Name: YCOMBINATOR.COM
   Registry Domain ID: 147225527_DOMAIN_COM-VRSN
   Registrar WHOIS Server: whois.gandi.net
   Registrar URL: http://www.gandi.net
   Updated Date: 2025-02-14T02:53:36Z
   Creation Date: 2005-03-20T23:51:07Z
But yes, I would not use Gandi in 2025, unless someone is pointing a gun at my head and making me choose between Gandi and GoDaddy...
← PreviousPage 2 of 2