HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wildmanx

1,370 karma · joined February 25, 2019

submissionscomments
wildmanx··on Deluge BitTorrent Client
For you and everybody else complaining about this aspect: This is open source software. GPL licensed. It's provided as-is. You are free to use it and express what you think about it, and the maintainers are equally free to do with your opinion whatever they like, which includes ignoring it.

Clearly, none of the maintainers found this to be a problem. They likely don't need proxy settings for themselves. And they apparently also don't want to spend the time and energy to fix an issue that they don't have. That doesn't mean it's not an issue. It's just not an issue for them and they choose to do other things in life than fix it for you. Do you really demand somebody who already gave something to you for free to do even more work for free to implement something that they don't need themselves? Why would they do it? To get you to stop complain?

It's open source, you are free to go fix it yourself. This is Hacker News, lots of people on here should have the competence to fix this. Yet, in the last 10 years, apparently nobody found it so bad that they fixed it. It is clearly not impacting as many people as you make it sound like.

"Nobody should use Deluge" is an unsuitable statement, just because it has an issue in your use case. Many people don't have that use case, and of those who do, nobody bothered to fix it yet. Complaining doesn't fix anything.

What needs just as much fixing as the raised issue is your attitude towards open source.

wildmanx··on Cache made consistent: Meta’s cache invalidation solution
A == "Design of your system"

B == "Inconsistency between your caches"

GP: A -> B

You: "Imposing order and synchrony is [bad things]" == "If you don't do A then [bad things]", i.e., (not A) -> [bad things]

Also you: "Even if we did, then [other issues]" == "Even if you don't do A then [other issues]", i.e., (not A) -> ..what? B?

You are certainly not arguing against the A -> B implication.

wildmanx··on Cache made consistent: Meta’s cache invalidation solution
> > the inconsistency between your cache nodes is a consequence of the underlying design of your system

> I disagree with this. First of all, imposing order and synchrony is expensive, slow and unreliable. Even if we do that, cache fill and invalidation will never be externally coordinated; and will collide on the cache host.

This is a weird reply. GP writes "A implied B" and you disagree by arguing that you had to do A. Sure. But it's still what implied B. Quite a fundamental logic flaw, no?

wildmanx··on Uber Eats Nationwide Shipping
Read the room, Uber. We are in a climate crisis.
wildmanx··on Entropy Is Fatal
> Yet so many supposedly intelligent managers use such approaches...

Yet so many supposedly intelligent engineers work for such managers...

wildmanx··on Entropy Is Fatal
> It seems that productivity growth is still necessarily limited in the end by physics.

Biology will put limits in place long before physics will.

Sadly, most techies completely ignore or miss this point.

wildmanx··on Sunsetting Atom
> That open source software forms some part of a commons is not really a thing in practice. Open source software is ran by maintainers, those maintainers own the projects, and they do with the software what they deem fit.

One should make a difference between (1) access to the source code to look, find bugs, make minor adjustments and (2) everybody with that access to be able to actively participate in the development.

In the sense of (1), open source is "some part of a commons". That's what the license gives you.

In the sense of (2), open source may or not be open to a community approach. It's fully legitimate for some company or other group of maintainers to provide (1) but deny anything related to (2). You are free to fork and make your own community, but there is nothing that guarantees you that your pull requests are accepted or even looked at, bug reports reacted to or anybody listening to wishes, concerns or other opinions about the project. It's nice if that's provided, and one could argue that some part of the spirit of open source is to enable a community, which in turn helps the original creators (and could be a major motivation to open source something), but nobody should be upset if maintainers choose otherwise.

It's nice if it's clearly communicated how maintainers see this though.

wildmanx··on Please don't unofficially ship Bottles in distribution repositories
> In particular there's a big divergence in availability, and security requirements.

I strongly disagree about the difference in security requirements. I don't want anybody to pwn my banks servers, not less or more than pwning my home desktop or mobile phone.

wildmanx··on The true cost of linked lists
> Big-O assumes all "operations" are equally costly.

