HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

widdershins

927 karma · joined January 31, 2013

submissionscomments
widdershins··on Will Wright on designing user interfaces to simulation games (1996)
A well-designed digital rotary knob isn't too hard to use - but it must be set by simply dragging up and down, not in a rotary motion, which is very unnatural with a mouse. They remain popular in audio software not just because of skeuomorphism (though that doubtless plays a role) but because they are a space-efficient way of putting lots of controls on a page. Audio software is usually highly parametric, so that's important.

Even though I understand this need, I'm still very keen on audio software that tries to break out of the 'everything is a knob' paradigm when it makes sense.

widdershins··on Japan's hydrogen strategy does nothing for decarbonisation: study
> behind each wind turbine field there is a very real gas turbine or lignite power plant

But isn't it still better to be using wind turbines 75% of the time when it's windy, and gas/coal only 25% of the time when it's not? Surely even without adequate battery storage that's an improvement?

widdershins··on Using Rust at a startup: A cautionary tale
> Speed in programming never matters except in the systems space. No one is gonna be able to tell Rust vs Go in a web API

Speed equals money. The same app running at twice the speed uses half the compute resources. You may also gain a lot of simplicity if you don't need to distribute your architecture so early on.

widdershins··on The Age of PageRank Is Over
I pay for YouTube too. Between that and Kagi search, it's ~$20 per month. Which seems crazy in today's environment of 'everything free'. But seriously, I use these both all day for both work and play, but I only watch an hour of Netflix a day. So which is really more valuable?

I agree that on the whole, people will continue to go for the free option, but I'm just glad that some options are appearing to pay, which rebalances the incentives a bit.

widdershins··on The Age of PageRank Is Over
I've been using Kagi the last few months. I've never had a reason to complain about its search results - they seem to work plenty well enough day to day that I don't really 'notice' them. Like most, I now search reflexively, as an extension of the mind, so I only 'notice' search when it's bad.

What really excites me is that is that I'm paying them. That sounds odd, but seriously. It's incredibly refreshing to know that the company providing my search results has an incentive to make things better for _me_ and not a legion of advertisers. With Google I can't help thinking about every keypress being logged to optimize sales pitches at me. I just don't feel that with Kagi, because I'm paying them.

Sure, they might be logging every keypress (I don't actually think they are, but you never can tell) but even if they were, I could be reasonably certain they were doing it to retain my subscription, which probably means making my search better, not selling me other stuff.

It's a priveleged position to be in, and the economic argument isn't watertight, but in the "search as a brain extension" space it still _feels_ premium, because it creates trust. And that frees up brain space for other things - like where the hell was that article I was looking for?

widdershins··on Ask HN: Am I getting older or did typing on the iPhone become unbearable?
Yes! And ill to I'll, or the other way around. It's driving me bonkers.
widdershins··on Show HN: Filesystem Watcher
Looks great! I'm wondering what operating systems are supported. I'm assuming Linux. What about macOS and Windows?
widdershins··on Something I implemented today: “is void”
No, the idea is to build a 'bubble' of new code that isn't subject to all the backwards-compatible flaws of the old syntax. It's just an experiment for now.
widdershins··on Introducing Svelte, and Comparing Svelte with React and Vue (2021)
Surely any reasonably smart React dev will become productive within a very short period of time? Or is it that people simply don't apply when they see Svelte on the tech list?
widdershins··on Crystal Programming Language
Ah, that's interesting information. I've been a (paid) user of Kagi these last few weeks and I'm really enjoying its snappiness.

Of course, no ads or trackers must help - when I look at the Network tab in developer tools the comparison with a google search is stark. ~4 requests vs. google's ~50.

widdershins··on Stable Diffusion is a big deal
Although it's likely that the images that appear online will be peoples' favourites of many candidates, also likely developed through many steps of AI tweaking. So that's still a useful signal for another AI to consume.
widdershins··on The Jank Language: LLVM Hosted Clojure
I'll be curious to see what the performance comparisons of typical Clojure programs will be. Persistent data structures tend to benefit a lot from highly optimised garbage collectors like those packaged with the JVM. And Clojure's highly dynamic style probably benefits a lot from JIT techniques too.

Still, it's a fascinating project, which I will watch closely.

widdershins··on Mary Schmich's “Wear Sunscreen”, which turned into an unlikely 90s hit (2019)
Doesn't the final sentence suggest that the list is more than slightly cynical? To me it seems like Radiohead are sneering at this safe middle-road existence.
widdershins··on George Orwell’s 1940 Review of Mein Kampf
No (though it does happen, see Constantinople's chariot teams). But expansionist and militaristic societies are often obsessed with sport, for example imperial Britain, Germany at the 1936 Olympics, and arguably the modern US.
widdershins··on Show HN: Get rid of Git submodules and never look back (now for GitHub users)
It also had terrible audio quality for me.
widdershins··on Straight.el: next-gen, purely functional package manager for the Emacs hacker
As I understand it, that's basically what this is.
widdershins··on Why isn’t new technology making us more productive?
But isn't that true of all innovations? That the earlier ones solve more basic/critical needs than the later ones? Would you trade a hot shower for glass in your windows? Or a plough that enables you face starvation less frequently?
widdershins··on The Modos Paper Laptop
There's one reason alone that I'd be interested, but it's a pretty big one: to work outside in the sunshine without a washed-out screen. For this purpose all I'd need is Emacs to run, and I'd be golden.

