HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

whydoyoucare

295 karma · joined December 26, 2018

submissionscomments
whydoyoucare··on U.S. Rep. Angie Craig drops college requirement for staffers
Add to that, let's assume college education is made affordable, will your position still remain the same?
whydoyoucare··on U.S. Rep. Angie Craig drops college requirement for staffers
For any hiring, there is required to be a minimum baseline. That has been college education so far, since it yields consistent and repeatable results (less work for hiring managers when they know someone has a 4 year engineering degree, as opposed to someone who has been educated in the school of life, don't you think?)

However way you look at it, hiring managers are going to require some baseline. What that baseline should be is debatable, and you can actually expand it to include trades like plumbing and electrical (many requirements do that).

But removing the college education requirement entirely is basically (a) increasing the burden on hiring manager, and (b) solving the wrong problem.

The real problem highlighted by the article is cost of college education, which needs to be addressed. Instead the proposal is let's hire highschool dropouts.

Let me ask this -- if college education is made affordable, will your position still be the same?

whydoyoucare··on U.S. Rep. Angie Craig drops college requirement for staffers
Can you substantiate your "value of a college education has approached zero" statement with data please?
whydoyoucare··on U.S. Rep. Angie Craig drops college requirement for staffers
By eliminating the requirement, the exact thing you lament about has been legalized. Now they have taken away whatever power we had as citizens to demand changes.
whydoyoucare··on U.S. Rep. Angie Craig drops college requirement for staffers
It is rare to gain relevant work experience without having a basic framework for the said work, and consistency to measure that basic framework from a pool of candidates, both which come from college/university education.

Equivalency can be established for senior positions, not entry level ones. I assume the staffers do have entry level positions. Can a plumber or an electrician claim to possess experience to become a staffer? I doubt it.

What is going to happen is most staffing positions will be filled by senior work equivalency, while entry level positions will be eliminated. Fast forward a few decades, and there will be no eligible candidates for staffer positions.

whydoyoucare··on U.S. Rep. Angie Craig drops college requirement for staffers
University education has a been a "baseline" to determine qualified candidates. It also sorta implies broadened horizons, overall mature thought process, and several other qualities that are desirable the advisors/staffers.

What other alternatives exists to University education that impart the same level of knowledge and understanding to an individual that can be consistently measured?

If education is expensive, then making it less expensive seems to be the natural solution than eliminating its requirement. Seems this is another virtue signaling in the name of equity that is taking the country back than forward. Reminds me of UCs' eliminating SAT in the name of equity, or how Palo Alto and Culver City (both in California) eliminated AP (Advanced Placement) courses because not everyone can take those.

whydoyoucare··on OpenBSD: Malloc leak detection available in -current
Yes, httpd. https://man.openbsd.org/httpd.8
whydoyoucare··on NPR quits Twitter after being labeled as 'state-affiliated media'
While I don't have proof, I believe the screaming of NPR about this issue was deliberate (yet again) attempt at painting Musk as the "Evil Overlord" about to destroy the very fabric of fairness, democracy and society.

And I never implied NPR cannot or should not leave if they disagree. The BBC example was simply drawing parallels with someone who made no stink about this and chose to stay. To my knowledge, there was no attempt from NPR to have that label corrected, which seems to be the first logical step.

Off topic, I never found NPR to be neutral or unbiased. They are great pretenders of neutrality though.

whydoyoucare··on NPR quits Twitter after being labeled as 'state-affiliated media'
If NPR is really concerned about getting balanced news to the masses, then their decision to quit twitter, in the lack of an alternative and equivalent platform, seems short-sighted and more like a temper tantrum of a kindergartner, than that of a thoughtful and mature news organization.

It also reinforces the conspiracy theories that they were never truly independent. By making a stinker about this issue, they are trying to paint Musk as the evil overlord hell bent on strangling anyone he dislikes. NYT, WaPo and other leftist media outlets are going to join (yet again) this bandwagon, guaranteed.

Did BBC quit? No.

NPR, grow up, be an adult.

whydoyoucare··on Garum Masala
Thanks, and yes, the title caught me off guard until I realized it was fish sauce as opposed to the hot spice (garam masala).
whydoyoucare··on India’s Tigers Bounce Back
Ah, see that's how we indulge in "planet destroying" activities - by associating that guilt with someone else. :)
whydoyoucare··on Our Man in Ajmer
I had the same feeling, the review is fantastic!
whydoyoucare··on We updated our RSA SSH host key
Very cogent explanation, and an important point that you highlight - factual real-world risk/threat model is far more important than hypothetical "the-world-is-burning" scenarios.

Having a correct threat model is the first step towards building reasonable security controls. But far too many are willing to pander to the "It rather involved being on the other side of this airtight hatchway" [0] scenarios.