This is a big misconception about "Big-O". It does not "assume" anything. It's just not what people think it is.

It's an asymptotic upper bound on counting something. In sorting algorithms you count the number of comparisons expressed as a function of collection size. In collection insertion algorithms on some underlying data structure, it's counting some not-very-clearly-defined atomic operations that are being executed when inserting an element.

Where the assumptions come from is if you start using the notation to give performance comparisons and also start assuming things about Big-O that are just not true. But that has nothing to do with "Big-O".

There is a family of symbols, called the Landau symbols, of which Big-O is only one. There is a lot of misuse of the symbol and in many cases what people actually mean is Theta(N) or Omega(N).

wildmanx··on Installing a payphone in my house
That's a lot of work just to show a "hello world".

The point was that it's hard to do it with the thing you already have. Of course it's easier if you just get a new thing -- which installing a new OS corresponds to in the software world.

wildmanx··on Installing a payphone in my house
> Messing around is how kids get their start in computers

And, sadly, they tend to get punished for it, once it's found out.

wildmanx··on Installing a payphone in my house
> but there's just something about today's Internet and a lot of the overwhelming amount of technology that just isn't fun or memorable.

That's right -- modern age stuff isn't as _hackable_. Especially not at the hardware level. You get an Alexa or a mobile phone or a camera, it's all just a chip on a PCB in a plastic case, not intended to be fiddled with by anybody (not the owner, not some repair show, literally _nobody_) just to be thrown away after a year or two and replaced by a new one.

It's all very sad. There is still some software component to things that's hackable, but even that's harder to do. In the past you turned on your C64 and could start write away code, average Joe Teenager needs to install some IDE and pull in hundreds of NPM dependencies from shady places just to show a hello world. Unless daddy/mommy gave them a Linux box, then the story is different.

wildmanx··on Ask HN: Burnt-out, directionless but want to turn it around
> OP is more valuable than a toilet cleaner, or a starbucks barista

Not to kill your point, but those two are dramatically under-valued and under-appreciated jobs in most societies around the world. Every time you use a toilet (other than the one in your home) which is hopefully clean, somebody had cleaned it recently. Imagine they hadn't. You'd have a terrible day. Every time you go grab a good Starbucks coffee. Maybe even sit down in a comfy sofa to be able to enjoy it. Imagine the barista had screwed it up.

Both experiences make a huge difference in people's lives. Hundreds if not thousands a day. Every day. But they are paid crap and talked about in the way you just did. Compare that to a coder churning away meaningless features in some meaningless app. Would I care if the coder wouldn't show up to work for the next 4 weeks with nobody stepping in their place? No. That answer is decisively different for the toilet cleaner and the barista.

wildmanx··on My students cheated... a lot
> This comment is saying "No one else here knows as much about this as I do", and little else.

No, it's not. Not at all.

But your comment is saying "How dare you suggest that we listen to experts? We all should have a say!". And that's the problem the gp post is pointing out. Do you argue like that with your doctor before surgery? With your lawyer before they defend you in court? With a chef before they cook a meal you ordered in a restaurant? No? Then why is education any different and suddenly everybody claims to know how it should work..

wildmanx··on Accidentally Saving the Day
I appreciate the story and the pride he must have felt. But this is the entirely wrong message. It perpetuates that the superstars are those jumping in last second in some heroic effort to save the day.

This is not how projects should work, and we should stop perpetuating these heroic stories. The actual superstars are all those people doing the less-than-glamorous grunt work. Planning things on time. Getting the infra ready, stable, well-tested, documented. Making schedules that have margins. The people carefully designing things so they are robust and don't break left and right. Thinking through their systematic testing. In short, preparing everything so that heroic acts are not necessary.