Being able to work outside would be fantastic for my well-being, and I'd accept quite a lot of compromise to get that.

widdershins··on DALL·E 2 and The Origin of Vibe Shifts
Just like several years ago you'd say "there's a big difference between these trippy deep-dream images and an actual meaningful illustration with a style and a coherent theme". But here we are.
widdershins··on Ask HN: Anyone highlight text as they read?
Yep. I constantly highlight and unhighlight paragraphs by triple-clicking as I read them. No idea why, it's something of a 'tick'.
widdershins··on Rails is not written in Ruby
Somehow this story seems to relate to the author's musings on conflicting monkey-patched libraries. It's all rather beautifully messy.
widdershins··on Mixbox: Practical pigment mixing for digital painting
It has some large lookup tables inside. It would be nice if these were extracted into a separate source file though.
widdershins··on Dozens of U.S. states say Apple stifles competition, back Epic
Because most of competition law is written such that practices only become illegal when then they demonstrably create or increase a monopoly or dominant market position. [1] The courts don't like to interfere in these practices as long as there's competition in the market.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_antitrust_law#Ty...

widdershins··on BCHS: OpenBSD, C, httpd and SQLite web stack
You can think of simplicity in various ways - some subset of which are valid. For example, you could say that using std::unique_ptr is simpler than manual memory management, because it automates much of the process, making it less likely that a developer will make a mistake. Or you could say that the 1000s of lines of C++ std code that you will pull in represents an increase of complexity, because the mechanics are hidden under layers of abstraction.

I'm open to both views, and most importantly to trade-off one against the other according to other constraints and context. For me, using C++ allows me to do that, because it's (mostly) a superset of C. Acknowledging, of course, that this brings a trade-off of its own, because decisions must continually made (and enforced) about what std/external libraries to use and when.

widdershins··on The race to grab all the UK’s lithium before it’s too late
A video I watched recently comes to a very different conclusion on almost every point you raised: that buying a new electric car is better for the environment within ~5 years of use, taking into account the 'new car' footprint.

I'm not an expert, so I won't claim to know who's correct. But the linked video provides lots of numbers, and you didn't, so I lean in favour of that conclusion.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L2IKCdnzl5k

widdershins··on Companies that use Lisp extensively
The reason people use C/C++ for audio is because a kind of 'soft realtime' performance is required. The thread producing audio cannot block for an unbounded amount of time, ever. If you are late to produce an audio buffer, a nasty audible glitch will be the result. This means no file access, no waiting for mutexes, and certainly no garbage-collection pauses.

This is why managed languages like Lisps are rarely (if ever) used for the DSP in audio applications. I am an audio programmer who loves all things lispy, so believe me, I wish this weren't the case.

widdershins··on Lite XL: A lightweight text editor written in Lua
Does this really warrant a fork? Couldn't better font rendering be merged into Lite? It's an interesting and quite new text editor. Getting traction for a new editor is hard, and having multiple forks seems like it could make it even harder.
widdershins··on Busting the 10x software engineer myth
To be fair, the grandparent said 'runtime errors', not 'bugs'. And it is a stated goal of the Elm language that runtime exceptions thrown from the compiled Javascript should be impossible. As far as I know, they have succeeded in that goal.

How this relates to 10x or not I don't know - I'm not sure the discussion is a productive one without further context.

It might be that for some tasks, Elm really does provide a huge benefit in productivity. In that case, it's probably fair to call a developer that selects and uses the tool correctly a 10x developer - provided they are able to evolve the culture of their company so that others can take advantage of it.

For other tasks, or in other contexts, Elm might be a hinderance. If it's lacking an indispensable library, or if the company culture is not ready to accept it as a core language, it won't help anyone to rewrite in Elm.

As always, one of the key things that makes a good (even 10x) developer is the ability to select the right tool, and to wield it gracefully.

widdershins··on I can't stand developing for Safari anymore
The UK spends less per capita on healthcare than almost any other G7 nation (except Italy) [1], while maintaining a good standard of care [2]. That suggests that compared to other countries:

1. There isn't plenty of money

2. It's spent quite effectively

[1] https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/healthan...

[2] https://www.kingsfund.org.uk/publications/articles/big-elect...

widdershins··on A Beginner’s Guide to Miles Davis
Yeah, I played Ahmad Jamal to my girlfriend and she thought it sounds very 'cocktail' jazz. And she's right, it does! But the melodies and phrasing in his work are complex and beautiful, just like Miles.
← PreviousPage 5 of 9Next →