HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

willbudd

304 karma · joined November 10, 2019

submissionscomments
willbudd··on US Marines defeat DARPA robot by hiding under a cardboard box
Not really. Depends entirely on how general-purpose (abstract) the learned concept is.

For example, detecting the possible presence of a cavity inside an object X, and whether that cavity is large enough to hide another object Y. Learning generic geospatial properties like that can greatly improve a whole swath of downstream prediction tasks (i.e., in a transfer learning sense).

willbudd··on Godalmighty, Exxon Knew Everything
Perhaps this is just my ignorance showing, but wasn't the data that Exxon based its own modelling on more or less publicly available? It can't have been a secret how many barrels were being pulled out of the ground each year? What am I missing?

Far from wanting to defend Exxon, but regardless whether or not they knew; if the narrative is that the "world outside Exxon" didn't know, doesn't that in itself amount to wilful ignorance or negligence at best?

What data did they have that the rest of the academic/political world couldn't add up on its own without corporate cooperation?

willbudd··on The James Webb Space Telescope is finding too many early galaxies
Not a physicist at all either; but on a per particle basis, I know gravity is by far the weakest of the fundamental forces. However, unlike the others, it doesn't have spin/charge/polarity that results in their vectors repelling each other. As such, black holes form when the large scale weak gravitational forces combine into a greater force than the strong short scale repelling forces exerted by the others (and especially so when nuclear fusion is involved). In a hot primordial plasma, the particles are by definition extremely energetic; pushing each other in all directions with far more vigor than the extent to which gravity attracts them. Hence being a big bang rather than a big crunch, I suppose.
willbudd··on State of JavaScript 2022
Good luck talking to cloud infrastructure such as Cognito-authorized AWS S3 buckets on the client side with a last century mindset like that.
willbudd··on A mistake that killed Japan’s software industry?
> And Perl has the best support for regular expressions.

To me this sounds a bit like driving to a supermarket three towns away because it has the best selection of coffee filters... :)

willbudd··on Deepmind’s AlphaCode conquers coding, performing as well as humans
> It can't expand the edges, it can't come up with anything truly original.

You're dead wrong about that. Remember Deepmind's original claim to fame? Alphago?

It came up with tactics and strategies that top professional go players considered to be novel to the point of being revolutionary. If you look at the way games are played by human professionals in the years before and after Alphago came on to the stage, you'll find they're different to an extent greater than any other upheaval in the many centuries-long history of the game.

AI is a much more diverse field than you seem to give it credit for. Paint with overly broad strokes like that, and you're bound to go astray.

willbudd··on The AI war and how to win it
That's simply not true. There are numerous problem domains in AI where Chinese research groups are advancing the SOTA, or at least are well-presented at the forefront. Your comment reads like little more than casual racism to me.
willbudd··on Fired? Why cooperatives might be your next career choice in tech
I've been interested in forming this kind of organizational structure for a while. However, I have doubts about how to ensure sufficient levels of trust between individuals involved, given the different dynamics in terms of monetary compensation and "hiring processes" compared to traditional top-down companies.

In that light, I wonder if perhaps a better alternative is for each individual to remain independent as their own one-man company in a freelancer kind of way, and instead to focus on streamlining the process of establishing ad-hoc micro contracts whenever collaborative tasks are to be undertaken -- while still keeping the community aspect of a cooperative in place somehow. At the same time, I guess the reason this isn't done more extensively, is simply due to the overhead of having to reach a consensus of the worth of contributions on a task-by-task basis...

willbudd··on Issue dialing 911 on Google Pixel 6 cell phones
Allowing one app to register more than one phone service provider smells like an Android API bug. Allowing an unlimited number definitely is a bug. Allowing the corresponding integer to overflow and... well... do we really need to argue this point?