Imagine the same story but somebody two months earlier had voiced a concern that Jabberwocky and ChaChing wouldn't play well together. Pushing for the APIs to be harmonized so that they could play together and integrate. Pushing all this against pressure that they are just delaying everything and should not worry so much and be more positive and agile. Imagine they had succeeded and everything had gone smoothly. This would have been much better for the company (since the existential risk wouldn't have existed in the first place). But that somebody wouldn't have ended being the superstar with the promotion and the bonus. It would likely have stuck to have been the guy just delaying things with their worries. That's what needs to change in sw eng culture.

wildmanx··on What One-person SaaS Healthchecks.io uses for hosting, hardware and software
As a counter argument, imagine an infinitely good insulation and 0 standby power (and a spherical cow inside, for illustration purposes). Then keeping it "running" is clearly better than letting the fridge warm up since power draw is 0 in the former case. Obviously the conditions are not as perfect, but with a very modern fridge, maybe you get sufficiently close that keeping running indeed is superior.

I'm not arguing that that's the case here. I'm arguing that you don't "always" expect things to be worse off letting it run. There is a threshold, when approaching the mentioned fantasy conditions, beyond which letting it run may be better.

wildmanx··on What One-person SaaS Healthchecks.io uses for hosting, hardware and software
While I agree with the overall sentiment (fix the big problems first to maximize payoff), the issue is one of attitude. Keeping a "save where possible" mindset, no matter how large the immediate payoff (within reasonable limits) has a much greater chance of success.

You have that effect in many areas of life. A quite obvious example is working out. Of course it won't make much of a difference if you skip today's workout or abort your 40 min run today halfway cause you don't feel like it. But it's the mindset/attitude. It makes you a quitter. It enables you to do the same thing again. And again. And in the end, the cumulative damage of the change in mindset is magnitudes worse than the single event.

wildmanx··on What One-person SaaS Healthchecks.io uses for hosting, hardware and software
> It actually uses less power being powered on continiously for 2 weeks (12 days from departure to arrival), than it does being powered off and working overtime for 6 hours trying to cool down. It's not much less power, but still less.

I suppose you mean energy rather than power? (Cause the argument makes less sense with power.)

That's an interesting phenomenon then since it goes counter to my (rather naive) understanding of physics. There could be some anomaly with the fridges efficiency curve that causes this. Maybe it's really inefficient cooling down the contents from room temperature while being really efficient maintaining the cool temp? After all, the latter is its main purpose..

wildmanx··on What One-person SaaS Healthchecks.io uses for hosting, hardware and software
> i very much fear arriving at a summer house where the fridge has been unpowered for a couple of weeks.

Another solution to this problem is to just empty the fridge and turn it off while not in the summer house for a few weeks.

wildmanx··on The Vulnerable World Hypothesis [pdf] (2019)
> To be human is to desire freedom and be free.

Hm? Like every species, being a member of that species means having been selected by evolution over countless generations to further the species. It's an ingenious distributed algorithm, if you wish. To "desire freedom" is a nice illusion that you are telling yourself, quite rightfully, but that's not what it means "to be human".

> edit: there is no benefit worthy of risking our freedom to tyrannical governance

Anarchy is not the solution. Brings us right back to medieval times.

wildmanx··on The Vulnerable World Hypothesis [pdf] (2019)
I'm a bit surprised by all those dismissive comments here. Isn't it useful that _some_ people sit down, think hard about what are the worst things that could happen to us as a species, and consider preventive measures? In every company you have people do this for the business. Every military considers threat scenarios. Heck, the all-beloved Elon Musk wants to bring us to Mars of all places to have a backup home, just in case. But Bostrom is talked down for having a "shtick"? It's his job.
wildmanx··on The Vulnerable World Hypothesis [pdf] (2019)
> Bostrom's brand of fear mongering does not appear to be based in science, logic, or basic common sense. I mean, a lot of world issues are obvious to the naked eye: overpopulation, consumption, housing prices, destruction of natural habitats.

I really wonder whether people commenting here have actually read the article. It's quite involved, I've already spent a few hours and am far from through. It's fair to assume that most people have spent less time.