[0] https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20060508-22/?p=31...

whydoyoucare··on Amazon doubling down on return to office
Heck no, as long as human minds are corruptible, unions will decimate the group they are designed to protect.
whydoyoucare··on Docker is deleting Open Source organisations - what you need to know
Profitable today. Moving from docker to github is just kicking the can down the road.
whydoyoucare··on Cheering Silicon Valley Bank Bailout, Gavin Newsom Doesn’t Mention He’s a Client
Thanks for the pointer, and I confess I overlooked that part.

That said, I hope my faith in the people making this call is not misplaced, though at some level I feel tormented because this does not seem fair. Only time will tell.

whydoyoucare··on Cheering Silicon Valley Bank Bailout, Gavin Newsom Doesn’t Mention He’s a Client
It is about legality, not morality.

Rescuing depositors by ignoring FDIC limits is violating the law. From the FDIC page: "Depositors should note that federal law expressly limits the amount of insurance the FDIC can pay to depositors when an insured bank fails, and no representation made by any person or organization can either increase or modify that amount." [1]

[1] https://www.fdic.gov/resources/deposit-insurance/brochures/i...

whydoyoucare··on Cheering Silicon Valley Bank Bailout, Gavin Newsom Doesn’t Mention He’s a Client
Nobody pays out money for uninsured goods. Making the depositors whole is sending a signal that (a) FDIC insurance limits are worthless and can be ignored, (b) Depositors can continue to be callous in their financial behavior, and (c) Banks can take known-stupid risks, worst case the bank will collapse, but depositor money is rock solid safe.

While a company parking millions of dollars will require several accounts to meet that FDIC limit, having two to five accounts at separate banks is certainly not out of reach for almost all institutional depositors. Spreading risk, that simple.

(Again, all this is hindsight, and I am not exactly privy to what forced startups to park their funds in a single bank, so take my commentary with that grain/rock of salt).

whydoyoucare··on Cheering Silicon Valley Bank Bailout, Gavin Newsom Doesn’t Mention He’s a Client
Any rescue beyond the $250K insured limit is basically tempting other banks to take similar risks in the future. It is a bad omen for the American financial machinery.

And I sincerely hope I am wrong on this count, and this is just an outlier...

whydoyoucare··on The FBI now recommends using an ad blocker when searching the web
I use https://oisd.nl/ which has reasonably curated list on my router with unbound. Works pretty good.
whydoyoucare··on Bankman-Fried, others made 300 illegal political donations, new indictment says
What prevents the US from having a Voter ID card like India does? A unique ID that is required to vote. That way, you only qualify to vote if you have a Voter ID, and once you turn the age of voting, you must get a Voter ID, like you got your SSN. For those who vote by mail, include a copy of your Voter ID with the ballot.

That will significantly reduce, if not eliminate, most of the fraud and put this argument to rest.

whydoyoucare··on The age of cargo cult Agile must end
Your last statement is insightful. Thank you.

The major problem facing the industry is doing agile just because everyone is doing it, not because it is the right tool for the job. No matter how much money or people you throw at it, it's not going to work.

whydoyoucare··on Unix Edition Zero (1971)
I find reading the scan of the manual more pleasant and nostalgic than the troff version! Haha.
whydoyoucare··on The Future of Thunderbird
Does Thunderbird even exist today? I moved away from it a long time ago, the sluggishness was a big turn off and it never improved. When I discovered sylpheed and then claws-mail, it was bye-bye TB.

Of course now that I am old, mutt has become my preferred MUA. Does email pretty well, and keeps away from a lot of modern overhead.

whydoyoucare··on We come to bury ChatGPT, not to praise it
ChatGPT is a credible BS generator (something that I made up reading your post). :-)
whydoyoucare··on Easter egg in flight path of last 747 delivery flight
I don't think "working for a paycheck" necessarily implies one is not trying his/her best. Also the sense of success may not even depend on "success at work". Being successful and trying their best is far more nuanced than usually made out to be.
whydoyoucare··on Twitterrific has been discontinued
Either way, and I am absolutely not in a position to draw any conclusion about any customer who requests or does not request a refund.
whydoyoucare··on Wyoming senators want to phase out sales of EVs
Or they don't wish to buy an EV. The choice should remain. Someone supporting a ban on gas vehicles because it is harmful to the environment, should also be ready to support similar bans on cigarettes, alcohol and fast food, because they are directly harmful to us.
whydoyoucare··on Pi-hole: Network-wide ad blocking
There are no dumb tvs' sold on the market anymore.
whydoyoucare··on On the Joy of Reading Slowly
Exactly my thoughts. The first four paras are the only useful part of the article, everything else is advertising tons of books.

On the other hand, the comments here are worth reading as always. :-)

← PreviousPage 2 of 8Next →