A phone OS should never have to rely on good app behavior to not collapse like a house of cards. Much less one made by a corporation with a 71% worldwide market share.

willbudd··on Stable Diffusion based image compression
I've been thinking about more or less the same idea, but the computational edge inference costs probably makes it impractical for most of today's client devices. I see a lot of potential in this direction in the near future though.
willbudd··on Hertzbleed Attack
To demonstrate the effectiveness of the attack they deliberately chose SIKE as a protocol that was thought to be very resilient against side channel shenanigans.

If anything, real-world contexts are likely to be lower hanging fruit.

willbudd··on New ultra-stealthy Linux backdoor isn’t your everyday malware discovery
Only a very small percentage of Linux binaries in the wild is fully static though (e.g., those that are compiled with musl). This is "thanks" to Glibc, which makes doing so nigh impossible.

I also highly doubt "many" programs make syscalls directly, but I could be wrong. I know I haven't done so since the days I dabbled in assembly, at least.

willbudd··on My students cheated... a lot
You don't need to know or trust any underlying technology though. The only thing you need is a basic grasp of Darwinian natural selection.

The "shittier" those "shitcoins" are, the quicker they'll die out. The ones that heavily incentivize early adopters might hang around longer, but they too will inevitably fizzle out if they don't offer any practical innovation.

But if something has a steadily growing user base year after year, maybe it's worth some attention after all?

Or you can just keep screeching "Shitcoins! Shitcoins!". I guess we can all settle for ourselves what form of discourse we consider more constructive and worthwhile.

willbudd··on My students cheated... a lot
Becoming successful requires a stubborn conviction that you can make your own ideas a reality. Doing well on tests requires the ability to re-enact the ideas of others.

They're both valuable skills of course, but they should be recognized as being distinct from each other; and measuring "intelligence" as some one-dimensional modality is a spectacular failure to do so, IMO.

This idea is also to an extent analogous to the tradeoff between exploration and exploitation in reinforcement learning (AI).

willbudd··on The absurd complexity of server-side rendering
I can't believe it took people 12 years since the publication of the WebSocket standard to figure this stuff out. Is everyone just running in circles?
willbudd··on Record-breaking hydrogen electrolyzer claims 95% efficiency
I've always thought of capillary action as a very interesting phenomenon that can make all sorts of seemingly improbable engineering tricks possible. Great to see such an elegant application thereof here.
willbudd··on On Being Indispensable
> I could have made so much more money if I stayed

Are you sure that isn't a bit of a "glass is half empty" perspective? There's no upper limit to how much money you can make by choosing your own path. (If, hypothetically speaking, you were inclined to pursue big $€¥£).

willbudd··on The day Steve Jobs dissed me in a keynote (2010)
That's fair, but there didn't even need to be an API. Just some feature to import WAV files and/or track listings would have gone a long way.
willbudd··on The day Steve Jobs dissed me in a keynote (2010)
Yeah, no doubt. Everything can be automated. And I'm sure some dirty hack was cobbled together to work around the situation rather than turning some poor human into a zombie with both RSI and PTSD. I'd hope.

But let's not turn the tables that way. My point is that "opportunity" should have been addressed _before_ Steve Jobs decided to fly in all those industry bigwigs to do his sales pitch. I mean, who was selling who here exactly? Different times I guess...

willbudd··on The day Steve Jobs dissed me in a keynote (2010)
Can you imagine having to manually insert 100000 CDs and all their metadata into some GUI, even though you have everything on file elsewhere already? And not just any GUI application, but the complete garbage that is iTunes.

Because some dev/clown has the hubris to proclaim "there is no other way"? I'd not care if you're Steve Jobs himself. That's some just laugh and leave the room level of Kafkaesque ridiculousness.

Glad I work in the era of public-facing APIs. Even if Apple still seems to be clinging on to their consume-only mentality.

willbudd··on AMD is now worth more than Intel
Yes, of course that's correct, and it has been like that for many years.

What is your point?

willbudd··on AMD is now worth more than Intel
I'm not questioning the existence of such elements in Taiwan — including some group apparently so formidable that you can't/won't even mention its name.