Your comment is not very much related to the type of events that he is describing in the article. How are housing prices even remotely a technological development leading to devastation of civilization? If anything they are just an artifact of a particular economic incentive structure.

wildmanx··on Arm Open Source makes a seamless migration to GitLab
Somebody needs to pay their bills. It's not going to be money coming in from the open source free tier users.
wildmanx··on Billion-Dollar Crypto Loan Is Easy to Get, but Gone in a Flash
> But yes, once you do all of that...it actually is a money printing machine that will never end as long as markets have volatility.

And despite this being inherent in the DeFi world, people still believe that such systems are better than fiat money?

wildmanx··on Off-Grid Cyberdeck with RPI and Pelican Case
> better data-density and durability than a stack of paper

Eh, what? Paper has survived for hundreds if not thousands of years. Show me your RPi 1000 years for now, next to an equally old bible, and we'll chat again. (Not a religious argument, the bible is just an example.)

Edit: Make it 100 years from now, the effects should be obviously already at that point.

wildmanx··on Can we make a black hole? And if we could, what could we do with it?
To add some understanding: the name does not mean "the child of Schwarz".

It's composed of two German words: "schwarz" which means "black" and "Schild" which means "shield". So "Blackshield". No children involved here.

wildmanx··on The saddest “just ship it” story (2020)
> Every single reason a founder can come up with not to be out there selling like "The product isn't finished", "It needs feature X", "It's not fast enough", "It needs better design", etc is wrong.

But don't you run the risk of some potential customer coming, trying it, deciding it's crap, moving on, and now they are burned for the foreseeable future? So, once your product isn't that crap anymore, they won't come back try again, since your brand is burned and has built a "that's crap" reputation?

wildmanx··on Everything with a battery should have an off switch
Maybe those other microwaves have a different design that doesn't make it necessary. So, sure, you can re-design the microwave oven, but that may entail significantly more work than to just deactivate the fan.

I could criticize cars with combustion engines for having one and being so noisy/stinky/... Then I could go on claiming that they should just turn them off, cause there are cars without combustion engines which are less noisy/stinky/... I'd be missing that there is more to it than just turning off the engine. I'd need to replace it with something else, like an EV. Maybe that did not exist yet when that car was build. So, claiming that this old Ford from 1970 having a combustion engine is stupid because "this is not a problem that other cars have" is missing the point. I could go rip the engine out because I don't like that it's noisy/stinky/... But I'm in for a surprise here. The vehicle won't move anymore. Something I'd have understood had I followed the principle put forward by Chesterton's Fence.

> Chesterton's Fence tells us that there is no cost to eliminating this ridiculously awful functionality

No. It tells you to first understand what you are doing. Blindly claiming something misses that part.

wildmanx··on Why I left Google: work-life balance
> Let me just put it coldly here: career can be re-established, friend can be re-found, losing family is a painful struggle but it's not impossible to start from scratch. But physical health, once you lose it, you'll likely lose everything else too. The same thing is also true for mental health.

You may want to consider rating mental health higher than physical health. They are correlated, but if in doubt and/or if you need to choose, mental health is the one.

And that's where the social/family component comes in. And the work component. Both contribute to mental health. Just as physical health does. But if work and family/friends "buckets" suck, then no matter how tip-top shape you get physically, mental health will suffer.

Therefore, it makes sense to not place the physical health bucket over the other two. All has to contribute to mental health.

wildmanx··on Why I left Google: work-life balance
> learned early not to pick useless feature projects and cleanup work.

And that's why things slowly rot away. Cleanup should be a priority, otherwise it eventually slows down new feature work.

In fact, a project should not be declared finished until its inevitable follow-up cleanup tasks have been completed as well. Just like a party weekend is not finished until you have cleaned up the mess after. Somebody is going to have to do it, and if it's not you right after you're done with your deliverables, then somebody else will have to do it. Possibly yourself further down the road when you actually want to do something else more exciting. Just like doing the dishes. Nobody wants to start preparing a big meal by having to do the dishes from the week prior.

← PreviousPage 4 of 13Next →