No, what I find highly implausible is the notion that such an extreme "unification at any costs" ideology has any significant popular support. More so still in the aftermath of the PRC's recent suppressive tactics in Hong Kong.

I'm sure the scenarios you hint at are indeed explored at great lengths among Beijing-funded think tank strategists, but I can't see Xi & co being naive enough to elevate such an approach as their most viable course of action.

willbudd··on AMD is now worth more than Intel
Peaceful coexistence? Sure.

Closer coordination and cooperation in a socioeconomic context? Also on the table.

But _integration_ with the communist PRC? Uhmm... yeah no, that's a pretty disingenuous characterization of the KMT side of Taiwanese politics.

willbudd··on AMD is now worth more than Intel
OK, I'll bite. What is this "diplomatic takeover" of Taiwan you speak of?

The historical circumstances of HK and Taiwan are nothing alike. Furthermore, the mainland communist party doesn't have any sway on Taiwanese politics, as far as I can tell ...other than as a common nemesis to unite against in relation to any issues that could affect the island's autonomy.

willbudd··on It's always been you, Canvas2D
I guess it didn't occur to you that retrieving and setting image data with getImageData()/putImageData() actually turn out to be indispensable features when generating complex multi-layer canvases. Your trivial heuristic would flag a lot of false positives.
willbudd··on In Japan, a million people have shut themselves in their rooms
I tried to offer my perspective to some extent in my reply to taurath above (or below).

And as for me being a "gaijin"? That's not even relevant, because my observations are based not on how people interact with me, but rather how my Japanese coworkers tend to communicate with each other on the numerous (almost exclusively open plan) work floors I have been part of for many years.

willbudd··on In Japan, a million people have shut themselves in their rooms
> Salarymen working conditions I would guess.

Working conditions vary hugely from company to company. On a spectrum from "black companies" -as they're called here- to "modern companies" with strict enforcement of work/life balance in terms of office hours and (lack of) overtime. Also, in my experience there's often a lot of variance within the same office too. Usually between those who have learned to set their own boundaries and those who haven't.

If anything, conditions are often the _opposite_ of rigid. Overtime is far more strictly regulated in Japan than in the US, for example. As such, blatantly over-exerting employees is nowhere near as common here as people overseas seem to assume. Because that kind of thing can land a company in a lot of trouble.

It's usually rather the un-rigid aspects that lead to stressful working conditions, as far as I can judge. People here generally strongly value being considerate of those around them, especially in terms of not being a burden to others, and one way this manifests itself is by a drive to meet implicit expectations of coworkers -- real or imagined. Over-promising and over-committing is a common mistake anywhere, but its an even easier trap to fall into in a country like this where expectations aren't rigidly outlined at all.

> The extremely rigid gender roles expected by society are another.

Well, yes, I concede that there is (still) a far larger gender-based bias in societal expectations than in many Western countries. However, wouldn't you say that in most aspects women are the side that draw the shorter sticks here? And yet, about 3 in 4 hikikomori are boys/men, so I'm not sure what kind of conclusion you'd want to draw from that...

willbudd··on In Japan, a million people have shut themselves in their rooms
I wonder where this myth of Japanese society being rigid comes from. As someone who has lived here a long time it makes very little sense to me.
willbudd··on An enhancement request I submitted to Bugzilla 15 years ago was just closed
Actually, upvoting my comments will beset you on a path to enlightenment and world peace. Source: trust me bro.
willbudd··on An enhancement request I submitted to Bugzilla 15 years ago was just closed
Upvote me if you absolutely detest stalebot.

Closing issues after a while if the reporting user fails to follow up on a request for additional information can be useful. But more often than not these stalebots kick in because the maintainer(s) never chimed in. Don't use a bot that can't distinguish between those two cases unless your only aim is to wage war on your users and sweep everything inconvenient under the rug.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →